| Course | MGT 434 Human Resources |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Discussion post |
| Length | About 440 words, 2 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 434 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post
Ranked by Units Picked: What a Quarterly Forced Ranking Did to a Warehouse's Pickers, Including the One Employee the Design Never Considered
Initial Post
The appraisal system I am evaluating ranks warehouse pickers each quarter on total units picked and puts the bottom tenth on a performance improvement plan. My verdict is that it measures one thing well and damages three others, and it has a legal flaw nobody designed for.
The system is in use at the composite auto parts distribution center I have been studying. Each of about 120 pickers is ranked by the total units they pick in the quarter. The top tenth receive a $300 bonus; the bottom tenth go on a 60-day improvement plan, and two consecutive quarters in the bottom tenth can lead to termination.
It does increase units picked, which is what it measures. But it has changed behavior in three ways managers did not intend. Experienced pickers now avoid orders made up of heavy or bulky parts, such as brake rotors and batteries, because those orders take longer per unit. Those orders sit in the queue until a newer picker gets them. Nobody volunteers to train new hires anymore, because time spent training lowers the trainer's count. And the required safety check on the order picker lift, a two-minute walk-around before each use, is skipped when the line backs up, since it counts as time not picking. The center rewards units while hoping for balanced workloads, training and safety, the pattern Kerr (1975) described as rewarding one thing while hoping for another.
The edge the design never considered is leave. A picker whose federal family and medical leave has been approved on an intermittent basis, for example to care for a parent with a chronic illness, works fewer hours in a quarter and therefore picks fewer total units. Under a total-units ranking, that employee slides toward the bottom tenth because of protected leave. Counting the effects of protected leave against an employee in a way that leads to discipline risks interfering with rights the law protects (Family and Medical Leave Act, 2018). The center has two pickers on intermittent leave, and one was placed on an improvement plan last quarter.
My question for the class: would converting the measure from total units to units per hour worked fix the scheme? It would solve the leave problem, since hours on leave are excluded. I am less sure it fixes the others. A per-hour rate still rewards avoiding heavy orders and skipping the safety check, and it still penalizes time spent training. What would you add to the measure, or take away from the ranking, to fix those three?
References
Family and Medical Leave Act, 29 U.S.C. ยง 2601 et seq. (2018).
Kerr, S. (1975). On the folly of rewarding A, while hoping for B. Academy of Management Journal, 18(4), 769-783. https://doi.org/10.2307/255378
What the MGT 434 Topic 5 instructions ask for
In MGT-434 Topic 5 the discussion question asks students to evaluate a performance appraisal system. Posts that describe a system without judging it, or criticize appraisal in general, miss the task. The prompt rewards a post that names a specific system, gives a verdict, reports the behavior the system has produced and identifies consequences its designers did not anticipate, including legal ones. Students should support the behavioral claims with research on rewards and incentives and close with a question that tests an obvious fix, so classmates have something specific to debate. A composite workplace is acceptable as the example. Students should also be precise about how the system is scored.
How this MGT 434 Topic 5 example is built
The post names the ranking system and its verdict in the opening lines. The scheme's design is described with its bonus and improvement plan. Three unintended behaviors follow: avoiding heavy orders, refusing to train new hires and skipping the lift safety check, each linked to Kerr's account of reward systems. A paragraph identifies the leave problem, an employee with approved intermittent leave sliding toward the bottom because of fewer hours, and notes that one such picker was already placed on a plan. The closing question asks whether a per-hour measure would fix the scheme and admits it would leave three problems unsolved.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 434 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty grading the discussion reward a specific system judged on its actual effects. The best posts report the behavior the system produces, not just its intended purpose, and connect each effect to the measure. Credit goes to finding consequences the design never considered, such as protected leave lowering a total count. The rubric values accurate use of research on rewards and a closing question that tests an obvious fix against the problems it may not solve. Excellent posts give classmates a concrete issue to argue about rather than a general invitation. Posts that describe the system without evaluating it usually score low. A clear description of how the ranking is calculated makes the critique checkable.
MGT 434 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Discussion posts on this question lose most of their credit by staying abstract. A contribution explaining that performance management should align with organizational goals has restated the textbook and named no system anybody could examine. Posts describing a scheme without reporting what people actually do under it have judged the design on intent, which is the one thing the question asks them not to do. Behaviors offered as general gaming, with nothing specific, give classmates nothing to confirm or test. The legal edge is where many posts say nothing, and a count that penalizes protected leave is exposure the supervisor applying it carries personally. Sources attached to claims they never make are spotted by markers who follow the reference, and a final line that merely summarizes hands the section nothing to push against.
Get an MGT-434 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-434 Topic 5 discussion question, the participation rubric for your section and any system you want examined. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the scheme named and judged, three behaviors described, the legal edge raised, one source used for one claim and a fix put up for dispute, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 434 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 434 Topic 1: Line Manager Decision Inventory
- MGT 434 Topic 2: Essential Functions Job Analysis
- MGT 434 Topic 3: Structured Interview Guide
- MGT 434 Topic 4: Internal Equity Pay Review
- MGT 434 Topic 6: Corrective Action Record
- MGT 434 Topic 7: Termination Decision File
- MGT 434 Topic 8: Practice Defense Memo
- MGT 420 Topic 5: Team Necessity DQ
- MGT 325 Topic 5: Rumor Versus Survey DQ
- BUS 470 Topic 5: Unwelcome Finding Dq Post
MGT 434 Topic 5 questions, answered
Is a workplace appraisal scheme acceptable as the example?
In most sections it is, and a scheme the writer has actually worked under supplies detail no textbook case can. Describe what is counted and what people do about it, keep individuals unnamed, and leave out anything that would identify a colleague who landed in the bottom band. Other students read the thread, and some may know the employer.
What is forced distribution and why is it contested?
A scheme requiring a set share of employees to fall into each rating band regardless of how the group actually performed. Supporters argue it counters rating inflation; critics point to competition between colleagues and to litigation where the bottom band skewed toward older workers. A post can take either side, provided it argues from the behavior the scheme produced.
Does an appraisal rating really matter legally?
It often matters later. Appraisals are among the first documents requested when a termination is challenged, and a run of satisfactory ratings followed by a dismissal for poor performance invites the argument that the stated reason was not the real one. A system that penalizes protected leave creates a separate problem. The example flags both as coursework, not legal advice.
Where can I find a free MGT 434 Topic 5 sample paper?
You can read the whole post on the pickers' quarterly ranking above, with a note in the margin explaining its structure. Share the appraisal system you want to evaluate and the prompt, and a free post can be written about it.
Why does the ranking create a leave problem in MGT 434 Topic 5?
An employee on approved intermittent family and medical leave works fewer hours and picks fewer total units, so the ranking pushes them toward the bottom tenth because of protected leave.