DBA 955 Topic 3 literature review blueprint example

Dissertation I Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 955 Topic 3 sample paper lays out a literature review on why commercial tenants renew as four premises leading to a study, for an asset manager at a composite property management company. It forms part of GCU DBA 955, Dissertation I, catalog code DBA-955, a course in the Grand Canyon University DBA. Following Webster and Watson, the review is concept-centric. Retention's cost, economic renewal research, relationship quality from Palmatier and colleagues and agent-delivered service read through Eisenhardt on agency each carry a premise. A table lists support and challenge for each, trade publications sit in a context column, and Torraco shapes the search log.

CourseDBA 955 Dissertation I
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeLiterature review blueprint
LengthAbout 1,000 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 955 Topic 3

1

Four Premises to a Study: A Literature Review Blueprint for Research on Why Commercial Tenants Renew

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

DBA-955: Dissertation I

Topic 3 Literature Review Blueprint

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the blueprint's organizing device. The candidate and the property company are composites; the sources are real. The blueprint shows structure and is not a chapter for submission.
2

Four Premises to a Study: A Literature Review Blueprint for Research on Why Commercial Tenants Renew

From Reading to Argument

A doctoral candidate who works as an asset manager at a composite commercial property management company proposes to study why office and light industrial tenants renew their leases. The candidate has read widely: two years of trade publications on leasing and tenant experience, several dozen journal articles on real estate and services marketing, and industry surveys of tenant satisfaction. The reading is not yet a review. Webster and Watson (2002) argued that an effective literature review is concept-centric rather than author-centric, organized around the ideas a study builds on rather than a summary of one source after another. This blueprint organizes the review as an argument in four premises, each of which must be established before the next can follow, ending at the gap the proposed study fills.

The Four Premises

The first premise is that tenant retention carries large economic weight for property owners. A tenant who leaves costs the owner months of vacancy, leasing commissions, improvements for the next tenant and free rent offered to attract one, often amounting to a year or more of the departing tenant's rent. This premise is the easiest to establish and should be the shortest section.

The second premise is that research on renewal has concentrated on economic factors: rent relative to market, lease terms, the cost of relocating and the availability of alternatives. This section must show what that research has found and, as important, what it has left unexplained, since even well-specified economic models leave much of the variation in renewal decisions to other factors.

The third premise is that work on relationship quality in business services suggests that day-to-day service interactions shape whether clients stay. Palmatier et al. (2006) synthesized studies of relationship marketing and found that relationship quality, including trust and commitment, was associated with customer loyalty and with seller performance, with effects that varied by context. This section must establish what relationship quality means, how it has been measured and where the evidence for its effects is strongest.

The fourth premise is that this work has rarely examined arrangements where the service provider is an agent acting for an owner. A tenant's daily experience is shaped by the property manager, who works for the owner, not by the owner directly. Eisenhardt (1989) reviewed agency theory, which examines how principals and agents with different interests and information manage their relationship. In leased property, the tenant experiences an agent's service while contracting with the principal, and the relationship marketing literature has not addressed what that triangle does to relationship quality and renewal.

The Blueprint

Under each premise, the blueprint records the bodies of literature that carry it, the strongest source for the premise, the strongest source against or qualifying it, and the claim the section must end on.

Table 1

Literature Review Blueprint by Premise

PremiseLiterature that carries itStrongest supportStrongest challenge or qualificationSection must end on
Retention matters economicallyReal estate finance; leasing cost studiesPublished estimates of tenant turnover costsVariation by market and property typeTurnover is costly enough to justify study
Renewal research is mostly economicReal estate economics; lease choice studiesModels of renewal on rent and termsStudies noting large unexplained variationEconomic factors leave much unexplained
Relationship quality affects retention in servicesServices and relationship marketingPalmatier et al. (2006) meta-analysisEffects vary by context and measureRelationship quality is a plausible missing factor
Agent-delivered service is understudiedAgency theory; services triadsEisenhardt (1989) on principals and agentsSome work on outsourced serviceThe gap: tenant relationship quality with an agent manager

Where the Argument Lands

The four premises lead to one research question: how do tenants' experiences of the property manager, as distinct from the owner, shape their decisions to renew? The question follows only if every premise holds. If retention were cheap, the study would not matter; if economic factors explained renewal well, there would be little left to explain; if relationship quality had no link to retention in business services, there would be no reason to look for it here; and if agent-delivered service had been studied thoroughly, there would be no gap. Writing the chain out this way also shows the committee where the argument is weakest, which is the fourth link, and where the review must therefore be most careful.

The Place of Trade Publications

The candidate's two years of trade reading are valuable but must be placed correctly. Trade publications describe practice, report surveys of uneven method and advocate for services their sponsors sell. They do not test claims. In the blueprint they appear in a separate column labeled context, used to show that the industry treats tenant experience as important and to describe practices the study will examine, but never cited as evidence that relationship quality causes renewal. Separating them in the plan prevents them from drifting into the argument when the chapter is drafted.

How the Search Will Be Run

Torraco (2005) argued that an integrative literature review should describe how literature was identified, selected and analyzed, so that readers can judge its coverage. The blueprint therefore fixes, for each premise, the databases to search, including business, real estate and services marketing indexes; the search terms and their combinations; the date range; and the inclusion rules, such as peer-reviewed empirical studies of business-to-business relationships. The search log will be kept as an appendix to the chapter.

What the Blueprint Prevents

Built this way, the review cannot become a catalog of everything the candidate has read. Every source must carry one of four premises or be left out. The fourth premise is the one most likely to be challenged by the committee, since a gap claimed is not a gap proven, and it will receive the most rigorous search. If that search finds a body of work on agent-delivered services the candidate has missed, the premise, and the study, will be narrowed before the chapter is written.

References

Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989). Agency theory: An assessment and review. Academy of Management Review, 14(1), 57-74. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1989.4279003

Palmatier, R. W., Dant, R. P., Grewal, D., & Evans, K. R. (2006). Factors influencing the effectiveness of relationship marketing: A meta-analysis. Journal of Marketing, 70(4), 136-153. https://doi.org/10.1509/jmkg.70.4.136

Torraco, R. J. (2005). Writing integrative literature reviews: Guidelines and examples. Human Resource Development Review, 4(3), 356-367. https://doi.org/10.1177/1534484305278283

Webster, J., & Watson, R. T. (2002). Analyzing the past to prepare for the future: Writing a literature review. MIS Quarterly, 26(2), xiii-xxiii.

DBA 955 Topic 3 instructions, in plain terms

In Topic 3, DBA-955 asks doctoral students to plan a literature review as an argument rather than a summary. Strong blueprints state the premises the review must establish in order, show how they lead to the research question and identify where the chain is weakest. Students should list for each premise the bodies of literature that carry it, the strongest supporting and challenging sources and the claim the section must end on. The blueprint should place practitioner sources correctly, describe how the search will be run and recorded, and explain what the plan prevents the chapter from becoming.

Inside the DBA 955 Topic 3 example

The finished blueprint is a planning document for the literature review chapter, and what appears here is its frame, not the chapter. Across its top runs the argument in four premises. Tenant retention carries large economic weight for property owners. Research on renewal has concentrated on rent, lease terms and relocation costs. Work on relationship quality in business services suggests that day-to-day service interactions shape whether clients stay. That work has rarely examined arrangements where the service provider is a manager acting for an owner rather than the owner itself. Under each premise sit the bodies of literature that carry it, the strongest source for and against, and the claim the section must end on. Trade publications appear in a separate column labeled context, since they describe practice without testing it.

Reading the DBA 955 Topic 3 rubric

Faculty reward reading organized into an argument. An Excellent blueprint follows Webster and Watson's concept-centric approach through four premises ending at the gap. Credit goes to a table giving each premise its literature, strongest support and challenge, using Palmatier and colleagues on relationship quality and Eisenhardt on agency. The rubric values showing the research question follows only if every premise holds. Strong blueprints keep trade publications as context and plan a search Torraco would recognize. Top marks go to naming the fourth premise as the weakest link.

Common DBA 955 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Literature chapters lose credit fastest when they are organized by topic and leave the reader to assemble the argument, and a blueprint that merely lists themes plans that failure in advance. Piling sources under a premise without saying what each shows gives the chapter volume without direction. Insider candidates frequently lean on trade publications they read at work, which describe practice persuasively and test nothing, and graders notice when a premise rests on them. A theoretical lens chosen because it appeared in a favorite article, without a reason tied to the problem, becomes difficult to defend when the committee asks why this lens and not another. Blueprints that never state the gap first cannot show that each section serves it. Premises that do not depend on one another produce a review that reads as several short essays sharing a bibliography.

Get a DBA-955 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-955 Topic 3 instructions and your classroom rubric, with any required sources. We write a custom structural example to them, showing a review planned as premises, in 24 to 48 hours, and the first one is free. Your dissertation is your own work: chapters are never written for a reader, and your IRB application, site permissions, committee correspondence and signatures stay yours.

More DBA 955 papers and DBA samples

DBA 955 Topic 3 questions, answered

How is a literature review different from a summary of sources?

A summary reports what each study found. A review argues something with those findings, typically that existing knowledge supports some claims, leaves others contested and has not reached the question the proposed study asks. The blueprint makes that argument visible before any prose is drafted, so each source is placed where it does work rather than where it happened to be read.

Can trade publications appear in a doctoral literature review?

They can supply context, such as how an industry describes its own practices or problems, but they rarely test claims and cannot carry a premise on their own. Committees expect premises to rest on peer-reviewed research or comparably rigorous work. The blueprint keeps trade material in a separate column so its role is clear and no premise depends on it quietly.

Where does the theoretical framework come from?

From the literature the review has already assembled, chosen because it explains the relationship the study asks about. In the example, relationship quality research offers a way to think about why service interactions affect whether clients stay, and the review tests whether that lens fits a setting with a manager between tenant and owner. A lens chosen for familiarity rather than fit is hard to defend.

Where can I find a free DBA 955 Topic 3 sample paper?

The structural example is shown here complete: from reading to argument, four premises, the blueprint table, where the argument lands, trade publications, the search plan and what the blueprint prevents. Send your DBA 955 Topic 3 prompt and a paper follows free.

Why is the fourth premise the weakest in DBA 955 Topic 3?

It claims that agent-delivered service has rarely been studied, and a gap claimed is not a gap proven. It therefore gets the most rigorous search, and the study narrows if that search finds missed work.