| Course | MGT 325 Managing Business Communications and Change |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Message retelling test |
| Length | About 960 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 325 Topic 8
Four Points, Three Retellings, Two Drafts: Testing Whether a Credit Union's Consolidation Message Survives Being Passed Along, Before It Goes Out
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-325: Managing Business Communications and Change
Topic 8 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Four Points, Three Retellings, Two Drafts: Testing Whether a Credit Union's Consolidation Message Survives Being Passed Along, Before It Goes Out
Why Test a Message Before Sending It
Topic 1 showed that Three Rivers Credit Union's consolidation memo decayed as it was retold, losing its reassurances by the time it reached the break room. That decay was discovered afterward. This report describes a way to discover it beforehand, by testing a draft on a small chain of people who pass it along from memory, and then revising the draft until its key points survive. The method has roots in Bartlett's serial reproduction studies, in which a story passed from person to person changed in consistent ways: details dropped out, unfamiliar elements were replaced with familiar ones and the story was reshaped toward what the teller expected (Bartlett, 1932).
The Points That Must Survive
Before testing, the communication team fixed four points the message must deliver, so survival could be judged against something definite.
1. Eastside closes on March 31, and service moves downtown.
2. Every Eastside employee has a job: a downtown position at the same pay and seniority.
3. Those who cannot move can apply for one of 40 remote roles or take severance.
4. No one is losing their job because of the consolidation; the scheduling coordinators have other positions.
Method
Three chains of three volunteers each were drawn from staff in another department, so none had heard the real announcement. The first person in each chain read the draft once, put it away and after ten minutes wrote what they would tell a colleague. The second person read only that version, waited ten minutes and wrote their own. The third did the same. Each third version was then marked against the four points as intact, distorted or gone. Using three short chains rather than one long one reduces the chance that a single person's quirks drive the result.
Results for the Original Draft
Table 1
Survival of Key Points in the Original Draft, Third Retelling
| Point | Chain A | Chain B | Chain C |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Closure date and move downtown | Intact | Intact | Distorted: "in the spring" |
| 2. Same pay and seniority downtown | Gone | Distorted: "you can transfer" | Gone |
| 3. 40 remote roles or severance | Gone | Gone | Distorted: "some options" |
| 4. No job losses | Gone | Distorted: "coordinators are leaving" | Gone |
Table 1 shows how the four points fared by the third retelling in each chain.
Only the closure survived reliably. The reassurances, the points the credit union most needed staff to hear, were lost or distorted in every chain. One third version read, "They're closing Eastside in the spring and the scheduling people are leaving," which is close to the break-room version in Topic 1.
Why did the closure survive while the reassurances vanished? The closure was concrete, a place and a date, and attached to something listeners already knew. The reassurances were in qualifications and numbers placed late in long sentences: "Those employees for whom relocation is not feasible may apply for one of 40 remote positions or elect severance under the terms described below." That sentence is accurate but abstract, and it reads as an exception rather than a promise. Ideas that are concrete and simple tend to survive being passed along, while abstract or qualified ones are dropped (Heath & Heath, 2007). The same pattern of leveling details and sharpening a few prominent ones was described long ago in studies of rumor (Allport & Postman, 1947).
The Revised Draft
The revision made three changes. First, the reassurance was moved to the opening sentence and joined to the closure, so the two travel together: "Eastside is closing on March 31, and every person who works there keeps a job." Second, the options were turned into a short, concrete list: "You can move downtown at your current pay. You can apply for one of 40 work-from-home jobs. Or you can take severance." Third, the coordinators were named as people with new positions rather than as a role being replaced: "Our two schedulers are moving into new roles in the credit union."
Results for the Revised Draft
Table 2
Survival of Key Points in the Revised Draft, Third Retelling
| Point | Chain D | Chain E | Chain F |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Closure date and move downtown | Intact | Intact | Intact |
| 2. Same pay and seniority downtown | Intact | Distorted: "same job downtown" | Intact |
| 3. 40 remote roles or severance | Distorted: "work from home or severance" | Intact | Distorted: "some can work from home" |
| 4. No job losses | Intact | Intact | Intact |
Three new chains, drawn from a different department, repeated the test on the revised draft.
The revised draft held up much better. The closure and the promise that no one loses their job survived in all three chains. Pay and seniority survived in two, and its distortion in the third, "same job downtown," still conveyed the main reassurance. The remote roles survived in one chain and were distorted in two, usually by losing the number 40, which suggests the number itself is hard to carry. That residual weakness is why the written FAQ in Topic 3 remains necessary: the number belongs in a document people can check, not only in a message they retell.
Limits and Recommendation
The test is small and artificial. Volunteers from another department have no personal stake, while real employees hearing about their own jobs may remember the threatening parts more vividly. Nine people per draft cannot estimate how often a point survives across a whole workforce. The test is useful for comparing drafts, not for predicting exact outcomes. Even so, it costs about an hour of nine people's time and found a weakness that, in the real announcement, cost weeks of rumor and correction. The credit union should run this test on every significant change message before it goes out, with the points fixed in advance and the revision tested in fresh chains.
References
Allport, G. W., & Postman, L. (1947). The psychology of rumor. Henry Holt.
Bartlett, F. C. (1932). Remembering: A study in experimental and social psychology. Cambridge University Press.
Heath, C., & Heath, D. (2007). Made to stick: Why some ideas survive and others die. Random House.
Reading the GCU MGT 325 Topic 8 instructions
The Topic 8 instructions for MGT-325 ask students to test how well a message survives retelling and to improve it. Proofreading the draft or asking a colleague whether it is clear does not test survival. The assignment rewards a small, structured test: points fixed in advance, chains of people who pass the message on from memory and each final version marked against those points. Students should explain why some points survived and others did not, revise the draft on that basis, test the revision in fresh chains and state the limits of a small test. Connecting the remaining weaknesses to other parts of the communication plan completes the work.
How the MGT-325 Topic 8 example is put together
The report opens by explaining why testing before sending beats discovering decay afterward, citing Bartlett. Four points are fixed. The method describes three chains of three volunteers from another department. Table 1 marks each point in the original draft as intact, distorted or gone, and the analysis explains why the concrete closure survived while abstract reassurances vanished. The revised draft moves the reassurance into the opening sentence and lists the options simply. Table 2 shows the revised draft's results, with the remote-role number still fragile, which justifies the written FAQ. Limits and a recommendation to test every major message close the report.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 325 Topic 8 rubric
Instructors grading the retelling test reward points fixed before the test and a clear marking scheme. Strong reports use more than one chain and explain the results with research on how messages change. Credit goes to a revision that responds directly to what failed and to testing that revision rather than assuming it works. The rubric values honest limits, since a small test with volunteers can compare drafts but cannot predict exact outcomes. The highest band connects remaining weaknesses to other communication choices, such as a written document for figures. Reports that revise the draft without testing it again usually lose marks. Reporting a result honestly when a revision only partly works also counts in the writer's favor.
MGT 325 Topic 8 help: mistakes that cost marks
Reports that ask a colleague whether the draft is clear lose most of the available marks, because clarity to a first reader is exactly what this test is designed to look past. Without intended points fixed in advance, survival cannot be judged and the comparison drifts toward impressions. Chains made of project insiders understate decay, since insiders fill gaps from knowledge the eventual audience will not have. A revision that polishes wording without addressing the points that vanished has not used the findings at all. Omitting the second test leaves the improved draft as a claim, when running the chain again is what demonstrates it. Reports that record only losses and never explain why some points lasted cannot guide the next message anyone writes.
Get an MGT-325 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-325 Topic 8 instructions, your section's rubric and the draft message you are testing. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the intended points fixed first, a retelling chain recorded, every point marked for survival and a revised draft tested again, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 325 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 325 Topic 1: Message Decay Analysis
- MGT 325 Topic 2: Audience Loss Segmentation
- MGT 325 Topic 3: Channel Selection Rationale
- MGT 325 Topic 4: Objection Audit
- MGT 325 Topic 5: Rumor Versus Survey DQ
- MGT 325 Topic 6: Cascade Briefing Kit
- MGT 325 Topic 7: Announcement Sequencing Plan
- MGT 420 Topic 8: Work Design Intervention Plan
- BUS 470 Topic 8: Client Handover Package
- MGT 434 Topic 8: Practice Defense Memo
- MGT 440 Topic 8: Project Closure Report
MGT 325 Topic 8 questions, answered
How many people should be in the retelling chain?
Three is a practical minimum, since that approximates the distance between the author and a front-line employee in many organizations. Longer chains show more decay but take longer to run. What matters more than the number is that each person hears only the previous version and passes it on from memory, which is how the message will actually travel.
What if the message survived perfectly?
Then report that honestly and look for the reason, which is useful in itself. Sometimes a message survives because it is short and concrete; sometimes the chain was too informed to test it properly. A perfect result from insiders proves little, so check whether the participants already knew the content before concluding that the draft is resistant to decay.
Does revising for retelling mean dumbing the message down?
No, though it usually means shortening what must survive. Detail can still live in a written document people consult; what needs revising is the core that will be repeated. Making that core concrete, attaching it to something familiar and removing reassurances that turn into promises when repeated produces a message that is simpler to retell without being less accurate.
Where can I find a free MGT 325 Topic 8 sample paper?
The credit union retelling test is on this page in full: the fixed points, the method, both results tables, the reasons points survived or vanished, the revised draft and the limits. Send the message you want to test and a free report can be drafted around it.
Why did the reassurances vanish in MGT 325 Topic 8?
They were abstract and placed late in long sentences, so retellers dropped them, while the closure was concrete and familiar. The revision put the job guarantee in the opening sentence beside the closure.