| Course | HCA 817 Professional Development and Leadership in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Portfolio inclusion argument |
| Length | About 960 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | Doctor of Health Administration (DHA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 817 Topic 7
Nine Items, Each Carrying a Claim, and Three Left Out: The Inclusion Argument for a Laboratory Director's Doctoral Portfolio
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
HCA-817: Professional Development and Leadership in Health Care
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Nine Items, Each Carrying a Claim, and Three Left Out: The Inclusion Argument for a Laboratory Director's Doctoral Portfolio
What the Portfolio Is Arguing
This portfolio supports one argument, drawn from the earlier work in this course: that I lead effectively where I can redesign a process and measure its result, that I have learned to extend that approach to decisions I do not control, and that my weaknesses lie in finance, workforce and published contribution, where the evidence shows work in progress rather than results. Every item below is included because it supports part of that argument. Items that would impress a reader without supporting it were cut.
Two sorting rules apply. The first comes from Miller (1990), whose framework for assessing clinical competence separates knowing, knowing how, showing how and actually doing. Material at the lower levels shows what a practitioner knows; material at the top shows what the practitioner did in real work, and a doctoral practice portfolio should be weighted toward the top. The second concerns joint work. A committee product tells a reader nothing about me until my part is named, so every jointly produced item states what I did.
The Nine Items
Table 1
Portfolio Items, the Claims They Support and the Writer's Part
| Item | Claim it supports | Miller level | My part if joint |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Draw-to-receipt analysis, 2022 | I diagnose delay with data | Does | Sole author |
| 2. Laboratory system turnaround reports, 2021 and 2024 | Emergency troponin turnaround fell from 71 to 48 minutes | Does | Institutional record; I specified the report |
| 3. Council minutes of March 12, 2024 and the tracked-changes pathway draft | I influence decisions I do not own | Does | The timed draw reminder and two-hour fallback; the pathway belongs to the council |
| 4. Microbiology transition plan and the infection prevention report | I lead consolidation, and I missed an effect I should have measured | Does | Plan is mine; report is infection prevention's |
| 5. 360-degree review summary, 2024 | My self-view has been checked externally | Shows how others see me | Not applicable |
| 6. Capital request, third version, with finance's two return memos | Financial management is a gap I am closing | Does | Request is mine; memos are finance's |
| 7. Critical access hospital's adopted troponin protocol | My work was taken up beyond my payroll | Does | Template mine; protocol issued by that hospital |
| 8. Editor's decision letter on my manuscript | My published contribution fails on methods so far | Does | Not applicable |
| 9. Stay interview findings, first 20 of 48 | Workforce work is under way | Does | Sole author |
Why the Items That Went Sideways Are In
Four items document things that went badly or are unfinished: the infection prevention report showing a 2.6-hour delay at the most distant hospital after consolidation, finance's two memos returning my capital request, the rejected manuscript and a half-finished set of stay interviews. I included them because the argument depends on them. A portfolio claiming that my weaknesses lie in finance, workforce and publication must show the evidence of those weaknesses, or the claim reads as modesty rather than finding. The sideways items also carry the most information. The infection prevention report shows exactly what I failed to measure; the finance memos show what an acceptable operating projection requires; the decision letter lists what a publishable version needs.
Driessen et al. (2007), reviewing portfolio use in medical education, found that portfolios worked best when their goals were clearly communicated and when they were supported by mentoring and integrated with assessment. For a practice portfolio, a clear goal means a clear argument, and an argument that hides its weak evidence is not clear to anyone reading it.
The Three Cuts
Three items were considered and left out. A certificate of completion for a process improvement course records attendance, which sits at the knowing level of Miller's framework, and item 1 already shows the method in use. The laboratory accreditation inspection checklist I prepared was a team product in which my part cannot be separated from that of the quality coordinator, and it demonstrates compliance rather than any claim in the argument. A thank-you letter from a patient's family, praising a fast result in the emergency department, was cut because it would need heavy de-identification to include and because it supports a claim the turnaround reports already make with better evidence.
De-identification and Permissions
All items were reviewed before inclusion. Patient information appears in none of them; the turnaround reports and the infection prevention report are aggregate. Council minutes are included with the council chair's permission, with physicians' names other than the chair's replaced by roles. The critical access hospital's protocol is a document that hospital has made available to affiliated sites, and its nursing director agreed to its inclusion. The stay interview findings report themes only, with no quotation that could identify a scientist, because several of the reasons given concern supervisors who still work in the laboratory. The 360 review appears as the summary human resources provided, not as individual comments.
How a Reader Should Use the Portfolio
A reader who takes the items in order will see the argument build from what I do well, through the one case where I extended it successfully, to the three areas where the evidence is still thin. The competency vocabulary comes from the executive self-assessment instrument used in my capability inventory (American College of Healthcare Executives, 2024), so each claim can be matched to the domain it concerns. Nothing in the portfolio asks the reader to accept a claim on my word.
The portfolio will also change. When the chemistry analyzer request goes to the capital committee in April, its approval or return replaces item 6; when the stay interviews are complete, item 9 becomes the full findings with the proposal to the compensation committee attached; and if the resubmitted manuscript is accepted, the acceptance letter joins the decision letter rather than replacing it.
References
American College of Healthcare Executives. (2024). ACHE healthcare executive 2024 competencies assessment tool.
Driessen, E., van Tartwijk, J., van der Vleuten, C., & Wass, V. (2007). Portfolios in medical education: Why do they meet with mixed success? A systematic review. Medical Education, 41(12), 1224-1233. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2007.02944.x
Miller, G. E. (1990). The assessment of clinical skills/competence/performance. Academic Medicine, 65(9), S63-S67. https://doi.org/10.1097/00001888-199009000-00045
HCA 817 Topic 7 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 7 instructions in HCA-817 ask doctoral learners to assemble and justify a professional portfolio. Many portfolios include everything the writer has produced with no stated purpose. The assignment rewards portfolios organized around an argument, in which every item is introduced by the claim it supports and sorted by whether it shows knowledge or actual practice. Learners should identify their specific part in any jointly produced item, include evidence of work that went badly where the argument depends on it, record the items left out and why, and explain how identifying information was removed.
How the HCA-817 Topic 7 example is put together
What is finished here is the reasoning, not the binder. Nine items are held and each one is introduced by the claim it is there to support, so a reader never has to guess why a budget variance report follows a conference program. Miller's levels sit behind the sorting: material showing what the practitioner knows is separated from material showing what the practitioner actually did, and the second pile is the one the topic wants. Work produced jointly is labeled with the writer's specific part, since a committee product tells a reader nothing until the contribution is named. Three cuts are recorded with reasons. Every item is real, de-identified where a patient, an employee or a named organization would otherwise be exposed.
Reading the HCA 817 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty grading the portfolio argument reward selection. Excellent portfolios state what they argue and attach a claim to every item so a reader never has to guess why it is there. Credit goes to weighting evidence toward actual practice rather than attendance or knowledge, and to naming the writer's part in team documents. The rubric values including unsuccessful work that the argument relies on. The highest level records cuts with reasons and explains de-identification and permissions, showing the portfolio was curated for an honest reader rather than accumulated. Portfolios padded with attendance certificates, or offering team documents without naming the writer's part, score lower.
HCA 817 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks
Marks are won and lost on selection, and volume is the usual trap. A portfolio holding everything the writer has ever produced makes no argument, and a reader who has to construct the case from the contents will construct a weaker one. Items filed with no claim attached leave a grader guessing, and graders do not guess generously. Certificates of attendance sit at the wrong level entirely, since they record presence rather than practice. Team documents offered without the writer's part identified are read as borrowed. Portfolios that show only successful work have been curated for a reader who does not exist, because the interesting items are usually the ones that went sideways and were repaired. The last deduction is silence about what the collection cannot prove.
Get an HCA-817 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-817 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric attached to them and the list of artifact types your section will accept. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the claim stated first, every entry carrying its verifier, capability separated from practice and three cuts argued in view, in 24-48h. The first one is free.
More HCA 817 papers and DHA samples
- HCA 817 Topic 1: Practice Claim Audit
- HCA 817 Topic 2: Capability and Evidence Inventory
- HCA 817 Topic 3: External Contribution Dossier
- HCA 817 Topic 4: Informal Authority Trace
- HCA 817 Topic 5: Change Attribution Post
- HCA 817 Topic 6: Falsifiable Development Plan
- HCA 817 Topic 8: Defended Contribution Statement
- HCA 822 Topic 7: Shared Authority Partnership Charter
- HCA 812 Topic 7: Compliance Program Effectiveness Review
- HCA 827 Topic 7: Adverse Scenario Stress Test
HCA 817 Topic 7 questions, answered
Do you build the portfolio itself?
No. A professional portfolio is a record of your own practice, and items invented to fill it would misrepresent you to a faculty reader and to any employer who later asked about one. The worked example uses a composite practitioner, which keeps the claim-first arrangement, the verification line and the cuts visible while your own documents stay yours.
What counts as evidence of practice rather than of learning?
Something that happened in the work and left a trace outside a classroom. A completed course, a certificate or a reading list shows learning. A protocol you drafted that a department adopted, minutes recording a recommendation you made, a variance report you produced and signed, or a result somebody else measured after a change you led all sit at the level this topic is asking about.
How do I handle documents my employer owns?
Describe them accurately, remove identifying detail, and say in the entry that the original stays with the organization and cannot travel with you. A doctoral reader is assessing whether you can tell a claim from its support, not whether you can hand over confidential files. Where an item cannot be shown at all, name the person who could confirm it existed and leave the reader to weigh that.
Where can I find a free HCA 817 Topic 7 sample paper?
This page carries the full inclusion argument, with what the portfolio argues, nine items in a table, why sideways items are in, the three cuts, de-identification and how a reader should use it. Request a free model built on a composite practitioner.
Why was the certificate cut in HCA 817 Topic 7?
A course completion certificate records attendance, the knowing level of Miller's framework, while the portfolio already shows the same method in use through the writer's draw-to-receipt analysis.