| Course | HRM 640 Designing HR for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Strategy and role behavior paper |
| Length | About 950 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM 640 Topic 1
Known on Arrival: The Competitive Position of a Fourteen-Hotel Group, What It Declines to Compete On and the Employee Behaviors That Position Requires
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
HRM-640: Designing HR for Competitive Advantage
Topic 1 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Known on Arrival: The Competitive Position of a Fourteen-Hotel Group, What It Declines to Compete On and the Employee Behaviors That Position Requires
The Position in One Sentence
Mesa Lantern Hotels, a composite group of fourteen independent-brand hotels across Arizona, New Mexico and Colorado, wins repeat business travelers by recognizing them: guests who return find that the hotel remembers who they are, what they prefer and what went wrong last time, without having to ask. Everything in this paper follows from that sentence, so it is worth testing before any discussion of people.
Evidence for the Position
The group's own figures support the claim. On illustrative figures from the past two years, repeat business travelers, defined as guests with three or more business stays in a year, fill about 40 percent of room nights. They pay average rates about 18 percent above nearby chain hotels in the same cities, and they book directly more often, so the group pays less in third-party commission on their stays. When surveyed, the most common reason they gave for returning was some version of being known: the room set up the way they like it, a front desk agent who greets them by name, a problem on a previous stay that was remembered and put right.
A position supported by premium rates and repeat behavior is real. A position supported only by a mission statement would not be worth building an HR system around.
The evidence also shows what the position is not. The group's leisure guests, who fill weekends and summer, pay rates close to the chains and return far less often. Recognition matters less to a family on a once-a-year trip than to a sales manager who spends forty nights a year on the road. The position is therefore specific to one segment, and HR choices should be judged by their effect on that segment's experience.
What the Group Does Not Compete On
Strategy requires choosing what not to do as well as what to do (Porter, 1996). Mesa Lantern does not compete on three things its rivals do better.
Price. Budget and midscale chains in each city charge less, and the group's cost structure, with older buildings and independent purchasing, cannot match them.
Scale. National chains offer hotels in hundreds of cities. A business traveler who needs one brand everywhere will not choose a fourteen-hotel group.
A points program. Chains with large loyalty programs reward frequent guests with free nights across their systems. Mesa Lantern has no points program, and building one would mean competing on the ground where the chains are strongest.
Naming these matters for HR design. A practice that would make sense for a price or scale competitor, such as minimizing staff per room or rotating staff across properties to cut costs, may undermine the position this group actually holds.
Role Behaviors the Position Requires
Table 1
Role Behaviors Derived From the Competitive Position
| Role | Behavior the position requires | Why it matters to the position |
|---|---|---|
| Front desk agent | Recalls a returning guest's preferences and history without being prompted | Recognition at arrival is the moment most repeat guests describe |
| Housekeeper | Records what a guest changed in the room, such as pillows, temperature or desk arrangement | Preferences captured in the room are what the front desk and the next stay draw on |
| Property manager or supervisor | Tolerates small unapproved spending by staff to put a guest's problem right | Recovery that waits for approval is recovery the guest no longer notices |
Schuler and Jackson (1987) argued that each competitive strategy asks different behavior of employees, and that HR practices should be chosen to encourage the behaviors the strategy needs. For a strategy built on recognition, three role behaviors stand out, each tied to a specific employee group.
These behaviors share a feature: they depend on knowledge that builds up over time in particular people. An agent who has checked in the same guest twenty times knows things no system holds. That is part of why the position is hard for a chain to copy, and it is also why HR practices that increase turnover or rotate staff are especially costly here. The resource-based view of strategic HRM treats such accumulated, firm-specific human capital as a potential source of lasting advantage (Wright & McMahan, 1992).
Current HR Practices
The group's current HR practices are listed below without judgment. The next topic tests each against the position and the behaviors above.
1. Pay set at the 75th percentile of the local hotel market for all hourly roles.
2. A low-deductible health plan for all employees working 30 or more hours.
3. A $500 signing bonus for new housekeepers.
4. A two-day guest service course for all new guest-contact staff.
5. Guest preference software linked to the reservation system.
6. A ten-year practice of filling supervisor roles internally where a candidate is ready.
7. A service recovery allowance of up to $150 per incident that agents may spend without approval.
8. Seniority-based shift scheduling, which keeps long-serving agents on the weekday shifts business travelers use.
9. Selective hiring for warmth, using a short behavioral interview.
10. Cross-training between front desk and food service.
11. A commission on room upgrades sold at check-in.
12. A housekeeping standard of 16 rooms per shift.
What Comes Next
The paper establishes the position, the bases on which the group declines to compete and the three behaviors the position requires. It deliberately does not yet say which practices help or hurt. That is the work of the following topics: testing which practices a rival could copy, whether they fit together and with the behaviors, and which employee groups each should cover. Starting from the business, rather than from a list of best practices, is what makes those later judgments possible.
References
Porter, M. E. (1996). What is strategy? Harvard Business Review, 74(6), 61-78.
Schuler, R. S., & Jackson, S. E. (1987). Linking competitive strategies with human resource management practices. Academy of Management Executive, 1(3), 207-219. https://doi.org/10.5465/ame.1987.4275740
Wright, P. M., & McMahan, G. C. (1992). Theoretical perspectives for strategic human resource management. Journal of Management, 18(2), 295-320. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639201800205
Reading the GCU HRM 640 Topic 1 instructions
HRM-640 begins with Topic 1, where students connect an organization's competitive strategy to the behavior it needs from employees. Papers that start from a list of best practices skip the step the course is built on. The prompt rewards a paper that states the competitive position precisely, supports it with evidence such as premium prices or repeat behavior, and names what the organization chooses not to compete on. Students should then derive specific role behaviors for named employee groups, explain why each matters to the position and list current HR practices without judging them yet, since later topics test those practices one by one.
Inside the HRM 640 Topic 1 example
The paper opens with the position in one sentence and then supports it with illustrative figures on repeat business travelers, their rates and their reasons for returning. A section names three bases the group declines, price, scale and a points program, and explains why each belongs to rivals with more hotels. Schuler and Jackson's argument links strategy to employee behavior, and Table 1 sets out three role behaviors for front desk agents, housekeepers and managers with the reason each matters. A paragraph ties the behaviors to accumulated, firm-specific knowledge. Twelve current practices close the paper, listed without judgment, and a short section explains what the following topics will test.
Where the marks sit in the HRM 640 Topic 1 rubric
Faculty grading the strategy paper reward a business-first argument. The strongest papers state the competitive position clearly, support it with evidence and name what the organization deliberately does not compete on, since those choices shape every later HR decision. Credit goes to role behaviors that are specific enough to observe on a shift and tied to identified employee groups rather than general values. The rubric values drawing on the strategy and HR literature to connect position to behavior. The top band explains why the behaviors are hard for rivals to copy and leaves current practices unjudged for the next stage. Papers that open with HR practices and work backward usually lose points.
HRM 640 Topic 1 help before you submit
Opening papers in this course most often go wrong by starting with HR. A paper praising the group's training and benefits before stating how the business wins has judged practices against nothing, and the rest of the term inherits an anchor that was never set. Strategies copied from a mission statement, such as a commitment to excellence, name no customer and no reason anyone pays more. Papers stating the organization's competitive basis without naming the bases it has declined leave every practice looking relevant. Role behaviors written as values, integrity or teamwork, cannot be observed and so cannot test a practice. Citing Schuler and Jackson for a claim they did not make, for instance that one set of practices suits every strategy, reverses their argument, and markers who know the source will notice.
Get an HRM-640 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the HRM-640 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the organization or case the assignment names. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the competitive position stated from evidence, declined bases named, role behaviors derived for specific jobs and current practices inventoried without verdicts, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HRM 640 papers and MBA samples
- HRM 640 Topic 2: Practice Imitability Audit
- HRM 640 Topic 3: Practice Bundle Fit Analysis
- HRM 640 Topic 4: Workforce Architecture Redesign
- HRM 640 Topic 5: Site Consistency Dq Post
- HRM 640 Topic 6: Implementation Gap Review
- HRM 640 Topic 7: Redesign Outcome Measure Plan
- HRM 640 Topic 8: Competing Proposal Executive Case
- LDR 670 Topic 1: Cross Border Leadership Analysis
- HRM 635 Topic 1: Capability Need Analysis
- MGT 605 Topic 1: Leading and Managing Compared
- FIN 650 Topic 1: Firm Objective and Agency Analysis
HRM 640 Topic 1 questions, answered
Why establish strategy before judging practices?
Because a practice is only good or bad relative to what the organization is trying to do. Generous individual sales commissions suit a firm competing on aggressive growth and damage one competing on patient, relationship-based service. Without the strategy stated first, a paper can only call practices common or uncommon, which says nothing about whether they help the organization win.
What did Schuler and Jackson argue?
Randall Schuler and Susan Jackson linked competitive strategy to the role behaviors employees need, arguing that innovation, quality enhancement and cost reduction strategies each call for different behavior, and therefore for different HR practices. Their work is a standard source for the vertical link between strategy and people, and papers use it to justify deriving behaviors before designing practices.
Where does the strategy come from if the case is vague?
From what customers pay for, wherever the case gives evidence of it: pricing relative to rivals, repeat business, the segments that generate margin. Where the case gives little, a paper can state a position as an assumption and label it, then hold every later judgment to it. What weakens a paper is changing the assumed strategy partway through the term.
Where can I find a free HRM 640 Topic 1 sample paper?
Everything in the hotel group paper appears here: the position, the evidence, what the group declines, the three role behaviors, the twelve current practices and what comes next. Send a description of the organization you are analyzing, and a free paper can be drafted around its strategy.
What role behaviors does HRM 640 Topic 1 derive?
Three: front desk agents recall returning guests' preferences unprompted, housekeepers record what a guest changed in the room, and managers tolerate small unapproved spending by staff to put a guest's problem right.