MGT 325 Topic 4 objection audit example

Managing Business Communications and Change Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 325 Topic 4 sample paper audits 22 objections staff raised about a credit union's plan, a composite, to merge two call centers, recorded in their own words. It belongs to GCU MGT 325, Managing Business Communications and Change, the course listed as MGT-325 in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management. Each objection goes into one of four bins: practical flaws, real costs, preferences and misunderstandings. Five practical flaws include a twelve-desk shortfall downtown, and six misunderstandings repeat the break-room version of the memo. The audit then compares original wording with what reached leadership, showing objections softened on the way up, a pattern Rosen and Tesser called the MUM effect.

CourseMGT 325 Managing Business Communications and Change
TopicTopic 4
Paper typeObjection audit
LengthAbout 970 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 325 Topic 4

1

Twenty-Two Objections in Four Bins: Auditing What Credit Union Staff Said About the Call Center Consolidation, and What Was Lost on the Way Up

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-325: Managing Business Communications and Change

Topic 4 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title gives the scale of the audit and its sorting method, and it promises to examine the route by which objections reached leadership. The credit union and every quoted objection are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Twenty-Two Objections in Four Bins: Auditing What Credit Union Staff Said About the Call Center Consolidation, and What Was Lost on the Way Up

Why Audit Objections

Three weeks after Three Rivers Credit Union announced the plan to fold the Eastside service floor into the downtown center, objections had reached leadership in a tidy form: a slide in the member services director's update listing "concerns about commute, workload and communication." That summary is too smooth to act on. This audit goes back to the objections in the words employees used, gathered from the human resources one-to-one meetings, an anonymous comment box, the director's notes from team meetings and the supervisors' own records. Twenty-two distinct objections were found. Each is sorted into one of four bins, because each bin calls for a different response.

Objections are not only resistance to be overcome. They are information about the change and about how it was communicated, and treating them as noise discards that information (Ford et al., 2008).

What this page is doingThe audit recovers objections in employees' own words before sorting them, because the tidy summary that reached leadership had already lost what made them useful.
3

The Four Bins

1. Practical flaws: something the designers missed that would make the plan fail or cost more than expected.

2. Real costs: a genuine loss the plan imposes on some employees, which the plan may still be right to impose but should acknowledge and, where possible, reduce.

3. Preferences: a reasonable wish that deserves a hearing but does not justify changing the plan.

4. Misunderstandings: an objection to something the plan never said. These are the bin this course cares about most, because each one shows exactly where the message went wrong.

The Audit

Table 1

Sample Objections by Bin, With Responses

BinObjection as saidRelated objectionsResponse it warrants
Practical flaw"Downtown only has 70 desks. Where are 34 more people going to sit?"3Check the floor plan; the facilities team confirmed 12 desks short. Add a second shift pattern or remote rotation.
Practical flaw"The new scheduling software doesn't know who's trained on business accounts."2Add skill tags before go-live; delay coordinator redeployment by four weeks.
Real cost"It's 45 minutes each way for me now. That's an hour and a half of my day."6Acknowledge; offer remote rotation priority to the longest commutes; parking subsidy downtown.
Real cost"Team leads are getting the coordinators' reports dumped on us with no time to do them."3Acknowledge; give leads two protected hours a week for the first quarter.
Preference"We'd rather keep our Eastside team together downtown."2Hear it; seat Eastside teams together for the first three months where floor space allows.
Misunderstanding"If you can't move you're out."4Correct in writing: 40 remote roles and severance are available.
Misunderstanding"The coordinators got fired."2Correct: both were offered and have accepted other positions.

Table 1 shows a sample from each bin, in employees' words, with the count of related objections.

What Each Bin Shows

Five objections were practical flaws, and two of them would have caused real problems. Downtown was twelve desks short of what the consolidation required, which nobody in the planning group had checked because the headcount figures came from finance rather than facilities. And the new scheduling software had not been set up to know which representatives were trained on business accounts, a detail the coordinators held in their heads. Both are fixable, but only because someone said them out loud.

Nine were real costs. The commute objections are the largest group, and they are legitimate: the plan does impose a longer journey on most Eastside staff. The right response is not to argue that the cost is small but to acknowledge it and reduce it where possible. Team leads' workload is a cost the drafters did not see, as Topic 2 predicted.

Two were preferences. Keeping the Eastside team together is a reasonable wish; the plan can accommodate it partly without changing anything material.

Six were misunderstandings, and they map directly onto the decay traced in Topic 1. "If you can't move you're out" is the break-room version of the memo almost word for word. The coordinators' redeployment was turned into dismissal. Neither objection is about the plan; both are about the message.

The proportions are themselves informative. Fewer than a quarter of the objections were about the plan's design, and more than a quarter were about a version of the plan that did not exist. Leadership had been treating all of them as resistance, which meant arguing against misunderstandings and overlooking practical flaws.

The Route Upward

The audit also compared each objection's original wording with the version that reached the director's slide. The pattern was consistent: objections were softened as they climbed. "Where are 34 more people going to sit?" became "some logistics questions." "Team leads are getting the coordinators' reports dumped on us" became "workload concerns." The six misunderstandings did not appear at all, because supervisors assumed they would sort themselves out.

People are reluctant to pass unwelcome news to those above them, the reluctance Rosen and Tesser (1970) labeled the MUM effect. Supervisors relaying objections may also fear appearing unable to manage their teams. Employees themselves often stay silent about concerns they believe leaders do not want to hear (Milliken et al., 2003). The comment box and human resources meetings caught what the supervisor route filtered out.

What this page is doingComparing each objection's original wording with the version that reached leadership turns a general claim about filtering into specific, checkable evidence.
4

Recommendations

Three actions follow. First, fix the two practical flaws before the consolidation date: resolve the desk shortfall and tag the scheduling software with skills. Second, respond to the real costs openly, in a written update that names the commute and workload costs and the measures taken to reduce them. Third, correct the misunderstandings with the written FAQ described in Topic 3, sent again with a short note saying which rumors it answers. For future changes, objections should reach leadership in employees' own words, through a channel that does not pass through the supervisors whose teams are raising them.

References

Ford, J. D., Ford, L. W., & D'Amelio, A. (2008). Resistance to change: The rest of the story. Academy of Management Review, 33(2), 362-377. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2008.31193235

Milliken, F. J., Morrison, E. W., & Hewlin, P. F. (2003). An exploratory study of employee silence: Issues that employees don't communicate upward and why. Journal of Management Studies, 40(6), 1453-1476. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-6486.00387

Rosen, S., & Tesser, A. (1970). On reluctance to communicate undesirable information: The MUM effect. Sociometry, 33(3), 253-263. https://doi.org/10.2307/2786156

MGT 325 Topic 4 instructions, in plain terms

The Topic 4 instructions in MGT-325 ask students to analyze employee objections to a change. Treating every objection as resistance to overcome misses the information objections carry. The assignment rewards an audit that records objections as employees said them, sorts them into categories that call for different responses and identifies which objections come from the message rather than the plan. Students should explain how objections changed as they moved up the organization, draw on research about upward communication and silence, and finish with specific actions for each category, including fixes to the plan and corrections to the message.

How this MGT 325 Topic 4 example is built

The audit begins with the tidy summary that reached leadership and explains why the original words matter. Four bins are defined. Table 1 lists sample objections in employees' words with counts and responses. A section explains what each bin shows: two practical flaws that would have caused real problems, commute and workload costs that deserve acknowledgment, a preference that can be partly met and misunderstandings that match the decayed message. The route upward is examined by comparing original wording with the director's slide. Recommendations fix the flaws, address the costs openly, correct the misunderstandings and change how objections reach leadership.

Reading the MGT 325 Topic 4 rubric

Instructors grading the objection audit reward objections recorded in employees' own words. Strong audits sort them into categories with distinct responses and treat misunderstandings as evidence about the message. Credit goes to finding practical flaws the designers missed and acknowledging real costs rather than arguing them away. The rubric values comparing original objections with the softened versions that reached leaders and explaining the softening with research. The highest band ends with actions for each bin and a better route for objections in future changes. Audits that summarize concerns in general terms usually land in the lower bands. Counting how many objections fall into each bin also matters, because the proportions tell leaders whether their problem lies mainly in the plan or in the message.

MGT 325 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks

An audit that treats every objection as resistance to be overcome forfeits most of its marks at once, because it throws away the flaws the front line spotted first. Sorting that stops at supporters and opponents records sentiment and learns nothing about the plan. Objections gathered only from managers have already been filtered, and a marker familiar with upward distortion will notice that the sample heard the polite version. Missing the misunderstanding category is the costliest omission for this course specifically, since those objections are direct evidence of how the message decayed. Responses applied uniformly, usually more explanation, answer a real flaw with a presentation. Audits that never say which objections changed the plan leave a reader unsure whether anything was learned.

Get an MGT-325 Topic 4 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-325 Topic 4 instructions, your section's rubric and the change and objections your case describes. We write a custom example to those criteria, with objections kept in their original wording, sorted into flaw, cost, preference and misunderstanding, and a response matched to each, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 325 papers and BS in Business Management samples

MGT 325 Topic 4 questions, answered

How can an objection be about the message rather than the plan?

When people object to something the plan does not actually contain. If employees protest a pay cut that was never proposed, the objection is real but its target was created somewhere in the retelling. Those objections are the most precise evidence of message decay available, because each one points to a specific distortion, and correcting it usually dissolves the objection without any change to the plan.

Why do objections get softer as they move up?

Because relaying bad news upward carries a personal cost for each messenger, and most people reduce that cost by trimming the message. A supervisor turns anger into concern, a manager turns concern into some questions, and the sponsor hears that the rollout is going reasonably well. Collecting objections directly from the front line, in their original wording, is the only reliable correction.

Should every legitimate objection change the plan?

No. Objections exposing a practical flaw should, since the plan will fail on that point regardless of how it is communicated. Objections naming a genuine cost often cannot be removed, but they deserve acknowledgment and whatever mitigation is possible. Preferences deserve a hearing and a reason. Distinguishing the three, and stating which changed the plan, is what makes the audit credible to the people who raised them.

Where can I find a free MGT 325 Topic 4 sample paper?

The objection audit is complete on this page, from the four bins and the sample table to what each bin shows, the route upward and the recommendations. Tell us what employees have said about your change, and a free audit can be built from it.

What is the MUM effect in MGT 325 Topic 4?

The reluctance to pass unwelcome news upward, described by Rosen and Tesser. In the audit, objections such as a desk shortage became some logistics questions by the time they reached leadership.