| Course | HCA 817 Professional Development and Leadership in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Capability and evidence inventory |
| Length | About 970 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | Doctor of Health Administration (DHA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 817 Topic 2
Rated Against the ACHE Domains, Weighted by Who Else Saw It: A Capability and Evidence Inventory for a Laboratory Services Director
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
HCA-817: Professional Development and Leadership in Health Care
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Rated Against the ACHE Domains, Weighted by Who Else Saw It: A Capability and Evidence Inventory for a Laboratory Services Director
The Instrument and Why I Borrowed It
The categories for this inventory are borrowed from a self-assessment instrument published for health care executives (American College of Healthcare Executives, 2024), which groups executive capabilities into five domains: how a leader communicates and manages relationships, leadership itself, professional conduct, understanding of how health care is financed and regulated, and business skills. I chose it over a list of my own for two reasons. It is written for health care executives rather than for leaders in general, so its items describe work I actually do, and it was written by someone other than me, so it cannot be shaped around what I already believe I am good at. From its many items I rated ten that touch my role running the laboratories at Saguaro Valley Health's three hospitals, and I did not add any of my own. I also did not choose the ten by how well I expected to score. I chose them by listing every decision I made last year that someone above or beside me later questioned, and keeping the items those decisions fell under, which is how financial management and physician relationships came to be included.
How Ratings Are Weighted
Each rating carries two entries: the evidence available today and the evidence a skeptical reader would want. Evidence is marked external when it comes from someone else's judgment or count, such as the 360-degree review human resources ran in 2024 with fourteen raters, my annual appraisals by the vice president of clinical operations, or a department's own report. It is marked internal when it rests on my impression. External evidence outweighs internal, for a specific reason. Kruger and Dunning (1999) found that people with the least skill in a domain tended to overestimate their performance the most, partly because the skill needed to perform well is the same skill needed to judge performance. Davis et al. (2006), reviewing studies of physicians, reported that doctors' ratings of their own competence matched observed performance weakly or not at all, with the least skilled and most confident among the worst self-assessors. My self-rating is therefore the entry I trust least.
The Inventory
Table 1
Capability Inventory With Evidence and Its Source
| Domain and item | My rating (1-5) | Evidence today | Type | Evidence a skeptic would want |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Business: performance improvement | 5 | Turnaround reports before and after; ED dashboard | External | Same result sustained a third year |
| Business: operations management | 4 | Accreditation inspections with no operations deficiencies, three cycles | External | Comparison with peer laboratories |
| Business: financial management | 3 | Capital request returned twice by finance before approval | External | A capital request approved on first submission |
| Leadership: change management | 4 | Consolidation completed; turnaround rose at one hospital | External | Evidence that I measured the effects in time |
| Communication: relationships with physicians | 4 | 360 review: pathologists and ED chair rated 2.9 of 5 | External | Physician ratings above 3.5 |
| Communication: workforce engagement | 3 | Turnover rose from 16% to 22% | External | Turnover falling, with exit reasons addressed |
| Professionalism: contribution to the field | 2 | One conference session; no publications | External | Peer-reviewed or adopted work |
| Knowledge: regulatory environment | 4 | No laboratory regulatory citations in eleven years | External | Evidence of proactive monitoring, not only absence of findings |
| Knowledge: reimbursement | 3 | My impression | Internal | Any external evidence |
| Leadership: developing others | 3 | Two supervisors promoted; one left within a year | External | Successors rated by their own staff |
Where My Rating and the Evidence Disagree
Three ratings moved after I set them beside the evidence. I first rated my relationships with physicians a 5, because I talk with the pathologists daily and have worked closely with the emergency department on troponin. The 360 review disagrees: the physician raters scored me 2.9, and their comments describe me as responsive but late to involve them in decisions that affect them, the microbiology consolidation being the example two of them named. I lowered the rating to 4 and still think it may be generous. I first rated financial management a 4. The record of a capital request returned twice, both times for weak operating cost projections, supports a 3. I first rated reimbursement a 3 with no evidence at all; I have left the rating but marked it internal, which in this inventory means it counts for little.
Two Strengths and Two Gaps
Two capabilities finish rated confidently and backed by external evidence: performance improvement and operations management. Both concern processes inside the laboratory, where I control the variables and the laboratory information system counts the result. Two finish weak with evidence that agrees: financial management and workforce engagement. A third weak rating, contribution to the field, I rated low myself and nobody would dispute.
The pattern repeats the finding from my practice claim audit. My strengths lie where I design the process and the system measures it; my gaps lie where the result depends on other people's decisions, such as finance's view of my projections, a scientist's decision to stay or a physician's sense of being consulted. The capabilities to develop are the ones that involve persuading or retaining people I do not direct.
What Would Change These Ratings
Each weak rating has a named piece of evidence that would raise it. Financial management rises if my next capital request, for chemistry analyzers due next spring, is approved on first submission with operating costs that hold within 5% in its first year. Relationships with physicians rise if the next 360 review scores physician ratings above 3.5. Workforce engagement rises only if turnover falls and the exit reasons named in interviews change. None of these can be raised by writing about them, which is the point of listing them this way. I have shared the table with the vice president of clinical operations, who will hold it at my next appraisal.
References
American College of Healthcare Executives. (2024). ACHE healthcare executive 2024 competencies assessment tool.
Davis, D. A., Mazmanian, P. E., Fordis, M., Van Harrison, R., Thorpe, K. E., & Perrier, L. (2006). Accuracy of physician self-assessment compared with observed measures of competence: A systematic review. JAMA, 296(9), 1094-1102. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.296.9.1094
Kruger, J., & Dunning, D. (1999). Unskilled and unaware of it: How difficulties in recognizing one's own incompetence lead to inflated self-assessments. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77(6), 1121-1134. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.77.6.1121
The HCA-817 Topic 2 assignment instructions
The Topic 2 instructions in HCA-817 ask doctoral learners to assess their own leadership capabilities. Submissions often report strength in every category or describe weaknesses as personality traits. The assignment rewards inventories that adopt a published instrument, rate against its categories rather than private ones and record for every rating both the evidence available now and the evidence a skeptical reader would want. Learners should mark which ratings rest on external judgment, such as appraisals or multisource reviews, and which rest on self-impression, explain where self-ratings and evidence disagree and name what would change each weak rating, supported by research on the accuracy of self-assessment.
How the HCA-817 Topic 2 example is put together
The finished inventory reads more like a ledger than a reflection. A published instrument supplies the categories, and the example names which one it borrowed and why, since a list of strengths the writer invents will grade itself kindly. Beside every rating sit two entries: the evidence available today, and the evidence a skeptical reader would want and will not get. Ratings resting on what other people said, a 360-degree review or a written appraisal, are marked external and weigh more than the writer's own impression. Kruger and Dunning appear briefly where self-rating error is discussed, used operationally rather than as decoration. Two capabilities finish rated confidently and evidenced by nothing, left visible on the page.
Reading the HCA 817 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty grading the capability inventory reward calibration. Excellent inventories use an external instrument consistently, attach evidence to every rating and weight external evidence above the writer's impression for a stated reason. Credit goes to showing ratings that changed when the evidence was examined, since unchanged self-ratings suggest the evidence was not read. The rubric values improvement areas framed as capabilities an instrument measures rather than traits. The highest level identifies a pattern across strengths and gaps and names the specific evidence that would raise each weak rating. Inventories whose evidence column is filled with the writer's own recollection generally fall into a middle band.
Common HCA 817 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Marks separate a calibrated inventory from a warm one, and the warm version is common. A self-assessment reporting strength across every category has told a reader about the writer's mood rather than their practice. Adopting an instrument in the opening paragraph and then rating against private categories wastes the only external reference in the paper. Improvement areas written as personality traits, such as impatience or a tendency to take on too much, sit outside anything a competency directory measures. Evidence lists made entirely of the writer's own recollection add nothing a doubtful reader would accept. The deduction that recurs at doctoral level is a reflection that closes on sincerity, having asserted growth without a single item another person could verify.
Get an HCA-817 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-817 Topic 2 instructions, your rubric and whichever competency instrument or scenario your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the instrument named, each rating carrying its class of evidence, the disagreements decided and the unsupported ratings left visible, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HCA 817 papers and DHA samples
- HCA 817 Topic 1: Practice Claim Audit
- HCA 817 Topic 3: External Contribution Dossier
- HCA 817 Topic 4: Informal Authority Trace
- HCA 817 Topic 5: Change Attribution Post
- HCA 817 Topic 6: Falsifiable Development Plan
- HCA 817 Topic 7: Portfolio Inclusion Argument
- HCA 817 Topic 8: Defended Contribution Statement
- HCA 822 Topic 2: Sourced Need Estimate
- HCA 812 Topic 2: Licensure and Accreditation Contrast
- HCA 827 Topic 2: Reinvestment Margin Memo
HCA 817 Topic 2 questions, answered
Is a self-assessment supposed to be modest?
It is supposed to be calibrated, which is a different thing. Rating yourself low with no evidence fails the same test as rating yourself high with no evidence, because neither number is anchored to anything. A high rating with an appraisal, a project record and a counted result behind it is defensible, and modesty would only have made the paper less accurate.
Which competency framework should the example use?
Use whichever one the assignment names, and where none is named, pick a published set such as the directories maintained by the American College of Healthcare Executives or the National Center for Healthcare Leadership. The particular choice matters less than using it consistently for every rating, and saying in one sentence what the framework does not measure.
What if nobody has ever given me a formal appraisal?
Then you use the external evidence that does exist and say the appraisal is missing. Committee minutes recording a recommendation you made, a sign-off on a project you led, a written note thanking you for something specific, and survey results from a service you ran are all authored by other people. Silence about the gap is what costs marks, not the gap.
Where can I find a free HCA 817 Topic 2 sample paper?
The complete inventory is on this page, with the borrowed instrument, the weighting rule, a ten-item table, where self-rating and evidence disagree, two strengths and two gaps and what would change them. Request a free example built around your framework.
Which ratings moved in HCA 817 Topic 2?
Physician relationships fell from 5 to 4 after a 360 review scored them 2.9, financial management fell from 4 to 3 after finance returned a capital request twice, and reimbursement stayed at 3 but was marked internal.