MGT 605 Topic 2 effectiveness theory survey example

Leadership and Organizations Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 605 Topic 2 sample paper surveys trait, behavioral and contingency theories of leadership effectiveness as a field correcting itself. It belongs to GCU MGT 605, Leadership and Organizations, listed as MGT-605 in Grand Canyon University's MBA. Stogdill's 1948 review found inconsistent traits, while later meta-analysis by Judge and colleagues put the five-factor model's multiple correlation near .48. The anomaly of one person succeeding in one setting and failing in another moved research to behavior, where consideration and initiating structure recur, then to Fiedler's and House's contingency accounts. What all three leave unexplained, the follower, closes the survey. The survey closes on what remains unexplained.

CourseMGT 605 Leadership and Organizations
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeEffectiveness theory survey
LengthAbout 1,040 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 605 Topic 2

1

A Field Correcting Itself: How Trait, Behavioral and Contingency Theories Each Answered the Question the Last Could Not

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-605: Leadership and Organizations

Topic 2 Effectiveness Theory Survey

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the thread that connects the three approaches. The grocery illustrations are a composite; the studies cited are real.
2

A Field Correcting Itself: How Trait, Behavioral and Contingency Theories Each Answered the Question the Last Could Not

One Question, Three Answers

Every approach surveyed here tries to answer one question: what separates effective leaders from ineffective ones? The trait approach looked for the answer in who leaders are, the behavioral approach in what they do, and contingency approaches in how what they do fits the situation. The three are best read not as a list but as a sequence, in which each approach arose because the previous one failed to explain something specific. This survey follows that sequence, reports what each approach actually found, names the anomaly that forced the next one, and closes with what all three leave unexplained.

Trait Approaches: What They Found

Early research searched for the personal qualities of leaders: intelligence, dominance, self-confidence, energy. The search found associations, but they were weak and inconsistent. Stogdill (1948), reviewing more than a hundred studies, concluded that no fixed set of personal qualities makes someone a leader, and that the traits that mattered varied with the situation. For decades, that review was read as the end of trait research. The reading was too strong. A later meta-analysis of studies using the five-factor model of personality put the combined relationship between the five traits and leadership at a multiple correlation of about .48, and extraversion related to leadership more consistently than any other trait (Judge et al., 2002). Traits do matter; dismissing the trait literature entirely misreports it.

The Anomaly That Forced a Change

What trait research could not explain was variation in the same person's effectiveness. A store manager who turns around a struggling grocery store can fail when moved to the chain's busiest flagship, with the same personality. If effectiveness were a fixed property of the person, that should not happen. Stogdill's finding that relevant traits varied by situation was the first sign of the problem. Researchers also needed something they could train, and traits are hard to change. Both pressures turned attention from who leaders are to what they do.

Behavioral Approaches: Recurring Dimensions

The Ohio State and Michigan studies of the 1950s observed and surveyed what leaders did, and two dimensions recurred across studies. Consideration describes behavior showing concern and respect for followers, such as listening, being approachable and acting on suggestions. Initiating structure describes behavior defining roles and tasks, such as setting goals, scheduling work and clarifying expectations. A meta-analysis found both related to leadership outcomes (Judge et al., 2004), consideration more strongly with followers' satisfaction and initiating structure with group performance. In grocery terms, a manager who listens to staff and one who builds clear schedules are both doing something effective, but different things.

Contingency Approaches: Naming What Varies

Behavioral research had its own limit: the same behavior worked in some settings and not others, and researchers could not find one best style. Contingency approaches answered by naming what in the situation changes the effect of a leader's behavior. Fiedler (1967) proposed that effectiveness turns on the fit between the leader's orientation, toward tasks or relationships, and how favorable the situation is, measured by leader-member relations, how structured the task is and the leader's formal power. House (1996) proposed in path-goal theory that leaders are effective when they supply what the situation lacks: directive behavior when tasks are ambiguous, supportive behavior when tasks are stressful or tedious. The variables that matter are therefore the structure of the task, the followers' experience and the leader's power. A night stocking crew with routine tasks needs little direction and some support; a new online-order team with unclear procedures needs direction first.

Table 1

Three Approaches as a Sequence

ApproachExplains effectiveness byKey findingWhat it could not explain
TraitWho the leader isTraits matter modestly; five-factor model R about .48Same person effective in one setting, not another
BehavioralWhat the leader doesConsideration and initiating structure both matterSame behavior effective in one setting, not another
ContingencyFit between behavior and situationTask structure, followers and power change the effectWhy followers attribute leadership; how leaders shape situations

What the Sequence Means for a Manager

Read as a sequence, the three approaches give practical advice that none gives alone. From trait research, selection matters: the chain should look for the qualities that predict leadership modestly but consistently, such as extraversion and conscientiousness, when choosing store managers, while not expecting personality to settle the question. From behavioral research, training matters: both consideration and initiating structure can be learned, and a manager weak in one can practice it. From contingency research, placement and adaptation matter. A manager who excels at giving direction should be sent to stores with new or unclear procedures, such as those launching online ordering, while a manager whose strength is support suits stores with experienced teams doing demanding but routine work. The chain's current practice of rotating managers among stores without regard to fit ignores the most recent of the three lessons.

Where the Evidence Is Weakest

The approaches also differ in how well their evidence has held. The behavioral dimensions have the strongest support across many studies. Trait associations are real but modest. Contingency theories are the most persuasive in principle and the hardest to confirm, because their predictions depend on measuring situations that are difficult to pin down.

What Remains Unexplained

All three approaches treat the leader as the cause and followers and situations as conditions. None fully explains why followers grant someone the status of leader in the first place, or how leaders change the situation rather than only fitting it. Contingency theories have also proved hard to test, because measuring the situation precisely enough to predict the right behavior is difficult. Later work on followers' perceptions and on leaders who transform their organizations takes up those questions, which is where the next topic begins.

Conclusion

Trait research found real but modest associations and could not explain why the same person succeeds in one setting and fails in another. Behavioral research found two recurring dimensions that matter but could not find one best style. Contingency theories named the situational variables, task structure, followers and power, that decide which behavior works. Each step answered the previous approach's failure, and together they leave the follower's role as the open question.

References

Fiedler, F. E. (1967). A theory of leadership effectiveness. McGraw-Hill.

House, R. J. (1996). Path-goal theory of leadership: Lessons, legacy, and a reformulated theory. Leadership Quarterly, 7(3), 323-352. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1048-9843(96)90024-7

Judge, T. A., Bono, J. E., Ilies, R., & Gerhardt, M. W. (2002). Personality and leadership: A qualitative and quantitative review. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87(4), 765-780. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.87.4.765

Judge, T. A., Piccolo, R. F., & Ilies, R. (2004). The forgotten ones? The validity of consideration and initiating structure in leadership research. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89(1), 36-51. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.89.1.36

Stogdill, R. M. (1948). Personal factors associated with leadership: A survey of the literature. Journal of Psychology, 25(1), 35-71. https://doi.org/10.1080/00223980.1948.9917362

Reading the GCU MGT 605 Topic 2 instructions

The Topic 2 assignment in MGT-605 asks MBA students to survey theories of leadership effectiveness. Strong surveys state the question all approaches share, report what trait research actually found, name the anomaly that forced each change of approach and give the recurring behavioral dimensions. Students should say what contingency theories claim varies, draw on research literature rather than popular writing and identify what remains unexplained. The paper should also say how strong the evidence is for each approach. Practical lessons for selection, training and placement show the survey's use. Each transition should name the specific failure that prompted the next approach.

How this MGT 605 Topic 2 example is built

The finished example tells the story as an argument rather than a chronology. Trait approaches came first and are given their due, since some characteristics do correlate with emerging as a leader, but the example names what they could not explain: why the same person succeeded in one organization and failed in another. Behavioral accounts answered that by looking at what leaders do, and the example reports the two dimensions that repeatedly emerge from that work. Contingency approaches then answered what behavior alone left open, that no single style worked everywhere. Each transition is argued from evidence. The example closes by asking what contingency accounts still cannot explain, which keeps the field open rather than finished.

Reading the MGT 605 Topic 2 rubric

Faculty reward transitions that explain why each approach arose. An Excellent paper reports Stogdill's review without dismissing traits, citing the later meta-analysis by Judge and colleagues. Credit goes to consideration and initiating structure with the evidence from Judge, Piccolo and Ilies. The rubric values Fiedler and House on task structure, followers and power. Strong papers table the three approaches with what each could not explain. Top marks go to practical lessons for selection, training and placement. Papers that report trait research accurately, neither dismissing it nor overstating it, show the literature read rather than summarized from a textbook. Credit also goes to naming the follower as the open question.

MGT 605 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks

Three approaches described in sequence with nothing connecting them is the standard version, and it earns what a summary earns. The transitions are the content: each approach exists because the previous one failed on something specific, and a paper that cannot say what will not have understood any of them. A second failure is dismissing trait research entirely, which overcorrects and misreports a literature that does find consistent associations. Papers lose marks for describing contingency approaches without naming what varies, since the whole claim is that effectiveness depends on something and the paper has to say what. Sources drawn from popular management writing rather than from the research literature are penalized here. Ending with a conclusion that leadership is complex adds nothing the reader did not bring.

Get an MGT-605 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-605 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with any approaches your section requires covered. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each approach presented as a correction of the last, the anomalies named and the remaining gap identified, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More MGT 605 papers and MBA samples

MGT 605 Topic 2 questions, answered

Did trait research simply fail?

No, and saying so is more accurate than the usual dismissal. Later work using better methods does find consistent associations between certain characteristics and emerging as a leader, and some with being effective. What traits could not do was explain variation across situations, which is a different failure from being wrong. Reporting that precisely demonstrates you read the literature rather than a summary of it.

What actually varies in a contingency account?

Depends on the model, and naming it is the point. Some make the maturity or capability of the followers decisive, some the structure of the task, some how much positional power the leader holds. Each identifies a different feature of the situation as the thing that determines which behavior works. A paper that says effectiveness depends on the situation without saying which feature has not applied the model.

How many approaches should I cover?

Whatever the rubric names, usually the three the drawer line lists, covered properly rather than five covered thinly. The marks are in the connections between them, so depth on three beats breadth on more. If your section names specific models within each approach, cover those, and cite the original work rather than a textbook chapter summarizing it.

Where can I find a free MGT 605 Topic 2 sample paper?

The theory survey is printed here in full: one question, trait findings, the anomaly, behavioral dimensions, contingency variables, practical lessons, the weakest evidence, what remains unexplained and the conclusion. Share your course's survey prompt and a connected survey follows at no cost.

Did trait research fail in MGT 605 Topic 2?

Not entirely. Early reviews found traits inconsistent, but later meta-analysis found the five-factor model related to leadership with a multiple correlation near .48. Traits matter modestly.