| Course | MGT 434 Human Resources |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Practice defense memo |
| Length | About 770 words, 3 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 434 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Operations Manager, Distribution Center
From: Human Resources Manager
Date: [Date]
Re: Reclassifying shipping coordinators as salaried exempt: the overtime risk, and another way to cut after-hours cost
Your Request
You asked HR to reclassify the four shipping coordinators from hourly to salaried exempt, at a salary equal to their current base pay plus about 5 percent. Your goal is to reduce overtime cost. The coordinators often answer calls and messages from drivers and stores after their shifts, and when that time is recorded it is paid at time and a half. A salary would cover that time without overtime. It is a reasonable goal, and this memo proposes a way to reach it. But reclassification would not achieve it safely, and it could cost far more than the overtime it saves.
Why a Salary Is Not Enough
Under federal wage law, an employee is exempt from overtime only if the job meets both a salary test and a duties test (Fair Labor Standards Act, 2018). Paying a salary above the minimum threshold satisfies the first test but not the second. The duties test turns on what the coordinators actually do, not on their title or how they are paid (Executive, Administrative, Professional, Computer and Outside Sales Employees, 2024).
The most likely exemption for the coordinators would be the administrative exemption, which requires that the employee's primary duty be office work directly related to management or general business operations and that it include the exercise of discretion and independent judgment on matters of significance (U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, 2008). The coordinators schedule pickups, update the shipping system, answer driver calls and resolve routing questions by following the center's routing guide and carrier rules. When a decision falls outside the guide, such as paying for an expedited carrier, they escalate it to you. Work that applies set procedures, with significant decisions referred upward, typically fails the duties test. Reclassifying them would very likely be a misclassification.
What Misclassification Would Cost
Table 1
Illustrative Exposure if the Coordinators Are Misclassified
| Item | Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Unrecorded overtime per year | 4 coordinators x 3 hours a week x 52 weeks x $33 overtime rate | $20,592 |
| Back pay for two years | $20,592 x 2 | $41,184 |
| Liquidated damages, equal amount | $41,184 | |
| Total before legal fees | $82,368 |
If the coordinators were reclassified and continued answering after-hours calls without pay, the center would be accumulating unpaid overtime. The figures below are illustrative but based on current call logs.
An employee who wins such a claim can usually collect two years of unpaid overtime, three if the employer acted willfully, doubled by liquidated damages and topped with legal fees (Fair Labor Standards Act, 2018). A claim by one coordinator often leads to a review of the others, and sometimes of other hourly roles. The exposure above, about $82,000 before fees, is far larger than the overtime the reclassification was meant to save.
Another Way to Reach Your Goal
The underlying problem is not the coordinators' pay classification; it is that all four are contacted after hours, without a schedule, whenever a driver or store has a question. That spreads unplanned overtime across everyone and makes it hard to control. I propose an on-call rota instead.
1. One coordinator is on call each evening on a rotating schedule, so each covers about one or two evenings a week.
2. Drivers and stores are given a single after-hours number that forwards to the on-call coordinator.
3. The on-call coordinator records time spent on calls through the mobile timekeeping app, and is paid for that time.
4. The other three coordinators are not contacted after hours except in an emergency defined in writing, such as a truck breakdown with a store-critical load.
5. You review the after-hours call log monthly and move recurring questions into the routing guide, so fewer calls are needed over time.
Based on the call logs, most after-hours calls are short and could be handled by one person. Concentrating them on one coordinator, instead of four answering separately, should cut recorded after-hours time from about twelve hours a week across the team to about five. At $33 an hour, that would reduce after-hours overtime from about $20,600 a year to about $8,600, a saving of roughly $12,000, without any legal exposure.
Next Step
If you agree, HR will draft the on-call schedule and the written emergency definition with you this week, and we can start the rota on the first of next month. I am also glad to review the coordinators' duties with you if you believe their work has changed in ways that would support an exemption; if it has, we should document it carefully before making any change.
References
Executive, Administrative, Professional, Computer and Outside Sales Employees, 29 C.F.R. pt. 541 (2024).
Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. ยง 201 et seq. (2018).
U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division. (2008). Fact sheet #17A: Exemption for executive, administrative, professional, computer and outside sales employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). U.S. Department of Labor.
MGT 434 Topic 8 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 8 instructions for MGT-434 ask students to defend a sound HR practice against a manager who wants to change it. A memo that simply cites the rule, or lectures the manager, rarely persuades. The assignment rewards a memo that restates the manager's goal fairly, explains the legal issue briefly in terms of what employees actually do, prices the risk with labeled figures and offers another way to reach the manager's goal. Students should keep the explanation accurate without overstating it, show the arithmetic and close with a practical next step that leaves room to revisit the question if the facts differ.
How the MGT-434 Topic 8 example is put together
The memo opens by restating the request and calling the goal reasonable. A section explains the salary and duties tests and why coordinators who follow a routing guide and escalate decisions likely fail the administrative exemption. Table 1 prices unrecorded overtime, two years of back pay and liquidated damages. A paragraph explains how such claims are recovered and how they spread. The alternative is a five-step on-call rota with a single after-hours number, recorded time and a written emergency definition, estimated to save about $12,000 a year. A next step offers to draft the rota and to review the duties if the work has changed.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 434 Topic 8 rubric
Instructors grading the practice defense memo reward a reader who feels understood rather than corrected. Strong memos restate the manager's goal fairly and keep the legal explanation short, accurate and tied to the actual work. Credit goes to a priced exposure with clear arithmetic and to an alternative that delivers what the manager wants by a lawful route. The rubric values concrete steps the manager can approve and an estimate of savings from the alternative. The highest band closes by offering a next step and leaving the door open if the facts are different. Memos that only cite the law and refuse the request usually lose points.
Common MGT 434 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Most lost marks here come from quoting policy at someone who does not care about policy. A reply stating that the law requires overtime and ending there has been correct and unpersuasive at once, and the manager will look for a way around it. Memos that never price the exposure ask the reader to fear something unmeasured, which is easy to wave away. Figures that fail to reconcile, such as an annual cost that does not match the hourly figures multiplied through, destroy the credibility the argument depends on. Papers casting the manager as the villain skip the legitimate cost concern and lose their only reader. The strongest versions end with an alternative, while those stopping at refusal leave the manager holding the original plan and a grievance.
Get an MGT-434 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-434 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric from your classroom and the practice or manager scenario the assignment sets. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the manager's goal stated first, the rule explained briefly, exposure priced on labeled figures, the fair point conceded and an alternative offered, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 434 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 434 Topic 1: Line Manager Decision Inventory
- MGT 434 Topic 2: Essential Functions Job Analysis
- MGT 434 Topic 3: Structured Interview Guide
- MGT 434 Topic 4: Internal Equity Pay Review
- MGT 434 Topic 5: Appraisal System Dq Post
- MGT 434 Topic 6: Corrective Action Record
- MGT 434 Topic 7: Termination Decision File
- MGT 420 Topic 8: Work Design Intervention Plan
- MGT 325 Topic 8: Message Retelling Test
- BUS 470 Topic 8: Client Handover Package
MGT 434 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why argue from consequence instead of policy?
Because the reader already knows the policy and has decided it is in the way. A manager who hears only that a rule exists will look for an exception, while one who sees the cost of the shortcut beside the cost of the practice has a reason to change course. Policy still appears in the memo, briefly, as the basis of the exposure.
Where do the damages figures come from?
Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, unpaid overtime can generally be recovered for two years, or three where a violation is willful, and liquidated damages can equal the back pay owed. The example applies that structure to labeled illustrative wages and hours. Real exposure depends on facts and on state law, so this is coursework support, not legal advice.
What if the manager outranks the writer?
That is the usual situation, which is why the memo concedes the fair point and offers an alternative instead of issuing a refusal. A supervisor or HR generalist writing upward keeps the tone factual, puts the figures where they can be checked and asks for a decision on a trial rather than an admission that the original idea was wrong.
Where can I find a free MGT 434 Topic 8 sample paper?
The memo to the operations manager appears here in full: the request, why a salary is not enough, the priced exposure, the on-call rota and the next step. Share the practice you need to defend, and a free memo can be drafted for your situation.
How is the exposure priced in MGT 434 Topic 8?
Four coordinators each answering about three hours of calls a week at a $33 overtime rate comes to $20,592 a year. Two years of back pay doubled by liquidated damages reaches $82,368 before legal fees.