| Course | MGT 465 Employee Relations |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Climate evidence review |
| Length | About 990 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 465 Topic 8
The Survey Says Kenosha, the Behavior Says Joliet: An Employee Relations Climate Review Weighing Grievances, Turnover and Absence Against an Engagement Score
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-465: Employee Relations
Topic 8 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
The Survey Says Kenosha, the Behavior Says Joliet: An Employee Relations Climate Review Weighing Grievances, Turnover and Absence Against an Engagement Score
The Question
Lakeview Distribution's leadership believes employee relations are better at its non-union Kenosha warehouse than at its union warehouse in Joliet. The belief rests on the annual engagement survey, which rated Kenosha 78 percent favorable and Joliet 64 percent. This review asks whether the survey tells the whole story by setting four behavioral indicators beside it for each site. All figures are illustrative.
Behavioral indicators record what employees do, not what they say on a survey. Where the two disagree, the disagreement itself is informative.
The Evidence
Table 1
Behavioral Indicators and Survey Results by Site
| Indicator | Joliet (240 selectors, union) | Kenosha (180 selectors, non-union) |
|---|---|---|
| Grievances or formal complaints filed | 31 grievances | 4 complaints |
| Resolved at early steps | 23 of 31 settled at steps one and two | Not tracked |
| Annual turnover | 19%, about 46 leavers | 41%, 74 leavers |
| Leavers within 90 days of hire | Not tracked separately; about 9 | 45 of 74 |
| Unplanned absence, share of scheduled hours | 3.1% | 5.8% |
| Written warnings issued | 22 | 40, of which 18 by one supervisor |
| Engagement survey, percent favorable | 64% | 78% |
| Survey response rate | 81% | 52% |
Table 1 sets the indicators side by side for last year.
The indicators were gathered from records each site already keeps: the grievance log at Joliet, the HR complaint file at Kenosha, payroll records for turnover and absence and the discipline database. No new data collection was needed.
Reading the Behavioral Indicators
On every behavioral indicator, Joliet looks healthier. Its turnover is less than half Kenosha's. Its unplanned absence is lower. Most of its grievances are settled at the first two steps, which suggests problems are being raised and resolved close to where they arise.
Kenosha's numbers point the other way. Four in ten selectors left last year, and 45 of the 74 left within ninety days of being hired, which suggests something goes wrong early in employment. Unplanned absence is nearly double Joliet's. And one supervisor issued 18 of the site's 40 written warnings, a concentration that suggests a problem with that supervisor's practices rather than with the selectors.
The low number of complaints at Kenosha, four against Joliet's 31 grievances, could be read as a sign of contentment. The other indicators suggest a different reading.
Early turnover deserves particular attention. When most leavers go within the first ninety days, the problem usually lies in hiring, onboarding or the first supervisor a new employee meets, rather than in pay or long-term career prospects. That narrows where Kenosha's management should look first.
Exit and Voice
Hirschman (1970) argued that people dissatisfied with an organization have two main responses: exit, leaving, or voice, trying to change things from within. Which they choose depends partly on whether voice is available and trusted. Where no channel for voice is trusted, dissatisfied people leave rather than complain.
Read this way, the two sites' numbers fit together. Joliet has a trusted voice channel, the grievance procedure, and its selectors use it: 31 grievances, most resolved early, and relatively low turnover. Kenosha has no comparable channel. Its selectors raise few formal complaints, and they leave in large numbers, often quickly. Freeman and Medoff (1984) found that unions tend to lower quit rates partly by giving workers a voice option, and research on non-union settings has found that employees who have more opportunities to voice concerns are more likely to stay (Spencer, 1986). Kenosha's few complaints are more likely a sign of missing voice than of satisfaction.
Why the Survey Disagrees
The survey reverses the picture, and two features of it explain much of the difference. First, only 52 percent of Kenosha selectors responded, compared with 81 percent at Joliet. With turnover at 41 percent and most leavers gone within ninety days, many of the least satisfied Kenosha employees were no longer there to answer, and those who remained and chose to respond may be the most settled. Second, the survey measures attitudes at a point in time; it cannot capture the experience of the 74 people who left during the year.
That does not make the survey wrong. Kenosha's long-service selectors may well be more engaged than Joliet's. But leadership should not treat a 78 percent score from half the workforce as evidence that relations at Kenosha are better overall.
A useful check would be to compare the survey responses of Kenosha's longest-serving selectors with those of employees hired in the past year. If newer employees are much less favorable, the overall score is being carried by the people who stayed.
What Leadership Should Do
Four actions follow. First, investigate the early turnover at Kenosha through exit interviews with leavers in their first ninety days, conducted by someone outside the site's management. Second, review the practices of the supervisor who issued 18 written warnings, and check whether that supervisor's crews account for a disproportionate share of early leavers. Third, create a trusted channel for raising concerns at Kenosha, such as a regular meeting between selectors and the site manager with a written record of issues and responses, or a confidential reporting line monitored by regional HR. Fourth, report the survey with its response rate and alongside the behavioral indicators in future, so that a high score from a small share of employees is not mistaken for a healthy climate.
The broader lesson is that no single measure tells leadership how employees feel. A climate review is most reliable when it combines what people say with what they do, and when the gaps between them are treated as evidence rather than noise.
Leadership should also be cautious about the opposite conclusion. The evidence does not show that unionization is the answer at Kenosha; it shows that Kenosha's employees lack a trusted way to raise problems. That gap can be closed in several ways, and management has an interest in closing it whether or not employees ever choose a union.
References
Freeman, R. B., & Medoff, J. L. (1984). What do unions do? Basic Books.
Hirschman, A. O. (1970). Exit, voice, and loyalty: Responses to decline in firms, organizations, and states. Harvard University Press.
Spencer, D. G. (1986). Employee voice and employee retention. Academy of Management Journal, 29(3), 488-502. https://doi.org/10.2307/256220
What the MGT 465 Topic 8 instructions ask for
The Topic 8 instructions for MGT-465 ask students to assess the employee relations climate using evidence. Relying on a single engagement score, or reading few complaints as a sign of contentment, can mislead leadership badly. The assignment rewards a review that sets behavioral indicators such as grievances, turnover, early turnover, absence and discipline beside survey results, explains where they disagree and accounts for features of the survey such as its response rate. Students should draw on theory that explains why silence may signal dissatisfaction, identify concentrations such as one supervisor's discipline record and recommend actions that create trusted channels for voice.
How the MGT-465 Topic 8 example is put together
The review opens with leadership's belief and the survey behind it. Table 1 sets eight indicators side by side for the two sites. A section reads the behavioral indicators, noting Kenosha's early turnover and one supervisor's share of warnings. The exit and voice section applies Hirschman, with support from research on unions, voice and retention. A section explains why the survey disagrees, focusing on Kenosha's 52 percent response rate and the experience of those who left. Four actions follow, including exit interviews, a review of one supervisor's practices and a trusted channel for concerns. The review also cautions against reading the evidence as a case for or against unionization.
MGT 465 Topic 8 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Instructors grading the climate review reward evidence drawn from what employees do as well as what they say. Strong reviews set indicators side by side, explain where they conflict and account for survey limitations such as low response rates. Credit goes to applying exit and voice theory to explain why fewer complaints can accompany worse relations. The rubric values spotting concentrations, such as one supervisor's disproportionate discipline, and recommending specific actions. The highest band changes how the organization will report climate in future. Reviews that accept a survey score at face value usually land in the lower bands. A clear statement of what the evidence does not show also strengthens the review.
Common MGT 465 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Trusting the survey over the building costs climate reviews the most. A paper concluding that Kenosha is healthier because more respondents answered favorably has measured willingness to answer, and its response rate shows who stayed silent. Counting grievances as a sign of conflict, without asking how many were settled early, penalizes the site with a working channel. Turnover reported as one annual figure hides the early quits that point to onboarding and supervision. Papers citing Freeman and Medoff as proof that unions improve every workplace overstate an argument about voice and quits, and markers familiar with the literature will notice. Discipline totals left unsplit by supervisor conceal where the problem sits. Recommendations urging management to prevent or encourage unionization stray outside a climate review and into conduct the NLRA regulates.
Get an MGT-465 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-465 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric for it and whatever workforce data or case the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with indicators defined and given denominators, sites compared on behavior, the survey tested for who is missing, the pattern read through the voice literature and neutral recommendations made, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 465 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 465 Topic 1: Employment Relationship Analysis
- MGT 465 Topic 2: Grievance Step Record Analysis
- MGT 465 Topic 3: Progressive Discipline File Review
- MGT 465 Topic 4: Concerted Activity Analysis
- MGT 465 Topic 5: Informal Resolution Dq Post
- MGT 465 Topic 6: Workplace Investigation Report
- MGT 465 Topic 7: Bargaining Preparation Brief
- MGT 460 Topic 8: Freeze-tested Workforce Plan
- MGT 455 Topic 8: Throughput Improvement Recommendation
- BUS 317 Topic 8: Funding Request Memo
- MGT 440 Topic 8: Project Closure Report
MGT 465 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why are grievance counts not simply bad news?
Because a grievance is also evidence that employees trust the channel enough to use it. A site with many grievances settled early may have a functioning relationship, while a site with almost none may have people who see no point in complaining. The share resolved at the first steps, and how quickly, says more about the climate than the raw count does.
What did Hirschman argue about exit and voice?
Albert Hirschman argued that people dissatisfied with an organization respond either by leaving or by speaking up to change it, and that the availability of voice affects how many choose exit. Richard Freeman and James Medoff later applied the idea to unions, arguing that collective voice tends to reduce quits. The example uses both to interpret the gap between complaints and departures.
Can the review recommend for or against a union?
A climate review is not the place for it. Whether to seek representation is the employees' decision, and employer conduct around that decision is regulated by the NLRA. The example recommends practices management controls, an independent complaint channel and supervisor-level reporting, and treats representation only as context for interpreting the data. None of this is legal advice.
Where can I find a free MGT 465 Topic 8 sample paper?
The two-site climate review is here in full, with the indicators table, the behavioral reading, exit and voice, why the survey disagrees and the four actions. Tell us what evidence your organization has and a free review can be built from it.
Why might few complaints signal trouble in MGT 465 Topic 8?
Where employees have no trusted channel to raise concerns, they tend to leave rather than complain. Kenosha's four complaints sit beside 41 percent turnover, most of it in the first ninety days.