| Course | MGT 660 Strategic Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Strategy definition analysis |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 660 Topic 1
A Strategy Rules Things Out: Testing Ridgeline Supply's Mission Against What It Forbids and Reconstructing the Strategy Its Investments Reveal
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-660: Strategic Management
Topic 1 Strategy Definition Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Strategy Rules Things Out: Testing Ridgeline Supply's Mission Against What It Forbids and Reconstructing the Strategy Its Investments Reveal
What Makes Something a Strategy
A statement is a strategy only if it rules options out. A firm that could pursue any customer, any product line and any way of competing under its stated direction has an aspiration, not a strategy. Porter (1996) argued that the essence of strategy is choosing what not to do, because activities that serve one position conflict with those that serve another, and a firm that tries to do everything ends up doing nothing distinctively. This analysis applies that test to the statements of Ridgeline Supply, a composite upper Midwest supplier of industrial maintenance goods with six branches, 214 employees and about 148 million dollars of annual revenue, and then reconstructs the strategy the company is actually following.
Common Statements, Tested
Ridgeline's annual plan contains four statements that its managers describe as strategy. Each can be tested by asking what it forbids.
Table 1
Ridgeline's Statements Tested by What They Forbid
| Statement | Type | What it rules out | Passes the test? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grow revenue 5 percent a year | Goal | Nothing about how to grow | No |
| Be the customer's first call | Aspiration | Nothing; every distributor wants this | No |
| Serve every MRO need in our region | Scope claim | Nothing within the region | No |
| Win on service, not price | Partial position | Price matching on commodity items | Partly |
Why Most Fail
A revenue target is a goal: it says what the company wants, not how it will choose among the ways to get there. A desire to be the customer's first call is shared by every competitor and therefore distinguishes nothing. The claim to serve every need in the region explicitly refuses to exclude anything. Only the fourth statement, winning on service rather than price, would forbid something if taken seriously: matching national distributors' prices on commodity catalog items. As the following sections show, the company has not taken it seriously.
Mission, Vision and Values
In principle the three serve different purposes. A mission states what the organization exists to do, a vision describes the future it is aiming at, and values describe how its people are expected to behave. In practice firms use the terms loosely, and Ridgeline's documents mix them: its mission statement contains a value, its vision contains a revenue target, and its values list includes a goal. The distinctions matter less than the question each should answer. Ridgeline's mission reads: to keep our customers' operations running with the right part, the right advice and the right service, every time. Asked what that mission would forbid, managers could name nothing. It would permit selling gloves on price to a hospital two states away, building a marketplace, or opening a seventh branch in any direction.
The Strategy the Investments Reveal
Mintzberg and Waters (1985) distinguished intended strategy from realized strategy, which can emerge from a pattern of decisions whether or not anyone planned it. Ridgeline's realized strategy is visible in where it has put money and people over five years. It spent about 3.1 million dollars on an online ordering portal designed to resemble the national distributors' sites. It introduced a price-match guarantee on its top 2,000 catalog items. It installed vending and storeroom programs in two large customer plants on terms copied from a national competitor. Meanwhile its sanitary hose and fitting assembly shop, which builds certified assemblies for food and dairy plants and earns gross margins near 38 percent against the company average below 25, received one added technician. The pattern describes a strategy of imitating the national distributors at regional scale, which is the position Ridgeline is least able to win.
Why Imitation Is the Weakest Position Here
Imitating the national distributors puts Ridgeline in a contest decided by scale. The nationals buy in volumes Ridgeline cannot approach, spread the cost of their websites and distribution centers over far larger sales, and can price commodity items below Ridgeline's cost. Each dollar Ridgeline spends to look like them buys a smaller version of their advantage. The investment pattern carries a further, unbudgeted cost: managers' attention went to the portal and the price-match program while the assembly shop, the one activity rivals cannot easily copy, ran at capacity with a growing backlog. The point Porter (1996) made, that operational effectiveness is not strategy, applies directly: doing what rivals do, only somewhat better, does not create a position.
A Statement That Would Constrain
Collis and Rukstad (2008) suggest a strategy statement should name an objective, a scope and an advantage. A statement that would rule things out might read: by 2029, earn a 30 percent gross margin by supplying certified fluid-handling assemblies and documented maintenance programs to food, dairy and pharmaceutical plants within 250 miles, where same-day certified service matters more than unit price. That statement forbids several current practices: price matching on commodity items, pursuing accounts outside the region and further investment in a portal designed to compete with national sites. It also directs investment toward the assembly shop and the technical staff who support it.
What Would Change Next Year
Adopting the constraining statement would change specific decisions in the next budget. The planned second phase of the portal, about 1.2 million dollars, would be canceled or reduced to order tracking for existing customers. The price-match guarantee would be withdrawn on items outside the plants Ridgeline serves with documented programs. The assembly shop would receive a second certified technician and a larger crimping station, and the sales team's commission plan would pay more for certified assemblies and maintenance programs than for catalog volume. Each change follows from what the statement forbids or requires, which is the evidence that it is a strategy and not a slogan.
Conclusion
Of Ridgeline's four strategic statements, three rule out nothing and the fourth is contradicted by the company's own investments. Its mission forbids nothing. Its realized strategy, read from five years of spending, is imitation of larger rivals. A statement naming an objective, a scope and an advantage would constrain the company's choices, which is the purpose a strategy serves.
References
Collis, D. J., & Rukstad, M. G. (2008). Can you say what your strategy is? Harvard Business Review, 86(4), 82-90.
Mintzberg, H., & Waters, J. A. (1985). Of strategies, deliberate and emergent. Strategic Management Journal, 6(3), 257-272. https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.4250060306
Porter, M. E. (1996). What is strategy? Harvard Business Review, 74(6), 61-78.
MGT 660 Topic 1 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 1 in MGT-660 asks MBA students to analyze what a strategy is and test a real or composite firm against that definition. Strong analyses define strategy by what it rules out, apply that test to several common statements and show why goals, aspirations and broad scope claims fail it. Students should distinguish mission, vision and values by what each governs while admitting firms use the terms loosely, and ask what the firm's stated mission would actually forbid. The analysis should then reconstruct the strategy the firm is following from where it has invested money and people, and propose a statement that would constrain its choices.
How the MGT-660 Topic 1 example is put together
The finished example insists that a strategy excludes something. A goal to grow, to lead the market or to delight customers commits a firm to nothing, since no competitor is pursuing the opposite, and the example uses that test throughout. Real strategies are shown to contain refusals of some kind: markets not entered, customers not served, capabilities deliberately left unbuilt. Mission and values are then examined for whether they constrain any actual decision, and the paper concludes that one particular statement does not. One firm's strategy is reconstructed from its behavior rather than from its documents, since what a company invests in is more reliable evidence than what it publishes.
Reading the MGT 660 Topic 1 rubric
Faculty reward a definition applied as a test rather than recited. An Excellent paper tables four of the firm's statements with what each forbids, following Porter's argument that strategy means choosing what not to do. Credit goes to reading the realized strategy from five years of investment, drawing on the distinction Mintzberg and Waters made between intended and realized strategy. The rubric values a proposed statement with objective, scope and advantage, as Collis and Rukstad recommend. Strong papers explain why imitating larger rivals is the weakest position. Top marks go to naming the budget decisions the new statement would change in the following year. Faculty also value a paper that treats the company's own documents as evidence to be tested rather than as answers.
MGT 660 Topic 1 help before you submit
Reproducing a company's mission statement approvingly is the weak version of this paper, since the assignment asks what strategy is and a published statement is evidence rather than an answer. A second failure is treating goals as strategy, which is the confusion the topic exists to remove and which shows as a paper listing what a firm wants to achieve with nothing about how it will choose. Papers lose marks for describing mission, vision and values as though the distinctions were rigid, when firms use the terms interchangeably. Analyzing a firm entirely from its own documents ignores the behavioral evidence available. Concluding that a firm needs a clearer strategy, with no account of what it currently is, ends without an analysis.
Get an MGT-660 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-660 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, with the company your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with strategy defined by exclusion, the firm's statements tested for what they forbid and the actual strategy reconstructed from behavior, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MGT 660 papers and MBA samples
- MGT 660 Topic 2: Weighted External Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 3: Internal Capability Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 4: Business Level Positioning
- MGT 660 Topic 5: Corporate Scope Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 6: MGT-660 Topic 6: Sample Paper, in Real Form
- MGT 660 Topic 7: Structure and Governance Fit
- MGT 660 Topic 8: Complete Strategic Plan
- MGT 655 Topic 1: Operations Strategy Analysis
- MGT 641 Topic 1: Agile Manifesto Assumptions Paper
- MGT 640 Topic 1: Strategic Initiative Triage Memo
- ACC 502 Topic 1: Accounting Equation Write-up
MGT 660 Topic 1 questions, answered
What separates a strategy from a goal?
A strategy contains choices that rule things out. Growing revenue by a stated amount is a goal; deciding to pursue it by serving mid market customers through direct sales while declining enterprise contracts is a strategy, because it commits the firm to forgoing something. Applying that test to any statement in front of you sorts the two quickly and reliably.
Does a mission statement matter?
Only where it constrains decisions, which many do not. A useful test is to ask what the mission would forbid the company from doing. If the answer is nothing, the statement is a description of good intentions rather than a strategic constraint, and saying so with evidence is a legitimate finding rather than a criticism the paper should avoid.
How do I find a firm's real strategy?
From its behavior. Where it has invested capital, which markets it has entered and left, what it has acquired, who it has hired and what it has publicly declined all reveal choices. Those are harder to obtain than a strategy document and considerably more reliable, since a firm's spending reflects what it actually decided rather than what it wanted to be seen deciding.
Where can I find a free MGT 660 Topic 1 sample paper?
The strategy definition analysis is shown here complete: what makes a strategy, four statements tested, why most fail, mission, vision and values, the strategy the investments reveal, why imitation is weakest, a constraining statement, next year's changes and the conclusion. Name the firm your course assigns and a version for it follows free.
Why is a revenue target not a strategy in MGT 660 Topic 1?
It states what the firm wants without ruling out any way of getting there. A strategy forbids options, such as price matching on commodity items.