| Course | HRM 640 Designing HR for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Fit analysis |
| Length | About 990 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM 640 Topic 3
Two Grids and Two Misfits: Testing Horizontal and Vertical Fit Among a Composite Hotel Group's HR Practices, and Why an Upgrade Commission and a Room Quota Fail Both
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
HRM-640: Designing HR for Competitive Advantage
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Two Grids and Two Misfits: Testing Horizontal and Vertical Fit Among a Composite Hotel Group's HR Practices, and Why an Upgrade Commission and a Room Quota Fail Both
Two Kinds of Fit
Topic 2 found that three of Mesa Lantern's practices resist imitation only as a set. This analysis tests that idea systematically. HR practices can fit in two ways. Horizontal fit asks whether practices reinforce one another, so that employees receive consistent signals. Vertical fit asks whether each practice encourages the role behaviors the competitive position requires. Research on HR systems has found that practices bundled so they reinforce one another are associated with better performance than the same practices adopted piecemeal (MacDuffie, 1995), and that the effect of a practice can depend on whether it matches the firm's strategy (Delery & Doty, 1996). The analysis uses two grids, one for each kind of fit, and the argument comes from where they agree.
Grid One: Horizontal Fit
Table 1
Horizontal Fit Among Seven Practices
| Hiring for warmth | Cross-training | Internal promotion | Recovery allowance | Seniority scheduling | Upgrade commission | 16-room standard | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hiring for warmth | + | + | + | + | - | 0 | |
| Cross-training | + | + | + | 0 | - | 0 | |
| Internal promotion | + | + | + | + | 0 | 0 | |
| Recovery allowance | + | + | + | + | - | 0 | |
| Seniority scheduling | + | 0 | + | + | 0 | 0 | |
| Upgrade commission | - | - | 0 | - | 0 | 0 | |
| 16-room standard | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Table 1 marks each pair among seven practices as reinforcing (+), neutral (0) or conflicting (-). The five parity practices from Topic 2, such as pay and benefits, are left out because they are neutral toward almost everything.
Five practices form a reinforcing core. People hired for warmth, trained across the front desk and restaurant, and promoted from within become the managers who trust agents to spend the recovery allowance, and seniority scheduling keeps those same agents on the shifts where repeat guests arrive. Each practice makes the others work better.
The upgrade commission conflicts with three of them. It rewards agents for pitching paid upgrades at check-in, which sits poorly with hiring for warmth and with the recovery allowance, since an agent paid to sell to a guest is less likely to spend money putting that guest's problem right. It also discourages cross-training in practice: agents covering the restaurant earn no commission, so covering it costs them money. Rewarding one behavior while hoping for another is a familiar failure in organizations (Kerr, 1975).
The reinforcing pairs are not equally strong. Internal promotion and the recovery allowance reinforce each other most, because supervisors who once worked the desk know what a guest problem looks like at eleven at night and are slow to second-guess an agent who spent forty dollars to fix it. Cross-training reinforces the allowance more weakly: an agent who has worked the restaurant knows what a meal credit costs and when it will feel generous to a guest. Seniority scheduling reinforces hiring for warmth only indirectly, by keeping the warmest long-serving agents in front of the guests who notice warmth most.
Grid Two: Vertical Fit
Table 2
Vertical Fit Between Practices and Role Behaviors
| Practice | Agent recalls preferences | Housekeeper records changes | Manager tolerates recovery spending |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hiring for warmth | + | + | 0 |
| Cross-training | + | 0 | 0 |
| Internal promotion | + | + | + |
| Recovery allowance | 0 | 0 | + |
| Seniority scheduling | + | 0 | 0 |
| Upgrade commission | - | 0 | - |
| 16-room standard | 0 | - | 0 |
Table 2 maps each practice against the three role behaviors derived in Topic 1: a front desk agent recalling a returning guest's preferences, a housekeeper recording what a guest changed and a manager tolerating small unapproved recovery spending.
The reinforcing core supports all three behaviors between them. The two practices outside it fail. The upgrade commission works against recognition: repeat guests came to be known, not to be sold to, and an agent paid by the upgrade has a reason to treat every arrival as a sales opportunity. It also makes managers more cautious about recovery spending, since the property's front desk is now measured partly on revenue per arrival.
The 16-room standard works against the housekeeper behavior. Recording what a guest changed, a different pillow, the thermostat set low, the desk moved to the window, takes a few minutes per room. At 16 rooms per shift, with stayover and checkout cleaning to finish, housekeepers report that there is no time to do it, and the preference software shows notes logged for fewer than one room in ten.
What the Two Grids Agree On
The grids reach the same conclusion from different directions. The upgrade commission fails horizontally, by conflicting with the core, and vertically, by discouraging recognition and recovery. The room standard is neutral toward the other practices but fails vertically, by leaving no time for the behavior the position most depends on in the room. Neither practice is unreasonable in itself; both are common in the industry. They are misfits here because this group competes on something most hotels do not.
The grids also show what is not a problem. Pay, benefits and the health plan, left out of both grids as parity practices, do not conflict with anything. Changing them would not strengthen the position, and holding them at market is sufficient. The analysis therefore narrows the redesign to two practices that need replacing and five that need protecting, rather than a wholesale overhaul.
Implications for the Redesign
The analysis supports three changes for the redesign stage. First, replace the upgrade commission with a team-level bonus tied to repeat-stay rates among business travelers, which rewards the behavior the position needs and does not penalize covering the restaurant. Second, reduce the housekeeping standard for rooms occupied by repeat guests, for example to count a returning guest's room as one and a quarter rooms, giving time to record changes. Third, treat the five-practice core as a single system, so that no practice in it is changed without considering the effect on the others. The cost of these changes, and how they will be measured, is taken up in later topics.
References
Delery, J. E., & Doty, D. H. (1996). Modes of theorizing in strategic human resource management: Tests of universalistic, contingency, and configurational performance predictions. Academy of Management Journal, 39(4), 802-835. https://doi.org/10.2307/256713
Kerr, S. (1975). On the folly of rewarding A, while hoping for B. Academy of Management Journal, 18(4), 769-783. https://doi.org/10.2307/255378
MacDuffie, J. P. (1995). Human resource bundles and manufacturing performance: Organizational logic and flexible production systems in the world auto industry. ILR Review, 48(2), 197-221. https://doi.org/10.1177/001979399504800201
HRM 640 Topic 3 instructions, in plain terms
HRM-640 Topic 3 asks students to evaluate how well HR practices fit with one another and with the organization's strategy. Listing practices and calling them aligned is not enough. The prompt rewards an analysis that tests horizontal fit, whether practices reinforce or undercut each other, and vertical fit, whether each practice encourages the behaviors the strategy requires. Students should present both tests in a form a reader can check, explain the patterns that matter rather than every cell, identify practices that fail and say why they fail in this organization even if they are common elsewhere, then draw clear implications for redesign.
How this HRM 640 Topic 3 example is built
The analysis opens by defining the two kinds of fit, supported by research on HR bundles and strategic contingency. Table 1 marks reinforcing, neutral and conflicting pairs among seven practices. The paper explains the reinforcing core and shows how the upgrade commission conflicts with three of its members, citing Kerr on rewarding one thing while hoping for another. Table 2 maps each practice to the three role behaviors from Topic 1. The upgrade commission and the room standard both fail, the latter because recording guest changes takes time the quota does not allow. A section shows where the grids agree, and three redesign implications close the paper.
Where the marks sit in the HRM 640 Topic 3 rubric
Faculty grading the fit analysis reward two distinct tests presented clearly. Strong papers mark every relationship but explain only those that matter, especially conflicts. Credit goes to linking each practice to the role behaviors the strategy needs, with reasons tied to the daily work of the employees involved. The rubric values recognizing that a practice can be common and sensible in general yet misfit a particular strategy. The highest band shows where the two tests agree and turns the findings into specific changes, such as replacing an individual commission with a team bonus. Analyses that assume every practice fits because each is individually good usually lose marks.
HRM 640 Topic 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Fit analyses are downgraded most for asserting harmony. Papers stating that the practices align with the strategy and support each other, with no pair examined, have described an intention rather than tested one. Checking only vertical fit misses the practices that serve the strategy individually and cancel each other out in combination, which is exactly where the upgrade commission sits. Matrices marked without reasons look thorough and cannot be checked. Misfits identified in principle but never traced to behavior, what an agent actually does at a crowded desk, leave the finding abstract. Citing MacDuffie as proof that any bundle works overstates a study of auto assembly plants and ignores its point about joining practices to the production system. Papers ending on a list of misfits without ranking them hand the next topic no starting point.
Get an HRM-640 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the HRM-640 Topic 3 instructions, your section's rubric and the organization or practice set the assignment uses. We write a custom example to those criteria, with both directions of fit defined, a pair-by-pair matrix, practices mapped to required behaviors, misfits traced to what people actually do and a ranked list for redesign, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HRM 640 papers and MBA samples
- HRM 640 Topic 1: Strategy and Role Behavior Paper
- HRM 640 Topic 2: Practice Imitability Audit
- HRM 640 Topic 4: Workforce Architecture Redesign
- HRM 640 Topic 5: Site Consistency Dq Post
- HRM 640 Topic 6: Implementation Gap Review
- HRM 640 Topic 7: Redesign Outcome Measure Plan
- HRM 640 Topic 8: Competing Proposal Executive Case
- LDR 670 Topic 3: Cross Border Negotiation Analysis
- HRM 635 Topic 3: Build Versus Buy Cost Case
- MGT 605 Topic 3: Transformational and Servant Models
- FIN 650 Topic 3: Beta and Required Return
HRM 640 Topic 3 questions, answered
What is the difference between horizontal and vertical fit?
Horizontal fit concerns the practices themselves: whether selection, training, rewards and promotion push employees in the same direction. Vertical fit concerns the link between the whole set and the strategy: whether the behaviors the practices encourage are the ones the business needs. A set can be internally consistent and still serve the wrong strategy, which is why a finished analysis tests both.
What are Delery and Doty's three perspectives?
John Delery and Harold Doty compared three views of strategic HR. The universalistic view holds that some practices work everywhere, the contingency view that practices must match strategy, and the configurational view that coherent patterns of practices matter more than any single one. Fit analyses lean on the latter two, and papers use the framework to say which view they are applying.
Is a conflicting pair always a problem?
Not always. Some tension is deliberate, such as pairing individual targets with a team bonus so neither dominates. The test is whether the conflict produces behavior the strategy cannot afford. The upgrade commission fails because it changes how agents treat the very guests the strategy depends on. A finished analysis explains why each conflict matters or why it can be tolerated.
Where can I find a free HRM 640 Topic 3 sample paper?
Both grids and the full argument for the hotel group are on this page, including the reinforcing core, the two misfits, where the grids agree and the redesign implications. Describe the practices you need to test, and a free analysis can be prepared on the same plan.
Why does the upgrade commission fail in HRM 640 Topic 3?
It pays agents to sell to repeat guests who came to be recognized, it makes managers more cautious about recovery spending and it discourages covering the restaurant, where nothing earns commission.