DNP 815A Topic 3 nursing theory selection example

Scientific Underpinnings Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DNP 815A Topic 3 sample paper puts three nursing theories to the same three questions for a scan-first urinary retention project, where 39 percent of postoperative catheterizations skip the required scan and night completion is 46 percent. It forms part of GCU DNP 815A, Scientific Underpinnings, catalog code DNP-815A, taken within Grand Canyon University's DNP. Orem's self-care deficit theory is tested and set aside because the deficit lies in the system. Kolcaba's comfort theory fits but fails on measurement, since its 48-item questionnaire cannot capture scan completion. The Quality Health Outcomes Model by Mitchell and colleagues survives and commits the project to four groups of measures.

CourseDNP 815A Scientific Underpinnings
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeNursing theory selection paper
LengthAbout 1,200 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDNP
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DNP 815A Topic 3

1

Three Theories, Three Questions, One Survivor: Selecting a Nursing Theory for a Scan-First Urinary Retention Project

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

DNP-815A: Scientific Underpinnings

Topic 3 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

April 5, 2027

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the method (a fixed test applied three times) and the outcome, so the reader expects evaluation rather than a survey. The unit is the composite carried from Topics 1 and 2.
2

Three Theories, Three Questions, One Survivor: Selecting a Nursing Theory for a Scan-First Urinary Retention Project

The Problem the Theories Must Address

On the composite 30-bed orthopedic unit, 39 percent of intermittent catheterizations of postoperative patients are performed without the bladder scan the protocol requires, and completion is 76 percent on day shift and 46 percent at night. Topic 2 added that voiding information is often missing at shift change. For theory selection, the problem has to be restated in terms any candidate theory would need to address: postoperative patients are being catheterized on incomplete information, some of them unnecessarily, because a nursing process step is inconsistently performed under conditions that differ by shift. The project will change that process, and the theory chosen has to say something about why the process fails, what should improve for patients if it is fixed, and what the project must observe to know.

The Three Questions Each Candidate Must Answer

Each theory is put to the same three questions. First, what does this theory say is happening in the problem as stated? Second, if the scan-first intervention works, what does the theory predict will change? Third, what does the theory therefore require the project to measure? The third question is the practical one. A theory that cannot answer it leaves the project with a framework on the first page and no connection between that framework and the data collected. Asking the same questions of every candidate is also what makes the choice defensible: a reader who disagrees can see exactly where each theory succeeded or failed.

Orem's Self-Care Deficit Theory, Tested and Set Aside

The self-care deficit nursing theory developed by Orem (2001) is a grand theory that explains nursing as action taken when a person's capacity for self-care falls short of the demands on it. Applied to the first question, it offers a reasonable account. A patient recovering from hip or knee replacement, often after spinal anesthesia and opioid analgesia, may be unable to meet the universal self-care requisite of elimination, so nursing moves into a partly compensatory system and acts on the patient's behalf. The bladder scan belongs to that compensatory action.

The theory begins to strain at the second question. It predicts that effective nursing agency will meet the patient's therapeutic self-care demand, which is true of the intervention but equally true of catheterizing without a scan, since both are compensatory actions directed at elimination. The theory does not distinguish between a well-informed and a poorly informed compensatory act. At the third question it offers nothing the project could observe. Nursing agency, self-care demand and the adequacy of a nursing system are concepts pitched at a level of abstraction that describes all nursing, and none of them points to a count, a rate or a volume. The theory is set aside because it cannot tell the project what to measure, not because it describes the situation wrongly.

Two Middle Range Candidates

The theory of comfort proposed by Kolcaba (1994) is a middle range theory that treats comfort as an immediate, holistic outcome of nursing care, experienced in relief, ease and transcendence across physical, psychospiritual, sociocultural and environmental contexts. Its answer to the first question is persuasive and patient-centered. A patient with a distended bladder is uncomfortable, and so is a patient catheterized for a bladder holding 180 milliliters; night nurses in Topic 1 described exactly this tension between relieving discomfort now and waiting for the scanner. Its answer to the second question is clear: if the intervention works, patients should experience fewer unnecessary catheterizations and less discomfort while retention is identified and treated.

The Quality Health Outcomes Model developed by Mitchell et al. (1998) is a middle range model derived from Donabedian's structure, process and outcome framework, with one important revision: it holds that interventions affect outcomes through the system in which they are delivered and the characteristics of the patients who receive them, rather than directly. Its answer to the first question fits the audit closely. A system characteristic, one shared scanner that is often on another unit at night, and a staffing characteristic, heavier assignments, shape whether the intervention is performed at all. Its answer to the second question is that outcomes should improve only to the extent the system permits the intervention and only in ways that depend on patient characteristics, such as spinal anesthesia or a history of prostatic enlargement, which raise the baseline risk of retention. At the third question it gives the project a full list of observable concepts: system characteristics, intervention delivery, patient characteristics and outcomes.

The Subtler Rejection

The comfort theory fails at the third question, and its fit is not the problem. Its central concept is measured with the General Comfort Questionnaire, a 48-item instrument built from the theory's taxonomic structure of comfort (Kolcaba, 1992). The concept is right for this problem. The instrument is not practical in this setting. The patients whose comfort matters most here are being assessed at night, often a few hours after surgery, with pain, opioids and sometimes a full bladder, and asking them to complete dozens of items at that moment would be unkind and would yield poor data. A single pain or discomfort rating could be collected, but that would measure something narrower than the theory's concept, and using the theory while measuring something else is the pattern this selection is meant to avoid.

Comfort therefore stays in the project as a value and as a patient-reported secondary item, but not as the framework. That distinction is worth keeping: a theory can be correct about what matters and still be the wrong choice when its concept cannot be measured where the project happens.

What this page is doingEach rejection is shown as a worked attempt against the same questions. The comfort theory is rejected on instrumentation, which is the practical reason the topic is written to surface.
3

What the Surviving Theory Obliges the Project to Measure

Choosing the Quality Health Outcomes Model commits the project to four groups of measures, one for each concept, and to analyzing them together rather than reporting outcomes alone. System characteristics: the scanner's location by hour, the nurse-to-patient ratio at the time of each catheterization, and shift. Intervention delivery: whether a scan was performed and documented before each catheterization, counting documentation in either the protocol field or a free-text note, as Topic 1 showed was necessary. Patient characteristics: procedure, anesthesia type, age, sex, and relevant history such as prostatic enlargement or preoperative voiding difficulty. Outcomes: catheterizations per 100 postoperative patients, the share of catheterizations performed at a scanned volume below the protocol's threshold, and catheter-associated urinary tract infections, recognizing that the last will be too rare on one unit to move within a project timeline.

The threshold itself needs an external reference, and the appropriateness-based algorithm for adult inpatients provides one: scanning is preferred over catheterization for diagnosis, and scanned volumes of 300 milliliters or more in symptomatic patients and 500 milliliters or more in asymptomatic patients are rated appropriate to prompt catheterization (Chrouser et al., 2024). The model's central claim also shapes the analysis. If completion rises on day shift but not at night, the model predicts that the system characteristic, the scanner's location, is limiting the intervention, and the project must be able to show that. Measuring completion without measuring the scanner's location would make that prediction untestable, so the location log is not optional.

References

Chrouser, K., Fowler, K. E., Mann, J. D., Quinn, M., Ameling, J., Hendren, S., Krapohl, G., Skolarus, T. A., Bernstein, S. J., & Meddings, J. (2024). Urinary retention evaluation and catheterization algorithm for adult inpatients. JAMA Network Open, 7(7), Article e2422281. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.22281

Kolcaba, K. Y. (1992). Holistic comfort: Operationalizing the construct as a nurse-sensitive outcome. Advances in Nursing Science, 15(1), 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1097/00012272-199209000-00003

Kolcaba, K. Y. (1994). A theory of holistic comfort for nursing. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 19(6), 1178-1184. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2648.1994.tb01202.x

Mitchell, P. H., Ferketich, S., Jennings, B. M., & American Academy of Nursing Expert Panel on Quality Health Care. (1998). Quality health outcomes model. Image: The Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 30(1), 43-46. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1547-5069.1998.tb01234.x

Orem, D. E. (2001). Nursing: Concepts of practice (6th ed.). Mosby.

DNP 815A Topic 3 instructions, in plain terms

Topic 3 in DNP-815A asks students to select a nursing theory to guide their project. Strong papers state the problem precisely, then apply each candidate theory to it using the same questions, such as what the theory says is happening, what it would direct the project to change and what it would require the project to measure. Students should reject theories by applying them first rather than dismissing them by type, explain subtler rejections where a theory fits but cannot be measured at the site and state what the chosen theory obliges the project to observe. Middle range theories usually suit projects that must measure outcomes. A table of the three questions for each theory helps faculty follow the reasoning.

How this DNP 815A Topic 3 example is built

The finished example evaluates rather than describes. One problem is fixed at the start, and three theories are then tested against it with the same three questions: what does this theory say is happening here, what would it predict changes if the intervention works, and what does it therefore require the project to measure. A grand theory is rejected because it operates at a level too abstract to specify any measure. A middle range theory survives because it names the concepts the project can actually observe. The third is rejected for a subtler reason, which is that its central concept has no validated instrument short enough to administer in this setting. The surviving theory is then followed into its measurement obligations.

DNP 815A Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward theories rejected after being applied. An Excellent paper puts Orem, Kolcaba and the Quality Health Outcomes Model to the same three questions. Credit goes to setting Orem aside because the deficit belongs to the night shift system, not the patient. The rubric values the subtler rejection of comfort theory, whose General Comfort Questionnaire measures comfort rather than scan completion. Strong papers explain why Mitchell and colleagues' model fits a system problem. Top marks go to its four concepts turned into measures, from scanner availability to retention outcomes.

Common DNP 815A Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

What sinks these papers is the survey format, where three theories are described in turn and one is named at the end with no test having been applied. A second failure is choosing a grand theory for a project needing measurable concepts, which produces a framework decorating the paper rather than directing it. Marks also go for stating a choice without saying what it obliges the project to measure, since that obligation is the entire practical value of selecting a theory. Rejections offered with no attempt at application read as preference. Papers that change the problem to fit a favored theory have reversed the exercise. Instruments assumed to exist, without being named, cause trouble two courses later.

Get a DNP-815A Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the DNP-815A Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the theories your section requires. We write a custom example to those criteria, testing candidates against one fixed problem, with rejections argued and the surviving theory's measurement obligations named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More DNP 815A papers and DNP samples

DNP 815A Topic 3 questions, answered

Grand or middle range?

Middle range, almost always, for a project that has to measure something. Grand theories describe nursing at a level that cannot specify an observation, which is valuable for the discipline and unhelpful for a project needing a baseline. Where instructions require engagement with a grand theory, use it to frame the problem and select a middle range theory to direct the measurement.

How do I reject a theory properly?

Apply it first. A rejection carries weight when the paper shows the attempt: here is what this theory says is happening, here is what it would have us measure, and here is why that fails for this setting. A rejection stated as a preference, with no application behind it, reads as a theory the writer did not want to work with.

What does a chosen theory actually commit me to?

Specific observations. If the theory holds that self efficacy drives the behavior, the project has to measure self efficacy, which means finding an instrument, administering it and reporting it. That obligation is the reason selection matters. A theory named in the introduction and absent from the measurement plan was decoration rather than a framework.

Where can I find a free DNP 815A Topic 3 sample paper?

The theory selection paper for DNP 815A Topic 3 covers the problem, three questions, Orem tested and set aside, two middle range candidates, the subtler rejection and what the surviving theory obliges the project to measure. Post your DNP 815A Topic 3 prompt and get a free paper.

Why was comfort theory rejected in DNP 815A Topic 3?

Not for poor fit but for measurement: its central concept is measured with a 48-item comfort questionnaire, which cannot show whether scans happen before catheterization.