HRM 640 Topic 8 competing proposal executive case example

Designing HR for Competitive Advantage Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This HRM 640 Topic 8 sample paper is an executive case for a $610,000 HR redesign competing with three other proposals at a composite hotel group. It belongs to GCU HRM 640, Designing HR for Competitive Advantage, the course listed as HRM-640 in the Grand Canyon University MBA with an Emphasis in Strategic Human Resource Management. Each point of repeat-stay rate is worth about $380,000 a year, so the redesign breaks even at about 0.8 points and targets two. All four proposals are tested on whether a competitor could match the result. A points program fails, revenue software is parity and the renovation is necessary, so the case pairs the renovation with the redesign.

CourseHRM 640 Designing HR for Competitive Advantage
TopicTopic 8
Paper typeExecutive business case
LengthAbout 960 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for HRM 640 Topic 8

1

Four Proposals, Two Funded: An Executive Case for a $610,000 HR Redesign at a Composite Hotel Group, Judged on Whether a Competitor Could Match the Result

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

HRM-640: Designing HR for Competitive Advantage

Topic 8 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the competition the case enters and the test it applies that the other proposals do not. The hotel group and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Four Proposals, Two Funded: An Executive Case for a $610,000 HR Redesign at a Composite Hotel Group, Judged on Whether a Competitor Could Match the Result

The Ask and the Return

1. Ask: $610,000 over two years to carry out the HR redesign developed in Topics 1 through 7.

2. What it buys: a senior agent grade, housekeeping lead roles, more time per room for repeat guests, handheld preference capture, a team bonus in place of the upgrade commission and the training to introduce them.

3. Return: each percentage point of repeat-stay rate among business travelers is worth about $380,000 a year in room revenue. The redesign breaks even at a gain of about 0.8 points a year and targets two points, worth about $760,000 a year.

4. Recommendation: fund the renovation and this redesign together; defer the loyalty program; fund revenue software only as a parity upgrade.

All figures are illustrative composites.

What this page is doingThe first page gives an executive with four proposals on the desk the ask, the break-even and the recommendation, including what the case advises not funding.
3

What the $610,000 Covers

Table 1

Components of the Redesign Ask, Illustrative

ComponentTwo-year costFinding behind it
Senior agent grade for long-serving agents$180,000Topic 4: deepen the internal track where knowledge of guests is unique
Housekeeping lead role on each floor$160,000Topic 4: internal track for housekeepers
Repeat-guest rooms counted as 1.25 in the housekeeping standard$140,000Topic 3: the 16-room standard fails vertical fit
Handheld preference capture at six properties$42,000Topic 6: paper notes reach the front desk for under one room in ten
Team bonus on repeat-stay rate, net of the upgrade commission removed$48,000Topic 3: the commission conflicts with recognition and recovery
Training and rollout$40,000Topic 6: perception lags implementation
Total$610,000

Table 1 breaks the ask into components, each traced to an earlier finding.

How the Return Was Estimated

Repeat business travelers fill about 40 percent of the group's room nights. One additional percentage point of repeat-stay rate means roughly 2,100 more returning stays a year across the group, at an average rate of about $181, or about $380,000 in room revenue. At $305,000 a year, the redesign pays for itself if the rate rises by 0.8 points. The target of two points, from 41 to 43 percent, is modest relative to the gap between the best and worst properties today, which is about nine points. The measure plan in Topic 7 defines how the gain will be measured and what would count as failure. Linking HR spending to an outcome the business already values is what allows it to be compared with capital proposals on equal terms (Becker et al., 2001).

The estimate counts only room revenue. Repeat guests also spend in the restaurant and book meetings, and they cost less to acquire because they book directly. Those effects are real but harder to measure reliably, so leaving them out makes the break-even conservative. The estimate also assumes the gain persists; if the repeat-stay rate rose and then fell back after two years, the return would be smaller, which is one reason the measure plan continues reporting beyond the first eighteen months.

Comparing the Four Proposals

Table 2

Four Proposals Compared, Illustrative

ProposalTwo-year costExpected effectCould a competitor match it?
HR redesign$610,000Two points of repeat-stay rate, about $760,000 a yearNot quickly: depends on years of guest knowledge and trust
Points loyalty program$1.4 millionMore repeat stays from points-seeking travelersYes: chains already run larger programs
Revenue management software$300,000Better pricing, perhaps 1 to 2 percent of room revenueYes: chains already use similar systems
Lobby and room renovation, four oldest properties$4.2 millionKeeps those properties competitiveYes, but the need is real

The executive team has four proposals before it. Table 2 compares them on cost, expected return and one question the other proposals do not ask: could a competitor match the result?

Resources that competitors can buy or build quickly can bring a firm to parity, but they cannot sustain an advantage (Barney, 1991). The loyalty program fails that test most clearly. Chains already run far larger points programs, and building one would pull the group toward competing on scale, a basis it declined in Topic 1 because rivals with hundreds of hotels hold it. The program would also shift what the group's best guests value from being known to collecting points, a contest it cannot win.

Revenue software is parity. The chains already use it, and the group probably needs it eventually to avoid underpricing. It does not differentiate, and it should be funded only if money remains after the priorities below.

The renovation is probably necessary. Four properties have lobbies and rooms that regular guests describe as tired, and recognition does not compensate for a room that feels neglected. It does not create an advantage, but without it the group could lose the guests the redesign is meant to keep.

What this page is doingEvery proposal is held to the same question, whether a rival could match it, and the case credits the renovation's necessity instead of dismissing a competing request.
4

Recommendation

The executive team should fund the renovation and the HR redesign together, as complementary investments: the renovation keeps the product at parity, and the redesign strengthens the source of advantage. The loyalty program should be deferred, because it pulls the group toward a position it cannot hold. Revenue software should be considered next year as a parity upgrade.

Choosing what not to fund is part of strategy, not a failure of ambition (Porter, 1996). The group's position rests on being known to repeat guests, and its scarce money should go first to the people and practices that make that possible, with a review at eighteen months against the failure conditions already set.

If the executive team can fund only one of the two recommended investments this year, it should fund the redesign and phase the renovation over two years, starting with the two properties most often mentioned in guest complaints. The redesign costs about one-seventh as much, works through all fourteen hotels and builds the part of the position no competitor can buy.

References

Barney, J. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99-120. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108

Becker, B. E., Huselid, M. A., & Ulrich, D. (2001). The HR scorecard: Linking people, strategy, and performance. Harvard Business School Press.

Porter, M. E. (1996). What is strategy? Harvard Business Review, 74(6), 61-78.

HRM 640 Topic 8 instructions, in plain terms

The Topic 8 instructions for HRM-640 ask students to make the case for an HR investment to executives who must choose among competing proposals. A case that ignores the other proposals, or presents HR spending as self-evidently good, will not persuade. The assignment rewards a first page with the ask, return and break-even, a cost breakdown traced to earlier analysis and a return estimated from an outcome the business already values. Students should compare all proposals on the same terms, including whether competitors could match their results, credit other proposals where they are necessary and recommend what to fund, defer or decline.

How the HRM-640 Topic 8 example is put together

The case opens with four numbered lines giving the ask, what it buys, the return and the recommendation. Table 1 breaks the $610,000 into six components, each traced to a finding from earlier topics. A section explains how one point of repeat-stay rate converts to about $380,000 in room revenue and how the break-even of 0.8 points follows. Table 2 compares the four proposals on cost, effect and whether a competitor could match them. Paragraphs explain why the points program fails, why revenue software is parity and why the renovation is still needed. The recommendation funds the renovation and redesign together and defers the loyalty program.

Where the marks sit in the HRM 640 Topic 8 rubric

Instructors grading the executive case reward a first page that lets a busy reader decide. Strong cases trace every dollar to earlier evidence and convert the expected effect into revenue with arithmetic a reader can check. Credit goes to comparing all proposals on the same basis and applying a test the others ignore, whether a rival could match the result, with the resource-based view cited. The rubric values crediting a competing proposal that is genuinely needed rather than dismissing it. The highest band recommends what to fund, defer and decline, and links the decision back to the strategy's choices. Cases that argue for HR spending in isolation usually lose points.

HRM 640 Topic 8 help before you submit

The closing case is marked on whether it survives comparison. A proposal arguing only its own merits, with no reference to the alternatives on the executive's desk, has been written for a reader who does not exist. Returns stated without a break-even ask the executive to share the writer's optimism. Papers that dismiss the other proposals rather than conceding their strengths lose credibility on the one page where credibility decides the outcome. Imitability asserted without tying it back to the strategy established earlier reads as a slogan instead of the finding of a term's analysis. Requests with no measure or review date leave the executive unable to stop the spending if it fails, and recommendations framed as all or nothing force a choice that a funding combination could have avoided.

Get an HRM-640 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the HRM-640 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the proposal, rivals or organization the case involves. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the ask and break-even first, all proposals compared in one table, copyability tied to strategy, rival strengths conceded and an end condition named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More HRM 640 papers and MBA samples

HRM 640 Topic 8 questions, answered

Why compare the proposal with its rivals at all?

Because the executive will, whether or not the paper does. A proposal that ignores the alternatives leaves the comparison to someone less sympathetic. Setting all of them on the same terms shows the writer understands the decision being made, and it lets the strongest argument, here that only the people redesign produces something a competitor cannot buy, carry its full weight.

Is recommending a combination a weaker position?

Usually not. Executives rarely fund one proposal and reject the rest, and a case showing how its request fits beside a necessary renovation is easier to approve than one demanding everything. The concession is also honest. What would weaken the case is recommending every proposal, which would amount to declining to make the argument at all.

How does this topic connect to the earlier ones?

It rests on all of them. The strategy from the opening topic defines what counts as advantage, the imitability audit supplies the copyability column, the fit and redesign work describes what is being funded, and the measurement plan provides the figure to watch. The case summarizes each in a line or two rather than repeating it, and points to earlier work for detail.

Where can I find a free HRM 640 Topic 8 sample paper?

You can read the hotel group's executive case here in full, including the one-page ask, the cost table, the return estimate, the four-proposal comparison and the recommendation. Send the proposal you need to make, and a free case can be drafted around it.

Why defer the loyalty program in HRM 640 Topic 8?

Chains already run far larger points programs, so the result could be matched, and building one would pull the group toward competing on scale, a basis it declined because rivals with hundreds of hotels hold it.