DBA 955 Topic 1 dissertation problem statement example

Dissertation I Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 955 Topic 1 sample paper reworks a composite freight brokerage director's grievance, that shippers treat carriers as interchangeable and pay in failed deliveries, into a problem a study could prove wrong. It was written for GCU DBA 955, Dissertation I, catalog code DBA-955, built into the Grand Canyon University DBA. Judgments about what shippers should value are marked and set aside. What survives asks whether relationship length is associated with on-time delivery for mid-sized shippers once lane, volume and season are held constant. Dyer and Singh and Kalwani and Narayandas source the consequence, and the gap follows Creswell and Creswell's deficiencies model.

CourseDBA 955 Dissertation I
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeDissertation problem statement
LengthAbout 960 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 955 Topic 1

1

From Grievance to Problem: Reworking a Brokerage Director's Conviction About Carrier Loyalty Into a Statement a Study Could Prove Wrong

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

DBA-955: Dissertation I

Topic 1 Dissertation Problem Statement

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the movement the section makes. The candidate and the brokerage are composites; the sources are real. The section shows structure and is not a chapter for submission.
2

From Grievance to Problem: Reworking a Brokerage Director's Conviction About Carrier Loyalty Into a Statement a Study Could Prove Wrong

The Grievance as First Written

A doctoral candidate who directs operations at a composite freight brokerage drafted the first version of the problem statement in one sentence: shippers treat carriers as interchangeable, switching for a few dollars a load, and they pay for it in failed deliveries. Eleven years of watching shippers move freight to the lowest bidder and then call to complain stand behind that sentence, and the experience is real. But the sentence cannot open a dissertation. Part of it is a judgment about what shippers should do, part is a claim about what happens, and the two are fused. This section separates them, keeps the claim and builds the problem statement around it in the order a first chapter usually requires: the problem, its consequence, the population and the gap.

Marking the Judgments

Three phrases in the first draft are judgments. That shippers should value relationships expresses the candidate's view of good practice. That switching carriers is shortsighted assumes the result the study would test. And that shippers treat carriers as interchangeable describes a mental attitude the candidate has inferred from behavior, not observed. None of these can be confirmed or refuted by evidence in the form written, and a committee would rightly ask how the candidate would know if they were wrong.

Removing them leaves a claim about something that is the case or is not: whether the length of a shipper's relationship with a carrier is associated with how reliably that carrier delivers the shipper's freight. That claim can turn out false. Long relationships might show no reliability advantage once other factors are considered, or a small one not worth the higher rates loyal shippers sometimes pay. The study is worth doing because either answer is informative.

The Problem, Stated

The problem statement that survives reads, in outline: among mid-sized shippers, the length of a carrier relationship may be associated with delivery reliability once lane, volume and season are held constant, but this association has not been measured in the truckload brokerage setting, leaving shippers to choose between rate savings and relationship stability without evidence on what the second is worth, and leaving brokers unable to advise them on that choice with anything firmer than anecdote. Each element is now checkable. Mid-sized shippers can be defined by annual freight spend. Relationship length can be measured in months of continuous tendering. Delivery reliability can be measured as on-time delivery against appointment. And the controls name the obvious alternative explanations.

The statement no longer says shippers are wrong. It says that a question with business consequences lacks an answer, which is the claim a problem statement must make.

The Business Consequence, Sourced

The section must show that the problem matters in terms drawn from published work rather than from the candidate's experience alone. Two bodies of work serve. Research on buyer-supplier relationships has argued that firms can earn relational rents, returns that neither party could earn alone, from relationship-specific investments, knowledge sharing and effective governance (Dyer & Singh, 1998). And research on long-term relationships in industrial markets has examined whether such relationships pay off, with Kalwani and Narayandas (1995) finding that suppliers in long-term relationships with selected customers achieved returns at least as high as firms using a transactional approach, partly through lower costs. Neither study concerns freight, which is precisely why the candidate's study is needed. Industry figures on the cost of failed deliveries can be added from published sources, cited as context rather than as evidence of the relationship the study tests.

The Population

The population is named with the boundaries a reader needs: shippers with annual truckload spend between about 2 and 25 million dollars, tendering through brokers in the continental United States, observed over a stated period. Large shippers are excluded because they often contract directly with carriers under dedicated arrangements, which changes the relationship being studied. Small shippers are excluded because they tender too few loads to measure reliability by lane. The population statement also notes that the candidate's employer is one source of data among several and that the study will draw on more than one brokerage, so findings do not describe one firm's customers alone.

Locating the Gap

Creswell and Creswell (2018) described a model for research introductions built around deficiencies in past literature: the writer states the topic, reviews what studies have addressed it, identifies what they have not addressed and explains why the omission matters for an audience. The final paragraph of the section follows that logic. Studies of relational exchange have concentrated on manufacturing supply relationships, where investments are large and switching is slow. Freight brokerage differs: switching is fast and cheap, the broker stands between shipper and carrier, and loads are tendered one at a time. Whether relationship length carries a reliability benefit in a market built for switching has not been tested. That is the gap, stated at a width the study can fill.

What the Section Must Not Do

The rewritten section avoids three temptations the first draft gave in to. It does not argue for the answer the candidate expects. It does not rely on the candidate's years in the industry as evidence, though it may mention them as the origin of the interest. And it does not overstate the gap; it claims only that this association in this setting is untested, a claim the literature review in a later chapter must then confirm. The candidate's conviction has not been discarded; it has been converted into a question the evidence can settle, and the dissertation will be stronger if the answer turns out to be one the candidate did not expect.

References

Creswell, J. W., & Creswell, J. D. (2018). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches (5th ed.). SAGE.

Dyer, J. H., & Singh, H. (1998). The relational view: Cooperative strategy and sources of interorganizational competitive advantage. Academy of Management Review, 23(4), 660-679. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1998.1255632

Kalwani, M. U., & Narayandas, N. (1995). Long-term manufacturer-supplier relationships: Do they pay off for supplier firms? Journal of Marketing, 59(1), 1-16. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299505900101

What the DBA 955 Topic 1 instructions ask for

Topic 1 in DBA-955 asks doctoral students to turn a professional concern into a dissertation problem statement. Strong statements mark the judgments in the original concern and set them aside, keeping a claim about what is the case that evidence could refute. Students should state the problem with a named population, measurable terms and controls for obvious alternatives, show the business consequence through published work rather than personal experience and locate the gap in the literature at a width the study can fill. The section should not argue for the expected answer or overstate what has not been studied.

How the DBA-955 Topic 1 example is put together

What the page presents is a problem statement section of the kind a proposal's first chapter carries, laid out as structure rather than as a chapter anyone could submit. It opens with the grievance in the candidate's own words and marks the parts of it that are judgments: that shippers should value relationships, that switching carriers is shortsighted. What remains is a claim about something that is the case. Among mid-sized shippers, the length of a carrier relationship is associated with delivery reliability once lane and volume are held constant, and that claim could plainly turn out false. The section then states the business consequence in terms sourced to published work rather than to the candidate's experience, names the population and closes by locating the gap, following the deficiencies logic Creswell describes for research introductions.

Reading the DBA 955 Topic 1 rubric

Faculty reward a grievance turned into a falsifiable problem. An Excellent statement marks what shippers should value and that switching is shortsighted as judgments. Credit goes to a claim relating relationship length to on-time delivery with lane, volume and season held constant. The rubric values sourcing the consequence to Dyer and Singh on relational rents and Kalwani and Narayandas on long-term relationships, and a population bounded by freight spend. Strong statements follow Creswell and Creswell's deficiencies model. Top marks go to a gap claimed no wider than the study can fill.

DBA 955 Topic 1 help before you submit

The problem statement most often goes wrong by being a recommendation in disguise, such as keeping carriers longer, which no study can confirm. A second weakness is a problem documented from the candidate's own workplace, whose incidents are vivid, unverifiable and suggestive of an internal project. Statements naming a problem without a population give no way to judge whether the claim concerns one firm, a sector or all freight. Many drafts state significance at length before the problem itself is clear, reversing the order a committee reads for. A gap asserted as a sentence claiming nobody has studied this, without describing what the nearest research did examine, fails on first reading. Wording that shifts between the problem, the purpose and the questions signals a study not yet settled.

Get a DBA-955 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-955 Topic 1 instructions and your classroom rubric. We write a custom structural example to them, showing a complaint converted into a researchable problem, in 24 to 48 hours, and the first one is free. Your dissertation is your own work: we never write chapters for a reader, and your IRB application, site permission letters, committee correspondence and signatures stay yours.

More DBA 955 papers and DBA samples

DBA 955 Topic 1 questions, answered

What makes a workplace complaint researchable?

A claim inside it that evidence could support or defeat. Complaints usually mix a preference about how an industry ought to behave with a factual belief about what happens when it does not, and only the second can be studied. The example keeps the factual belief, attaches a population and the conditions under which it should hold, and sets the preference aside as a question for practitioners.

Can I use problems at my own company as evidence?

As context, carefully, and rarely as the evidence a problem statement rests on. Committees read incidents from the candidate's own employer as anecdote and may ask whether the study is an internal project. Published industry and scholarly sources establish that a problem exists beyond one firm. Your employer may still become a research site later, once access and the ethics of studying colleagues are settled.

Will you write my problem statement?

No. A dissertation is the candidate's own work, and the problem statement is where that ownership begins. What we provide is a structural example on a composite case, showing how the moves of a problem statement fit together so the architecture is visible before you build your own. Chapters, IRB materials, site permissions and committee correspondence remain yours to write and sign.

Where can I find a free DBA 955 Topic 1 sample paper?

The structural example is shown here complete: the grievance as written, the judgments marked, the problem stated, the business consequence sourced, the population and the gap. Paste in your DBA 955 Topic 1 prompt and a free paper follows.

Why exclude very large and very small shippers in DBA 955 Topic 1?

Large shippers often contract directly with carriers under dedicated arrangements, which changes the relationship studied. Small shippers tender too few loads to measure reliability by lane.