| Course | HCA 465 Health Care Administration and Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Interprofessional conflict case |
| Length | About 1,040 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 465 Topic 4
Meals When Patients Want Them, Insulin When the Meal Arrives: An Interprofessional Conflict Case That Would Survive Replacing Everyone in It
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-465: Health Care Administration and Management
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Meals When Patients Want Them, Insulin When the Meal Arrives: An Interprofessional Conflict Case That Would Survive Replacing Everyone in It
The Disagreement
At Mesa Grande Medical Center, the nursing leaders of the three medical-surgical units and the food and nutrition services department have argued for eight months about when patients with diabetes receive their meals. Two years ago, food and nutrition services replaced fixed tray delivery at 7:30 a.m., noon and 5 p.m. with room service: patients call and order within their diet between 6:30 a.m. and 7 p.m., and trays arrive within 45 minutes. Nursing leaders now want patients who receive mealtime insulin returned to fixed meal times. The food and nutrition services manager wants to keep room service for everyone. The conflict has outlasted one nurse manager and one food service supervisor, which suggests it does not come from personalities. It comes from what each group is held accountable for.
What Each Group Answers For
Nursing answers for glycemic safety. Nurses check capillary glucose before meals and give rapid-acting insulin so that it acts when food is absorbed. If insulin is given and the tray arrives an hour late, or the patient eats little, the patient can become hypoglycemic, and hypoglycemia events are reported on the units' safety dashboard. National standards for diabetes care in the hospital call for mealtime insulin to be coordinated with meal delivery and for hypoglycemia to be tracked and prevented (American Diabetes Association Professional Practice Committee, 2025). Under room service, nurses do not know when a patient has ordered or when the tray will come, so they cannot time insulin.
Food and nutrition services answers for nutritional intake, food cost and patient satisfaction with meals. Room service was introduced because patients ate more and wasted less when they chose the time and content of their meals. A hospital that compared room service with a traditional model reported higher energy and protein intake and lower plate waste and cost (McCray et al., 2018), and Mesa Grande's own data show plate waste falling from 34 to 19 percent after the change. Returning patients with diabetes to fixed times would remove about 30 percent of patients from the model and reverse some of those gains for the patients who may need good intake most.
How the Conflict Shows Up on the Units
The disagreement is felt most on the units at breakfast. Between 7 a.m. and 9 a.m., a nurse with five patients may have two on mealtime insulin, and neither patient's tray time is known. Some nurses give insulin at a fixed time and hope the tray arrives; others wait for the tray and then leave it cooling while they check glucose and draw up the dose. Tray staff report leaving trays at the bedside of patients who are asleep, in the bathroom or away for tests. In a two-week review of 61 breakfast trays for insulin patients on one unit, the dose and the meal were separated by over half an hour on 23 occasions: 14 with insulin first and 9 with the tray first. Two hypoglycemia events in that period followed insulin given before a tray that came late. Both groups have used these same events to argue for their own position.
Both Positions at Their Strongest
Nursing's position, in its own terms: "We cannot give insulin safely to a patient whose meal might come at any time. Every late tray after a dose is a hypoglycemia risk, and we are the ones at the bedside when the glucose reads 52. Fixed times let us plan the medication pass." Food and nutrition services' position, in its own terms: "Patients with diabetes are often the ones who eat least when meals come at fixed times, and poor intake after insulin is itself a hypoglycemia risk. The problem is not room service but that nursing does not know when the tray is coming. That is an information problem, not a menu problem." Both positions are correct about something. Nursing is right that insulin timing needs a predictable meal. Food and nutrition services is right that fixed times do not guarantee the patient eats.
What Kind of Conflict This Is
Research on workplace conflict distinguishes relationship conflict, about personalities, from task conflict, about the work itself, and finds that task conflict can improve decisions if it does not turn personal (Jehn, 1995). This is task conflict about how two legitimate goals fit together. Of the conflict-handling modes commonly described, forcing, accommodating, avoiding, compromising and collaborating (Thomas, 1992), the groups have so far alternated between forcing, each escalating to their vice president, and avoiding, leaving unit staff to improvise. A compromise, such as fixed times only for insulin patients at breakfast, would split the difference without solving either side's problem. Collaboration is possible because both groups want the same outcome for the patient: enough food, at the time insulin acts.
A Resolution Both Sides Could Accept
The case points to a solution that addresses the information gap. When a patient with an order for mealtime insulin calls room service, the call center would ask when the patient wants the meal, schedule delivery for that time, and send an automatic message to the assigned nurse with the expected delivery time. The tray would be delivered to the nurse or flagged at the door so that glucose can be checked and insulin given when the patient is ready to eat, rather than before. A four-week pilot on one unit would measure hypoglycemia events after meals, time from tray arrival to insulin, plate waste and patient satisfaction. Sponsorship would sit jointly with the hospital's senior nursing executive and the executive over support services, which moves the decision to the level where both accountabilities meet.
What the Resolution Costs
Neither side gets exactly what it wanted. Nursing accepts that meal times will still vary and that nurses must respond to messages about trays, which adds interruptions. Food and nutrition services accepts extra steps in the call center and tray delivery for about a third of patients. The hospital pays for a small change to the call center software. The benefit is that the next pair of leaders will inherit a shared process rather than a standing argument.
References
American Diabetes Association Professional Practice Committee. (2025). 16. Diabetes care in the hospital: Standards of care in diabetes-2025. Diabetes Care, 48(Suppl. 1), S321-S334. https://doi.org/10.2337/dc25-S016
Jehn, K. A. (1995). A multimethod examination of the benefits and detriments of intragroup conflict. Administrative Science Quarterly, 40(2), 256-282. https://doi.org/10.2307/2393638
McCray, S., Maunder, K., Krikowa, R., & MacKenzie-Shalders, K. (2018). Room service improves nutritional intake and increases patient satisfaction while decreasing food waste and cost. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 118(2), 284-293. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jand.2017.05.014
Thomas, K. W. (1992). Conflict and conflict management: Reflections and update. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 13(3), 265-274. https://doi.org/10.1002/job.4030130307
What the HCA 465 Topic 4 instructions ask for
The Topic 4 instructions in HCA-465 ask students to analyze a conflict between professional groups in a health care organization and recommend how a manager should address it. Students typically describe the conflict and the parties, identify its sources, apply conflict management theory and propose a resolution. The assignment rewards analysis that looks beyond personalities to structural causes, such as different accountabilities, goals or resources. Students should present each side fairly, in terms the group itself would use, and propose a resolution that addresses the underlying cause rather than splitting the difference, supported by management and conflict research.
How the HCA-465 Topic 4 example is put together
The finished case describes a disagreement that would survive replacing every person in it. It states what each group is accountable for, since that is usually where the trouble originates: one group answers for throughput and the other for a standard that slows throughput down. Both positions appear at their strongest, in the terms the group itself would use, rather than in the version its opponent repeats to the manager. The manager's authority over each group is described, and it is rarely symmetrical, which changes what a settlement can look like. A decision follows with its reasoning visible, and it names what the group that did not prevail receives instead. A short closing passage covers how each side hears the outcome.
Reading the HCA 465 Topic 4 rubric
The HCA-465 conflict rubric rewards structural thinking. Excellent cases state what each group is accountable for and show how those accountabilities collide, which explains why the conflict persists as people change. The rubric gives credit for presenting both positions at their strongest and for using conflict theory to classify the dispute and the ways it has been handled. Recommendations score highest when they address the root cause, identify who has the authority to sponsor the solution and include measures. The highest level also states what the resolution costs each side, since a resolution that costs nothing usually resolves nothing.
Common HCA 465 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
The heaviest losses come from cases that resolve into personality. Describing one party as difficult explains nothing and leaves the next manager the same problem after both people have moved on. Positions summarized in the opponent's words are visibly unfair, and a reader can tell the writer never took one side seriously. Cases that never mention what each group is accountable for have removed the reason the disagreement exists. Decisions that split the difference with no reasoning read as avoidance rather than judgment. Ignoring the reporting line, and assuming a manager can direct a group answering to somebody else, produces a settlement nobody has the standing to impose. Versions with no offer to the losing side have ended the conversation rather than the conflict.
Get an HCA-465 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-465 Topic 4 instructions, your rubric and the conflict scenario the assignment describes. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each group's accountability named, both positions written at full strength, the manager's real standing described and a decision that gives the losing side something, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 465 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 465 Topic 1: Management Role Analysis
- HCA 465 Topic 2: Delegation Decision Memo
- HCA 465 Topic 3: Departmental Budget Memo
- HCA 465 Topic 5: Authority Gap Discussion Post
- HCA 465 Topic 6: Performance Management Case
- HCA 465 Topic 7: Decision Rationale Memo
- HCA 465 Topic 8: Management Philosophy Paper
- HCA 460 Topic 4: Supply Chain Analysis
- HCA 240 Topic 4: Reimbursement Comparison
- HCA 450 Topic 4: Accreditation Readiness Report
- HCA 360 Topic 4: Data Stewardship Plan
HCA 465 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why treat this as structural rather than personal?
Because the structural version is the one a manager can change. Personalities move on and the dispute returns, which tells you the cause sat in the arrangement rather than in the people. Naming the two accountabilities that collide gives you something to adjust, whether that is a handoff, a schedule or a shared measure that stops rewarding one group for what costs the other.
What if one group does not report to me?
Then say so and plan for persuasion rather than instruction. Many health care disputes cross reporting lines, and a manager who writes as though everyone can be directed produces a settlement nobody will enforce. Naming who does hold authority over the other group, and what would have to be taken to that person, is stronger than pretending the line is not there.
Is a compromise always the right outcome?
No. Some disputes have a correct answer, usually where a standard exists for a reason and one side is asking it to bend. Splitting the difference there produces a rule nobody follows. What every settlement does need is an account of what the side that lost is getting, which may be a review date, a resource or a decision going the other way next time.
Where can I find a free HCA 465 Topic 4 sample paper?
The complete conflict case is on this page, with each group's accountability, unit data, both positions, the type of conflict, the proposed pilot and its costs. A free model for the conflict in your own prompt is available on request.
Why is compromise not the answer in HCA 465 Topic 4?
Because splitting the difference, such as fixed times only at breakfast, solves neither group's problem. The underlying issue is that nurses do not know when trays will arrive, so the resolution fixes that information gap.