BUS 655 Topic 5 promotion attribution dq post example

Sports Business Analytics Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

In this BUS 655 Topic 5 sample paper, an initial discussion post claims that a giveaway night's crowd overstates what the giveaway did, and a short response to a classmate follows. The post belongs to GCU BUS 655, Sports Business Analytics, catalog code BUS-655, within the Grand Canyon University MBA with an Emphasis in Sports Business. The club in question, a composite, drew 7,200 on a July Saturday scarf night, but its attendance model expected 6,300 without a promotion. Matches either side came in below their own expected levels, so the net lift falls to about 450. First-time buyers suggest roughly 290 of that is new demand. Against $21,000 of scarves, the night likely lost money.

CourseBUS 655 Sports Business Analytics
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeDiscussion post and reply
LengthAbout 520 words, 3 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for BUS 655 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

The Scarf Night Crowd Was 7,200, but the Scarf Brought Perhaps 450: Separating a Promotion's Effect From the Date It Was Given

Initial Post

The crowd on our club's scarf giveaway night overstates what the giveaway did, possibly by half or more, and the marketing team's plan to double the number of giveaways next season rests on that overstatement.

The composite club I am analyzing gave 5,000 scarves to the first fans through the gates on a Saturday evening in July against a familiar league opponent. Turnstile scans reached 7,200, the second-largest crowd of the season, and marketing called it the giveaway's result. But three different quantities are being blurred. There is the crowd that came, the crowd that date would have drawn anyway, and the crowd that was borrowed from other matches.

The second quantity comes from the club's attendance model. A July Saturday evening against that opponent, with no rain in the forecast, was already the strongest slot on the calendar, and the model expected 6,300 people with no promotion. That leaves about 900 above expectation.

The third quantity is the one most often missed. The home matches immediately before and after, a Wednesday and the following Saturday, each came in below their own expected levels, by about 250 and 200. Some fans who would have come to one of those matches simply moved to scarf night. Subtracting the dip leaves a net lift of about 450 fans. Studies of baseball promotions found real attendance effects, but also that their size varies widely by type and timing, which is why each one needs its own estimate (McDonald & Rascher, 2000).

First-time buyers offer a check. The ticketing system recorded 610 first-time buyers that night against a usual 320 for a Saturday, so roughly 290 of the lift looks like new demand rather than regulars moving dates. That is the part worth paying for, if those buyers come back.

The scarves cost about $21,000. At roughly $32 in ticket and concession revenue per fan, 450 extra fans bring in about $14,400. On these illustrative numbers the night lost money unless enough first-time buyers return, which the club can track over the next season. Measuring promotional returns precisely is hard even with large samples, so a club with one giveaway a year should expect wide uncertainty and say so (Lewis & Rao, 2015).

What this page is doingThe post names three quantities the prompt tends to blur and works through each with a source for the expected figure, so the net effect is derived rather than asserted.
2

Reply to Jordan

Jordan, I see why you read the full 7,200 as the effect: the crowd was nearly 2,000 above the season average, and the timing lines up perfectly with the giveaway. My concern is that the season average is the wrong comparison. Your club's promotion fell on a summer Saturday too, which is when crowds are largest whether or not anything is handed out. Could you run the night through your attendance model, or simply compare it with the same fixture on a Saturday the season before? If the gap shrinks a lot, the giveaway may still be worth it, but for the first-time buyers it brings rather than for the size of the crowd. I would also look at whether your midweek match that same week came in light.

What this page is doingThe reply explains why the classmate's reading is understandable, identifies the specific comparison that misleads and offers two checks the classmate can run with data already available.
3

References

Lewis, R. A., & Rao, J. M. (2015). The unfavorable economics of measuring the returns to advertising. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 130(4), 1941-1973. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjv023

McDonald, M., & Rascher, D. (2000). Does bat day make cents? The effect of promotions on the demand for Major League Baseball. Journal of Sport Management, 14(1), 8-27. https://doi.org/10.1123/jsm.14.1.8

What the BUS 655 Topic 5 instructions ask for

In BUS-655 Topic 5 the discussion question asks how to tell what a promotion actually achieved. A post that reports the crowd on promotion night as the effect misses the point. Credit goes to a disputable claim plus a clear separation of the crowd that came, the crowd the date would have drawn anyway and the crowd moved from other matches. Students should use an attendance model or comparable fixture for the expected figure, check nearby matches for borrowed demand, look for evidence of genuinely new buyers, compare the result with the promotion's cost and acknowledge the uncertainty involved.

How this BUS 655 Topic 5 example is built

The initial post opens with its claim and a consequence for next season's plans. The scarf night is described with its crowd of 7,200. Three quantities are named and worked through: the expected 6,300 from the attendance model, the dips of 250 and 200 at the matches either side, and a net lift of about 450. Research on baseball promotions supports estimating each one separately. First-time buyers show how much is new demand, and a cost comparison closes the post. The reply to Jordan explains why the season average misleads and suggests two checks using data the classmate already has.

BUS 655 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Instructors grading the discussion reward a post that separates gross crowd from net effect with figures. The strongest posts name an expected baseline from a model or comparable date and explain where it came from. Credit goes to checking neighboring matches for demand that simply moved, a step many posts skip. The rubric values evidence of new demand, such as first-time buyers, and a comparison of the effect with what the promotion cost. Excellent replies explain why a classmate's reading is understandable before showing the comparison that misleads, and they suggest checks the classmate can run. Posts that equate the crowd with the effect usually score low.

BUS 655 Topic 5 help before you submit

Posts that report the promotion's crowd as its effect repeat the error the prompt is written to expose. Answers that mention cannibalization as a concept and never look at the adjacent dates earn little for it, since the check is cheap and the data sits in the ticketing system. A baseline chosen loosely, the season average rather than the expected crowd for that slot, inflates the lift of any promotion scheduled on a strong date, and nearly all giveaways are. The opposite overreach also costs credit: declaring the promotion worthless because the crowd would have been large anyway, without estimating what it added, swaps one assertion for another. A reply that only seconds the classmate leaves participation points on the table. Attendance invented for a named club is a defect, whereas composite dates with labeled figures are fine.

Get a BUS-655 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the BUS-655 Topic 5 discussion question as it appears in your classroom, the participation rubric and any classmate post you must answer. The custom example is written to those criteria, with the crowd separated from the effect, a baseline built, adjacent dates checked and a reply that engages the other view, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More BUS 655 papers and MBA samples

BUS 655 Topic 5 questions, answered

Why not compare the promotion night with the season average?

Because promotions are rarely scheduled on average dates. Clubs put giveaways on weekends in good weather against popular opponents, which are the dates that sell best anyway. Comparing with the season average credits the promotion with the advantage of its slot. An expected crowd for that specific date, from a model or from matched past dates, is the fairer comparison.

What is cannibalization in attendance?

Demand that a promotion moves rather than creates. A fan who would have attended Friday switches to Saturday for the giveaway, so Saturday gains, Friday loses and the club's season total barely changes. Checking the dates around the promotion against their own expected levels shows whether that happened, and subtracting the shortfall gives a truer picture of what the promotion added.

Can a discussion post really estimate a causal effect?

It can estimate one honestly, with its assumptions stated, which is what the prompt usually wants. A post will not settle the question the way a planned experiment would, and saying so strengthens it. Many strong answers end by proposing the test that would settle it, such as alternating promotions across comparable dates, which leads naturally into later topics on testing decisions.

Where can I find a free BUS 655 Topic 5 sample paper?

Both the opening post on the scarf night and the reply to Jordan appear here with margin notes. Share the promotion you are analyzing and the figures you have, and a free post can be written around them.

How big was the giveaway effect in BUS 655 Topic 5?

About 450 fans, not 7,200. The attendance model expected 6,300 for that date, and the matches either side came in about 450 below their expected levels, suggesting some fans simply moved to the giveaway night.