| Course | HCA 465 Health Care Administration and Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Management role analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 465 Topic 1
What the Food and Nutrition Services Manager Can Decide Alone: A Management Role Analysis of One Hospital Department, Sorted by Authority
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-465: Health Care Administration and Management
Topic 1 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
What the Food and Nutrition Services Manager Can Decide Alone: A Management Role Analysis of One Hospital Department, Sorted by Authority
The Department and Where the Role Sits
Mesa Grande Medical Center is a 260-bed community hospital. Its food and nutrition services department employs 62 people: 7 registered dietitians led by a chief clinical dietitian, 4 diet technicians, 14 cooks and production staff, 26 patient meal and tray staff, 9 retail cafeteria workers and 2 clerical staff. The department serves about 750 patient meals a day through a room service model, in which patients order by phone within their diet order, and runs a cafeteria for staff and visitors. The manager's own supervisor is the vice president for support services. The chief clinical dietitian reports to the manager for administrative purposes, but the clinical practice of dietitians is also governed by the medical staff through the hospital's diet order policy. Production and tray staff are covered by a collective bargaining agreement. A role has no shape until it is placed in this kind of structure, so the analysis starts here.
Decisions the Manager Settles Alone
The manager has authority to decide, without approval, most matters of daily operation within the approved budget. These include staff schedules and shift assignments within the union contract, the cafeteria menu rotation and daily specials, the purchase of food and supplies from contracted vendors up to $10,000 per order, the assignment of dietitians to units, the room service call center's hours within its staffing budget, and the department's internal procedures for tray assembly and delivery. The manager also approves time off, conducts performance reviews for direct reports and issues verbal and written warnings. Mintzberg's classic study of managerial work described managers as allocators of resources and handlers of disturbances as much as planners (Mintzberg, 1973), and at Mesa Grande most of the manager's day falls into exactly these decisions: moving two tray staff to a unit that opened extra beds, or deciding what to serve when a produce delivery fails.
Decisions the Manager Recommends Upward
A second group of decisions belongs to someone above the manager, and the manager's role is to prepare the recommendation. Capital purchases over $10,000, such as replacing the blast chiller or the dish machine, go to the vice president and then the capital committee. Changes to the number of budgeted positions require approval from the vice president and finance. New vendor contracts over the purchasing threshold go through supply chain management. Changes to cafeteria prices for employees are approved by human resources because they affect a staff benefit. For each of these, the manager's influence depends on the quality of the recommendation: the data, the options considered and the consequences of not acting.
Decisions the Manager Cannot Make
A third group is outside the manager's authority altogether, even though the department lives with the results. Who may write diet orders is decided by the medical staff and the hospital's policies within federal rules; since 2014, federal regulations have allowed hospitals to grant qualified dietitians privileges to order therapeutic diets, but whether Mesa Grande does so is a medical staff decision (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, 2014). Food safety requirements, such as cooking and holding temperatures, are set by the state's adoption of the federal model food code and enforced by county inspectors (U.S. Food and Drug Administration, 2022). Wage rates, overtime rules and seniority for union staff are set by the collective bargaining agreement. When nursing units change the times at which patients receive insulin, the timing of meals is affected, but nursing policy belongs to the chief nursing officer.
Table 1
Decisions in the Food and Nutrition Services Manager's Role, by Authority
| Decision | Settled alone | Recommended upward | Outside authority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staff schedules | Yes, within contract | ||
| Cafeteria menu | Yes | ||
| Supplies under $10,000 | Yes | ||
| Capital equipment | To vice president and capital committee | ||
| New positions | To vice president and finance | ||
| Dietitian diet-ordering privileges | Medical staff | ||
| Food safety temperatures | State food code, county inspection | ||
| Union wage and seniority rules | Collective bargaining agreement | ||
| Insulin and meal timing on units | Nursing policy |
How the Three Groups Fill a Week
A two-week log kept by the manager shows how the three groups of decisions divide her time. About 55 percent went to decisions she settles alone: rebuilding the schedule around two call-outs, approving substitutions when a supplier shorted the order, walking the tray line at lunch and meeting new staff. About 25 percent went to preparing recommendations, most of it on the case for replacing a dish machine that fails once a month, including three vendor quotes, repair history and the labor cost of hand washing during breakdowns. The remaining 20 percent went to matters outside her authority: two meetings with nursing about late trays, a conversation with the chief clinical dietitian about proposing diet-ordering privileges to the medical staff, and a union steward meeting about weekend rotation. The log shows a pattern common to middle managers. The largest share of time goes to the decisions the manager owns, but the results the hospital judges her on depend heavily on the smallest share, the conversations with people who hold authority she lacks. Planning that time deliberately, rather than letting it happen only when problems arise, is one of the few ways a manager in this position can improve the numbers she is held to.
Where the Role Is Hardest
The role is hardest where the manager is accountable for results that depend on decisions in the third group. The manager is measured on patient satisfaction with meals and on food cost per patient day, yet tray delivery times on the units depend partly on nurses and nursing assistants, and meal timing for patients with diabetes depends on nursing's insulin schedule. The manager cannot order either change. The practical skill of the role is therefore influence without authority: building the relationships, data and shared goals that let other leaders make the decisions the department needs. A manager who understands where each decision sits spends less time pushing against authority that belongs to someone else and more time preparing the case that will move it.
References
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2014). Medicare and Medicaid programs; regulatory provisions to promote program efficiency, transparency, and burden reduction; part II. Federal Register, 79(91), 27106-27157.
Mintzberg, H. (1973). The nature of managerial work. Harper & Row.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration. (2022). Food code 2022. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
What the HCA 465 Topic 1 instructions ask for
Topic 1 of HCA-465 asks students to analyze the role of a health care manager in a specific setting. The instructions typically ask students to describe the manager's responsibilities, the organizational structure around the position and the skills and functions the role requires, drawing on management theory. Students should go beyond listing tasks to explain what authority the manager actually holds, which decisions require approval from others and how the manager achieves results that depend on people outside the department. The strongest papers ground the analysis in one real or realistic department, explain reporting relationships clearly and connect the role to classic and current management literature in APA format.
Inside the HCA 465 Topic 1 example
The finished example reads as an inventory with authority attached rather than a description of what managers do. It names the department, its size and who reports to whom, because a role has no shape without a place to sit in. Decisions are then listed in three groups: the ones the manager settles alone, the ones the manager recommends to someone above, and the ones that arrive already made. Each entry carries the constraint that limits it, such as a labor agreement, a licensure requirement or a headcount ceiling set at the corporate level. The closing paragraphs pick two items from the first group and show the manager choosing, since the point of an inventory is that somebody has to act on it.
Reading the HCA 465 Topic 1 rubric
GCU's rubric for the role analysis rewards clarity about authority. Excellent papers place the manager in a specific structure, with size and reporting lines, before describing the work. The rubric gives credit for sorting decisions into those the manager owns, those she recommends, and those that belong to others, with concrete examples of each. Credit also goes to showing where the role is hardest, usually where results depend on authority the manager lacks. The highest level connects these observations to management theory, uses realistic evidence such as a time log, and draws practical conclusions about how the manager should spend her time.
HCA 465 Topic 1 help before you submit
Marks concentrate on whether the role has been located, and generic versions give themselves away in the first paragraph. Writing about what health care managers do, without naming a department or a reporting line, produces a paragraph that would fit any organization and describes none. Copying duties from a posted job description substitutes the employer's wishes for the authority the position actually carries. Inventories with no constraints attached read as though the manager could do anything, which no reader who has held the job believes. Listing decisions without saying who settles them misses the sorting the topic exists to teach. Versions that stop at the list, with nothing chosen and nothing defended, hand a reader a catalog and no evidence its author could use it.
Get an HCA-465 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-465 Topic 1 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the department or scenario you were assigned. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the role located in a real seat, the decisions sorted by who settles them and one of them carried to a choice, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HCA 465 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 465 Topic 2: Delegation Decision Memo
- HCA 465 Topic 3: Departmental Budget Memo
- HCA 465 Topic 4: Interprofessional Conflict Case
- HCA 465 Topic 5: Authority Gap Discussion Post
- HCA 465 Topic 6: Performance Management Case
- HCA 465 Topic 7: Decision Rationale Memo
- HCA 465 Topic 8: Management Philosophy Paper
- HCA 460 Topic 1: Capacity Analysis
- HCA 240 Topic 1: Charge to Payment Breakdown
- HCA 450 Topic 1: External Standards Review
- HCA 360 Topic 1: Health Record Purpose Analysis
HCA 465 Topic 1 questions, answered
What decisions does a health care manager actually own?
Fewer than the job description implies and more than the manager often realizes. Scheduling, assignment, day to day discipline, small purchases and how the department absorbs a bad month are usually settled locally. Hiring headcount, capital and pay bands generally are not. Writing that split down for one specific department turns a vague sense of the role into something you can defend.
Can I use a department I have never worked in?
Yes, provided you specify it enough to reason about. Give it a size, a service, a set of professions and a reporting line, then hold those fixed for the rest of the paper. An invented but consistent department supports real analysis; a department that changes shape whenever the argument needs it supports nothing, and markers notice the drift quickly.
Is management the same thing as leadership here?
Not in this topic. Leadership describes how a person influences others; management describes the authority a position carries and the resources it controls. The distinction matters because an argument about influence can be made without naming a department, while an argument about authority cannot. Keeping them apart early prevents a paper that admires a style and settles nothing.
Where can I find a free HCA 465 Topic 1 sample paper?
This page holds the full management role analysis, with the department structure, decisions sorted by authority, a time log and the challenge of influence without authority. Share your own department for a free worked model.
Which decisions are outside the manager's authority in HCA 465 Topic 1?
In the example, dietitian diet-ordering privileges belong to the medical staff, food safety temperatures to the state food code, wage and seniority rules to the union contract, and insulin timing on the units to nursing policy.