| Course | DBA 955 Dissertation I |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Gap verification memo |
| Length | About 830 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 955 Topic 4
Memorandum
To: Dissertation Chair
From: Doctoral Candidate
Date: [Date]
Re: Results of the gap verification search
The Original Claim
The proposal as first drafted claimed that no research has examined how general managers of franchised hotels experience brand-standard audits. You asked me to test that claim with a documented search before the literature review chapter is written. This memo reports the search, what it found and the narrower gap that survives. In short, the original claim does not hold, but a narrower one does, and I propose to restate the study around it.
The Search
I searched three bodies of literature, two of which I had not read before.
First, business scholarship in ABI/INFORM and Business Source Complete, combining franchis* with audit*, quality assurance, brand standards, monitoring and compliance, for 1990 to the present. The searches returned about 1,140 items; 61 remained once duplicates were removed and each title and abstract was checked for empirical or conceptual work on franchisor monitoring.
Second, hospitality management journals, searched through the same databases and Google Scholar, combining hotel with general manager, franchise, brand standards, management company and owner, for the same period. About 380 items were returned and 27 survived screening.
Third, the franchising literature in entrepreneurship and strategy journals, which I had never read. I searched for agency theory, franchisor control, plural forms and franchisee autonomy, and followed citations backward from two review articles. About 210 items were returned and 34 survived.
The full search log, with every string, date and count, is attached as an appendix.
What Already Exists
The broad claim collapses. Franchisor control and monitoring have been studied extensively. Combs et al. (2004) reviewed franchising research and found agency theory among its dominant lenses, with franchisors' monitoring of franchisees a central concern. Agency theory itself, from Jensen and Meckling (1976) onward, treats monitoring as a cost principals bear to align agents' behavior with their interests, and franchising research has applied it to explain why franchisors audit, how often and with what consequences. Studies of quality assurance in hotel franchising exist as well, mostly from the franchisor's perspective, examining audit scores, guest satisfaction and the franchisor's decisions about renewal.
What Remains Thin
What remains thin is the general manager's experience. In most hotel franchises the franchisee is an owner or ownership group, and the general manager is its employee, or an employee of a third-party management company, not the franchisee itself. Monitoring research addresses the franchisor-franchisee relationship. The general manager answers to two principals at once: the owner, who sets budgets and judges profit, and the brand, which sets standards and conducts audits. When the brand's audit requires spending the owner will not approve, the general manager stands between them.
Hospitality studies of the general manager role describe the tension between owners and brands, but mostly in terms of who holds authority over which decisions. None of the screened studies examined how general managers experience and handle audits in particular, or how they manage conflicting demands from owner and brand during and after an audit. Of the 122 items screened in, I found three that touched this experience directly, all practitioner surveys without a stated method.
The Gap, Restated
The restated gap is: how general managers of franchised hotels, answering to both an owner and a brand, experience and respond to brand-standard audits when the two principals' demands conflict. The restatement is narrower than the original in three ways. It concerns general managers, not franchisees. It concerns conflict between principals, not audits in general. And it builds on agency theory rather than claiming to stand outside it, since the dual-principal problem is itself an agency problem with a specific shape.
Why the Narrower Gap Is Stronger
Losing the broad claim helps the study. A proposal claiming that nobody had studied franchise audits would have been dismissed by any committee member who knew the franchising literature, and the search shows that such members would be right. The narrower gap connects the study to an established theory, gives it a reason to exist that the literature itself supplies, and points to a population, general managers under dual principals, that I can reach through my professional network without studying my own company's properties. Alvesson and Sandberg (2011) argued that strong research questions often come from challenging the assumptions of an existing literature rather than from claiming an empty space beside it; the restated gap does the first. It also gives the eventual findings an audience beyond hotels, since dual-principal arrangements exist wherever managers run outlets owned by one party and branded by another.
What I Ask of You
I ask you to review the search log and tell me whether any database or body of literature is missing. I also ask whether the restated gap is wide enough to sustain a dissertation. I believe it is, because the dual-principal experience is common across franchised hotels and consequential for owners, brands and managers, but I would rather hear now than at the proposal defense if you see it differently.
References
Alvesson, M., & Sandberg, J. (2011). Generating research questions through problematization. Academy of Management Review, 36(2), 247-271. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2009.0188
Combs, J. G., Michael, S. C., & Castrogiovanni, G. J. (2004). Franchising: A review and avenues to greater theoretical diversity. Journal of Management, 30(6), 907-931. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jm.2004.06.006
Jensen, M. C., & Meckling, W. H. (1976). Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure. Journal of Financial Economics, 3(4), 305-360. https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-405X(76)90026-X
The DBA-955 Topic 4 assignment instructions
Topic 4 in DBA-955 asks doctoral students to verify a claimed research gap through a documented search. Strong memos restate the original claim, record every database, search string, date range and count, and include literatures the candidate had not read before. Students should report honestly what already exists, even when it undercuts the claim, and identify what remains thin with evidence from the screened items. The memo should restate the gap at a width the literature supports, explain why the narrower gap is stronger and ask the chair specific questions about coverage and adequacy.
Inside the DBA 955 Topic 4 example
Written to the candidate's chair, the finished memo reads as a report of a test rather than as a defense of a belief. It restates the original claim in one sentence, then records the search: ABI/INFORM and Business Source Complete for business scholarship, hospitality management journals for sector work, and the franchising literature in entrepreneurship and strategy, which the candidate had never read. Each database entry lists the terms combined, the date range, what was returned and how many items survived screening. The result is uncomfortable and useful. Franchisor control and monitoring have been studied extensively, often through agency theory, so the broad claim collapses. What remains thin is the general manager's experience of answering to two principals at once, the owner and the brand. The memo restates the gap at that width.
Where the marks sit in the DBA 955 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward a gap tested rather than defended. An Excellent memo logs searches across business, hospitality and franchising literatures with counts at each stage. Credit goes to conceding that franchisor monitoring is well studied, citing Combs and colleagues and Jensen and Meckling on agency. The rubric values locating what remains thin, the general manager answering to two principals during audits. Strong memos explain why the narrower gap is stronger, with Alvesson and Sandberg as support. The best memos also ask the chair what the search missed.
DBA 955 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
A search summarized as relevant databases and keywords gives the committee nothing to check, and costs this memo more than any other weakness. Searches confined to the candidate's own sector miss adjacent disciplines where the question has often been studied under different vocabulary, and insiders are prone to this because their reading follows their industry. Some memos report the search honestly and then restate the original gap unchanged, which reads as a result ignored. Counting items returned without describing what they examined leaves the reader unable to judge coverage. A narrowed gap presented without saying why it still matters invites the reply that it is too small to justify a dissertation. Memos that treat a covered claim as a failure, rather than as the normal outcome of a real search, argue against the very process a committee expects to see.
Get a DBA-955 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-955 Topic 4 instructions and your classroom rubric. We write a custom structural example to them, showing a claimed gap tested by a recorded search, in 24 to 48 hours, and the first one is free. Your dissertation is your own work: we never write its chapters for a reader, and your IRB application, site permission letters, committee correspondence and signatures stay yours.
More DBA 955 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 955 Topic 1: Dissertation Problem Statement
- DBA 955 Topic 2: Insider Positionality Statement
- DBA 955 Topic 3: Literature Review Blueprint
- DBA 955 Topic 5: Inconvenient Finding Dq Post
- DBA 955 Topic 6: Design Choice Justification
- DBA 955 Topic 7: Access Feasibility Plan
- DBA 955 Topic 8: Proposal Method Defense Brief
- DBA 960 Topic 4: Fieldwork Departure Log
- DBA 839 Topic 4: Data Decision Rights Matrix
- DBA 965 Topic 4: Unsettled Questions Section
- DBA 835 Topic 4: Disclosure Obligation Map
DBA 955 Topic 4 questions, answered
How do I know if my research gap is real?
By searching in a way someone else could repeat and reporting what the search found, including work that undercuts the claim. Candidates who study their own industry often search only its literature and miss adjacent fields that examined the same question in other terms. A gap still standing after a recorded search across those fields can be defended; one asserted from personal reading usually cannot.
Is it bad if the search shows my gap is mostly covered?
No, that is the ordinary result of a real search, and committees tend to trust a narrowed gap more than a sweeping one. The example concedes most of the original claim to the franchising literature and keeps a smaller question about managers answering to two principals. A precise opening with a clear link to existing work is a stronger foundation than an unexamined claim of novelty.
Do you run the literature search for my dissertation?
No. The search is part of the dissertation and belongs to the candidate, who has to be able to explain and defend every decision in it. The example shows how a verification memo is typically organized, using a composite hotel case, so the elements of a repeatable search record are visible. Your chapters and committee correspondence are yours to write.
Where can I find a free DBA 955 Topic 4 sample paper?
The verification memo is set out in full here: the original claim, the search, what already exists, what remains thin, the gap restated, why the narrower gap is stronger and what the chair is asked. Send your DBA 955 Topic 4 prompt and a paper follows free.
What is the dual-principal problem in DBA 955 Topic 4?
A franchised hotel's general manager answers to the owner, who sets budgets, and to the brand, which sets standards and audits them. When an audit demands spending the owner refuses, the manager stands between the two.