| Course | DNP 815A Scientific Underpinnings |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Philosophy of science application paper |
| Length | About 1,380 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP 815A Topic 1
Sixty-One Percent Before the Catheter: What an Empirical and an Interpretive Position Can Each Establish About a Skipped Bladder Scan
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
DNP-815A: Scientific Underpinnings
Topic 1 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
March 22, 2027
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Sixty-One Percent Before the Catheter: What an Empirical and an Interpretive Position Can Each Establish About a Skipped Bladder Scan
The Practice Problem, Stated as a Figure
On a composite 30-bed orthopedic surgical unit in a community hospital, the nurse-driven urinary retention protocol requires a portable bladder scan before any intermittent catheterization of a postoperative patient who has not voided. The step exists because the scan separates a full bladder from an empty one, and catheterizing an empty or modestly filled bladder exposes the patient to discomfort, urethral trauma and infection risk for no benefit. A three-month chart audit of 184 intermittent catheterizations found a documented scan beforehand in 112 of them, or 61 percent. The remaining 72 catheterizations were performed on clinical judgment alone.
The figure is the anchor for this paper. It gives each philosophical position something concrete to explain, and it keeps the analysis from drifting into a history of ideas. The question throughout is practical: what can each way of knowing tell a DNP project about this 61 percent, and what is it unable to tell?
The Empirical Position and What It Accepts as Evidence
The empirical position, in the postpositivist form that most quantitative nursing research uses, holds that knowledge about practice comes from observation that can be measured, repeated and checked by someone else. It accepts imperfect measurement and expects error, but it treats a claim as warranted only when the observation behind it could be made again by another observer with the same result (Weaver & Olson, 2006). Evidence under this view is a count, a rate, a comparison between groups or an association that holds after other explanations have been considered. A nurse's account of why a step was skipped is data only in the sense that it can be coded and counted; its meaning to the nurse is outside what the position is built to weigh.
Applying the Empirical Position to the 61 Percent
Applied to the audit, the empirical position produces three findings with some confidence. First, the rate itself: 61 percent, with a denominator of 184 catheterizations and a measurement window of three months, drawn from the same documentation fields for every case. Second, variation by shift. Of the 92 catheterizations performed on day shift, 70 were preceded by a scan, or 76 percent; of the 92 performed at night, 42 were, or 46 percent. A 30-point difference in a sample this size is unlikely to be chance. Third, an association with workload: completion was lower when the catheterizing nurse was assigned six patients than when the assignment was five or fewer.
The position can go one step further and test an explanation that is itself observable. The unit shares one scanner with the adjacent surgical unit, and the equipment log shows the scanner was on the other unit for a large part of most nights. That association between scanner location and skipped scans can be measured directly.
What the empirical position cannot establish is why a particular nurse, standing at a particular bedside, decided to catheterize without scanning. The shift difference and the scanner log suggest an answer, but an association between night shift and skipped scans is compatible with several reasons: the scanner was unavailable, the nurse judged the scan unnecessary, the patient was in pain and relief was the priority, or the documentation was completed later and incompletely. Each would call for a different intervention, and the counts cannot distinguish among them. Treating the association as the reason would be a causal claim the design does not support.
The Interpretive Position, Applied to the Same Problem
The interpretive position holds that practice is carried out by people acting on meanings, and that knowledge of practice therefore includes understanding those meanings from the inside. It accepts as evidence the accounts of the people doing the work, gathered through interviews or observation and interpreted in context, and it judges the quality of a claim by its credibility and depth rather than by its repeatability (Weaver & Olson, 2006). The personal and aesthetic patterns of knowing described by Carper (1978) in nursing sits close to this view: much of what a nurse knows at the bedside is perceptual and situated, and it is not captured by a count.
Applied to the same 61 percent, the interpretive position asks the nurses. Semi-structured conversations with eight nurses, four from each shift, produced three distinct lines of reasoning. The first was confidence in palpation and observation: several experienced nurses described being able to see and feel a distended bladder and regarded the scan as confirming what they already knew. The second was the scanner's absence at night, described less as an inconvenience than as a choice between leaving a patient in discomfort for 30 minutes and catheterizing now. The third was unexpected. Two night nurses said they scanned more often than the audit showed but documented the result in a free-text note rather than the protocol field, because the field sat on a screen they rarely opened at night.
That third finding shows what the interpretive position can establish and the empirical position could not: it revealed a reason the measurement itself may be wrong. What the interpretive position cannot establish is how widespread any of these lines of reasoning is. Eight conversations tell the project that the documentation problem exists; they cannot say whether it accounts for 5 of the 72 missing scans or 40 of them. They also cannot say whether the confidence in palpation is justified, which is itself an empirical question.
Different Questions, Not Rival Answers
Put side by side, the two positions did not compete to explain the same thing. The empirical position answered how often, where and under what conditions. The interpretive position answered what the step means to the people who skip it and what they are weighing when they do. Neither answer substitutes for the other. The shift and workload associations would have produced a staffing or equipment intervention; the interviews show that at least part of the night-shift gap may be a documentation artifact, and that part of the remainder reflects a judgment about palpation that nurses hold with some confidence. The evidence on that judgment matters: a meta-analysis found that using a bladder scanner rather than nurse judgment alone was associated with markedly lower odds of catheter-associated urinary tract infection (odds ratio 0.27; Palese et al., 2010), which suggests the confidence is not fully warranted as a basis for skipping the scan.
Declaring one position superior would miss the point of setting them against each other. A project built only on the empirical findings would buy a second scanner and might see little change if the documentation issue carries much of the gap. A project built only on the interviews would redesign the documentation screen and would not know whether the real rate had moved.
Which the Project Needs First
The project needs the empirical question answered first, then the interpretive one, then the empirical one again. The sequence matters because asking why before establishing how often can produce detailed explanations for a problem that turns out to be smaller, or different, than it looked. Here, the first audit already raised a doubt about its own measure. The next step is therefore a short prospective audit, two weeks long, in which the scan result is checked against both the protocol field and free-text notes, so the true completion rate is known with the documentation artifact removed.
With that rate in hand, interpretive work can be aimed where the remaining gap sits. If the corrected night rate is still well below the day rate, a second round of conversations with night staff about palpation and the tradeoff with patient discomfort becomes the priority. The recently published appropriateness-based algorithm for adult inpatients, which prefers scanning to catheterization for diagnosis and sets scan volumes that should prompt catheterization, gives those conversations a reference point that staff did not help build but can argue with (Chrouser et al., 2024). The final step returns to measurement. Whatever the project changes, success will be judged by the corrected rate and by catheterizations performed at low scanned volumes, so the project will count scans documented in either field, catheterizations by scanned volume and shift, and the scanner's location by hour.
References
Carper, B. A. (1978). Fundamental patterns of knowing in nursing. Advances in Nursing Science, 1(1), 13-24. https://doi.org/10.1097/00012272-197810000-00004
Chrouser, K., Fowler, K. E., Mann, J. D., Quinn, M., Ameling, J., Hendren, S., Krapohl, G., Skolarus, T. A., Bernstein, S. J., & Meddings, J. (2024). Urinary retention evaluation and catheterization algorithm for adult inpatients. JAMA Network Open, 7(7), Article e2422281. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.22281
Palese, A., Buchini, S., Deroma, L., & Barbone, F. (2010). The effectiveness of the ultrasound bladder scanner in reducing urinary tract infections: A meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 19(21-22), 2970-2979. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2702.2010.03281.x
Weaver, K., & Olson, J. K. (2006). Understanding paradigms used for nursing research. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 53(4), 459-469. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2648.2006.03740.x
Reading the GCU DNP 815A Topic 1 instructions
Topic 1 in DNP-815A asks students to examine how philosophical positions on knowledge apply to nursing practice. Strong papers state a practice problem as a figure, then apply at least two positions to it, explaining what each accepts as evidence and what it can establish. Students should show that the positions ask different questions rather than offering rival answers, and decide which question their project needs answered first and why. Faculty value application over history: a sentence placing each position is enough, and the space should go to what each position does with the same problem. Carper's patterns of knowing can help show what each position leaves out.
How this DNP 815A Topic 1 example is built
The finished example uses philosophy as a tool rather than describing it as a subject. A single problem runs through the whole paper: a required safety step completed in sixty one percent of cases on one unit. The paper asks what a strictly empirical position can establish here, which is the rate, its variation by shift and its association with workload, and then what it cannot, which is why the step is skipped. It then asks what an interpretive position can establish, which is the reasoning staff use, and what it cannot, which is how widespread that reasoning is. Neither is presented as superior. The conclusion is that the project needs both and states which question each is answering, with the sequence between them argued.
Reading the DNP 815A Topic 1 rubric
Faculty reward positions applied to the same problem. An Excellent paper states the 61 percent rate with its denominator of 184 and its window, then derives three empirical findings, including the night shift gap. Credit goes to the interpretive position, after Weaver and Olson, uncovering nurses' reasons for trusting palpation, with Carper's patterns of knowing in support. The rubric values treating the positions as answering different questions. Strong papers avoid declaring a winner. Top marks go to sequencing empirical, interpretive and empirical questions for the project, with reasons.
DNP 815A Topic 1 help before you submit
There is one error this section catches every time: a paper that recounts the history of positivism and its critics without applying either to anything. A second failure is declaring one position superior, which misreads a course built on the premise that practice scholarship needs both. Marks also go for describing ways of knowing as a list, since the list is in the reading and reproducing it demonstrates nothing. Papers that never state a practice problem leave the philosophy with no object. Comparisons that put each position to a different question compare nothing. Conclusions with no sequence attached leave the writer without a first step for the project ahead. Papers that argue about knowledge without ever naming what the project will count leave the philosophy with no consequence.
Get a DNP-815A Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the DNP-815A Topic 1 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with any framework your section requires. We write a custom example to those criteria, applying each position to one stated practice problem, reporting what each can and cannot establish, with the sequence argued, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More DNP 815A papers and DNP samples
- DNP 815A Topic 2: Discovery and Practice Scholarship Contrast
- DNP 815A Topic 3: Nursing Theory Selection
- DNP 815A Topic 4: Borrowed Theory Evaluation
- DNP 815A Topic 5: Practice Model Comparison DQ Pair
- DNP 815A Topic 6: Translation Framework Application
- DNP 815A Topic 7: Framework Selection for Practice Problem
- DNP 815A Topic 8: Theory Durability Statement
- DNP 820 Topic 1: Translation Science Orientation
- DNP 810 Topic 1: Genomic Practice Role Paper
- DNP 825 Topic 1: Population Thinking Paper
- DNP 805 Topic 1: Informatics Competency Analysis
DNP 815A Topic 1 questions, answered
Why does philosophy of science matter to a practice project?
Because it decides what will count as evidence that your project worked. A position that accepts only measured outcomes will not credit what staff tell you about why a step is skipped; a position that accepts only accounts will not establish how often it happens. Choosing knowingly, and saying which question each method answers, prevents an argument in the methods courses.
Should I pick one position and defend it?
Not in this course. Papers arguing that one view is correct misread what a practice doctorate does, since translation work almost always needs a rate and a reason. Show what each position establishes for your problem and where each stops. The defensible conclusion is a sequence, not a winner.
How much history should I include?
Almost none. A sentence placing a position is enough; a chronology of who argued what is the reading restated. The marks here are for application, and a paper that spends half its length on background arrives at its own problem with no room to work on it. Start with the practice problem and bring in the philosophy where it decides something.
Where can I find a free DNP 815A Topic 1 sample paper?
The philosophy paper for DNP 815A Topic 1 covers the problem as a figure, the empirical position and its evidence, the empirical position applied, the interpretive position applied, different questions and which the project needs first. Send your DNP 815A Topic 1 prompt and a paper follows free.
Why answer the empirical question first in DNP 815A Topic 1?
Asking why before establishing how often can produce detailed explanations for a problem that turns out to be smaller or differently located than assumed. The rate and its pattern come first.