| Course | DNP 815A Scientific Underpinnings |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Discovery versus practice design paper |
| Length | About 1,230 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP 815A Topic 2
One Handover Question, Designed Twice: A Discovery Study and a Practice Project on Omitted Voiding Information at Shift Change
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
DNP-815A: Scientific Underpinnings
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
March 29, 2027
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
One Handover Question, Designed Twice: A Discovery Study and a Practice Project on Omitted Voiding Information at Shift Change
A Question Both Traditions Could Take Up
The Topic 1 conversations on the composite orthopedic unit surfaced a detail that bears on the skipped bladder scans: several night nurses said they often did not know when a postoperative patient had last voided, because the information had not come across at shift change. The question that follows is one that both a researcher and a practice scholar could reasonably pursue: does a structured bedside handover that includes a fixed voiding line, stating the time of last void, the most recent scan volume and when the next scan is due, reduce the omission of voiding information at shift change?
The question is deliberately narrow, and it matters for patients. An omitted voiding line leaves the receiving nurse to reconstruct the patient's status from the chart or to guess, and guessing is how catheterizations happen without a scan. The same question is designed below as a discovery study and as a practice project, in enough detail that either design could be criticized on practical grounds.
The Discovery Version
A discovery study would aim to establish whether structured handover with a voiding line reduces omissions across surgical inpatient units in general. Its design would be a cluster randomized trial. Twelve adult surgical units in six hospitals would be randomized, six to the structured handover and six to usual practice, with randomization at the unit level because handover is a unit practice and individual randomization would contaminate the comparison. The primary outcome would be the proportion of handovers omitting any element of the voiding line, measured from audio recordings coded by raters blinded to allocation. Secondary outcomes would include catheterizations without a preceding scan and catheter-associated urinary tract infections. The sample size would be calculated from an expected baseline omission rate and the intraclass correlation within units, and the study would run for roughly two years including recruitment and analysis.
The claim such a study could support is general: in surgical units like these, structured handover with a voiding line reduces omissions by a stated amount, with a confidence interval. Its audience is the research literature and, through it, guideline developers. The multicenter handoff study by Starmer et al. (2014) shows the scale this kind of claim requires: nine hospitals, 10,740 admissions, standardized oral and written handoffs with training and observation, and a 23 percent reduction in the medical error rate, with no significant change in the length of oral handoffs. Its authority comes from that scale and from the control of competing explanations.
The Practice Version
A practice project would aim to reduce omitted voiding information on one unit, the orthopedic unit where the problem was found. It would run as a quality improvement project measured repeatedly before and after the change. The unit's existing bedside handover sheet would be revised with the charge nurses and two staff nurses from each shift, adding the voiding line in the place nurses said they would actually look. Baseline data would come from 40 observed handovers over two weeks, checked against a short list of elements; the same observation would be repeated in two-week blocks after the change, with results posted for staff. Plan-do-study-act cycles would allow the line's wording and position to be adjusted if nurses bypassed it.
Success in this version is local and specific: the proportion of handovers that include all three voiding elements rises and stays up for three months, and the share of catheterizations preceded by a documented scan increases on the same unit. The audience is the people who work there, the nurse manager, and the hospital's quality committee. The timeline is about 16 weeks from planning to the end of the sustainment check.
The Two Designs Compared
Table 1
Discovery and Practice Designs for the Same Handover Question
| Dimension | Discovery study | Practice project |
|---|---|---|
| Sample | Twelve units in six hospitals, randomized by unit | One unit, all handovers during observation blocks |
| Control | Concurrent control units; blinded outcome coding | Unit serves as its own baseline; no concurrent control |
| Timeline | About two years | About 16 weeks |
| Audience | Researchers, guideline developers, journal readers | Unit staff, nurse manager, quality committee |
| What counts as success | A statistically significant reduction in omissions, with an effect size that transfers | Voiding elements present in most handovers and sustained for three months on this unit |
Table 1 compares the designs on five dimensions. The differences are connected: once the audience is chosen, most of the rest follows. A study written for a journal needs control and scale because its readers must trust that the finding holds elsewhere. A project written for one unit needs speed, local fit and staff ownership, because its readers will act on it next month.
What Each Cannot Deliver
The practice project cannot support a generalizable claim. It has no concurrent control, so a rise in complete handovers could reflect the attention of being observed, a new charge nurse, or a seasonal drop in surgical volume. It adapts the intervention as it goes, so the version tested at the end is not the version tested at the start. And it runs on one unit with its own culture and staffing. A practice project that reported its result as evidence that structured handovers work in general would be overclaiming in exactly the way the distinction between the two degrees is meant to prevent (Edwardson, 2010). Its honest claim is that the change worked here, under these conditions, for this period.
The discovery study cannot change the unit where the problem was found. Even if the orthopedic unit were one of the twelve, it would have a 50 percent chance of landing in the control arm, and the trial protocol would forbid local adaptation during the study. Its result would arrive in about two years, and a systematic review of bedside handoff research found that the literature already includes many studies with varied designs and outcomes (Mardis et al., 2016); one more trial would add to that body of evidence without guaranteeing that anyone on this unit reads it. The two designs are complementary in the sense Edwardson (2010) describes: discovery research builds knowledge the practice scholar can translate, and practice projects surface questions that researchers can take up. Neither does the other's job.
Placing My Own Problem
My DNP project belongs in the practice tradition. The problem is defined by one unit's audit, the people who need to act on the result work on that unit, and the change has to fit its handover routine, its scanner and its documentation screens. I am not trying to establish whether structured handover works in surgical units in general; the multicenter evidence already gives reason to expect that standardized handoffs can reduce errors without lengthening them (Starmer et al., 2014). I am trying to find out whether a voiding line, placed where these nurses will use it, closes a specific gap here.
Placing the project there has consequences I accept in advance. I will write its results as a local improvement with its limits stated, not as a finding. I will measure what the unit cares about, which includes nurses' time, rather than only what a journal reviewer would ask for. And if the result is strong, the right next step is not to generalize it myself but to describe the method clearly enough that a researcher could test it across units.
References
Edwardson, S. R. (2010). Doctor of philosophy and doctor of nursing practice as complementary degrees. Journal of Professional Nursing, 26(3), 137-140. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.profnurs.2009.08.004
Mardis, T., Mardis, M., Davis, J., Justice, E. M., Riley Holdinsky, S., Donnelly, J., Ragozine-Bush, H., & Riesenberg, L. A. (2016). Bedside shift-to-shift handoffs: A systematic review of the literature. Journal of Nursing Care Quality, 31(1), 54-60. https://doi.org/10.1097/NCQ.0000000000000142
Starmer, A. J., Spector, N. D., Srivastava, R., West, D. C., Rosenbluth, G., Allen, A. D., Noble, E. L., Tse, L. L., Dalal, A. K., Keohane, C. A., Lipsitz, S. R., Rothschild, J. M., Wien, M. F., Yoon, C. S., Zigmont, K. R., Wilson, K. M., O'Toole, J. K., Solan, L. G., Aylor, M., . . . Landrigan, C. P. (2014). Changes in medical errors after implementation of a handoff program. New England Journal of Medicine, 371(19), 1803-1812. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMsa1405556
What the DNP 815A Topic 2 instructions ask for
Topic 2 in DNP-815A asks students to distinguish discovery research from practice-focused scholarship. Strong papers take one question that both traditions could address and design it both ways, so that the differences in aim, design, sample, measurement and audience appear side by side. Students should state what each design cannot deliver, such as generalizable claims from a single-unit project or timely local change from a multisite trial, and avoid ranking one tradition above the other. The paper should place the student's own problem in one tradition by asking who is waiting for the answer and what they will do with it. Faculty expect the comparison in a table.
Inside the DNP 815A Topic 2 example
The finished example runs a single question through two designs. The question concerns whether a structured handover reduces omitted information, and the paper shows what a discovery study would do with it, which involves controlled conditions, a generalizable claim and a journal audience, against what a practice project would do, which involves one unit, local adaptation and an audience of people who work there. The differences are then made concrete: sample, control, timeline, what counts as success, and who acts on the result. The example is clear that neither produces the other's output, and that a practice project reporting a generalizable finding has usually overclaimed. It ends by placing the writer's own problem in one of the two.
DNP 815A Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward one question designed both ways. An Excellent paper frames omitted voiding information at handover as a cluster randomized trial across surgical units, citing Starmer and colleagues' I-PASS work, and as a unit project measured repeatedly. Credit goes to a table comparing aim, design, sample, measurement and audience, with Edwardson on the two traditions. The rubric values stating that the practice project lacks a concurrent control. Strong papers say what the trial cannot deliver to one unit. Top marks go to placing the project by who acts on the result.
DNP 815A Topic 2 help before you submit
Most of the lost marks here go to papers that define both traditions in the abstract and never build anything, which leaves the contrast unusable. A second failure is ranking the two, usually treating discovery research as the more rigorous, which misunderstands what a practice doctorate is for. Marks also go for a practice project described as producing generalizable knowledge, since overclaiming in exactly that direction is what this section is written to catch. Comparisons that omit the audience miss the difference that drives all the others. Papers that never place the writer's own problem leave the contrast academic. Designs sketched without samples or timelines cannot be compared on anything concrete. Designs described without an audience obscure the difference that produces every other difference between them.
Get a DNP-815A Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the DNP-815A Topic 2 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with any framework your section requires. We write a custom example to those criteria, designing one question twice, comparing across five dimensions, stating what neither can deliver and placing your own problem, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More DNP 815A papers and DNP samples
- DNP 815A Topic 1: Philosophy of Science Application
- DNP 815A Topic 3: Nursing Theory Selection
- DNP 815A Topic 4: Borrowed Theory Evaluation
- DNP 815A Topic 5: Practice Model Comparison DQ Pair
- DNP 815A Topic 6: Translation Framework Application
- DNP 815A Topic 7: Framework Selection for Practice Problem
- DNP 815A Topic 8: Theory Durability Statement
- DNP 820 Topic 2: Searchable Question Construction
- DNP 810 Topic 2: Gene Environment Interaction Paper
- DNP 825 Topic 2: Measure and Denominator Analysis
- DNP 805 Topic 2: Data Standards Analysis
DNP 815A Topic 2 questions, answered
Is discovery research more rigorous?
Different, not superior, and papers that rank them usually misread the program. A controlled study answers a question the discipline has and cannot change the unit it was conducted on. A practice project changes one site and cannot support a claim about anywhere else. Each is rigorous against its own standard, and confusing the standards is where the overclaiming starts.
Can a practice project produce generalizable findings?
Not as its output, and claiming otherwise is precisely what this section sets out to catch. A project can be reported in enough detail that another site could attempt something similar, which is transferability rather than generalizability. The distinction matters because faculty read a generalizability claim as evidence the writer has not understood what they are doing.
How do I place my own problem?
Ask who is waiting for the answer. If the people waiting work at your site and want something to change there, it is a practice project. If the answer would be addressed to a field that does not yet know something, it is discovery work and probably belongs to a different degree. Most writers' problems place themselves once the question is asked plainly.
Where can I find a free DNP 815A Topic 2 sample paper?
The design paper for DNP 815A Topic 2 covers a question both traditions could take up, the discovery version, the practice version, the two designs compared, what each cannot deliver and the writer's own problem placed. Share your DNP 815A Topic 2 prompt for a free paper.
Why can the practice project not generalize in DNP 815A Topic 2?
It has no concurrent control, so a rise in complete handovers could reflect being observed, a new charge nurse or lower surgical volume. Its aim is change on one unit, not a general claim.