| Course | HCA 817 Professional Development and Leadership in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Practice claim audit |
| Length | About 950 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | Doctor of Health Administration (DHA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 817 Topic 1
Two Claims Pass and One Fails: A Practice Claim Audit of Eleven Years Running Laboratory Services at a Three-Hospital System
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
HCA-817: Professional Development and Leadership in Health Care
Topic 1 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Two Claims Pass and One Fails: A Practice Claim Audit of Eleven Years Running Laboratory Services at a Three-Hospital System
The Three Claims, in My Own Words
I have been administrative director of laboratory services at Saguaro Valley Health, a composite three-hospital system, for eleven years. I am not a physician; the laboratory's medical director is a pathologist, and I answer to the vice president of clinical operations for the laboratory's budget, staffing and service. Before any definition of doctoral practice, I wrote down the three things I would say in a job interview if asked what I have accomplished, in the words I would actually use:
Claim A: I cut troponin turnaround for the emergency departments from over an hour to under 50 minutes at all three hospitals. Claim B: I consolidated microbiology into one core laboratory without hurting service. Claim C: I improved retention of our medical laboratory scientists.
I kept this wording deliberately. The theory a practitioner espouses, meaning what they say guides their action, can differ from the theory in use that their actions actually reveal (Argyris & Schön, 1974). A claim polished until it sounds defensible has already moved toward the espoused version, so the audit tests the unpolished one.
The Evidence Rules
Each claim needs three kinds of evidence: an artifact I produced, a record an institution keeps without my involvement, and a result counted by someone with no stake in my rating. My own recollection counts as none of the three. The vocabulary I am measured against comes from the American College of Healthcare Executives (2024) competencies assessment tool, whose domains include business skills and knowledge, leadership, and communication and relationship management, and from the interprofessional competency model for health care leadership developed by Calhoun et al. (2008), which separates execution, transformation and people competencies. Each claim is mapped to a competency before the evidence is read, so the evidence cannot choose the competency after the fact.
Claim A: Troponin Turnaround
Table 1
Evidence for Claim A
| Evidence type | Item | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Artifact I produced | 2022 project charter and draw-to-receipt analysis | I identified that 62% of the delay was before the specimen reached the analyzer |
| Institutional record | Laboratory information system turnaround report, 2021 and 2024 | Median order-to-result fell from 71 to 48 minutes; 90th percentile from 118 to 79 |
| Independent count | Emergency department quality dashboard, maintained by the emergency department's analyst | Same direction; median 47 minutes in 2024 |
Claim A passes, with one correction to its wording. The median fell below 50 minutes at all three hospitals, but the 90th percentile at the smallest hospital is still 88 minutes, so "under 50 minutes" describes the typical case, not every case. Mapped competency: business skills and knowledge, specifically performance improvement.
Claim B: Microbiology Consolidation
The artifacts are the 2021 capital request and the transition plan I wrote. The institutional records are the laboratory's accreditation inspection report after consolidation, which found no deficiencies related to the move, and the laboratory information system's reports of blood culture time to first report. The independent count is the infection prevention department's quarterly report. The records show that time from collection to the first Gram stain report stayed flat for the two larger hospitals but rose by a median of 2.6 hours at the smallest, Saguaro Valley North, whose specimens now travel 34 miles by courier. "Without hurting service" is true for two hospitals and false for one. Claim B partly passes. Mapped competency: leadership, specifically change management, and here the evidence also shows a planning failure: I assumed courier timing would hold and did not measure it until the infection prevention report raised it four months later.
Claim C: Retention
Claim C fails. The human resources turnover report, which I do not prepare, shows medical laboratory scientist turnover of 16% in my second year and 22% last year. My artifacts, a career ladder I proposed and a recognition program I started, exist, but the record does not show that either changed anything. Exit interview summaries, kept by human resources, name night shift coverage and pay relative to a nearby reference laboratory as the main reasons for leaving, neither of which my programs addressed. Garcia et al. (2021), reporting a national vacancy survey of medical laboratories, found vacancy rates high across the profession, which may mean my claim was never within my control to deliver; but I made the claim, and the evidence does not support it. Mapped competency: communication and relationship management, specifically workforce engagement. I keep Claim C in the audit because dropping it would convert the audit into a list of successes, and because it is the finding most useful for my development plan.
What the Audit Shows About My Practice
The pattern across the three claims is consistent. I do well where the problem can be measured in a system I control, such as specimen flow, and I overstate results where the outcome depends on people and forces I influence but do not control, such as a courier route or a labor market. My espoused theory is that I lead through data. My theory in use, on this evidence, is that I lead through process design and then stop measuring once the process is built. The competency most in need of work is therefore not a technical one. It is the discipline of continuing to measure after a change is declared finished, and of measuring outcomes that sit partly outside my department, such as whether a scientist stays or a culture result reaches a physician in time. Both failures in this audit were discoverable from records the system already kept; I simply did not look at them until someone else did. The next topics in this course take that finding forward.
References
American College of Healthcare Executives. (2024). ACHE healthcare executive 2024 competencies assessment tool.
Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. (1974). Theory in practice: Increasing professional effectiveness. Jossey-Bass.
Calhoun, J. G., Dollett, L., Sinioris, M. E., Wainio, J. A., Butler, P. W., Griffith, J. R., & Warden, G. L. (2008). Development of an interprofessional competency model for healthcare leadership. Journal of Healthcare Management, 53(6), 375-389. https://doi.org/10.1097/00115514-200811000-00006
Garcia, E., Kundu, I., Kelly, M., & Soles, R. (2021). The American Society for Clinical Pathology 2020 vacancy survey of medical laboratories in the United States. American Journal of Clinical Pathology, 157(6), 874-889. https://doi.org/10.1093/ajcp/aqab197
Reading the GCU HCA 817 Topic 1 instructions
HCA-817 opens with Topic 1, which asks doctoral learners to examine the claims they make about their own professional practice. Many papers define doctoral practice from a dictionary or a mission statement and then describe the writer's career favorably. The assignment rewards audits that state a small number of claims in the writer's ordinary words, set evidence rules before reading the evidence and test each claim against artifacts, institutional records and independent counts. Learners should map each claim to a published competency framework, keep any failed claim in the audit and describe what the pattern of results shows about how they actually practice.
Inside the HCA 817 Topic 1 example
The finished audit is short on definition and long on paperwork. It states the three claims in the writer's own words first, because a claim polished to sound defensible has already drifted from what happened. Each claim then receives a column of evidence: an artifact the writer produced, a file an institution keeps, and a result counted by somebody with no stake in the rating. Argyris and Schon's separation of espoused theory from theory in use runs underneath the exercise, since the audit is hunting for the second. Competency directories published by bodies such as the American College of Healthcare Executives supply the vocabulary the writer is measured against. One of the three claims fails, and the example prints the failure.
HCA 817 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like
GCU's rubric for the practice claim audit rewards evidence over narrative. Excellent audits separate what the writer produced, what an institution recorded and what someone independent counted, and treat recollection as no evidence at all. Credit goes to applying a named competency framework to each claim rather than citing it once. The rubric values honest corrections to claims that pass only partly. The highest level keeps a failed claim with its evidence and draws a conclusion about the gap between espoused theory and theory in use, since an audit in which every claim passes suggests the claims were chosen after the evidence.
HCA 817 Topic 1 help before you submit
Marks at this level follow the evidence column rather than the prose around it. A paper deriving doctoral practice from a dictionary and a mission statement has answered a question nobody asked, since the definition was never the hard part. Claims resting on the writer's own recollection collect nothing, because recollection is the thing under test. Naming a competency framework and then never applying it leaves a citation doing decorative work. Graders also distrust an audit in which all three claims pass, since three for three usually means the claims were selected after the evidence was found. The heaviest loss comes from dropping the failed claim, which converts an audit into an advertisement and removes the only part a doctoral reader believes.
Get an HCA-817 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-817 Topic 1 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and whatever practice setting the assignment names. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the standard named first, three claims tested across three kinds of evidence and one of them retired, back in 24-48h. The first one is free.
More HCA 817 papers and DHA samples
- HCA 817 Topic 2: Capability and Evidence Inventory
- HCA 817 Topic 3: External Contribution Dossier
- HCA 817 Topic 4: Informal Authority Trace
- HCA 817 Topic 5: Change Attribution Post
- HCA 817 Topic 6: Falsifiable Development Plan
- HCA 817 Topic 7: Portfolio Inclusion Argument
- HCA 817 Topic 8: Defended Contribution Statement
- HCA 822 Topic 1: Three-role Obligation Brief
- HCA 812 Topic 1: Enforcement Authority Trace
- HCA 827 Topic 1: Sustainability Definition Comparison
HCA 817 Topic 1 questions, answered
What makes a practice claim doctoral rather than professional?
The level shows in what gets offered as proof, not in the vocabulary. A professional claim can rest on experience and still be entirely true. A doctoral claim is expected to name the artifact, the file or the counted result behind it, and to say what that evidence cannot settle. Writing the limit down is often what lifts a paper.
Can I write this if my evidence sits with a former employer?
Yes, and the constraint belongs in the paper rather than hidden from it. Describe the artifact accurately, keep it de-identified, and state plainly that the original remains with the organization. Faculty are judging whether you can tell evidence from assertion, not whether you can produce files you no longer hold. Inventing a document you cannot show is the one move that costs everything.
Do you write my practice history for me?
No. Your record of practice is yours, and an audit built on events that never happened would be useless to you and easy to puncture with one follow-up question. What we supply is a finished example on a composite practitioner, so the columns and the reasoning are visible, and you then run the same test on claims you can actually stand behind.
Where can I find a free HCA 817 Topic 1 sample paper?
This page holds the complete practice claim audit, with three claims, the evidence rules, the troponin, microbiology and retention findings and what the pattern shows. Share the requirements from your course and we will send a free audit example based on a fictional director.
Why keep the failed claim in HCA 817 Topic 1?
Dropping it would turn the audit into a list of successes. Turnover rose from 16 to 22 percent despite the writer's programs, and that finding is what makes the two passing claims believable and shapes the development plan.