MGT 605 Topic 3 transformational and servant models example

Leadership and Organizations Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 605 Topic 3 sample paper sets out transformational and servant leadership by their components and tests both in a grocery distribution center at holiday peak. It forms part of GCU MGT 605, Leadership and Organizations, catalog code MGT-605, in Grand Canyon University's MBA. Bass's four components and the servant model's focus on followers' growth are tabled with the conditions each needs. Prescribed work, spans of forty and temporary staff defeat both at peak. Judge and Piccolo find contingent reward nearly as strong as transformational behavior, and Hoch and colleagues find servant leadership adds variance, so the chain fits each model to its own setting.

CourseMGT 605 Leadership and Organizations
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeTransformational and servant models
LengthAbout 1,040 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 605 Topic 3

1

Influence Without Rank, and What It Needs: Transformational and Servant Leadership Tested Against a Grocery Distribution Center at Peak Season

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-605: Leadership and Organizations

Topic 3 Transformational and Servant Models

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states what the two models share and the setting that tests them. The grocery chain and its distribution center are a composite; the sources are real.
2

Influence Without Rank, and What It Needs: Transformational and Servant Leadership Tested Against a Grocery Distribution Center at Peak Season

What the Two Models Share

Transformational and servant leadership are often presented as the enlightened alternatives to command and control. What they share is narrower and more useful: each describes influence exercised through something other than positional authority. A transformational leader moves people through a vision and through attention to their development; a servant leader moves them by putting their growth and wellbeing first. This paper sets out each model by its components, states what each requires from the organization, applies both to a setting where they would struggle, a composite grocery chain's distribution center at holiday peak, and reports what the research supports.

Transformational Leadership by Its Components

Bass (1985) set out four components of transformational leadership. The first, idealized influence, is behavior that earns followers' trust and identification, such as acting on stated values when it is costly. Inspirational motivation is articulating a compelling direction and the reasons for it. Intellectual stimulation is challenging followers to question assumptions and propose new approaches. The fourth, individualized consideration, means coaching each follower according to that person's own needs. Bass contrasted these with transactional leadership, in which a leader exchanges rewards for performance, and argued that transformational behavior adds to, rather than replaces, effective transactions.

Servant Leadership by Its Components

Greenleaf (1977) described a leader who serves first and judges success by whether the people served develop, becoming more capable and more independent. Eva et al. (2019) reviewed twenty years of studies and characterized servant leadership as other-oriented, marked by putting each follower's individual needs and interests first in one-to-one relationships and by an outward concern for the wider organization and community. Its content is therefore specific: putting followers' development ahead of the leader's own goals, attending to individuals rather than to the group as a mass, and stewardship of the organization's effect on others. Reduced to being kind to staff, the model loses everything that distinguishes it.

What Each Requires From the Organization

Neither model works everywhere. Transformational leadership requires a direction worth committing to and enough discretion for followers to act on intellectual stimulation; in a job where every step is prescribed, invitations to question assumptions have nowhere to go. It also requires trust, which takes time to build. Servant leadership requires time for one-on-one attention, a span of control small enough to allow it and employment stable enough for development to pay off. It also requires an organization that tolerates leaders putting followers' growth ahead of short-term output, at least some of the time.

Table 1

The Two Models and What They Need

ModelCore componentsOrganizational conditions required
TransformationalIdealized influence, inspirational motivation, intellectual stimulation, individualized considerationA credible direction, discretion to act, time to build trust
ServantPrioritizing followers' growth and needs, one-on-one attention, stewardshipSmall spans of control, stable employment, tolerance for slower short-term output

What Each Costs

The models also carry costs that admiring accounts omit. Transformational leadership concentrates followers' commitment on the leader, so a store whose team follows an inspiring manager can lose its direction when that manager is promoted or leaves. Its emphasis on a compelling vision can also crowd out dissent if followers come to identify too closely with the leader's account of the future. Servant leadership costs time, the scarcest resource a store manager has, and a leader who always puts followers' immediate needs first can avoid hard decisions, such as removing a poor performer whose work burdens the rest of the team. Neither cost is a reason to reject the model; each is a reason to name the conditions under which it is worth paying.

A Setting Where Both Struggle

The chain's distribution center during the six weeks before the winter holidays tests both models hard. Volume doubles. Half the night shift are temporary workers hired for the season, many staying only a few weeks. Each supervisor oversees about forty pickers whose work is measured in cases picked per hour against a fixed standard, and the warehouse system assigns every task. Transformational leadership struggles because there is little discretion to exercise: the work is fully specified, and intellectual stimulation has no outlet while the system directs each pick. A vision of the season's purpose can help, but the temporary workers' commitment is to a paycheck for a few weeks. Servant leadership struggles for a different reason: a supervisor with forty people and constant volume pressure cannot give one-on-one attention to each, and development offers little return to someone leaving in January. What works in that setting is mostly transactional: clear standards, fair and immediate recognition for meeting them, and visible help clearing problems that slow the line.

What the Research Finds

The evidence is more qualified than popular accounts suggest. Pooling many studies, Judge and Piccolo (2004) reported positive relationships between transformational leadership and followers' satisfaction, motivation and performance, but contingent reward, an exchange-based behavior, showed relationships almost as strong with several of those outcomes. That supports Bass's claim that the two work together and undercuts the claim that transformation replaces exchange. For servant leadership, Hoch et al. (2018) found that, unlike ethical and authentic leadership, it explained a meaningful share of variance in outcomes beyond transformational leadership. Eva et al. (2019) also note that much servant leadership research has relied on cross-sectional surveys, which limit what can be concluded about cause.

Which Model Suits the Chain

For the chain's stores, where teams are stable, managers have some discretion and the business is trying to change how it serves customers, transformational leadership combined with clear contingent rewards suits best. For the distribution center's permanent staff outside peak season, servant leadership is a realistic choice, since supervisors could then reduce their spans and invest in the employees who will stay. At peak, the chain should ask its supervisors for transactional clarity and practical support, and should not judge them by models the setting cannot accommodate.

Conclusion

Both models describe influence beyond positional authority, and each has specific components and conditions. A peak-season distribution center, with prescribed work, large spans and temporary staff, defeats both. The research supports transformational leadership working alongside contingent reward and suggests servant leadership adds something distinct, but neither is a universal recommendation.

References

Bass, B. M. (1985). Leadership and performance beyond expectations. Free Press.

Eva, N., Robin, M., Sendjaya, S., van Dierendonck, D., & Liden, R. C. (2019). Servant leadership: A systematic review and call for future research. Leadership Quarterly, 30(1), 111-132. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2018.07.004

Greenleaf, R. K. (1977). Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of legitimate power and greatness. Paulist Press.

Hoch, J. E., Bommer, W. H., Dulebohn, J. H., & Wu, D. (2018). Do ethical, authentic, and servant leadership explain variance above and beyond transformational leadership? A meta-analysis. Journal of Management, 44(2), 501-529. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206316665461

Judge, T. A., & Piccolo, R. F. (2004). Transformational and transactional leadership: A meta-analytic test of their relative validity. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89(5), 755-768. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.89.5.755

The MGT-605 Topic 3 assignment instructions

In Topic 3, MGT-605 asks MBA students to analyze transformational and servant leadership. Strong analyses state what the two share, set out each by its components rather than its reputation and name the organizational conditions each requires. Students should apply both to a setting where they would struggle, report what research supports and does not and recommend which suits their own workplace. The paper should also name what each model costs the leader and the organization. Claims about outcomes should rest on meta-analytic evidence where it exists. The setting chosen should be one the writer knows, so the failure of each model can be described concretely.

How the MGT-605 Topic 3 example is put together

The finished example treats admiration as a hazard. Transformational leadership is described by its components and then examined for what it needs: a leader people already trust, a purpose capable of being shared, and enough stability that a vision has time to matter. Servant leadership is given the same treatment, and the example names its harder condition, that the organization must tolerate a leader who prioritizes the development of subordinates over immediate output. Both are then tested against a setting where they would fail, a turnaround with weeks of runway or a workforce that has been promised transformation twice before. Evidence appears throughout, and the example distinguishes what the research supports from what the concept promises.

Where the marks sit in the MGT 605 Topic 3 rubric

Faculty reward models conditioned before they are recommended. An Excellent paper gives Bass's four components and the servant model's content, citing Greenleaf and Eva and colleagues. Credit goes to a table of conditions and a peak-season distribution center where both struggle. The rubric values the meta-analysis by Judge and Piccolo on contingent reward and Hoch and colleagues on servant leadership's added variance. Strong papers name each model's costs. Top marks go to a recommendation fitted to each setting. Papers that explain why contingent reward performs almost as well as transformational behavior, and what that implies for the workplace, show the evidence read rather than admired.

MGT 605 Topic 3 help before you submit

Admiration substituted for analysis is the dominant weakness, and it produces a paper explaining why transformational leadership is superior with nothing said about what it costs or requires. A second failure is servant leadership described as being kind to staff, which drops the model's actual content about prioritizing growth and stewardship and reduces it to a disposition. Papers lose marks for omitting the conditions, since a model that only works in a stable, trusting organization is a much narrower recommendation than the paper usually implies. Claims about outcomes need evidence rather than assertion, and the literature is more qualified than popular accounts suggest. Concluding that a leader should use both, with no conditions attached, avoids the choice the topic asked for.

Get an MGT-605 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-605 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the organization or case your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each model given its conditions, both tested where they fail, the research separated from the promise and one chosen with reasons, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More MGT 605 papers and MBA samples

MGT 605 Topic 3 questions, answered

Is transformational leadership always the better model?

No, and papers assuming it lose the analytic mark. It requires trust that already exists, a purpose people can plausibly share and enough time for a vision to matter. In a crisis with weeks of runway, or where staff have heard transformational language before and watched nothing follow, it is actively counterproductive. The model has conditions, and naming them is the analysis.

What is servant leadership actually claiming?

That the leader's first obligation is the growth and capability of the people they lead, and that organizational results follow from it rather than the reverse. That is a substantive and demanding claim, not a synonym for being considerate. It also implies a cost the organization must accept, since developing somebody often means letting them do work more slowly than you could.

How do I evaluate a model rather than describe it?

Ask what it needs to be true, then find a setting where that thing is absent. Every leadership model carries assumptions about the followers, the timescale and the organization's tolerance. Naming the assumption and then constructing the case where it fails converts description into evaluation, and it is reliably the strongest section in papers on this topic.

Where can I find a free MGT 605 Topic 3 sample paper?

The model analysis is shown here complete: what the models share, transformational components, servant components, conditions, costs, a setting where both struggle, the research, which suits the chain and the conclusion. Describe your workplace and a fitted recommendation follows free.

Why do both models struggle at the distribution center in MGT 605 Topic 3?

Picking work is fully prescribed, leaving no room for intellectual stimulation, and supervisors with forty temporary workers cannot give one-on-one attention. Clear standards and fair recognition work better there.