DBA 960 Topic 7 firm disguise test example

Dissertation II Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 960 Topic 7 sample paper tests whether industry readers could identify a composite specialty coatings producer, one of few in its North American niche, from a dissertation's site description. It forms part of GCU DBA 960, Dissertation II, catalog code DBA-960, a doctoral seminar in Grand Canyon University's DBA. Seven attributes, from headcount and region to a trade-press expansion, are kept generalized, removed or altered by need, as a table records. Following Kaiser and Saunders and colleagues, quotations go to broad groups, not titles. Online searches and two outside industry readers test the result, and the Belmont Report shapes what insiders may still recognize.

CourseDBA 960 Dissertation II
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeFirm disguise test
LengthAbout 970 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 960 Topic 7

1

Could an Industry Reader Name It? Testing the Disguise of a Specialty Coatings Producer Before the Dissertation Describes It

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

DBA-960: Dissertation II

Topic 7 Firm Disguise Test

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the test. The candidate and the coatings producer are composites; the sources are real. Details are illustrative.
2

Could an Industry Reader Name It? Testing the Disguise of a Specialty Coatings Producer Before the Dissertation Describes It

Why Disguise Must Be Tested

A doctoral candidate has studied how a composite specialty coatings producer decides when to pass raw material cost increases on to its industrial customers. The producer is one of only a few firms in its North American niche, coatings for agricultural and construction equipment, and anyone who knows the industry could probably identify it from a careless description. The firm agreed to the study on the condition that it would not be identifiable, and participants were promised confidentiality. Kaiser (2009) argued that the main threat to confidentiality in qualitative research is not data theft but the identification of participants from details in published findings, which researchers often underestimate. Disguise is therefore treated here as a factual claim about what readers can infer, to be tested, not a label to be applied.

Attributes That Could Point to the Firm

The site description as first drafted contained seven attributes that could identify the firm: its headcount, about 420 employees; its region, the upper Midwest; its product line; its market position as the second-largest supplier in its niche; a plant expansion covered last year in the trade press; the chief executive's public remarks on pricing at an industry conference; and its ownership by a family holding company. Each was judged, one by one, against the argument the dissertation makes, which concerns how a mid-sized supplier facing much larger customers decides on price increases.

Table 1

Identifying Attributes and Their Treatment

AttributeNeeded for the argument?Treatment
Headcount, about 420Partly: scale relative to customers mattersGeneralized to mid-sized, 300 to 600 employees
Upper MidwestNoRemoved
Product line, agricultural and construction equipment coatingsPartly: industrial customers matterGeneralized to industrial equipment coatings
Second-largest in nicheYes: bargaining position mattersKept as one of a few suppliers in its niche
Plant expansion in trade pressNoRemoved
CEO's public remarks on pricingNoRemoved; quotations not used
Family holding company ownershipPartly: affects time horizonGeneralized to privately held

Attributes the argument needs are kept in generalized form. Those it does not need are removed. A few nonessential details are altered, such as the number of plants, and the methods chapter will say that some details have been changed to protect the firm without saying which.

Participant Roles

Participant roles need the same treatment, and they are harder. The firm has one technical director, one vice president of sales and a pricing team of three. A quotation attributed to the technical director names that person to anyone in the industry and to every colleague at the firm. Saunders et al. (2015) described the compromises researchers make between anonymity and the richness of data, noting that participants may be identifiable to people who know them even when strangers cannot identify them. The dissertation therefore attributes quotations to broad groups, commercial staff, technical staff and senior management, rather than to titles, and removes from quotations any detail that only one person could know. Where a quotation cannot be made safe without losing its point, it is paraphrased or dropped.

The Reader Test

The revised description is then tested. Two readers from the coatings industry, outside the firm and with no connection to the study, are given the site description and a sample of disguised quotations and asked to identify the firm and, if they can, any participant. The readers are recruited through the candidate's chair from an industry advisory board, sign a confidentiality agreement and are told only that the study concerns pricing in industrial coatings. Each reader records how they reasoned, so that any detail that gave the firm away can be traced. If either reader names the firm, or narrows it to two candidates, the description is revised and tested again with a new reader.

Searching for the Firm Online

Before the reader test, the candidate runs a simpler one. Each retained attribute and each distinctive phrase in the quotations is searched online, alone and in combination, to see whether public sources lead to the firm. A phrase a participant used about a customer's purchasing policy, for instance, turned out to echo a trade press interview the firm's sales vice president had given, and the quotation was paraphrased. Industry directories were also checked: a mid-sized, privately held coatings producer serving industrial equipment makers returns about a dozen firms, enough to make identification uncertain, while adding the upper Midwest would have narrowed it to two.

If the Test Fails Twice

If a second reader can still identify the firm after revision, the problem lies in the argument's dependence on the firm's distinctive position, and further disguise would distort the findings. In that case the candidate would return to the firm and ask whether it will accept being identifiable, with participants re-consented on that basis, or would narrow the dissertation's claims to those that can be made without the distinctive details. The candidate would not publish a description known to identify the firm under a promise of confidentiality.

What Disguise Cannot Do

Disguise protects the firm from outsiders more effectively than from insiders. Participants at the firm will likely recognize their own words and may recognize colleagues', whatever the dissertation does. The Belmont Report's principle of respect for persons (National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research, 1979) requires that participants understand such risks when they consent. The consent form told them that colleagues might recognize them in the findings, and the dissertation will be shared with the firm's contact before publication, solely to check for identifying details, not to approve content. That review is limited to identification; if the firm objects to a finding, the finding stays, though the candidate will check that it is fairly worded and supported by the data.

References

Kaiser, K. (2009). Protecting respondent confidentiality in qualitative research. Qualitative Health Research, 19(11), 1632-1641. https://doi.org/10.1177/1049732309350879

National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1979). The Belmont report: Ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research. U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/belmont-report/index.html

Saunders, B., Kitzinger, J., & Kitzinger, C. (2015). Anonymising interview data: Challenges and compromise in practice. Qualitative Research, 15(5), 616-632. https://doi.org/10.1177/1468794114550439

The DBA-960 Topic 7 assignment instructions

The Topic 7 assignment in DBA-960 asks doctoral students to test whether a disguised organization could be identified. Strong tests list every attribute in the draft description that could point to the firm, judge each against what the argument needs and keep, generalize, alter or remove it accordingly. Students should apply the same treatment to participant roles, search public sources for distinctive details and have outside industry readers attempt identification. The paper should state what happens if the test fails and acknowledge that disguise protects better against outsiders than against colleagues inside the firm.

How the DBA-960 Topic 7 example is put together

The finished test begins with the site description as first drafted and lists every attribute in it that could point to the firm: headcount, region, product line, market position, a plant expansion covered by the trade press and the chief executive's public remarks on pricing. Each attribute is then judged against the argument. Some are needed, such as the firm's mid-sized scale relative to its customers, and are kept in generalized form. Others, like the expansion, add nothing and are removed. A few nonessential details are altered, with a note in the methods chapter saying so. Participant roles get the same treatment, since the firm has one technical director and a quotation attributed to that title would name her. Two readers from the coatings industry, outside the firm, then attempt to identify it.

DBA 960 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward disguise treated as a claim to test. An Excellent paper tables seven identifying attributes and their treatment, citing Kaiser on identification through published detail. Credit goes to attributing quotations to groups rather than unique titles, following Saunders and colleagues. The rubric values online searches of retained details and two outside industry readers, with revision after any identification. Strong papers plan for repeated failure. Top marks go to telling participants, under the Belmont Report's respect for persons, that colleagues may still recognize them.

Common DBA 960 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Disguises fail most often because they remove the firm's name and leave everything that identifies it, a regional producer with a stated headcount and product line being recognizable to exactly the sector readers the dissertation is written for. Candidates also lose credit for testing the disguise themselves, since an insider cannot unknow the firm and is the worst judge of what an outsider could infer. Another common gap is attending to the organization and forgetting participants, whose unique titles identify them even when the firm is well hidden. Altered details introduced without disclosure mislead readers about the setting. Some papers overcorrect and generalize the firm until the findings lose the context that made them meaningful. A test that never records what was agreed with the organization leaves the level of description open to dispute after publication.

Get a DBA-960 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-960 Topic 7 instructions and your classroom rubric. We write a custom structural example to them, showing a site description tested against industry readers, in 24 to 48 hours, and the first one is free. A dissertation is the candidate's own work: we never write chapters for a reader, and your IRB application, site permission letters, committee correspondence and signatures remain yours.

More DBA 960 papers and DBA samples

DBA 960 Topic 7 questions, answered

Is removing the company name enough to disguise it?

Rarely. In a concentrated industry, a combination of region, size, product line and a publicized event can single out a firm for people who work in that industry, who are also the dissertation's most likely readers. The example lists every such attribute, decides which the argument needs and generalizes or removes the rest, then asks industry readers outside the firm to attempt an identification.

Can I change details to protect the organization?

Nonessential details can be altered if the methods chapter says that alteration occurred, so readers know the description is not exact. Details the findings depend on should be generalized rather than changed, since altering them would misrepresent the setting. The example alters a few peripheral facts, discloses the practice and keeps the firm's scale relative to its customers because the argument rests on it.

How do I protect participants whose titles are unique?

Group titles before attributing any quotation, so a role held by one person becomes part of a broader category such as senior technical staff. Where even the category is small, consider whether the quotation is needed at all. The example merges roles across the firm and states the residual risk plainly, because in a small niche no disguise is certain.

Where can I find a free DBA 960 Topic 7 sample paper?

The disguise test is shown here complete: why test, identifying attributes and their treatment, participant roles, online searches, the reader test, repeated failure and what disguise cannot do. Post your DBA 960 Topic 7 prompt and get a free test.

Why remove the region in DBA 960 Topic 7?

The argument does not need it, and adding the upper Midwest to the other retained details would narrow matching firms from about a dozen to two. Removing it costs nothing and protects the firm.