| Course | HRM 640 Designing HR for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Imitability audit |
| Length | About 980 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM 640 Topic 2
What a Chain Could Copy by Next Quarter: An Imitability Audit of Twelve HR Practices at a Composite Hotel Group, and the Three That Survive Only Together
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
HRM-640: Designing HR for Competitive Advantage
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
What a Chain Could Copy by Next Quarter: An Imitability Audit of Twelve HR Practices at a Composite Hotel Group, and the Three That Survive Only Together
The Question the Audit Asks
Topic 1 established that Mesa Lantern, the composite fourteen-hotel group used throughout this course, competes by recognizing repeat business travelers, and it listed twelve current HR practices without judging them. This audit asks of each practice the question a rival chain would ask: could we match it, and how quickly? A practice that a competitor can copy within a quarter may still be worth keeping, but it cannot be the source of a lasting advantage. Only practices that are valuable, rare, costly to imitate and supported by the organization can be (Barney, 1991).
The Four Tests
Each practice is scored on four tests adapted for human resources (Barney & Wright, 1998). Value: does it encourage one of the three role behaviors the position requires? Rarity: do nearby competitors lack it? Imitability: would a competitor find it costly or slow to copy? Organization: does the group actually support it in daily operation, so that it works as designed? A practice must pass all four to contribute to a sustained advantage.
The Audit
Table 1
Imitability Audit of Current HR Practices
| Practice | Value | Rarity | Costly to imitate | Organized | How a chain would match it |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pay at the 75th percentile | Y | N | N | Y | Raise its pay band; a budget line |
| Low-deductible health plan | Y | N | N | Y | Change carriers at renewal |
| Housekeeper signing bonus | N | N | N | Y | Offer the same bonus next week |
| Two-day guest service course | Y | N | N | Y | Buy a similar course from a vendor |
| Guest preference software | Y | N | N | N | License the same system; chains already have larger ones |
| Selective hiring for warmth | Y | N | N | Y | Adopt a behavioral interview |
| Cross-training, front desk and food service | Y | N | N | Y | Schedule training hours |
| Upgrade commission | N | N | N | Y | Already common in chains |
| Housekeeping standard of 16 rooms | N | N | N | Y | Industry norm |
| Internal promotion to supervisor, ten years | Y | Y | Y | Y | Cannot buy a decade of promotion history |
| Recovery allowance managers honor | Y | Y | Y | Partly | Can copy the policy, not the trust that makes agents use it |
| Seniority scheduling of long-serving agents | Y | Y | Y | Y | Cannot hire agents who already know these guests |
Table 1 scores the twelve practices. Y means the practice passes the test; N means it fails.
Why Nine Practices Fail
Nine practices fail at least one test quickly, and most fail the imitability test because a chain could match them with a budget line or a vendor contract. Market-leading pay is valuable, since it helps keep experienced agents, but any chain in the same city can raise its pay band within a quarter. The health plan and signing bonus are matched at the next renewal or the next job posting. The guest service course and the preference software can both be bought; the chains in Mesa Lantern's cities already run larger guest-preference systems than it does. Selective hiring and cross-training are good practice, but they are widely taught and easily adopted. The upgrade commission and the housekeeping standard are common across the industry and, as Topic 3 will show, may work against the role behaviors.
Failing the audit does not mean a practice should be dropped. Competitive pay and good benefits are parity practices: without them the group would lose staff, but with them it only keeps pace. The audit's purpose is to stop the group from believing these practices are what sets it apart.
The Three That Survive, and the Barriers Behind Them
Three practices pass, and the reason each resists imitation is different. Barney (1991) identified three conditions that make a resource hard to copy: it depends on a unique history, the link between the resource and the advantage is unclear to outsiders, or it rests on complex social relationships.
Internal promotion depends on history. For ten years the group has filled supervisor roles from within, so most supervisors learned the guests and the properties as agents and housekeepers. A chain could announce an internal promotion policy tomorrow, but it could not acquire a decade of supervisors who came up this way.
The recovery allowance depends on social complexity. The written policy, $150 per incident without approval, could be copied in a memo. What could not be copied is the trust between agents and managers that makes agents actually spend it, built over years in which managers did not second-guess them. The audit marks this practice only partly organized, because Topic 6 will examine properties where that trust is weaker.
Seniority scheduling depends on causal ambiguity as well as history. Long-serving agents work the weekday shifts business travelers use, and over years they have learned individual guests. A competitor might see the result, guests who feel known, without seeing that the scheduling rule is part of what produces it.
Why They Survive Only Together
The three survivors depend on one another. Internal promotion produces managers who once worked the front desk and who trust agents to spend the allowance. Seniority scheduling keeps experienced agents in front of repeat guests long enough to know them. The allowance gives those agents a way to act on what they know. Remove any one and the others weaken: an allowance without trusted, experienced agents goes unused, and experienced agents without authority to fix problems can recognize guests but not recover them. Practices that fit the strategy and reinforce one another are harder to imitate than any single practice, because a rival would have to copy the whole system at once (Schuler & Jackson, 1987).
The audit therefore points the redesign in a clear direction: protect and strengthen the three survivors as a set, keep the parity practices at parity and look closely at any practice that works against them.
References
Barney, J. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99-120. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108
Barney, J. B., & Wright, P. M. (1998). On becoming a strategic partner: The role of human resources in gaining competitive advantage. Human Resource Management, 37(1), 31-46. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1099-050X(199821)37:1<31::AID-HRM4>3.0.CO;2-W
Schuler, R. S., & Jackson, S. E. (1987). Linking competitive strategies with human resource management practices. Academy of Management Executive, 1(3), 207-219. https://doi.org/10.5465/ame.1987.4275740
Reading the GCU HRM 640 Topic 2 instructions
The Topic 2 instructions in HRM-640 ask students to assess whether an organization's HR practices could be a source of sustained competitive advantage. Calling every practice strategic earns little. Credit goes to an audit that applies a clear set of tests, such as value, rarity, imitability and organization, to each practice and shows specifically how a competitor would match those that fail. Students should explain why surviving practices are hard to copy, using concepts such as unique history, causal ambiguity and social complexity, and consider whether practices resist imitation alone or only in combination. Distinguishing parity practices from sources of advantage is expected.
How this HRM 640 Topic 2 example is built
The audit restates the question a rival would ask and introduces four tests adapted for human resources. Table 1 scores twelve practices with yes or no on each test and a column showing how a chain would match each one. A section explains the nine failures, noting that competitive pay and benefits remain worth keeping as parity practices. The three survivors are then examined one by one, each linked to a barrier from Barney's account: history for internal promotion, social complexity for the allowance and causal ambiguity for scheduling. A final section argues that the three resist imitation only as a set and points the redesign toward protecting them together.
HRM 640 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Instructors grading the imitability audit reward tests applied consistently to every practice. Strong papers show how a competitor would match each failing practice, usually with a budget line or vendor contract, so the verdicts can be checked. Credit goes to recognizing that failing practices may still be needed for parity. The rubric values naming the specific barrier that protects each surviving practice, with the resource-based literature cited accurately. The highest band explains why surviving practices depend on one another and draws a clear implication for redesign. Audits that declare every practice a competitive advantage, or that never consider how rivals would copy them, tend to lose marks.
Common HRM 640 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
An imitability audit earns little when it grades practices by how good they sound. Papers listing generous benefits and strong training as sources of advantage forget that a rival can buy both within a budget cycle. Verdicts without a copying route, stating only that a practice would be hard to imitate, give the reader nothing to verify. Audits that keep failing practices among the strengths out of loyalty to them undercut their own table. Citing Barney while treating rarity alone as enough misreads the framework, since a rare practice that is cheap to copy stays rare only briefly. Papers dropping parity practices from the analysis altogether forget that losing them would still cost the organization its people, even though keeping them wins nothing against the chains.
Get an HRM-640 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the HRM-640 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the organization or practice list the assignment gives. A custom example is written to those requirements, with the strategy restated, four resource-based tests applied, a copying route for each failure, named barriers for each survivor and parity practices kept, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HRM 640 papers and MBA samples
- HRM 640 Topic 1: Strategy and Role Behavior Paper
- HRM 640 Topic 3: Practice Bundle Fit Analysis
- HRM 640 Topic 4: Workforce Architecture Redesign
- HRM 640 Topic 5: Site Consistency Dq Post
- HRM 640 Topic 6: Implementation Gap Review
- HRM 640 Topic 7: Redesign Outcome Measure Plan
- HRM 640 Topic 8: Competing Proposal Executive Case
- LDR 670 Topic 2: Culture Framework Critique
- HRM 635 Topic 2: Costed Talent Gap Statement
- MGT 605 Topic 2: Effectiveness Theory Survey
- FIN 650 Topic 2: Issuer Side Valuation
HRM 640 Topic 2 questions, answered
What are Barney's resource-based tests?
Jay Barney argued that a resource supports sustained advantage when it is valuable, rare, imperfectly imitable and not easily substituted, and his later VRIO version asks whether the organization is set up to exploit it. He traced imperfect imitability to unique history, causal ambiguity and social complexity. HR practices are a common application, since the framework explains why most of them fail.
If most practices can be copied, why keep them?
Because some are parity practices: they create no advantage, but lacking them would cost the organization people it needs. Competitive pay and a decent health plan usually fall here. An audit removing them from the list of strengths is correct, while one recommending they be abandoned has confused a lack of advantage with a lack of value, a different and costlier mistake.
How precise does a copying estimate need to be?
Precise enough to check, not precise to the week. Saying a chain could match the health plan at the next benefits renewal, or license comparable preference software within a quarter, gives a reviewer something concrete to dispute. Saying a practice would be difficult to imitate gives nothing. The example states a route and a rough period for every practice it removes.
Where can I find a free HRM 640 Topic 2 sample paper?
The full hotel audit is above, from the four tests and the twelve-row table to the nine failures, the three survivors and their barriers, and why they work only together. Share the practices of the organization you are studying, and a free audit can be written for them.
Which practices survive in HRM 640 Topic 2?
Internal promotion over ten years, a recovery allowance that managers actually honor and seniority scheduling of long-serving agents. Each is protected by history, trust or causal ambiguity, and they survive mainly as a combination.