| Course | DBA 955 Dissertation I |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Insider positionality statement |
| Length | About 990 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 955 Topic 2
What Standing Inside Gives and Costs: An Insider Positionality Statement for a Study of How Store Managers Build Schedules
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-955: Dissertation I
Topic 2 Insider Positionality Statement
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
What Standing Inside Gives and Costs: An Insider Positionality Statement for a Study of How Store Managers Build Schedules
The Facts of Position
The candidate is a senior human resources business partner at a composite retail chain of about 260 stores and proposes to study how store managers build weekly staff schedules. The candidate reports to the regional vice president of human resources, supports two of the chain's five regions, about 110 stores, and has worked at the company for nine years. In that role the candidate advises store managers on scheduling policy, reviews schedules flagged for labor law concerns and handles grievances, including complaints from staff about unfair hours. Many of the store managers who might become participants have been on the other side of a grievance the candidate handled. These facts open the statement because every later choice depends on them.
Why Name Position at All
Research conducted inside one's own organization is common in professional doctorates, and it has defenders. Brannick and Coghlan (2007) argued that insider research is legitimate and valuable, because insiders hold knowledge of the setting that outsiders take years to acquire, provided that insiders examine and account for how their position shapes the research. The positionality statement is that account. It does not apologize for the candidate's role; it names what the role adds to the study and what it endangers, so that a committee and later readers can judge the findings with that in view.
How Position Shaped the Question
Position affected the study before any data were planned. The candidate first framed the question around compliance: why managers break scheduling rules. That framing came from the grievance desk, where rule-breaking is what arrives. A conversation with a store manager outside the candidate's regions changed it. The manager described scheduling as a weekly negotiation among a labor budget, staff availability, sales forecasts and favors owed, in which rules are one constraint among several. The research question now asks how managers build schedules under competing constraints, a broader question that does not presume the answer is misconduct. The statement records this shift because it shows preunderstanding at work and because the original framing would have made role duality much worse.
Three Consequences
Coghlan and Brannick (2014) described three issues insider researchers must manage: preunderstanding, role duality and organizational politics. Each takes a specific form here.
Preunderstanding is the knowledge the candidate brings. Fluency in the chain's scheduling rules, labor budget formulas, union provisions in two states and the software managers use means interviews can move quickly to substance, and the candidate will recognize when a manager describes a workaround. The same fluency blinds. Practices the candidate has stopped noticing, such as managers trading shifts informally to avoid the system's rules, may pass unexamined because they seem normal. And the candidate's settled views about which managers schedule well may color what is heard.
Role duality is the tension of holding two roles at once. A store manager speaking to the candidate as a researcher is also speaking to the function that investigates complaints and advises on discipline. A manager who bends a scheduling rule to keep a good employee may not describe that honestly to someone who could report it. Mercer (2007) described insider research as a double-edged sword in this respect: familiarity can encourage candor or inhibit it, depending on what participants fear.
Organizational politics is the third consequence. Whatever the findings say, they will be read inside the company as a human resources position. A finding that managers routinely work around labor budgets could be read as an accusation of operations leaders, or as human resources building a case for more control.
Safeguards and Their Limits
For each consequence the statement pairs a safeguard with an honest note on what it cannot remove.
Table 1
Consequences of Insider Position, Safeguards and Their Limits
| Consequence | Safeguard | What it cannot remove |
|---|---|---|
| Preunderstanding narrows what is noticed | Reflexive journal after each interview; a peer debriefer outside the company reviews coding | The candidate's assumptions shape the questions asked in the first place |
| Role duality inhibits candor | No participants from the candidate's own two regions; interviews arranged by a third party; no recording of names in transcripts | Managers elsewhere still know the candidate's function |
| Findings read as an HR position | Findings reported to the company only in aggregate; vice president of operations co-sponsors access | Some readers will still attribute motives |
| Candidate learns of a policy violation | Agreement in advance that the research role takes precedence, except where a legal duty to report applies, and participants told so | The candidate cannot unlearn what is heard |
The Hardest Case
The last row of the table deserves its own paragraph, because it is where the two roles collide most sharply. If a manager describes scheduling a minor beyond the hours state law allows, the candidate's employment role may require action. The statement does not pretend this tension can be resolved by design. It proposes that participants be told before the interview, in writing, which kinds of disclosure the candidate would be obliged to act on, so that each can decide what to say, and that the interview guide avoid questions likely to elicit such disclosures. That protects participants at some cost to the data, a cost the statement accepts openly.
What the Statement Commits To
The statement commits the candidate to three practices that will appear in the method chapter: excluding the candidate's own regions from the sample, keeping a reflexive journal whose entries are summarized in the dissertation's limitations section, and reporting at least one instance where preunderstanding was shown to be wrong by what a participant said. That last commitment is a test of the safeguards. If no such instance occurs, the statement asks the committee to treat the absence as a warning rather than a reassurance. The journal will be kept from the first recruitment contact, not from the first interview, because decisions about whom to approach are where an insider's assumptions first act on the data.
References
Brannick, T., & Coghlan, D. (2007). In defense of being "native": The case for insider academic research. Organizational Research Methods, 10(1), 59-74. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428106289253
Coghlan, D., & Brannick, T. (2014). Doing action research in your own organization (4th ed.). SAGE.
Mercer, J. (2007). The challenges of insider research in educational institutions: Wielding a double-edged sword and resolving delicate dilemmas. Oxford Review of Education, 33(1), 1-17. https://doi.org/10.1080/03054980601094651
Reading the GCU DBA 955 Topic 2 instructions
The Topic 2 assignment in DBA-955 asks doctoral students to write a positionality statement for research in their own organization. Strong statements open with the facts of position, including reporting lines and past dealings with likely participants, and explain why naming position matters. Students should show how position has already shaped the research question, analyze specific consequences of insider status and pair each with a safeguard and an honest account of what it cannot remove. The statement should address the hardest case where organizational and research duties collide and commit to practices the method chapter will carry.
Inside the DBA 955 Topic 2 example
The finished statement occupies a few pages of the proposal's method discussion, and the page presents its skeleton rather than a submittable section. It opens with the facts of position: the candidate's title, her reporting line, the regions she supports and the grievances she has handled for store managers who may become participants. Drawing on Coghlan and Brannick's account of insider research, it then names three consequences. Preunderstanding gives her fluency in scheduling rules and blinds her to practices she has stopped noticing. Role duality means a manager speaking to her is also speaking to the function that investigates complaints. Organizational politics means her findings will be read as an HR position whatever they say. For each consequence the statement pairs a specific safeguard with an honest note on what that safeguard cannot remove.
Where the marks sit in the DBA 955 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty reward position named with its limits. An Excellent statement opens with title, reporting line, regions and grievances handled. Credit goes to Brannick and Coghlan's defense of insider research and to showing the question broadened from rule-breaking to competing constraints. The rubric values Coghlan and Brannick's preunderstanding, role duality and politics made specific, with Mercer on candor, and a table of safeguards and limits. Strong statements face a disclosed violation openly. Top marks go to committing to report a case where preunderstanding proved wrong.
DBA 955 Topic 2 help before you submit
The version graders mark down most often reads as a confession of bias followed by a promise of objectivity, which describes a feeling and changes nothing in the design. Statements that list the candidate's role without saying how participants will read the confidentiality promise miss the consequence that matters most to the data. A second loss comes from generic safeguards, such as bracketing or reflexivity, named without saying which risk each addresses or how it will be checked. Some drafts present insider status only as an advantage, dwelling on access and rapport while skipping the role conflict a committee will raise at once. Others overcorrect and treat the position as disqualifying, undermining the study's rationale. Citing insider research literature without applying its concepts to the candidate's actual title and reporting line leaves the section generic enough to belong to anyone.
Get a DBA-955 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-955 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric from your classroom. We write a custom structural example to them, showing position, risks and matched safeguards, in 24 to 48 hours, and the first one is free. A dissertation is the candidate's own work: we never write chapters for a reader, and your IRB application, site permission letters, committee correspondence and signatures remain yours.
More DBA 955 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 955 Topic 1: Dissertation Problem Statement
- DBA 955 Topic 3: Literature Review Blueprint
- DBA 955 Topic 4: Gap Verification Memo
- DBA 955 Topic 5: Inconvenient Finding Dq Post
- DBA 955 Topic 6: Design Choice Justification
- DBA 955 Topic 7: Access Feasibility Plan
- DBA 955 Topic 8: Proposal Method Defense Brief
- DBA 960 Topic 2: Within-firm Recruitment Protocol
- DBA 839 Topic 2: Post-acquisition Integration Analysis
- DBA 965 Topic 2: Findings Chapter Presentation
- DBA 835 Topic 2: Materiality Assessment
DBA 955 Topic 2 questions, answered
What do Coghlan and Brannick mean by role duality?
In their work on researching one's own organization, Coghlan and Brannick describe the tension of holding an organizational role and a researcher role at once, with colleagues relating to the person in both. The example applies that idea to a human resources partner whose participants know she also handles complaints, and it treats their caution in interviews as a design condition to be managed and reported.
Does insider status weaken a dissertation?
Not by itself. Insider research can reach data and meanings an outsider would never see, and business doctorates are commonly built this way. What weakens a study is an insider position left unexamined, where the committee has to guess how the researcher's role shaped recruitment, interviews and interpretation. Stated plainly, with specific safeguards and admitted limits, the position becomes part of the method.
Can you write my positionality statement for me?
No. The statement describes your own position, relationships and expectations, and only you can know them or answer for them before a committee. The example on this page is a structural illustration built on a composite candidate, showing the parts such a statement typically contains and how they connect. Your dissertation, and every document submitted with it, is yours to write.
Where can I find a free DBA 955 Topic 2 sample paper?
The structural example is printed here in full: facts of position, why to name it, how it shaped the question, three consequences, safeguards and limits, the hardest case and commitments. Forward the DBA 955 Topic 2 prompt you received for a free paper.
Why exclude the candidate's own regions in DBA 955 Topic 2?
Store managers there have dealt with the candidate over grievances and policy, so role duality would weigh most heavily on their answers. Interviewing managers elsewhere reduces that pressure without removing it.