| Course | DBA 960 Dissertation II |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Permission scope reconciliation |
| Length | About 950 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 960 Topic 1
Three Documents, One Study? Reconciling a Protocol, a Site Letter and a Finance Agreement Before Collection Begins
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-960: Dissertation II
Topic 1 Permission Scope Reconciliation
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Three Documents, One Study? Reconciling a Protocol, a Site Letter and a Finance Agreement Before Collection Begins
Why Reconcile Before Collecting
A doctoral candidate who works as a category manager at a composite regional grocery chain is about to begin collecting data for a study of how promotional funding from suppliers shapes shelf allocation decisions. Three documents authorize the work. The university's review board approved the research protocol. A regional vice president signed a site letter permitting the study. And the finance department signed a data agreement covering access to promotional records. Each was obtained separately, months apart, and each was written by different people with different concerns. Before any record is gathered, the candidate has laid them side by side to confirm that they describe the same study. The federal regulations governing research with human subjects place the responsibility for conducting research as approved on the investigator (Protection of human subjects, 2018), and collecting data outside what was permitted, even inadvertently, would put the study and its participants at risk.
The Dimensions Any Permission Must Settle
Every permission must settle six things: who signed and on what authority, which data, which period, which participants, what use and what publication. Bell et al. (2019) noted that access in business research is typically negotiated with several gatekeepers, each controlling a different part of what the researcher needs, which is why the documents can diverge without anyone intending it. The reconciliation compares the three documents on these six dimensions.
Table 1
Three Permission Documents Compared on Six Dimensions
| Dimension | Approved protocol | Site letter | Finance agreement | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who signed, on what authority | Review board | Regional vice president, merchandising | Finance director | Vice president does not control finance systems |
| Which data | Supplier-level promotional funding extracts; shelf plans; interviews | Sales data, in general terms | Promotional funding records, summary level | Letter vague; finance offers summary, protocol needs supplier level |
| Which period | Three fiscal years | Not stated | Two fiscal years | One year missing |
| Which participants | Category managers and merchandisers | Merchandising staff | Not applicable | Consistent |
| What use | Doctoral dissertation | Research study | Internal research only | Finance term may bar the dissertation |
| What publication | Dissertation and journal articles | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Publication unaddressed |
Four Gaps
The table exposes four gaps. The first is authority. The regional vice president who signed the site letter controls merchandising staff and can permit interviews with them, but has no authority over the finance system that holds promotional funding records. The site letter cannot extend to those records, whatever its wording.
The second is scope of data. The site letter mentions sales data in general terms, and the finance agreement offers promotional funding records at summary level, by category and quarter. The protocol requests supplier-level extracts, because the study asks whether funding from particular suppliers is associated with their shelf space. Summary data cannot answer that question.
The third is period. Finance agreed to two fiscal years; the protocol names three, chosen so that the study spans a change in the chain's promotional policy. Two years would leave the change at the edge of the data.
The fourth is publication. No document mentions it. The finance agreement restricts use to internal research only, a phrase written for analysts that could be read to bar a dissertation that will be published and archived.
Resolutions Sought
For each gap the reconciliation records the resolution sought, from whom, and whether collection waits for it. Interviews with merchandising staff can begin now, since the site letter and protocol agree on them and neither depends on the finance records still under discussion. Collection of promotional records waits for all three finance resolutions.
On authority, the candidate will ask the finance director to confirm in writing that the finance agreement, not the site letter, governs access to funding records. On scope, the candidate will ask finance to extend the agreement to supplier-level extracts, with supplier names replaced by codes, which addresses finance's concern about disclosing commercial terms while preserving the analysis. On period, the candidate will request the third year and, if finance refuses, will seek the review board's approval for a protocol amendment narrowing the study to two years and moving the policy change to a secondary question. On publication, the candidate will ask finance and the vice president to confirm that the dissertation, with suppliers and the chain disguised, may be published, and will provide the disguise plan for their review.
The Politics Behind the Gaps
The gaps are not careless drafting. Each signatory wrote to protect something. Finance limited the period and level of detail because supplier funding terms are commercially sensitive and are negotiated under confidentiality. The vice president signed a general letter because a specific one would have required consulting finance. Gatekeepers grant access to protect their own interests as well as to help, and what they grant can move as their positions do (Cunliffe & Alcadipani, 2016). Reconciling the documents now, while the parties are willing, is easier than discovering the gaps after a supplier complains.
What Happens If a Resolution Is Refused
If finance refuses supplier-level data, the study cannot answer its central question with records and would rely on interviews alone, a weaker design the candidate would take to the chair before proceeding. If publication is refused, the study cannot proceed at this site, and the candidate would rather learn that now than after a year of collection.
Every exchange in this process, including telephone conversations, which will be confirmed afterward by email, will be kept in writing and filed with the protocol, so that the review board, the chair and the company can see what was asked, what was agreed and when. If any resolution changes what the protocol describes, the amendment goes to the review board before the affected data are collected, not after.
References
Bell, E., Bryman, A., & Harley, B. (2019). Business research methods (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.
Cunliffe, A. L., & Alcadipani, R. (2016). The politics of access in fieldwork: Immersion, backstage dramas, and deception. Organizational Research Methods, 19(4), 535-561. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428116639134
Protection of human subjects, 45 C.F.R. pt. 46 (2018).
Reading the GCU DBA 960 Topic 1 instructions
Topic 1 in DBA-960 asks doctoral students to confirm that their permissions cover what data collection will actually touch. Strong reconciliations compare every permission document on the same dimensions, including who signed and on what authority, which data, which period, which participants, what use and what publication. Students should identify each gap, explain why it matters for the analysis, and record the resolution sought, from whom and whether collection waits for it. The paper should consider why the documents diverged and state what happens to the study if a needed resolution is refused.
Inside the DBA 960 Topic 1 example
The finished reconciliation is a comparison table with a short commentary, and it describes the permission documents rather than reproducing or drafting them. Down the left run the dimensions any permission has to settle: who signed and on what authority, which data, which period, which participants, what use and what publication. Across the top sit the three documents. The table exposes four gaps. The regional vice president who signed the site letter controls merchandising staff but not the finance system that holds promotional funding records. The letter mentions sales data in general while the protocol requests supplier-level extracts. Finance agreed to two fiscal years where the protocol names three. No document mentions publication at all. For each gap the commentary records the resolution sought, from whom, and whether collection waits for it.
DBA 960 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward permissions checked before collection starts. An Excellent reconciliation compares protocol, site letter and finance agreement on six dimensions in one table, following Bell, Bryman and Harley on multiple gatekeepers. Credit goes to finding a signatory without authority over finance records, summary data where supplier-level extracts are needed, a missing year and silence on publication. The rubric values resolutions with named sources and the federal rule placing responsibility on the investigator. Strong papers read gatekeeper interests with Cunliffe and Alcadipani. Top marks go to stating what a refusal would end.
DBA 960 Topic 1 help before you submit
Reconciliations earn the least when they treat a signed site letter as settling everything, since a signature is only as broad as the signer's authority and grocery finance systems rarely belong to merchandising. Candidates also lose credit by resolving a mismatch in favor of the protocol, collecting three years because the university approved three when the organization released two. A frequent omission is publication, which none of the documents mention and which becomes contentious the moment findings disappoint the company. Some papers identify gaps accurately and then begin collection while resolutions are pending, which turns a careful document into a record of knowing risk. Tables comparing documents on data alone miss participants, period and use. A reconciliation with no dates, and no record of when each gap closed, cannot show the committee that collection actually waited.
Get a DBA-960 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-960 Topic 1 instructions and your classroom rubric. We write a custom structural example to them, showing permissions reconciled against the approved protocol, in 24 to 48 hours, and the first one is free. A dissertation is the candidate's own work: we never write chapters for a reader, and your IRB application, site permission letters, committee correspondence and signatures remain yours.
More DBA 960 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 960 Topic 2: Within-firm Recruitment Protocol
- DBA 960 Topic 3: Sensitivity Exclusion Log
- DBA 960 Topic 4: Fieldwork Departure Log
- DBA 960 Topic 5: Collection Shortfall Dq Post
- DBA 960 Topic 6: Decliner Profile Analysis
- DBA 960 Topic 7: Firm Disguise Test
- DBA 960 Topic 8: Achieved Sample Description
- DBA 955 Topic 1: Dissertation Problem Statement
- MGT 805 Topic 1: Structural Trade-off Essay
- DBA 839 Topic 1: Platform Postmortem Essay
- MGT 820 Topic 1: Analytics Advantage Thesis
DBA 960 Topic 1 questions, answered
What if my site permission does not match my IRB approval?
Resolve the difference before collecting anything. Usually that means either obtaining broader permission from someone entitled to give it or amending the approved protocol, via institutional review, to match what the organization released. Both routes appear in the composite grocery study, where the protocol is narrowed to the period finance agreed to release rather than collecting beyond it.
Who counts as an authorized signatory?
Someone whose position lets them bind the organization on the particular records or staff in question. Seniority alone does not qualify a signer when the records belong to another function. The example finds a merchandising vice president who could approve staff interviews but not the release of finance records, and it seeks confirmation from the office that actually controls those records.
Can collection start while one permission is still pending?
Only for data sources the confirmed permissions already cover, and many candidates wait regardless so the whole dataset is gathered under one consistent set of terms. The example leaves every source touched by an open gap alone until that gap closes, and dates each closure, so a committee reading the log later can see that nothing was gathered ahead of its authorization.
Where can I find a free DBA 960 Topic 1 sample paper?
The reconciliation is shown here complete: why reconcile first, six dimensions in a comparison table, four gaps, resolutions sought, the politics behind the gaps and what a refusal would mean. A paper written to your DBA 960 Topic 1 prompt costs nothing.
Why can interviews begin before records in DBA 960 Topic 1?
The site letter and protocol agree on interviews with merchandising staff, and those do not depend on finance. Promotional records wait until finance resolves authority, scope, period and publication.