| Course | MGT 805 Designing Organizational Structures |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Grouping comparison paper |
| Length | About 1,200 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 805 Topic 2
Which Interdependencies Each Grouping Keeps Inside: Comparing Function, Product Line, Customer Segment and Geography at an Agricultural Equipment Manufacturer
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
MGT-805: Designing Organizational Structures
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Which Interdependencies Each Grouping Keeps Inside: Comparing Function, Product Line, Customer Segment and Geography at an Agricultural Equipment Manufacturer
The Criterion
Coldwater Implement Company, a composite manufacturer of grain handling, irrigation and precision guidance equipment, is currently grouped by function. Its leaders are considering three alternatives: grouping by product line, by customer segment or by geography. Each could be compared on cost, control or tradition. This paper uses a different criterion, drawn from Thompson (1967): which interdependencies does each basis keep inside a single unit? Thompson argued that organizations group positions so as to minimize coordination costs, placing the most demanding interdependencies within the same unit where they can be handled by mutual adjustment, and leaving the less demanding ones to cross boundaries. A grouping basis is therefore a bet about which work needs to be coordinated most closely. The criterion was preferred to cost because coordination failures, not headcount, are the firm's current problem.
Mapping the Work
Eighteen core work flows were identified from process documents and interviews with managers. Each was classed using Thompson's three types. Pooled interdependence, where units draw on a common resource but do not otherwise depend on each other, describes six flows, such as the three product lines sharing the corporate parts warehouse. Sequential interdependence, where one unit's output is another's input, describes five, such as manufacturing shipping finished dryers to dealers through the sales function. Reciprocal interdependence, where units must adjust to each other repeatedly, describes seven. A clear example is guidance software engineering and receiver hardware engineering during a release, when every software change may require a hardware change and the reverse.
Thompson ranked these types by coordination cost: pooled interdependence can be handled by rules, sequential by planning and reciprocal only by mutual adjustment, which is easiest within a unit. The seven reciprocal flows therefore carry the comparison. The other eleven matter, but they can cross boundaries at modest cost.
Four Bases Against the Seven Reciprocal Flows
Table 1
Reciprocal Flows Kept Inside a Unit Under Each Grouping Basis, Illustrative
| Reciprocal flow | Function | Product line | Customer segment | Geography |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guidance software and receiver hardware engineering | Inside | Inside | Inside | Crosses |
| Irrigation engineering and dealer sales on custom pivot quotes | Crosses | Inside | Inside | Crosses |
| Grain dryer engineering and plant manufacturing at model launch | Crosses | Inside | Crosses | Crosses |
| Guidance support and software engineering on field faults | Crosses | Inside | Inside | Crosses |
| Irrigation service and irrigation engineering on pivot failures | Crosses | Inside | Crosses | Crosses |
| Electronics controller design shared across all three lines | Inside | Crosses | Crosses | Crosses |
| Large-farm account sales and field service on harvest contracts | Crosses | Crosses | Inside | Inside |
| Reciprocal flows contained | 2 | 5 | 4 | 1 |
Table 1 records which of the seven reciprocal flows each basis would contain within a single unit. Customer segments are defined as large commercial operations and family farms, the two segments Coldwater's marketing plan uses.
What Each Basis Gives Up
Containment is only half of the trade, so each basis must also be judged by what it costs. Function, the current basis, contains only two reciprocal flows, but it protects the specialization Coldwater most values: one group of electronics engineers serving all three lines, and one manufacturing organization able to move work between plants as the seasons change.
Product line grouping contains five reciprocal flows, the most of any basis. Its costs are concrete. The two plants build all three lines, so product grouping would either split each plant among three masters or assign plants to lines and lose the ability to balance seasonal demand. It would also duplicate engineering: the electronics controller work now shared across lines would be divided three ways, and the one reciprocal flow the functional form protects would cross a boundary.
Customer segment grouping contains four flows and leaves engineers answering to two segment heads whose requests compete, since the same guidance product serves both segments. Geography contains only one flow, and its case rests on a foreign dealer network Coldwater has not built; the firm sells mainly in nine Midwestern and Plains states, where regional differences are small.
The Eleven Flows That Cross Boundaries Cheaply
The pooled and sequential flows deserve a brief check, because a basis that contained the reciprocal flows while disrupting all the others would not be a good choice. Under product line grouping, the six pooled flows would still draw on shared resources such as the parts warehouse, the dealer financing program and the information technology group, and rules and budgets can govern those as they do today. The five sequential flows, including the movement of finished goods from plants to dealers and of warranty returns from dealers to engineering, would need schedules and service standards between units. Coldwater already writes such standards between its functions, so the change would alter who signs them rather than whether they exist. None of the eleven flows would become much harder to coordinate under any of the four bases, which is why they do not decide the comparison. Thompson's ordering explains this: the cheaper forms of coordination work tolerably well across boundaries, while mutual adjustment does not.
Mintzberg's Families of Bases
Mintzberg (1979) sorted grouping bases into two broad families. Functional bases, grouping by knowledge, skill or work process, encourage specialization and economies of scale but make coordination of the work flow harder. Market bases, grouping by product, client or place, contain the work flow within units but sacrifice specialization and scale. The comparison in Table 1 is an application of that distinction. The three market bases contain more reciprocal flows than the functional one, and product line contains the most. The choice is therefore whether the seven reciprocal flows matter more to Coldwater than the specialization functional grouping protects.
Puranam et al. (2012) add a useful refinement: the coordination problem depends not only on whether tasks are interdependent but on whether the people performing them know enough about each other's work to predict it. The reciprocal flows within product lines involve exactly that kind of shared knowledge, which develops only when people work together over time.
The Counting Objection
A reader might object that the comparison counts flows as if they were equal, treating a weekly handoff and a daily negotiation alike. The objection is fair, so the flows were weighted. Each reciprocal flow was scored for frequency, from monthly to daily, and for uncertainty, from routine to novel, and the scores were multiplied. The software and hardware release flow and the guidance field fault flow scored highest; the harvest contract flow scored lowest. Recalculated with these weights, product line still contains about 78 percent of weighted reciprocal interdependence, customer segment about 60 percent, function about 34 percent and geography about 6 percent. The ranking holds.
Recommendation
The comparison favors product line grouping, because it keeps the most demanding interdependencies inside units where people can adjust to each other directly. That verdict comes with costs the firm should accept knowingly: divided or reassigned plant capacity, duplicated engineering and a weaker home for the shared electronics work. Because the costs fall heavily on manufacturing and electronics, a full product line structure may not be the only answer. A partial form, discussed in later topics, could group the fastest-changing line by product while leaving shared resources in functions. The present comparison establishes the direction and its price.
References
Mintzberg, H. (1979). The structuring of organizations: A synthesis of the research. Prentice-Hall.
Puranam, P., Raveendran, M., & Knudsen, T. (2012). Organization design: The epistemic interdependence perspective. Academy of Management Review, 37(3), 419-440. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2010.0535
Thompson, J. D. (1967). Organizations in action: Social science bases of administrative theory. McGraw-Hill.
Reading the GCU MGT 805 Topic 2 instructions
The Topic 2 assignment in MGT-805 asks doctoral learners to compare bases for grouping work and to justify a choice for a specific organization. The course moves past listing each basis with its textbook advantages. A paper meets the prompt when it chooses an explicit criterion, explains why that criterion matters for the case, and applies it to evidence about how the organization's work actually flows. Learners should use Thompson's types of interdependence and Mintzberg's distinction between functional and market bases, apply them flow by flow, and state what the preferred basis would cost. At doctoral level the analysis should also answer the methodological objection a reader is likely to raise and show whether the conclusion survives it.
Inside the MGT 805 Topic 2 example
Four bases are scored in the finished comparison on one criterion drawn from Thompson: which interdependencies each keeps inside a single unit, where they are cheapest to coordinate. The manufacturer's eighteen core work flows are mapped first, all composite, and seven are classed as reciprocal, meaning two groups must adjust to each other repeatedly, such as guidance software and receiver hardware engineering during a release. Functional grouping contains two of the seven, product line five, customer segment four and geography one. The comparison then states what each basis gives up: product grouping splits the shared plant and duplicates engineering, customer grouping leaves engineers answering to several segment heads, and geography suits a foreign dealer network the firm does not have. Mintzberg's distinction between functional and market bases frames the verdict, which favors product line grouping and names its costs.
Reading the MGT 805 Topic 2 rubric
The rubric rewards a comparison with a criterion stated and defended before any basis is judged. An Excellent paper maps the organization's work flows, classes each by type of interdependence and counts which flows each basis contains, listing every crossing flow so the count can be checked. Credit goes to charging every basis with its costs, especially the winner, here a divided plant and duplicated engineers. Faculty look for Thompson and Mintzberg applied to the case rather than defined in the abstract. Strong papers anticipate the objection that flows are not equal and test the ranking with a weighting. Top marks go to a recommendation framed as a trade-off with its price stated.
Common MGT 805 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Comparisons that list each basis with its textbook advantages and disadvantages supply no criterion, so the reader cannot tell why one list outweighs another. A paper choosing product grouping because the firm has product lines has matched labels rather than examined work. Thompson's categories are often defined correctly and then never applied to a single flow, which leaves the interdependence argument abstract. Papers that ignore what the winning basis costs, here a divided plant and duplicated engineers, present a trade-off as an improvement. The counting objection is predictable at doctoral level, and a comparison without weighting has no answer when a reader raises it. Treating geography as a live option without asking whether the firm operates in enough places to justify it signals that the bases were compared from a template.
Get an MGT-805 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-805 Topic 2 instructions, your rubric and the organization or case the assignment describes. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a criterion stated, work flows classified, each basis tested against them, its costs named and the counting objection answered, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 805 papers and DBA samples
- MGT 805 Topic 1: Structural Trade-off Essay
- MGT 805 Topic 3: Coordination Cost Quantification
- MGT 805 Topic 4: Matrix Strain Analysis
- MGT 805 Topic 5: Structural Blind Spot Dq Post
- MGT 805 Topic 6: Strategy-structure Lag Analysis
- MGT 805 Topic 7: Divisional Redesign Proposal
- MGT 805 Topic 8: Structural Choice Defense
- MGT 820 Topic 2: Data Asset Inimitability Analysis
- DBA 965 Topic 2: Findings Chapter Presentation
- MGT 825 Topic 2: Preliminary Agreement Analysis
- DBA 960 Topic 2: Within-firm Recruitment Protocol
MGT 805 Topic 2 questions, answered
What are pooled, sequential and reciprocal interdependence?
James Thompson's three types. Pooled units contribute separately to a shared whole, sequential units pass work in one direction, and reciprocal units feed work back and forth. Each type is costlier to coordinate than the one before, and Thompson argued that organizations group the most interdependent positions together first. The example applies that reasoning flow by flow at the manufacturer.
What does Mintzberg say about bases for grouping?
Henry Mintzberg sorted bases into two broad families: grouping by knowledge, skill or work process, which he treated as functional, and grouping by output, client or place, which he treated as market-based. Functional grouping favors specialization and economies of scale, while market grouping keeps work-flow interdependencies inside a unit. The example uses that distinction to explain what its verdict gains and loses.
Can an organization group on more than one basis?
Almost always, at different levels. A firm might group by product at the top and by function inside each product unit, or by geography for sales and by function for engineering. The comparison in the example concerns the first grouping below the chief executive, since that choice decides which conflicts reach the top of the organization and which are settled further down.
Where can I find a free MGT 805 Topic 2 sample paper?
Every part of the grouping comparison is here: the criterion, the eighteen-flow map, the reciprocal flow table, the costs of each basis, the weighting test and the recommendation. Describe the organization and its options and we can write a free comparison built on its work flows.
Why does product line win in MGT 805 Topic 2?
It keeps five of the seven reciprocal flows inside one unit, more than any other basis, and still ranks first when flows are weighted by frequency and uncertainty. The paper states its costs: divided plant capacity and duplicated engineering.