| Course | MGT 660 Strategic Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Weighted external analysis |
| Length | About 1,020 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 660 Topic 2
Buyers, Substitutes and Rivals Explain Most of It: A Weighted External Analysis of Regional Industrial Supply for Ridgeline Supply
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-660: Strategic Management
Topic 2 Weighted External Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Buyers, Substitutes and Rivals Explain Most of It: A Weighted External Analysis of Regional Industrial Supply for Ridgeline Supply
Drawing the Industry Boundary
Where the industry boundary is drawn decides what the analysis finds. Drawn broadly, as all distribution of maintenance, repair and operating supplies in the United States, the industry is dominated by national distributors and online marketplaces, and Ridgeline Supply, a composite company selling about 148 million dollars a year, looks like a minor participant. Drawn narrowly, as the supply of maintenance products and services to food, dairy and pharmaceutical plants within about 250 miles of Ridgeline's six upper Midwest branches, it is a regional market in which Ridgeline is one of a handful of serious suppliers. This analysis uses the narrow boundary, because that is where Ridgeline's customers buy and where its competitors meet it, but notes where the broad market's forces reach in.
The Five Forces, With Evidence
Porter (2008) argued that industry profitability is shaped by five forces: the bargaining power of buyers, the power of suppliers, substitutes, potential entrants and the rivalry among firms already competing. Each is assessed here with evidence, following the method of industry analysis Porter (1980) set out. Buyer power is strong: Ridgeline's twenty largest customers account for about 41 percent of its revenue, and their purchasing departments rebid hundreds of standard part numbers to several distributors every year. The threat of substitutes is strong for commodity items: online marketplaces and manufacturers' direct sites now take a growing share of orders for gloves, filters and standard fasteners, items that need no advice. Rivalry is strong and price-based on commodity lines, where two national distributors and three regionals compete. Supplier power is moderate: makers of branded bearings and power transmission products set authorization terms and minimum purchases, but most commodity items have many sources. The threat of entry is low for the parts of the business that require certification, documentation and on-site technicians, and high for commodity catalog sales, which anyone with a website can enter.
Table 1
The Five Forces in Regional Industrial Supply
| Force | Strength | Main evidence | Effect on profitability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer power | Strong | Top 20 customers about 41 percent of revenue; annual rebids | Presses margins on standard items |
| Substitutes | Strong on commodity items | Marketplaces and direct sites take no-advice orders | Caps prices on catalog items |
| Rivalry | Strong on commodity items | Two nationals and three regionals price-match | Price competition |
| Supplier power | Moderate | Brand authorization terms; many commodity sources | Limited |
| Threat of entry | Low for certified work, high for catalog | Certification and technicians versus a website | Protects certified work only |
Which Forces Explain the Industry's Profitability
Three forces explain most of what is happening to profitability. Buyer power and substitutes together explain why margins on catalog items have fallen: concentrated buyers can compare prices instantly against alternatives that require no relationship. Rivalry intensifies the effect, because the nationals use catalog pricing to win accounts. Supplier power and entry matter less to the overall picture, but entry matters greatly to one segment: certified and service-intensive work, where entry barriers protect margins. The industry is therefore two industries under one name, and an analysis that averaged the forces across both would miss that.
Macro Factors, Filtered
A scan of political, economic, social, technological, environmental and legal factors produces a long list, and most items have no plausible route to Ridgeline's results. Three do. Food safety regulation raises the documentation food plants must keep: the Food Safety Modernization Act (FDA Food Safety Modernization Act, 2011) shifted federal oversight toward preventing contamination, and plants must show that equipment in contact with food meets sanitary standards, which increases demand for certified assemblies with traceable records. A shortage of experienced maintenance technicians makes plants more willing to outsource storeroom management and preventive maintenance. Tariffs on steel and aluminum raise the cost of stainless fittings and hose ends, squeezing margins where Ridgeline cannot pass them on. Factors such as demographic change and consumer trends were set aside because their route to Ridgeline's results runs through so many intermediate steps that they cannot be acted on.
What the Broad Boundary Would Have Shown
Had the analysis used the national boundary, its conclusions would have been different and worse for Ridgeline. Nationally, scale economies in purchasing, distribution centers and software are the dominant entry barrier, and they favor the largest firms; a regional distributor appears structurally disadvantaged on every force. That framing is what led Ridgeline to imitate the nationals, since it seemed the only way to survive in their industry. The narrow boundary shows that Ridgeline competes in a different arena for its most profitable work, one where proximity, certification and technicians on call matter more than scale. Both views are accurate for the markets they describe. The choice between them is the first strategic judgment in the analysis, and it should be made explicitly rather than inherited from industry reports written for the national market. The analysis keeps the broad view in sight for commodity items, where national forces genuinely reach Ridgeline's customers.
From Forces to Consequences
The significant forces become consequences of two kinds, those Ridgeline can influence and those it must adapt to. It can influence buyer power in the certified segment by documenting its work in ways that switching would forfeit, such as maintaining a plant's equipment records. It can raise entry barriers further by certifying more technicians. It cannot influence marketplace substitution for commodity items or the nationals' pricing, and must adapt by refusing to compete on price where it cannot win. The regulatory and labor factors are tailwinds for the certified and service segments that Ridgeline can choose to ride.
Conclusion
With the industry drawn around the plants Ridgeline actually serves, buyer power, substitutes and rivalry explain most of the pressure on profitability, and they bear almost entirely on commodity sales. Entry barriers protect certified and service-intensive work, and food safety rules and a technician shortage push demand toward it. The external analysis points Ridgeline away from the segment it has been investing in and toward the one it has neglected. The internal analysis that follows tests whether Ridgeline has the capabilities to act on that finding.
References
FDA Food Safety Modernization Act, Pub. L. No. 111-353, 124 Stat. 3885 (2011).
Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors. Free Press.
Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 86(1), 78-93.
Reading the GCU MGT 660 Topic 2 instructions
The Topic 2 assignment in MGT-660 asks MBA students to analyze a firm's external environment and weight what they find. Strong analyses define the industry boundary first, since the same firm looks different under a narrow or broad definition, and work each competitive force with evidence of how strongly it operates. Students should rank the forces and say which explain most of the profitability observed, filter the macro factors to those with a plausible route to the firm, and convert the significant ones into consequences, separating what the firm can influence from what it must adapt to. Assessments should rest on evidence rather than impressions.
Inside the MGT 660 Topic 2 example
The finished example ranks rather than enumerates. Each force is assessed for how strongly it operates in this industry specifically, with evidence, since supplier power that is decisive in one sector is irrelevant in another. The example is explicit that two or three forces usually explain most of an industry's profitability and the rest are background. Macro factors receive the same treatment and are filtered for relevance, because a scan listing every political and technological trend has not analyzed anything. Each force is then converted into a consequence for the firm, and the example names which the firm can influence and which it can only prepare for. Every assessment carries the evidence that produced it.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 660 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty reward forces weighed rather than listed. An Excellent paper defines a narrow regional boundary and explains what the national boundary would have shown instead. Credit goes to a table rating each force with evidence and its effect on profitability, using Porter's five forces. The rubric values seeing two industries under one name, commodity and certified work, with different forces in each. Strong papers discard macro factors with no route to results and cite the food safety statute that raises demand for documentation. Top marks go to consequences divided into what the firm can influence and what it must adapt to. Faculty also value evidence drawn from the firm's own customer concentration and order data rather than general impressions of the industry.
MGT 660 Topic 2 help before you submit
Listing forces without weighting them is the failure the drawer line names, since an analysis where everything matters equally directs no action. A second weakness is a macro scan that reports every category regardless of relevance, which demonstrates coverage rather than judgment and buries the two factors that matter. Papers lose marks for an industry boundary left undefined, because the same firm looks differently positioned depending on whether the industry is drawn narrowly or broadly. Assessments made without evidence read as impressions. Analyses that stop at the assessment, with no consequence drawn for the firm, leave a description of an industry where a strategic input was wanted. Frameworks reproduced with no industry attached demonstrate recall of a diagram.
Get an MGT-660 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-660 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the firm and industry your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the boundary argued, every force weighted with evidence, macro factors filtered and the governing forces converted into consequences, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MGT 660 papers and MBA samples
- MGT 660 Topic 1: Strategy Definition Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 3: Internal Capability Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 4: Business Level Positioning
- MGT 660 Topic 5: Corporate Scope Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 6: MGT-660 Topic 6: Sample Paper, in Real Form
- MGT 660 Topic 7: Structure and Governance Fit
- MGT 660 Topic 8: Complete Strategic Plan
- MGT 655 Topic 2: Forecast Error Analysis
- MGT 641 Topic 2: Scrum Event Purpose Audit
- MGT 640 Topic 2: Competing Business Case Appraisal
- ACC 502 Topic 2: Accounting Cycle Problem Set
MGT 660 Topic 2 questions, answered
How do I weight the forces rather than list them?
Assess each for how strongly it operates in this industry and say why, then rank them. Supplier power matters enormously where one input dominates cost and there are few sources, and hardly at all where inputs are commodities. Evidence such as concentration, switching costs and margin data supports the assessment, and the ranking is what turns a framework into an analysis.
Where should I draw the industry boundary?
Around the set of firms genuinely competing for the same customer need, and argue the choice. Draw it too narrowly and every firm looks dominant; too broadly and none does. Substitutes are the usual test: if customers would readily switch to something outside your boundary, the boundary is wrong. State your definition, since every conclusion in the paper depends on it.
How many macro factors should I include?
Only those with a plausible route to affecting this firm's profitability, which is usually two or three rather than a complete sweep of the categories. A scan that dutifully reports something under every heading has prioritized coverage over judgment and buries the factors that matter. Discarding categories explicitly, with a reason, is stronger than filling them.
Where can I find a free MGT 660 Topic 2 sample paper?
The external analysis is printed here in full: the industry boundary, the five forces with evidence, which forces explain profitability, macro factors filtered, what the broad boundary would show, consequences and the conclusion. Describe the industry your firm competes in and a weighted analysis follows at no cost.
Why draw the industry narrowly in MGT 660 Topic 2?
Ridgeline's customers buy within a region, and its competitors meet it there. The national view makes scale decisive and hides the certified segment where Ridgeline has an advantage.