MGT 640 Topic 2 competing business case appraisal example

Fundamentals of Project Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 640 Topic 2 sample paper appraises three competing business cases at a composite insurer that has 6.0 million dollars to spend and proposals totaling 7.4 million. It belongs to GCU MGT 640, Fundamentals of Project Management, listed as MGT-640 in the Grand Canyon University MBA with an Emphasis in Project Management. The investment committee fixed its weights before any proposal was scored: strategic contribution and financial return at 30 percent each, delivery risk and demand on scarce staff at 20 percent each. Net present value at a 10 percent hurdle rate is then set beside the scores. Each case is reduced to the one assumption carrying most of its value, and the agent portal, resting on an unsupported premium rise, is the one declined.

CourseMGT 640 Fundamentals of Project Management
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeBusiness case appraisal
LengthAbout 960 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 640 Topic 2

1

Six Million Dollars, Three Cases, Two Approvals: Appraising Competing Business Cases at an Insurer by Agreed Weights, Net Present Value and the One Assumption Each Rests On

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-640: Fundamentals of Project Management

Topic 2 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the constraint first, because it is why the appraisal must choose, and names the three tests applied to every case. The insurer and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Six Million Dollars, Three Cases, Two Approvals: Appraising Competing Business Cases at an Insurer by Agreed Weights, Net Present Value and the One Assumption Each Rests On

The Constraint

Larkspur Mutual's investment committee has $6.0 million available for new initiatives this year. Three proposals have reached it: a refresh of the pricing models for personal auto insurance, a fraud analytics system for claims and an online portal for independent agents. Together they would cost $7.4 million, so at most two can proceed. This appraisal compares the three on the same terms and recommends which two. All figures are illustrative.

Weights Agreed Before Scoring

The weights were fixed by the committee ahead of any scoring, which removed the chance to adjust them afterward in favor of a favorite proposal. Strategic contribution and financial return each carry 30 percent. Delivery risk and demand on scarce staff, chiefly the data engineers and the one architect, each carry 20 percent. Each criterion is scored from 1 to 5, with 5 best. Agreeing criteria and weights in advance is a basic safeguard in portfolio selection (Project Management Institute, 2017).

Table 1

Weighted Scores Against Criteria Agreed in Advance

CriterionWeightPricing refreshFraud analyticsAgent portal
Strategic contribution30%444
Financial return30%443
Delivery risk (5 = lowest)20%433
Demand on scarce staff (5 = lowest)20%33.54
Weighted score3.83.73.5

Net Present Value

Table 2

Net Present Value at the Insurer's Hurdle Rate

ProposalCostNet present value at 10%Main source of benefit
Fraud analytics$2.6M$3.1MLower claim payments on fraudulent claims
Pricing refresh$3.0M$2.6MBetter loss ratio through more accurate pricing
Agent portal$1.8M$1.2MHigher agent-written premium

Each proposal's cash flows were discounted at the insurer's 10 percent hurdle rate over five years. Net present value converts future benefits and costs into today's dollars, so that projects with different timing can be compared directly (Brealey et al., 2020).

The two methods agree that the agent portal ranks third. They disagree on the order of the other two, but both pass comfortably on either measure, and their combined cost of $5.6 million fits within the $6.0 million available.

Timing and Risk in the Figures

Net present value is sensitive to when benefits arrive. Fraud analytics begins saving money within about six months of delivery, as soon as flagged claims are reviewed, which is why its value is highest despite a lower cost. The pricing refresh takes longer, because new rates must be filed and approved in each state and then apply only as policies renew, so its benefits build over two to three years. The portal's benefits would also build slowly, as agents adopt it, and depend entirely on the premium assumption examined below.

The figures also leave out the hours each project would draw from the insurer's scarcest specialists, since those costs are not charged to projects. Topic 6 examines that constraint directly; for this appraisal, it is reflected only in the scoring weight for demand on scarce staff.

The Assumption Each Case Rests On

Scores and net present values depend on the assumptions behind them. The appraisal therefore reduces each case to the single assumption carrying most of its value and asks how well it is supported.

Pricing refresh. Most of the value comes from an expected improvement of about one point in the personal auto loss ratio. That assumption is supported by the actuarial team's back-testing of the new models on the past three years of policies, which showed a similar improvement. The evidence is reasonably strong.

Fraud analytics. Most of the value comes from detecting fraudulent claims the current process misses. The vendor's estimate of savings came from other insurers, but the claims unit also ran a three-month pilot on a sample of claims, which flagged cases later confirmed as fraud at a rate consistent with the estimate. The evidence is moderate.

Agent portal. Most of the value comes from an assumed 5 percent rise in premium written by independent agents. No baseline supports it. The insurer does not currently measure how much agents' writing depends on the ease of quoting, and the proposal offers no pilot, survey or comparison with other carriers. If the rise were 2 percent instead of 5, the portal's net present value would fall below zero. Business cases for projects are frequently built on optimistic benefit estimates that are never tested, which is a major reason so many projects disappoint (Flyvbjerg, 2014).

Testing the key assumption is more useful than adjusting every figure in a case. A business case may contain dozens of estimates, but usually one or two carry most of its value, and if those are sound, smaller errors elsewhere rarely change the decision.

The committee should ask each sponsor to name that assumption in one sentence.

What this page is doingEach case is reduced to its most important assumption and the evidence behind it, which is where the appraisal finds the real difference between the proposals.
3

Recommendation

The appraisal recommends approving the pricing refresh and fraud analytics, at a combined cost of $5.6 million. Both score well on the agreed criteria, both have strong net present values and both rest on assumptions with evidence behind them. The agent portal should not be funded this year. Its sponsor should be invited to establish a baseline of agent-written premium and run a small pilot with a few agencies, so that next year's committee can judge the 5 percent assumption on evidence rather than hope.

The remaining $0.4 million should be held as a contingency for the two approved projects rather than spent on a partial version of the portal, since a portal funded at a quarter of its cost would deliver none of its benefits.

The committee should also record its reasoning in the minutes, including why the portal was declined and what evidence would bring it back. A decision recorded with its basis is easier to revisit fairly next year than one remembered as a preference.

References

Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Flyvbjerg, B. (2014). What you should know about megaprojects and why: An overview. Project Management Journal, 45(2), 6-19. https://doi.org/10.1002/pmj.21409

Project Management Institute. (2017). The standard for portfolio management (4th ed.). Project Management Institute.

What the MGT 640 Topic 2 instructions ask for

The Topic 2 brief in MGT-640 centers on project selection under a budget that cannot fund every request. Students are asked to compare proposals using both a scoring model and financial measures, and to show how those methods support a choice between them. A strong response explains how the selection criteria were set and by whom, applies them consistently, and goes further than reporting numbers by asking what each figure depends on. Graduate papers should use net present value or a comparable discounted measure, test the ranking against reasonable changes in weights or assumptions, and recommend which proposals proceed. The brief also expects a reasoned explanation for the proposal that is not funded, since selection is as much about saying no as about approval.

How this MGT 640 Topic 2 example is built

The finished appraisal starts from the constraint: 6.0 million dollars is available and the three proposals total 7.4 million, all figures labeled illustrative, so only two can proceed. Weights agreed by the investment committee before any scoring give 30 percent each to strategic contribution and financial return and 20 percent each to delivery risk and demand on scarce staff. On that basis the pricing refresh scores 3.8 of 5, fraud analytics 3.7 and the agent portal 3.5. Net present values at the insurer's 10 percent hurdle rate follow: 3.1 million for fraud analytics, 2.6 million for pricing and 1.2 million for the portal. Each case is then reduced to the assumption carrying most of its value. The portal's rests on a 5 percent rise in agent-written premium that no baseline supports, and the appraisal recommends the other two.

Reading the MGT 640 Topic 2 rubric

Faculty marking the appraisal reward a process that a skeptical committee could audit. An Excellent paper fixes its criteria and weights before scoring and says so, gives evidence beside every score and treats net present value as an output of stated assumptions rather than a verdict. The rubric gives credit for isolating the assumption each case rests on, since that is where approval decisions actually turn. Sensitivity matters too: a paper that tests whether the ranking survives other plausible weights shows the committee how firm its choice is. Strong recommendations name the funded proposals and explain the declined one in terms its sponsor could act on. Citations to capital budgeting and portfolio selection research support the method, and figures are labeled as illustrative.

MGT 640 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks

Selection papers weaken fastest when the criteria arrive after the proposals, because scoring then works backward from a preferred answer. An appraisal presenting weighted scores without saying when the weights were set leaves that suspicion open. Scores given as bare numbers, with no evidence beside them, cannot be challenged or defended, which makes the table decorative. Treating NPV as settled, rather than as the product of one or two assumptions, misses the graduate question of what the figure depends on. Papers that ignore a sensitivity result showing the ranking flips under plausible weights have hidden the most important fact from the committee. Recommendations naming the winners and saying nothing about the declined proposal skip the defense a graduate recommendation requires, and a sponsor will ask exactly why the portal lost.

Get an MGT-640 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-640 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric for it and the proposals, figures or case the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with weights fixed before scoring, cases summarized in one form, each NPV tested at its key assumption, the ranking checked for sensitivity and the rejected proposal defended, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 640 papers and MBA samples

MGT 640 Topic 2 questions, answered

How much NPV detail does a graduate appraisal need?

Enough to show what the figure depends on, rather than a full discounted cash flow model. The example states the hurdle rate, the horizon and the main cash flows, labels them illustrative, then identifies the assumption the value leans on and shows how the NPV moves if it fails. Committees tend to trust an appraisal that exposes its weakest assumption more than one that hides it.

Why defend the proposal that was not funded?

Because its sponsor will ask, and because the reasons shape what comes back next cycle. A decline that says only that other proposals scored higher gives the sponsor nothing to fix. The example states that the portal's case rests on an unmeasured premium rise and has no benefit owner, which tells the distribution team exactly what a stronger resubmission would need.

Are weighted scoring models reliable?

They are useful for making criteria explicit and comparable, and weak when treated as precise. Scores are judgments, weights are choices, and close totals such as 3.8 against 3.7 rarely mean one proposal is truly better. The example uses the model to structure the discussion, tests how the ranking responds to different weights, and lets the committee see where the decision is fragile.

Where can I find a free MGT 640 Topic 2 sample paper?

You can read the entire business case appraisal here, including the weights, the scores, the net present values and the assumption behind each proposal. Share the proposals your class case gives you and we can prepare a free appraisal built on them.

Why is the agent portal declined in MGT 640 Topic 2?

Its value depends on a 5 percent rise in agent-written premium with no baseline behind it. It also has the lowest score at 3.5 of 5 and the smallest net present value at 1.2 million dollars.