| Course | NUR 643EA Advanced Health Assessment for Nurse Educators |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Clinical judgment teaching paper |
| Length | About 970 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NUR 643EA Topic 4
A Split That Closed When He Sat Up: Judging a Second Heart Sound in a 22-Year-Old, and Why the Judgment Cannot Be Handed Over as a Rule
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NUR-643EA: Advanced Health Assessment for Nurse Educators
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
February 4, 2030
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Split That Closed When He Sat Up: Judging a Second Heart Sound in a 22-Year-Old, and Why the Judgment Cannot Be Handed Over as a Rule
The Feature as It Presented
Mr. L., a composite 22-year-old college swimmer, came for a preparticipation physical. Lying supine, at the left upper sternal border, his second heart sound was split, and the split could still be heard at the end of expiration. A split that persists through expiration is the feature that separates an ordinary finding from one that needs explaining, because in physiologic splitting the pulmonic component falls behind the aortic during inspiration, as more blood returns to the right heart, and the two come back together during expiration (Bickley et al., 2021). An expiratory split raises the possibilities of a wide physiologic split, as with right bundle branch block, and of a fixed split, the classic sign of an atrial septal defect. For several minutes I did not know which this was, and the note below keeps that uncertainty where it was.
What Surrounded It
Across the respiratory cycle, supine: the split was wider on inspiration and narrower, but still present, on expiration. It moved; it was not fixed. The rest of the examination: no murmur at the left upper sternal border, where an atrial septal defect often produces a soft systolic flow murmur; no right ventricular lift at the lower left sternal border; normal first heart sound; no third or fourth sound; pulses and blood pressure normal. History: no breathlessness, palpitations or fainting, a year of competitive swimming without limitation, no family history of sudden death. Then I sat him up and listened again at the end of expiration. The split closed.
What tipped the call was that the expiratory split disappeared when he sat up: in young adults, the extra venous return of lying flat can keep the pulmonic valve closing late enough to be heard separately even in expiration, and a split that closes with the change in position is behaving like physiology, not like a defect. What would have tipped it the other way: a split that stayed the same width through inspiration and expiration and did not close when he sat or stood, or the same finding with a systolic murmur at the upper left sternal border or a right ventricular lift. Either would have sent him for an electrocardiogram and an echocardiogram before clearance.
Why No Rule Can Be Handed to a Novice
No rule produced that call. A rule such as "refer any split heard in expiration" would send a large share of healthy young people for echocardiography, and novices who learned it would stop listening to how the split behaved. A rule such as "a split that varies with breathing is normal" would miss the wide physiologic split of right bundle branch block, which varies with breathing and still reflects a conduction abnormality. Both rules have been taught by well-meaning preceptors, and composite classes show both results: learners who flag every split and learners who dismiss one that deserved an electrocardiogram. Expert clinical judgment appears to rest less on explicit rules than on a large store of examples against which a new case is compared (Norman, 2005). The teaching task is to build that store deliberately.
Graded Cases That Move the Boundary
Novices work through five short audio cases, each with a history and a description of what happens when the patient changes position. The boundary moves a little each time. Case 1: a split heard only in inspiration, seated. A variant. Case 2: a split heard in expiration supine that closes when seated, the case above. A variant. Case 3: a split heard in expiration both supine and seated, still wider in inspiration, in a patient with no symptoms. A finding: it needs an electrocardiogram, since it may reflect delayed right ventricular conduction. Case 4: a split that stays the same width in all phases and positions, with a soft systolic murmur at the upper left sternal border. A finding needing echocardiography. Case 5: a split heard only in expiration, closing on inspiration, in an older adult with a harsh systolic murmur, a paradoxical split. A finding. For each case, novices say whether they would clear, investigate or refer, and what single change in the case would reverse their decision. Items built around uncertain situations, where learners judge how a new piece of information changes a hypothesis, capture this kind of reasoning better than recall questions (Charlin et al., 2000).
The Third Case, Where It Broke
A composite novice cleared Case 3. Her reason: "It changes with breathing, so it's physiological." She had built the variable rule from Cases 1 and 2. I asked what had been different about Case 2 that made it safe. She said it closed when he sat up. I asked whether Case 3 closed when the patient sat up. She reread it and said no, and then, after a pause, "So the breathing isn't what matters, it's whether it goes away in expiration when they're upright." That is closer, and it is her sentence rather than mine. She then overcorrected on Case 5, calling the paradoxical split physiologic because it varied, which tells me the series needs another case between 4 and 5.
The Case I Would Add
The next case to add is a young adult with a known right bundle branch block on an old electrocardiogram and a wide, varying split that persists upright. It would teach that a split can be explained and still be a finding, and that the right answer can be to note it and not refer, if the explanation is already documented. It would also give the novice who overcorrected on Case 5 a bridge: a split whose explanation is on paper, sitting between the clearly benign and the clearly abnormal.
References
Bickley, L. S., Szilagyi, P. G., Hoffman, R. M., & Soriano, R. P. (2021). Bates' guide to physical examination and history taking (13th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.
Charlin, B., Roy, L., Brailovsky, C., Goulet, F., & van der Vleuten, C. (2000). The Script Concordance test: A tool to assess the reflective clinician. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 12(4), 189-195. https://doi.org/10.1207/S15328015TLM1204_5
Norman, G. (2005). Research in clinical reasoning: Past history and current trends. Medical Education, 39(4), 418-427. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2929.2005.02127.x
The NUR-643EA Topic 4 assignment instructions
Topic 4 in NUR-643EA asks nurse educators to teach a clinical judgment that resists reduction to a rule. Strong papers describe the feature as it presented and everything around it that informed the call, then show why any rule a novice could follow would fail, either by over-referring healthy people or by being applied too loosely. Students should design graded cases that move the boundary a little at a time, report where a novice's reasoning broke and what rule the novice had built from earlier cases, and propose the case that would correct it. The paper should reach a definite call on the original patient and say what it rests on. Research on script concordance and clinical reasoning should support the design, and each graded case should state the history and positional change that a learner hears with it.
Inside the NUR 643EA Topic 4 example
The feature is a split of the second heart sound in a composite young adult, which is ordinary until it is not. The paper settles it by what surrounds it rather than by the sound alone: what happened across the respiratory cycle, what the rest of the examination held, what the person's history made likely, and what would have moved the call. The reasoning is written so a reader can see the point at which it tipped. The teaching half then admits that no rule produced that call, which is why novices cannot be handed one. A rule would send them either into flagging every variation or into missing the case the rule did not anticipate, and both outcomes are described from composite classes.
NUR 643EA Topic 4 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward judgment taught through graded cases. An Excellent paper records a split that varied with breathing and closed when a 22-year-old swimmer sat up, using Bickley and colleagues. Credit goes to showing why refer any split heard in expiration would over-refer. The rubric values five audio cases that move the boundary, drawing on Charlin and colleagues and Norman on clinical reasoning. Strong papers report a novice clearing Case 3 on a rule from Cases 1 and 2. Top marks go to adding a case with right bundle branch block.
NUR 643EA Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
The clinical call is worth less here than the account of how it was reached, and much less than the teaching half. A paper that names the feature, declares it benign and cites a reference has answered the question a practitioner was asked. Reasoning written backward from the answer is visible because everything supports and nothing complicates; graders on this topic look for the element that pointed the other way. Handing a novice a numeric rule is scored as the shortcut it is, and the paper is expected to say what the rule would cost. Graded cases with no reported failure read as designed rather than used. A threshold described as clinical judgment, with nothing under it, gives a novice no way in.
Get an NUR-643EA Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the NUR-643EA Topic 4 instructions, your rubric and the feature your section is working with. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the ambiguity held open, the deciding element and its counterfactual named, and graded cases that build the threshold by use, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More NUR 643EA papers and MSN samples
- NUR 643EA Topic 1: Skill Performed and Taught
- NUR 643EA Topic 2: Think Aloud Examination
- NUR 643EA Topic 3: Documentation for the Next Clinician
- NUR 643EA Topic 5: Expert Blind Spot Dq Pair
- NUR 643EA Topic 6: Reflex Exam Across Three Ages
- NUR 643EA Topic 7: Learner Technique Correction
- NUR 643EA Topic 8: Single Skill Teaching Plan
- NUR 646EA Topic 4: Evaluation Method Justification
- NUR 641EA Topic 4: Resistant Misconception Study
- NUR 648EA Topic 4: Earned Independence Rationale
- NUR 635 Topic 4: Respiratory Therapy Plan
NUR 643EA Topic 4 questions, answered
Why is a rule the wrong thing to give a novice?
Because both ways of following one fail. A novice who applies it strictly flags every variation and stops being useful, and a novice who applies it loosely misses the case it was written for. The example argues that a threshold is built by working cases near the boundary, and that saying so is a teaching position a rubric can credit.
Does the paper have to reach a definite call?
It reaches one, and it says what the call rests on. What it avoids is pretending the call was obvious from the start, since the whole teaching half depends on the ambiguity being real. A page that resolves the feature in its first sentence has removed the thing the topic exists to work with.
How many graded cases belong in the series?
The instructions posted in your classroom set the scope, and sections differ. What the rubric responds to is whether the cases move the boundary in small steps and whether at least one of them was hard enough to catch somebody. A long series of easy cases takes more space and shows less than three that sit near the line.
Where can I find a free NUR 643EA Topic 4 sample paper?
The paper for NUR 643EA Topic 4 covers the feature as it presented, what surrounded it, why no rule can be handed over, graded cases that move the boundary, the third case where it broke and the case to add. Your own NUR 643EA Topic 4 prompt gets a free paper.
Is a split second heart sound in a young adult usually normal in NUR 643EA Topic 4?
Often, when it widens on inspiration and narrows or closes on expiration or sitting up. A fixed or persistent wide split needs further workup.