HCA 465 Topic 7 decision rationale memo example

Health Care Administration and Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This HCA 465 Topic 7 sample paper is a decision rationale memo from a food and nutrition services manager to the chief clinical dietitian explaining why her request for an eighth dietitian position is declined this year. It was prepared for GCU HCA 465, Health Care Administration and Management, the course listed as HCA-465 in the Grand Canyon University BS in Health Care Administration. The decision comes first, then the reasoning in the order it ran: the accepted assessment delay figure, a time review showing 18 percent of dietitian hours on work others could do, the budget climate, and the criterion that settled it. The memo explains what was weighed and set aside, what the manager will do instead, what would change the answer and how the dietitian can respond.

CourseHCA 465 Health Care Administration and Management
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeDecision rationale memo
LengthAbout 840 words, 2 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Health Care Administration
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for HCA 465 Topic 7

1

Memorandum

To: Chief Clinical Dietitian, Food and Nutrition Services

From: [Author Name], Manager, Food and Nutrition Services, Mesa Grande Medical Center

Date: [Date]

Re: Your request for an additional registered dietitian position: decision and reasons

 

The Decision

I am not submitting your request for an eighth registered dietitian position in next year's budget. I want you to hear that plainly before anything else, and I want you to see how I reached it, what I weighed, and what would lead me to decide differently in six months. I know you and your team have been working above capacity, and this decision does not mean I think the case you made was weak. Part of it was strong, and I have acted on that part below.

How I Reached It

I started from your proposal, which argued that seven dietitians cannot complete timely assessments for the number of patients screened at risk of malnutrition. Your data showed that 22 percent of at-risk patients waited more than 48 hours for a dietitian assessment last quarter. I accept that figure, and I accept that delays matter: malnutrition in hospitalized adults is common, underrecognized and linked to worse outcomes and longer stays, and timely assessment by a dietitian is a central part of addressing it (Tappenden et al., 2013).

Next, I asked whether the delay came from too few dietitian hours or from how existing hours are used. I reviewed two weeks of your team's time records. About 18 percent of dietitian time went to tasks that do not require a dietitian: entering diet orders transcribed from paper, calling units to confirm tray delivery problems, and completing menu selections for patients on standard diets. If those tasks moved to diet technicians and the call center, the freed time would equal a little more than one dietitian position.

Then I looked at what the budget would allow. The vice president has told all department managers that no new positions will be approved next year unless they are revenue-producing or required by regulation. A new dietitian position would compete with requests from pharmacy and respiratory therapy that meet one of those tests. I judged that a request likely to be declined at the next level would cost us credibility for the request I expect to make next year.

The criterion that settled the matter was the second one. Before asking the hospital for a new position, we need to show that dietitian hours are going to dietitian work. If the redistribution works and delays persist, the case for a new position becomes much stronger, because we can show that the remaining shortfall is real.

What this page is doingThe reasoning is laid out in the order it actually ran, with the settling criterion named, so the reader can see what would have to change for a different answer.
2

What I Am Doing Instead

Three actions start next month. First, diet technicians will take over menu selections for patients on standard and consistent-carbohydrate diets, and I am moving 0.5 of a technician position from the retail cafeteria to clinical support to cover it. Second, the call center will handle tray delivery problems directly with the units. Third, I will ask the medical staff to consider diet-ordering privileges for dietitians, which would remove the order transcription step entirely. You will lead the first action and decide which patients' menus remain with dietitians. A pilot at another hospital showed that restructuring malnutrition workflows improved documentation and timeliness without adding staff (Silver et al., 2018).

What I Weighed and Set Aside

Two other considerations came up, and I want you to know how I treated them. The first was your team's morale. Two dietitians have told me they are tired of working through lunch, and a denied position may feel like the department does not value their work. I weighed that seriously, and it is part of why the redistribution starts next month rather than next quarter: the relief it offers is sooner than a new hire would be, since recruiting and orienting a dietitian takes four to six months. The second was the risk of doing nothing while we wait. A patient who is malnourished and not seen for three days may lose ground that is hard to recover. That risk is why I am asking you to decide which patients' menus remain with dietitians, so that the patients at highest risk are protected first while the new workflow settles.

What Would Change the Answer

Each month you and I will look together at how many at-risk patients waited beyond two days for assessment. If, after four months of the redistribution, more than 10 percent still wait longer than 48 hours, I will submit a request for an additional position in the mid-year budget revision, using your data and the redistribution results. I will also bring your original proposal, with my recommendation, to the vice president at that point, so that your work on it is visible.

Your Response

People accept unwelcome decisions more readily when they understand how they were made and feel heard in the process (Brockner & Wiesenfeld, 1996). If you think I have misread your data or missed something, tell me before the budget is submitted on the 15th. I will take any new information seriously, and if it changes my assessment I will say so.

References

Brockner, J., & Wiesenfeld, B. M. (1996). An integrative framework for explaining reactions to decisions: Interactive effects of outcomes and procedures. Psychological Bulletin, 120(2), 189-208. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.120.2.189

Silver, H. J., Pratt, K. J., Bruno, M., Lynch, J., Mitchell, K., & McCauley, S. M. (2018). Effectiveness of the Malnutrition Quality Improvement Initiative on practitioner malnutrition knowledge and screening, diagnosis, and timeliness of malnutrition-related care provided to older adults admitted to a tertiary care facility: A pilot study. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 118(1), 101-109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jand.2017.08.111

Tappenden, K. A., Quatrara, B., Parkhurst, M. L., Malone, A. M., Fanjiang, G., & Ziegler, T. R. (2013). Critical role of nutrition in improving quality of care: An interdisciplinary call to action to address adult hospital malnutrition. Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition, 37(4), 482-497. https://doi.org/10.1177/0148607113484066

The HCA-465 Topic 7 assignment instructions

The Topic 7 instructions in HCA-465 ask students to communicate a management decision and its rationale, often to a person affected by it. Students typically state the decision, explain the options considered and the criteria used, and address the concerns of the reader. The assignment rewards clear, honest communication that respects the reader: the decision should not be buried, the reasoning should be traceable, and the reader should know what happens next and what could change the outcome. A memo format is common, and students should draw on management and organizational justice research to explain why the way a decision is communicated matters as much as the decision itself.

How this HCA 465 Topic 7 example is built

The finished memo is addressed to the affected person and reads that way, which changes almost every sentence in it. The decision comes first, stated plainly, because burying it under context reads as evasion to the only reader who matters here. The reasoning follows in the order it actually ran, including the criterion that settled the matter, so the reader can see what would have produced a different answer. The alternative that was seriously considered is named and rejected on record, which is what makes the memo a rationale instead of a notice. What the decision does not mean is stated explicitly, since people read an adverse outcome as a verdict on their standing unless told otherwise. It ends by marking what remains open.

Where the marks sit in the HCA 465 Topic 7 rubric

Marks on the decision memo go to honesty and structure. Excellent memos state the decision in the first lines and then present the reasoning in the order it actually ran, naming the criterion that settled it. The rubric rewards acknowledging the strengths of the request being declined and explaining what was weighed and set aside. Credit goes to concrete actions taken instead, to clear conditions under which the decision would change, and to an invitation for the reader's response. The highest level writes for the affected person rather than for a file and supports the approach with research on how people react to decisions.

Common HCA 465 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Marks go to memos a real person could receive, and most losses come from writing about the reader instead of to them. Third person throughout signals that the memo was produced for a file, and the affected person will read it exactly that way. Opening with background and reaching the decision on the second page is heard as evasion however careful the reasoning. Rationales with no rejected alternative give the reader nothing to weigh and invite the reply that other options were never considered. Softening the outcome to spare feelings creates a memo that has to be corrected later, which costs more than the plain version would. Boundaries left unstated open a negotiation the manager did not intend. Blaming policy without owning the decision is the last common failure.

Get an HCA-465 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send us the HCA-465 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric your classroom lists and the decision or scenario you were given. We write a custom example to those criteria, addressed to the person affected, with the criterion stated, the rejected alternative on record and the boundary between settled and negotiable made clear, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.

More HCA 465 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples

HCA 465 Topic 7 questions, answered

Should the decision come before the reasoning?

Almost always. A reader who knows the outcome can follow the argument; a reader still waiting for it skims for the verdict and misses everything on the way. Delaying the answer also reads as an attempt to build agreement before delivering bad news, which most recipients recognize and resent. State the decision, then explain it.

Why name an option I rejected?

Because the reader is already thinking of it. A rationale that ignores the obvious alternative invites the response that nobody considered it, and the manager then defends the same decision twice. Naming the option, giving the reason it lost and being honest about what it would have cost turns an objection into a disagreement about a stated criterion.

How honest should I be about a decision that hurts?

Honest about the outcome, careful about the framing, and never misleading. Telling somebody a reassignment is an opportunity when it is not damages the manager's credibility for every later message. Stating the decision plainly, giving the reason, and saying what it does not mean about their standing treats the person as capable of hearing it, which most people are.

Where can I find a free HCA 465 Topic 7 sample paper?

The complete decision rationale memo is on this page, with the decision, the reasoning in order, what was set aside, the actions instead, what would change the answer and the invitation to respond. A free model for your own decision can be requested.

What settled the decision in HCA 465 Topic 7?

The finding that about 18 percent of dietitian time went to tasks others could do. Before asking for a new position, the department must show dietitian hours are going to dietitian work, so the memo redistributes tasks first.