PSY 839 Topic 1 intervention matching rationale example

Performance Enhancement Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PSY 839 Topic 1 sample paper starts from a head coach's two-line referral saying that Riley, a composite softball pitcher, "loses focus in games" and needs toughness work. It was written for GCU PSY 839, Performance Enhancement, catalog code PSY-839, part of Grand Canyon University's PhD in Psychology. Three parties are named and Riley is treated as the client under APA Standard 3.07. Consent comes before assessment. Interview, game observation and Butler and Hardy's performance profile redefine the problem as composure lost after disputed calls. Self-talk refocusing, backed by Hatzigeorgiadis and colleagues, is chosen over the standard package. The scenario is a composite.

CoursePSY 839 Performance Enhancement
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeIntervention matching rationale
LengthAbout 1,300 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramPhD in Psychology
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for PSY 839 Topic 1

1

Composure After a Disputed Call: Redefining a Coach's Focus Referral and Matching One Intervention to a Collegiate Pitcher

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

PSY-839: Performance Enhancement

Topic 1 Intervention Matching Rationale

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title names the redefined problem and the matching task. The pitcher, coach and department are composites built for coursework; the sources are real.
2

Composure After a Disputed Call: Redefining a Coach's Focus Referral and Matching One Intervention to a Collegiate Pitcher

The Referral as Written

The head softball coach at a composite university sent a two-line referral to the athletic department's performance consultant: the starting pitcher, Riley, a junior, "loses focus in games" and needs "mental toughness work" before conference play. The coach attached box scores from three losses. Riley did not ask for help, had not been told the referral was coming and learned of it from the coach at practice.

Every element of that referral is a claim, not a finding. "Loses focus" is the coach's interpretation of what happened, "mental toughness work" is a proposed remedy, and the box scores show runs allowed without showing why. This rationale settles whose interests are in play, records how consent was obtained, uses assessment to redefine the problem and then compares three candidate interventions before selecting one.

Three Parties With Different Interests

Three parties have a stake in the work. The coach wants wins in conference play and has authority over Riley's innings. The athletic department employs the consultant, pays for the service and has an interest in athletes' welfare as well as results. Riley would receive the intervention, would bear any cost of disclosure and has interests that extend beyond this season, including a possible professional career and a degree.

These interests can conflict. A coach who learns that a pitcher is struggling psychologically might reduce the pitcher's innings, which would serve the team's short-term interest and harm Riley's. The APA ethics code requires that when services are requested by a third party, the psychologist clarify at the outset the relationship with each party, including who is the client and the probable uses of the information obtained (American Psychological Association, 2017, Standard 3.07). Here the consultant treats Riley as the client and the coach as the referral source, and that arrangement is put to Riley before any assessment begins.

Consent Before Any Assessment

The first meeting with Riley was about consent, not about pitching. The consultant explained what performance work involves, that it is voluntary and that declining would carry no penalty from the department. The consultant also set out what the coach would be told: whether Riley chose to take part and, with Riley's agreement, a general description of the plan, but not the content of conversations. The exceptions to confidentiality, such as a risk of serious harm, were stated plainly.

Riley agreed to an assessment of three sessions and reserved the decision about any intervention until after hearing the results. That reservation matters. Informed consent in this setting is not a signature collected once; the ethics code describes it as covering the nature and course of the service and the involvement of third parties (American Psychological Association, 2017, Standard 3.10), and those details are not yet known at the first meeting. Agreeing step by step keeps Riley's consent informed as the work takes shape.

What Assessment Found

Assessment combined three sources. An interview asked Riley to describe good and poor outings in detail. Observation of two games recorded what happened between pitches, including posture, time taken and interactions with the catcher. The third source was a performance profile, a method Butler and Hardy (1992) developed in which athletes name the qualities they believe matter for top performance in their own position, rate their ideal level on each and rate their current level. Because the athlete generates the qualities, the profile records the performer's own account of the problem rather than the coach's.

Table 1

Assessment Sources and the Formulation They Support

SourceWhat it showedWeight given
Coach's referralGeneral loss of focus in gamesStarting hypothesis only
InterviewFrustration after calls Riley considered wrongModerate; self-report
Game observationRushed, high pitches in the two pitches after disputed callsHigh; directly observed
Performance profileLargest gaps on letting go of bad calls and staying even after a walkHigh; Riley's own priorities

Riley's profile named eleven qualities. The largest gaps between ideal and current ratings were not for concentration but for "letting go of bad calls" and "staying even after a walk." Observation agreed. In both games, the runs that mattered followed a disputed ball call: Riley's time between pitches lengthened, the next two pitches were rushed and high in the zone and the inning got away. Riley's attention in other situations was steady. The formulation that replaces the referral is therefore narrower: Riley loses composure after perceived injustice, specifically disputed calls, and the loss shows within the next few pitches.

Three Candidate Interventions

Three interventions were considered against that formulation. The first is a refocusing plan built on instructional and motivational self-talk: a short cue phrase used between the disputed call and the next pitch, paired with a reset action such as stepping off the circle. Hatzigeorgiadis et al. (2011) reported in a meta-analysis of 32 studies that self-talk interventions produced a moderate positive effect on sport performance, with larger effects for tasks requiring precision and for interventions that included practice of the self-talk. Pitching location is such a task.

The second is the standard mental skills package the department usually delivers, which teaches goal setting, imagery, relaxation and self-talk across eight sessions. The third is an acceptance-based approach drawn from Gardner and Moore (2004), who argued that efforts to control or eliminate negative internal states can backfire and proposed instead that athletes learn to notice frustration without acting on it while keeping attention on the task and on their values. Gardner and Moore presented a theoretical rationale and early case material rather than controlled trials, so the evidence for this option is thinner than for self-talk.

Why the Package Was Set Aside

The package would spend most of its sessions on problems the assessment did not find. Riley already sets goals, has a working pre-pitch routine and reports no difficulty with arousal before games. Teaching those skills would treat Riley as a generic case, use time that conference preparation does not allow and risk losing Riley's engagement in the first weeks, when Riley is still deciding whether the work is worth continuing. A matched intervention addresses the formulation directly and shows Riley that the assessment was taken seriously.

The Selection

The refocusing plan was selected, with one element of the acceptance-based approach added. Riley will learn a reset sequence for use after a disputed call: step off, take one breath, say the cue phrase "next pitch, low glove" and look at the catcher's mitt. The acceptance element is a brief instruction that the frustration does not need to disappear before the next pitch; the aim is to pitch well while frustrated, not to stop feeling frustrated. Riley chose the cue phrase and agreed to practice the sequence in bullpen sessions where the catcher calls deliberate false balls.

The choice rests on three grounds: it targets the formulated problem, the evidence for self-talk in precision tasks is reasonably strong, and Riley preferred a short, concrete sequence to a longer program. The acceptance element is included because Riley described trying hard not to be angry and finding that it made things worse, a pattern Gardner and Moore (2004) would predict.

How Success Will Be Judged

The indicator is specific to the formulation: the proportion of pitches in the strike zone and the runs allowed in the two batters following a disputed call, compared across the first and second halves of conference play. A general measure such as earned run average would mix the target problem with everything else that affects runs. Riley will also rate, after each outing, how well the reset sequence was used, which distinguishes an intervention that failed from one that was not applied. The coach will be told that the work is under way and that results will be reviewed at midseason with Riley's agreement on what is shared.

References

American Psychological Association. (2017). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct (2002, amended effective June 1, 2010, and January 1, 2017). https://www.apa.org/ethics/code

Butler, R. J., & Hardy, L. (1992). The performance profile: Theory and application. The Sport Psychologist, 6(3), 253-264. https://doi.org/10.1123/tsp.6.3.253

Gardner, F. L., & Moore, Z. E. (2004). A mindfulness-acceptance-commitment-based approach to athletic performance enhancement: Theoretical considerations. Behavior Therapy, 35(4), 707-723. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0005-7894(04)80016-9

Hatzigeorgiadis, A., Zourbanos, N., Galanis, E., & Theodorakis, Y. (2011). Self-talk and sports performance: A meta-analysis. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 6(4), 348-356. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691611413136

PSY 839 Topic 1 instructions, in plain terms

Topic 1 in PSY-839 asks doctoral students to match an intervention to a performer. Strong rationales open with the referral as written and treat its description of the problem as a claim. Students should name who requested the work and who receives it, record how consent was obtained and what will be reported, and assess the problem from more than one source, including the performer's own view. The rationale should compare several candidate interventions against the resulting formulation with evidence for each, explain why a standard package was set aside and name an indicator that would show whether the chosen intervention is working.

How the PSY-839 Topic 1 example is put together

The finished rationale opens with the referral as the coach wrote it, a request to fix a composite collegiate pitcher's focus, and notes that the pitcher did not ask for help. Its first substantive section records the consent conversation: what the work involves, what the coach will and will not be told, and the pitcher's right to decline. Assessment follows, combining an interview, game observation and Richard Butler and Lew Hardy's performance profile, where the pitcher names the qualities she values. The pattern that emerges is not general inattention but a loss of composure after disputed calls. A comparison then weighs a refocusing plan built on self-talk against the full skills package and an acceptance-based option drawn from Frank Gardner and Zella Moore's work, and selects one.

Reading the PSY 839 Topic 1 rubric

Faculty reward a problem redefined before a technique is chosen. An Excellent rationale names the coach, the department and Riley, applies the third-party standard and records consent before assessment. Credit goes to combining interview, observation and Butler and Hardy's performance profile in a table that narrows focus to composure after disputed calls. The rubric values weighing self-talk, the standard package and Gardner and Moore's acceptance approach on evidence. Strong rationales explain the package's rejection. Top marks go to an indicator measured on the two batters after a disputed call.

Common PSY 839 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

A rationale that begins with techniques and fits the performer to them has skipped the matching the topic is named for, and most lost credit traces to that order. Papers that never ask who requested the work treat the coach's description of the problem as a finding. Consent is often mentioned in a sentence and never described, leaving unclear what the athlete agreed to and what will be reported. Another deduction follows when assessment consists of the coach's account alone, since a performer's own view of the problem is part of the evidence. Comparisons listing interventions without evidence for each cannot justify the selection. Rationales closing without any indicator of success give the consultant no way to tell a matched intervention from a mismatched one.

Get a PSY-839 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the PSY-839 Topic 1 instructions, the rubric and the case or referral your section supplied. A custom example is written to those criteria, naming who requested the work, recording consent, redefining the problem through assessment and matching one intervention to it, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More PSY 839 papers and PhD in Psychology samples

PSY 839 Topic 1 questions, answered

What is a performance profile?

An assessment method developed by Butler and Hardy in which the performer identifies the qualities they believe matter for excellence in their role, then rates their current level and the level they aim for on each. Because the performer generates the qualities, the profile gives the consultant the athlete's own account of the problem, which is useful when someone else made the referral.

Why not deliver the full skills package?

Because a package addresses problems in general and this rationale is about one problem in particular. Delivering goal setting, imagery, relaxation and self-talk together spends the performer's limited time and patience on techniques the assessment did not indicate, and it makes evaluation harder, since no one can tell which component did anything. Matching also shows the performer that the work is about them.

What is an acceptance-based approach?

An approach that aims to change how a performer relates to unwanted thoughts and feelings rather than to reduce or control them. Gardner and Moore's Mindfulness-Acceptance-Commitment approach is the best-known version in sport, drawing on acceptance and commitment therapy. The rationale considers it alongside change-based methods because the evidence base for both is still developing and the performer's preference matters.

Where can I find a free PSY 839 Topic 1 sample paper?

The rationale for PSY 839 Topic 1 covers the referral, three parties, consent, what assessment found, three candidates, why the package was set aside, the selection and how success will be judged. Send your PSY 839 Topic 1 prompt and a rationale follows free.

Why is the coach not the client in PSY 839 Topic 1?

The coach referred the pitcher, but the pitcher receives the service and bears the cost of any disclosure. The paper settles that at the outset, as the ethics standard on third-party requests requires.