PSY 839 Topic 5 skeptical performer dq post example

Performance Enhancement Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PSY 839 Topic 5 sample paper sets out, through one post and two replies, how a consultant should meet Drew, a composite veteran midfielder sent by the head coach who doubts the sessions are worth the time. It belongs to GCU PSY 839, Performance Enhancement, listed as PSY-839, built into the Grand Canyon University PhD in Psychology. The doubt is granted as reasonable, and consent and confidentiality limits are settled first. Miller and Rollnick's motivational interviewing guides a short trial Drew defines. Replies explain why a research-heavy pitch backfires and cite Linder and colleagues and Martin on stigma. Each reply cites research.

CoursePSY 839 Performance Enhancement
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeSkeptical performer DQ post
LengthAbout 490 words, 1 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramPhD in Psychology
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for PSY 839 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Two Replies

A Skeptic Worth Listening To: Consent and Collaboration With a Coach-Referred Midfielder

Initial Post

The veteran midfielder's doubt is usually a reasonable judgment, and it calls for collaboration rather than persuasion. Drew, a composite fifth-year player sent by the head coach, has heard a great deal of mindset advice over the years with little evidence behind it, and did not choose to come. Treating that doubt as resistance to overcome would repeat the experience that produced it.

Consent comes before anything else. A coach's referral does not oblige the athlete, and participation that is not voluntary is not consent in any meaningful sense. The first conversation should establish that Drew may decline without consequence from the consultant, explain what the coach will and will not be told and state the limits of confidentiality. If those terms are not settled first, everything that follows rests on an agreement Drew never made.

The method I would use draws on Miller and Rollnick (2013), whose motivational interviewing avoids arguing for change, asks open questions that elicit the person's own reasons for and against it and supports the person's autonomy over the decision. Their central observation is that arguing for change tends to provoke the person to argue the other side, strengthening the case against it. With Drew, that means asking what has and has not helped in the past, what Drew would want from the remaining season and what would make a session worth the time. If Drew sees some value, a short trial follows, with success judged by a result Drew names, such as composure after conceding a goal.

A question for the group: when, if ever, should a consultant keep working with an athlete who remains unconvinced after a fair trial?

Reply to Jordan

Jordan, your plan was to win Drew over by presenting the strongest research on mental skills in the first session. I see the appeal, but I think it is likely to backfire. Miller and Rollnick (2013) describe how presenting arguments for change to someone who is ambivalent tends to draw out counterarguments, so a research summary may lead Drew to list every reason it does not apply. It also confirms the suspicion that the consultant is selling something. Would you consider asking Drew what evidence would be convincing, and offering a small trial to collect it?

Reply to Morgan

Morgan, you raised the possibility that Drew's reluctance is partly about how teammates would see it, and I think the research supports you. Linder et al. (1991) found that athletes described as consulting a sport psychologist were rated less favorably than the same athletes described otherwise, a negative halo effect. Martin (2005) found that college athletes, particularly men in contact sports, reported more stigma toward sport psychology consulting than other groups. Meeting Drew somewhere other than the team facility, or framing the sessions as performance work open to the whole squad, might reduce that cost.

References

Linder, D. E., Brewer, B. W., Van Raalte, J. L., & DeLange, N. (1991). A negative halo for athletes who consult sport psychologists: Replication and extension. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 13(2), 133-148. https://doi.org/10.1123/jsep.13.2.133

Martin, S. B. (2005). High school and college athletes' attitudes toward sport psychology consulting. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 17(2), 127-139. https://doi.org/10.1080/10413200590932434

Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S. (2013). Motivational interviewing: Helping people change (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.

The PSY-839 Topic 5 assignment instructions

Topic 5 in PSY-839 asks doctoral students how to work with a performer who doubts the value of sport psychology. Strong initial posts state the position in the first line, treat the doubt as a judgment worth hearing and settle consent before any method, since a referral does not oblige the athlete. Students should cite an evidence-based collaborative approach and explain why arguing for change tends to backfire. One reply should answer a classmate's persuasion strategy, the other should add research a classmate's point lacks, and every post should carry citations. Each reply should engage what the classmate actually proposed.

How the PSY-839 Topic 5 example is put together

Granting the skeptic's case is the post's first move: a composite veteran midfielder sent by his head coach has met plenty of unsupported advice about mindset, and he did not choose to attend. It then argues that the consultant's first obligation is to confirm he may decline, since participation that is not voluntary is not consent. The method it proposes draws on William Miller and Stephen Rollnick's motivational interviewing: avoiding argument, eliciting his own reasons for or against change and supporting his sense that he can decide. A short trial is offered with a result he names himself. Replying to a classmate who planned to win the athlete over with research findings, the first reply explains why that pitch tends to backfire. Another reply brings sources on the stigma athletes attach to consulting a sport psychologist.

Where the marks sit in the PSY 839 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty reward the skeptic's case granted first. An Excellent post confirms that the midfielder may decline and explains what the coach will hear. Credit goes to Miller and Rollnick's motivational interviewing for eliciting the athlete's own reasons, and to a trial judged by a result Drew names. The rubric values a reply showing why a research pitch draws counterarguments. Top marks go to a reply citing Linder and colleagues' negative halo and Martin's stigma findings, with a practical change to where sessions are held.

Common PSY 839 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Posts treating the athlete's doubt as an obstacle to be removed lose credit at once, because the prompt is about working with skepticism, not defeating it. Initial posts that never mention consent overlook the central complication of a coach-referred performer, who may not have agreed to anything. A persuasion strategy built on citing research tends to confirm the athlete's view that the consultant is selling something, and posts proposing one miss the motivational interviewing evidence on why arguing for change strengthens opposition. Some posts go the other way and abandon the athlete at the first objection, which is capitulation rather than collaboration. Replies that praise a classmate's empathy without engaging the method add little. Posts silent on confidentiality leave unresolved what the coach will hear.

Get a PSY-839 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Include the PSY-839 Topic 5 prompt, the discussion rubric and the classmate posts your replies must answer. A custom example is written to those criteria within 24 to 48 hours, with an initial post that grants the skeptic's case, settles consent and proposes a collaborative method, plus two replies with sources. The first one is free.

More PSY 839 papers and PhD in Psychology samples

PSY 839 Topic 5 questions, answered

What is motivational interviewing?

A collaborative conversational method developed by Miller and Rollnick, originally for helping people resolve ambivalence about changing behavior. It emphasizes empathy, avoiding argument, drawing out the person's own reasons and respecting their autonomy to decide. Its use in performance settings is an adaptation, and the post treats it as a way to structure the conversation with a doubtful athlete, not as treatment.

Can a coach require an athlete to see a consultant?

A coach can make the request and may control team expectations, but a performer's participation in psychological work should be voluntary and informed. The post argues that a consultant should confirm this directly with the athlete, explain what will and will not be shared with the coach, and accept a refusal. Work begun under compulsion rarely produces engagement and raises real ethical questions.

Why do athletes resist sport psychology?

Several reasons appear in the literature and in practice. Some athletes associate consulting a psychologist with weakness or with clinical problems, some have encountered unsupported material presented as psychology, and some resent being sent by a coach. Research on the stigma attached to sport psychology consultation suggests that how the service is introduced and named affects willingness to engage.

Where can I find a free PSY 839 Topic 5 sample paper?

An opening post on the skeptical midfielder appears here in full, followed by replies to two classmates on persuasion and stigma. Forward the PSY 839 Topic 5 prompt you received for a free post.

Why not persuade the athlete with research in PSY 839 Topic 5?

Presenting arguments for change to someone who is ambivalent tends to draw out counterarguments, and it confirms the suspicion that the consultant is selling something. Asking what evidence would convince the athlete works better.