MGT 805 Topic 7 divisional redesign proposal example

Designing Organizational Structures Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 805 Topic 7 sample paper proposes moving a composite agricultural equipment manufacturer's precision guidance business into a self-contained division and lists what the change will make harder to see. It sits in GCU MGT 805, Designing Organizational Structures, catalog code MGT-805, near the close of a DBA course on structure. The division of about 310 people would own guidance engineering, subscription sales, renewals and support, while grain handling and irrigation stay functional with product integrators. Four blind spots are traced to their mechanisms: drifting electronics expertise, two dealer contacts, transfer disputes and squeezed experimentation. Each gets a watcher outside the division, and the overhead objection is answered in figures.

CourseMGT 805 Designing Organizational Structures
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeRedesign proposal
LengthAbout 1,170 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 805 Topic 7

1

A Precision Guidance Division and the Four Things It Will See Less Well: A Redesign Proposal for an Agricultural Equipment Manufacturer That Lists Its Own Costs

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

MGT-805: Designing Organizational Structures

Topic 7 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title gives the design and its admitted costs equal billing, which is the standard this proposal sets for itself. Coldwater Implement Company and all figures are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

A Precision Guidance Division and the Four Things It Will See Less Well: A Redesign Proposal for an Agricultural Equipment Manufacturer That Lists Its Own Costs

The Problem

Earlier analysis established two facts about Coldwater Implement Company's precision guidance business. Subscription renewals have fallen from 82 to 71 percent over two years, and software features wait for an annual model-year calendar built for equipment. Both trace to a functional structure in which guidance subscriptions are sold by equipment representatives, renewed by the parts function and released on engineering's manufacturing rhythm. This proposal redesigns the structure for guidance while leaving the slower grain handling and irrigation lines in functions, and it gives as much attention to what the change will break as to what it will fix.

The Design

A precision guidance division of about 310 people would be created, reporting to the chief executive with its own profit and loss. It would hold guidance software engineering and receiver hardware engineering, subscription sales and renewals, and customer support for guidance products. Manufacturing of receivers would remain in the shared plants, which build them alongside other electronics, and the division would buy receivers from manufacturing at a transfer price. Dealer relations would remain with the corporate sales force, which would continue to sell guidance hardware through dealers while a small division team handled subscriptions directly with farmers. Grain handling and irrigation would remain functional, coordinated by two product integrators with defined decision rights.

What this page is doingThe boundary is drawn precisely, including what stays shared, so each blind spot can later be traced to a specific line on it.
3

What the Division Will See Better

Three things would gain an owner. Renewals would belong to the division head, measured monthly instead of annually, with a team whose work is to understand why farmers leave. Release timing would move from the model-year calendar to a schedule set by the division, so finished features could reach subscribers within weeks. Subscriber complaints, now split between the help desk and parts billing, would reach one management team. Each gain has a measure: the monthly renewal rate, the days from a feature's completion to its release, and the share of complaints resolved at first contact. Should none of the three move within twelve months, the design has failed on its own terms.

Four Blind Spots and Their Mechanisms

The division will also see some things less well than the current structure does, and each blind spot comes from a specific feature of the design.

First, electronics expertise will drift. Today the same group of electronics engineers designs guidance receivers, irrigation controllers and grain dryer controls, and they learn from each other's problems. Once guidance engineers work inside the division, their daily contact with the controller engineers who remain in functional engineering will fall, and knowledge that now moves through conversation will stop moving. The effect will be slow and hard to see, which is why it needs watching.

Second, dealers will face two contacts for one farm. A dealer selling a tractor package with a guidance receiver will deal with the corporate sales representative for the hardware and the division's subscription team for the license. Without coordination, farmers will hear two different offers.

Third, receivers sold with grain equipment will create transfer disputes. Some grain carts and dryers are sold with guidance receivers built in. The division will want a high transfer price for those receivers, and the grain line will want a low one. Eccles (1985) shows that transfer pricing disputes in divisional firms are rarely settled by formula, because they reflect real disagreements about strategy and performance measurement.

Fourth, quarterly targets may squeeze experimentation. Mintzberg (1979) argued that headquarters controls divisions mainly through performance measures, and that this pressure pushes divisions toward standardized, formalized structures resembling machine bureaucracy. Subscription software depends on testing features with farmers and abandoning the ones that fail, work that looks like wasted cost in a quarterly profit statement.

What this page is doingEach blind spot is traced to the mechanism that creates it, which lets a reader judge how serious it is.
4

Watchers Placed Outside the Division

Table 1

Watch Measures for the Division's Blind Spots

Blind spotWatch measureOwner
Electronics expertise driftShared components and design reviews across lines per quarterChief technology officer
Two dealer contactsDealer complaints about conflicting offersCorporate sales vice president
Transfer disputesDisputes referred upward and days to settleChief financial officer
Squeezed experimentationShare of engineering time on features in field testChief executive, reviewed with the division head

Each blind spot needs a measure, and where possible the measure should be owned outside the division, since a unit seldom reports clearly on what its own design hides. Table 1 sets out the four.

Cooperation Across the Boundary

Hill et al. (1992) found that related diversified firms perform better with cooperative structures, in which divisions share resources and are evaluated partly on joint results, while unrelated diversifiers perform better with competitive structures that hold each division to its own profit. Coldwater's guidance division is related to the rest of the firm through shared plants, dealers and electronics knowledge. The proposal therefore ties part of the division head's bonus to firm-wide results and requires quarterly joint design reviews with functional engineering, accepting some loss of the clean accountability a fully competitive division would offer.

The Overhead Objection

The strongest objection is that a division of 310 people cannot carry the overhead of its own finance, planning and human resources staff. The duplicated roles would number about nine positions at an illustrative loaded cost of 1.1 million dollars a year. Each point of renewal recovered is worth about 312,000 dollars a year in revenue. The division would therefore cover its added overhead by recovering about four points of renewal, a little over a third of the eleven points lost in two years. On the division's own plan, that recovery would occur within its second year.

What this page is doingThe objection is answered in figures, so the reader can see exactly what recovery the design needs to pay for itself.
5

Transition

The change should be phased to limit disruption during the selling seasons. Renewals and subscription support would move first, at the start of the quarter after approval, because they involve the fewest people and the clearest gain. Software engineering would follow after the next spring planting season, so no release planned for farmers' busiest weeks is interrupted by reassignment. Receiver hardware engineering would move last, once the transfer price for receivers built into grain equipment has been agreed, since moving engineers before that price exists would invite the dispute the proposal is trying to manage. Each step would be reviewed against the watch measures before the next begins. The engineers who now split their time across lines are the hardest case. About 20 of them would be asked to choose a home, and the joint design reviews would be scheduled before they move so that the habit of working together survives the change of reporting line.

Costs Accepted and Costs Expected to Fall

Two of the four costs are accepted permanently. Dealers will always deal with two parties for guidance products, and transfer pricing will always generate some disputes. Two are expected to fall with management effort: expertise drift can be limited by joint design reviews, and experimentation can be protected by setting aside a fixed share of engineering time that quarterly targets cannot reclaim. The proposal asks the board to approve the division on that understanding.

References

Eccles, R. G. (1985). The transfer pricing problem: A theory for practice. Lexington Books.

Hill, C. W. L., Hitt, M. A., & Hoskisson, R. E. (1992). Cooperative versus competitive structures in related and unrelated diversified firms. Organization Science, 3(4), 501-521. https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.3.4.501

Mintzberg, H. (1979). The structuring of organizations: A synthesis of the research. Prentice-Hall.

The MGT-805 Topic 7 assignment instructions

Topic 7 in MGT-805 asks doctoral learners to propose a structural redesign and to account honestly for its costs. A paper meets the prompt when it states the problem the redesign addresses, draws the new boundary precisely and shows what will improve, with a measure for each expected gain. The course places equal weight on what the new structure will hide, so learners should name each blind spot, explain the mechanism that creates it and assign someone to watch it. Doctoral papers should draw on the literature on divisional forms, cooperation between related units and transfer pricing, answer the strongest objection in figures and say which costs the organization accepts permanently and which it expects to reduce.

Inside the MGT 805 Topic 7 example

Equal space goes, in the finished proposal, to what the division fixes and what it breaks. It creates a precision guidance division of about 310 people, figures composite, holding software and receiver engineering, subscription sales and renewals, and customer support, with its own profit and loss. Grain handling and irrigation remain functional, linked by product integrators. Four blind spots the change opens are then named. Electronics expertise shared across all three lines will drift as division engineers stop working beside the others. Dealers will face two contacts for one farm. Receivers sold with grain equipment will raise transfer disputes. And, following Mintzberg's argument that performance control pushes divisions toward machine bureaucracy, quarterly targets may squeeze the experimentation software development needs. Each blind spot receives a measure and a watcher outside the division.

MGT 805 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Graders award an Excellent proposal for giving costs the same attention as gains. The rubric rewards a boundary drawn precisely, including what stays shared, and gains tied to measures that could show the design failing. Credit goes to blind spots explained through their mechanisms rather than labels such as silos, and to watch measures owned outside the division. Faculty look for Mintzberg's warning about performance control applied to software experimentation, and for related-diversification research used to justify cooperative incentives. Strong papers answer the overhead objection with figures, here about four renewal points to cover nine duplicated roles. The top band sequences the transition and separates permanent costs from reducible ones.

MGT 805 Topic 7 help before you submit

A redesign that lists only its gains leaves the organization to discover the costs after the change, and the course treats that omission as the central error. Naming blind spots as labels, such as silos or duplication, without the mechanism that produces each leaves a reader unable to judge how serious they are. Papers that move all three product lines into divisions ignore the earlier evidence that grain handling and irrigation meet few of the conditions a self-contained unit needs. Summarizing Mintzberg's divisionalized form as decentralization loses his warning about what performance control does to the divisions themselves. Watch measures reported by the division alone rely on the unit least placed to see its own gaps. Without the overhead objection answered in figures, the proposal leaves its most obvious challenge for the reader to raise.

Get an MGT-805 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-805 Topic 7 instructions, your section's rubric and any organization, prior analysis or case the assignment supplies. A custom example comes back in 24 to 48 hours, written to them, with the redesign drawn, gains paired with measures, each new blind spot traced to its mechanism, watchers assigned and the overhead objection answered. The first one is free.

More MGT 805 papers and DBA samples

MGT 805 Topic 7 questions, answered

What is Mintzberg's divisionalized form?

One of Henry Mintzberg's structural configurations, in which a central headquarters oversees semi-autonomous units, usually organized by market, and coordinates them mainly through standardized outputs such as performance targets. He argued that this control tends to push the divisions themselves toward machine bureaucracy, favoring predictability over innovation. The example treats that tendency as one of the costs the new division must watch.

Why name the blind spots a redesign creates?

Because every structure trades one set of visible problems for another, and a proposal listing only gains invites the organization to be surprised later. Naming the new blind spots, with their mechanisms, lets leaders decide in advance whether to accept each cost and who will watch for it. The example assigns every blind spot a measure and an owner outside the division.

Why keep two product lines functional?

Because the case for a self-contained unit rests on conditions those lines do not share. Grain handling and irrigation change slowly, depend on the same plant, and gain more from engineering depth than from speed. Splitting them into divisions would duplicate capability without bringing the benefit, so the proposal applies the divisional form only where the work's interdependencies and pace justify its overhead.

Where can I find a free MGT 805 Topic 7 sample paper?

The divisional redesign proposal is shown here in full, covering the design, the expected gains, four blind spots, the watch measure table, cooperation incentives, the overhead figures and the transition. Describe the redesign your course asks for and a free proposal can be written to fit.

How does the division cover its overhead in MGT 805 Topic 7?

Nine duplicated finance, planning and human resources roles cost about 1.1 million dollars a year. Each renewal point recovered is worth about 312,000 dollars, so recovering roughly four of the eleven lost points covers the cost.