| Course | MKT 607 Marketing Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Environmental and competitor scan |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MKT 607 Topic 2
Sources, Magnitudes and the Competitors That Matter: An Environmental and Competitor Scan for a Fresh Dog Food Subscription in the Southwest
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MKT-607: Marketing Management
Topic 2 Environmental and Competitor Scan
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Sources, Magnitudes and the Competitors That Matter: An Environmental and Competitor Scan for a Fresh Dog Food Subscription in the Southwest
The Firm and the Market Bounded
Copperfield Kitchen, a composite company, cooks fresh dog food for roughly forty thousand subscriber households across Arizona, New Mexico and Nevada, and through about 60 independent pet stores in the same states. The scan is bounded to fresh and gently cooked dog food bought by households in those three states, because that is where Copperfield can deliver within two days and where its customers compare it with alternatives. National trends are used where they reach this market, with their source and size stated.
Macro Forces, Each With a Source and a Magnitude
Household spending on pets is rising, but more slowly than it appears. In the federal Consumer Expenditure Surveys, average annual spending on pets per household rose from 681 dollars in 2019 to 880 dollars in 2024, about 29 percent (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025a). Prices climbed too: the price index for pet food and treats increased about 23 percent between the 2019 and 2024 annual averages, and the index for pet services including veterinary care about 36 percent (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025b). Much of the spending growth is therefore price, not volume, and the real gain in what households buy for their pets is in the single digits. Second, veterinary costs are rising faster than food costs, which squeezes the budget left for premium food in households under financial pressure. Third, the number of households continues to grow slowly, about 135.8 million consumer units in 2024 against 134.6 million in 2023. A market described simply as growing would hide the fact that Copperfield's growth must come mostly from taking share, not from a rising tide.
Table 1
Pet Spending and Prices, United States, Annual Averages
| Indicator | 2019 | 2024 | Change | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average household spending on pets | 681 dollars | 880 dollars | +29% | Consumer Expenditure Surveys |
| Price index, pet food and treats | 155.0 | 190.8 | +23% | Consumer price index |
| Price index, pet services including veterinary | 253.7 | 343.9 | +36% | Consumer price index |
The Competitors That Matter
The competitor set is chosen by asking which offers Copperfield's customers actually consider when they buy, using its cancellation survey and the alternatives new subscribers name. Five groups qualify. Two national fresh dog food subscriptions, both shipping frozen meals from out of state, are the closest substitutes. A refrigerated fresh roll sold in supermarkets is the cheaper fresh alternative. Premium dry foods sold in pet stores are what most new subscribers were feeding before. And a regional pet store chain's own frozen raw line competes for the same specialty-store shelf. Two groups were excluded with reasons: economy kibble, because almost no Copperfield customer names it as an alternative, and home cooking, because the few who cite it leave for reasons of cost and control that Copperfield cannot address.
Competitors by Observable Behavior
Each competitor is described from what it does, not what it claims, using Copperfield's quarterly audit of competitors' websites, store shelves and advertising. The national subscriptions price a medium dog at about 4 to 6 dollars a day, offer steep first-box discounts and advertise heavily online; one has begun selling in a national pet chain. The supermarket roll costs roughly 2 dollars daily to feed a medium dog, with no portioning and occasional promotional discounts. Premium dry foods sit at about 1.80 to 2.50 dollars a day and are moving into fresh toppers sold beside them. The regional chain's frozen raw line is priced between dry and fresh and is placed at checkout.
Competitive Intensity
Rivalry for subscribers is intense and conducted largely through acquisition discounts, which raise every subscription firm's cost to win a customer. Buyer power is moderate: switching is easy, but customers who have settled a dog on a diet are reluctant to change it. The threat of substitutes is strong from both directions, cheaper fresh rolls below and premium dry food with toppers beside. Entry is relatively easy for brands using co-packers, though building cold-chain delivery is not. Porter (2008) argued that the strongest forces determine an industry's profitability, and here rivalry through discounts and substitution from cheaper fresh options are the two that will press on Copperfield's margins.
What the Scan Cannot Yet Show
The federal figures are national, and the scan's market is three states. No public source reports fresh dog food sales by state, so the size of Copperfield's actual market must be estimated from its own data and from the competitors' visible activity, and that estimate carries more uncertainty than the national trends. The competitor audit describes prices and placements but cannot see each rival's retention or acquisition cost, which matter most for judging how long their discounting can continue. And the cancellation survey reflects only customers who left, not those who never tried Copperfield. The next step in the research should be a short survey of premium dry food buyers in the three states, asking what would make them consider fresh food and at what daily price.
Implications
Three implications follow, each tied to evidence above. Because real market growth is small, Copperfield's plan must specify whose customers it intends to win, most plausibly premium dry food households. Because the national subscriptions are expanding into stores, Copperfield's retail presence should be defended with products that carry its portioning advantage onto the shelf. And because rivals compete on first-box discounts, Copperfield should compete on retention, where its two-day regional delivery and fresh rather than frozen meals give it a measurable edge, instead of matching discounts it cannot afford.
Conclusion
Sized properly, the pet market's growth is mostly price, so Copperfield must take share. The competitors that matter, chosen from what customers actually consider, include cheaper and more convenient substitutes as well as direct rivals. The scan points Copperfield toward premium dry food households, toward defending its store shelf and toward competing on retention rather than on acquisition discounts.
References
Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 86(1), 78-93.
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2025a). Consumer expenditure surveys: Average annual expenditures on pets and number of consumer units, 2019-2024 [Data set]. https://www.bls.gov/cex/
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2025b). Consumer price index: Pet food and treats, pets and pet products, and pet services including veterinary, annual averages 2019-2024 [Data set]. https://www.bls.gov/cpi/
MKT 607 Topic 2 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 2 assignment in MKT-607 asks MBA students to scan a firm's environment and competitors. Strong scans bound the market so the analysis has a scope, work macro forces one at a time with a source and a magnitude for each, and identify the competitors that matter with the reasoning for who was included and who was left out. Students should describe competitors by observable behavior such as pricing, placement and recent moves, assess competitive intensity, state what the evidence cannot yet show and end with implications tied to specific findings. Excluded competitors should be named with the reason for leaving them out.
How this MKT 607 Topic 2 example is built
The finished example cites as it goes. Each external factor carries the source that established it, whether a regulatory filing, an industry report, a trade publication or a company disclosure, and the example distinguishes what a source can support from what it merely suggests. Factors are not merely listed but sized: a demographic shift is stated with its magnitude and timing, since a trend without a number cannot be weighed against anything. Competitors are analyzed by what they actually do rather than by reputation, with pricing, positioning and recent moves each evidenced. The scan then converts to implications, because a list of forces with no consequence for this firm is an environment report rather than an analysis.
MKT 607 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward sources and magnitudes rather than impressions. An Excellent paper tables federal spending and price data to show how much growth is price, citing the Consumer Expenditure Surveys and the consumer price index. Credit goes to a competitor set built from cancellation and signup surveys, with exclusions explained. The rubric values competitors described from a quarterly audit of websites and shelves and intensity assessed with Porter's forces. Strong papers name the gaps in the evidence and the research that would fill them. Top marks go to three implications, each tied to a finding above it.
MKT 607 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Scans built from general impressions are the standard failure, and the drawer line names the requirement directly: sources rather than summaries. A second weakness is factors listed with a direction and no magnitude, since a market described as growing tells a reader nothing about whether to invest. Papers lose marks for a competitor set assembled without justification, because omitting a substitute or including an irrelevant firm changes every conclusion afterward. Describing competitors by their marketing claims rather than their observable behavior reports what they say about themselves. A scan that ends without implications leaves the firm holding an environment report and no decision. Scans that treat every listed force as equally important give a reader no way to prioritize a response, and prioritizing is the whole point of running one.
Get an MKT-607 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the MKT-607 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the firm and market your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each factor sourced and sized, the competitor set justified, behavior used over reputation and the scan converted into implications, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MKT 607 papers and MBA samples
- MKT 607 Topic 1: Value Proposition Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 3: Buyer Decision Process Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 4: Secondary Research Appraisal
- MKT 607 Topic 5: Segmentation and Positioning Plan
- MKT 607 Topic 6: Product and Life Cycle Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 7: Pricing Strategy Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 8: Channel and Promotion Plan
- MGT 660 Topic 2: Weighted External Analysis
- MGT 655 Topic 2: Forecast Error Analysis
- ACC 502 Topic 2: Accounting Cycle Problem Set
- MGT 641 Topic 2: Scrum Event Purpose Audit
MKT 607 Topic 2 questions, answered
What counts as a usable source for a market scan?
Anything a reader could check and evaluate. Regulatory filings, published industry reports, trade press, government statistics and company disclosures all qualify, with different reliability. A company's own claims are evidence of what it says rather than of what is true. What does not qualify is an unattributed assertion about market conditions, however plausible, since nobody can weigh it.
How do I decide which competitors to include?
By who your customers would actually turn to instead of you, which is often wider than the obvious set. Direct competitors selling the same thing matter, and so do substitutes solving the same problem differently, and sometimes doing nothing is the real alternative. State your reasoning, because a competitor set assembled by convention rather than by customer behavior will produce a misleading analysis.
How specific should a trend be?
Specific enough to weigh against a cost. A market growing by a stated percentage over a stated period supports an investment argument; a market described as growing does not. Where you cannot find a figure, say so and describe what evidence you do have, which is far better than implying precision that no source in your paper actually supplies.
Where can I find a free MKT 607 Topic 2 sample paper?
The scan is printed here in full: the market bounded, macro forces with sources, the competitors that matter, observable behavior, competitive intensity, what the scan cannot show, implications and the conclusion. Outline your firm's market and a scan with sources and magnitudes follows at no cost.
Why does pet spending growth overstate demand in MKT 607 Topic 2?
Household pet spending rose about 29 percent from 2019 to 2024, but pet food prices rose about 23 percent. Most of the increase was price, so real growth was small.