| Course | MGT 434 Human Resources |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Termination file |
| Length | About 970 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 434 Topic 7
Assembled Before Anyone Is Told: A Termination Decision File for an Inventory Clerk, Including the Rating That Seems to Contradict It
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-434: Human Resources
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Assembled Before Anyone Is Told: A Termination Decision File for an Inventory Clerk, Including the Rating That Seems to Contradict It
The Reason in One Sentence
Pat Lindqvist, inventory clerk, is being terminated for repeated cycle count errors after a final written warning, the third documented error in seven months, each of which caused a recorded inventory variance.
Every other document in this file has to support that sentence. If a document does not support it, or seems to contradict it, the file addresses that document directly rather than leaving it for someone else to find. The file is assembled before Pat is told, so the decision rests on what was known at the time rather than on reasons added afterward.
The History in Date Order
Table 1
Documented Count Errors and Corrective Steps
| Date | Event | Document in file |
|---|---|---|
| March 12 | Count error: 40 brake pads recorded as 400; variance of $3,960 later corrected | Variance report; written coaching note signed by Pat |
| June 3 | Count error: wrong bin counted for alternators; variance of $2,150 | Variance report; written warning signed by Pat |
| July 15 | Annual review: rating of meets expectations | Annual review form |
| August 20 | Count error: water pumps counted as zero in an occupied bin; variance of $4,870; a store order was short-shipped | Variance report; final written warning signed by Pat |
| October 8 | Count error: 120 oil filters recorded as 12; variance of $1,190 | Variance report |
Pat's job includes daily cycle counts, counting a set of bin locations and entering the counts in the warehouse management system. A count error is an entry that does not match a recount by a second clerk within 24 hours. The center's standard, explained in the clerk training Pat completed, is that errors should not exceed one per month.
The sequence matters as much as the count. Pat was told after each of the first three errors what the standard was and what would follow another error, and each step is signed. The October error came after a final warning that stated the next step plainly.
The Awkward Document
The July annual review rated Pat as meeting expectations. If this termination is challenged, that rating will be offered as evidence that Pat's performance was acceptable and that the stated reason is a pretext. In disputes over whether an employer's stated reason is genuine, evidence that undermines the reason can allow a jury to infer discrimination (Reeves v. Sanderson Plumbing Products, Inc., 2000). The file must therefore explain the rating rather than ignore it.
Three facts do that. First, the rating's comment section, written by the same supervisor, says: "Count accuracy needs improvement; two errors this year resulted in variances. Must reduce errors." The rating did not overlook the problem; it named it. Second, the review covered the period from July of the previous year, when Pat had no documented errors for the first eight months, which explains an overall rating of meets expectations. Third, the two errors that led to the final warning and to this decision, August 20 and October 8, both came after the review. The rating describes performance before the decisive errors, not after them.
The supervisor should not now revise or add to the July review. Changing an old document after a decision would invite the inference the file is meant to avoid.
Who Decided, and on What Evidence
Pat is 54. The Age Discrimination in Employment Act protects employees aged 40 and older from adverse employment decisions because of age (Age Discrimination in Employment Act, 2018). The file therefore records who made the decision and what they relied on. The decision was made by the shipping and receiving manager, after review by the HR manager, on the basis of the four variance reports, the three signed corrective documents and the center's written accuracy standard. The supervisor's recommendation is attached. No replacement had been identified or discussed at the time of the decision; the position will be posted after Pat's departure. Two other clerks, aged 29 and 47, received written warnings for count errors in the past year and did not reach a third error after their final warnings.
The file also notes what was not considered: Pat's age, Pat's approved vacation in September and any comment about Pat's pace or retirement plans. The supervisor confirmed in writing that no such comments were made.
Recording who decided, and on what evidence, is not an admission that age played a part. It is what allows the center to show, if challenged, that the decision rested on documented performance and that similar errors by younger clerks led to similar steps.
The Meeting Script
Attending: the shipping and receiving manager and the HR manager. Location: the HR office, at the start of Pat's shift on a Tuesday, so Pat does not work a partial shift first.
1. State the decision and the reason once: "Pat, we have decided to end your employment, effective today, because of a further count error on October 8 after the final written warning in August." Do not debate the decision or list every error again.
2. Effective date: today.
3. Final pay: paid through today, including accrued vacation, by direct deposit on the next regular payday, or sooner if state law requires.
4. Benefits: health coverage continues through the end of the month; information about continuation coverage will be mailed within the required period. Retirement plan balances remain Pat's.
5. Property: badge, locker key and handheld scanner returned before leaving.
6. Questions: answer factual questions about pay, benefits and property. If Pat disputes the reason, listen, note what Pat says and confirm it will be added to the file.
The meeting should take no more than fifteen minutes. The manager should treat Pat with respect throughout; a termination handled with dignity is less likely to be challenged and is the right way to end a working relationship (Falcone, 2010).
References
Age Discrimination in Employment Act, 29 U.S.C. ยง 621 et seq. (2018).
Falcone, P. (2010). 101 sample write-ups for documenting employee performance problems: A guide to progressive discipline and termination (2nd ed.). AMACOM.
Reeves v. Sanderson Plumbing Products, Inc., 530 U.S. 133 (2000).
What the MGT 434 Topic 7 instructions ask for
MGT-434 Topic 7 asks students to prepare a termination decision so that it can withstand review. Collecting documents after the employee has been told, or listing every complaint ever made, weakens the file. The prompt rewards a file built before the meeting around a single stated reason that every document supports. Students should present the history in date order, confront any document that seems to contradict the decision, record who decided and on what evidence when the employee is in a protected group, and prepare a short meeting script covering the reason, effective date, final pay, benefits and property.
Inside the MGT 434 Topic 7 example
The file opens with the reason in one sentence and explains why it was assembled first. Table 1 lists the count errors in date order with the document for each. A section addresses the July rating, quoting its comment on accuracy and showing that the decisive errors came after it, with case law on why such a document matters. The decision-maker section notes the clerk's age, names who decided and on what evidence, compares the treatment of two younger clerks and states what was not considered. A one-page meeting script covers attendees, the reason given once, pay, benefits, property and questions. Every document named in the file is listed in the table with its date.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 434 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty grading the termination file reward one reason stated plainly and supported by every document. Strong files present events in date order and confront the document most likely to be used against the decision, using its own text and dates. Credit goes to recording who decided and on what evidence, particularly when the employee is in a protected age group, and to comparisons with how others were treated. The rubric values a short, respectful meeting script that gives the reason once and covers final pay and benefits accurately. Files that ignore a favorable rating, or offer several shifting reasons, usually lose marks. Consistency between the stated reason and every attached document is checked first.
MGT 434 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks
Termination files are marked on consistency more than on tone. A dismissal explained as poor performance in the file, as restructuring in the meeting and as a fresh start in a reference letter has produced shifting reasons, which is among the strongest evidence a pretext argument can use. Files leaving a satisfactory rating unaddressed let the employee's attorney introduce it first. Treating at-will employment as permission to skip documentation misreads the doctrine, since it removes the need for cause but not the prohibition on unlawful reasons. Reviews that never check age, recent leave or a recent complaint have skipped the exposure most likely to exist. Scripts that argue with the employee, apologize for the decision or improvise a reason in the room undo the file that came before them.
Get an MGT-434 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-434 Topic 7 instructions, your rubric and the employee scenario the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with one reason held consistent, the history in date order, contradicting documents confronted, protected status reviewed and the meeting scripted, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free, and none of it is legal advice.
More MGT 434 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 434 Topic 1: Line Manager Decision Inventory
- MGT 434 Topic 2: Essential Functions Job Analysis
- MGT 434 Topic 3: Structured Interview Guide
- MGT 434 Topic 4: Internal Equity Pay Review
- MGT 434 Topic 5: Appraisal System Dq Post
- MGT 434 Topic 6: Corrective Action Record
- MGT 434 Topic 8: Practice Defense Memo
- MGT 420 Topic 7: Structural Root Cause Diagnosis
- MGT 325 Topic 7: Announcement Sequencing Plan
- BUS 470 Topic 7: Client Briefing Deck
MGT 434 Topic 7 questions, answered
If employment is at-will, why build a file at all?
Because at-will status removes the need for cause without removing the prohibition on unlawful reasons. When a dismissal is challenged as discriminatory or retaliatory, the employer has to show the real reason, and the file is where that reason either holds up or falls apart. A dismissal with no record behind it leaves a supervisor's memory set against the employee's account.
What should never be said in the meeting?
Any reason other than the one in the file, any comment touching age, health, family or leave, and any promise nobody has approved, such as a reference or a severance amount. Apologizing in a way that suggests the decision came from elsewhere invites the question of where. The script keeps the meeting short and factual, and it declines to debate.
Are severance agreements part of this topic?
Sometimes. Where a release of claims is offered to an employee aged forty or older, the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act sets specific requirements, including time to consider the agreement and a period to revoke it. The example notes where a release would sit in the file without drafting one, since that document belongs with counsel rather than with a supervisor.
Where can I find a free MGT 434 Topic 7 sample paper?
The clerk's termination file is above in full, with the reason, the dated history, the treatment of the July rating, the decision record and the meeting script. Send the facts of the situation you are working on, and a free file can be prepared from them.
How does MGT 434 Topic 7 handle the good rating?
The rating's own comment flagged count accuracy, it covered a period with few errors, and the two errors that led to the final warning and the decision both came after it.