| Course | MGT 605 Leadership and Organizations |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Leading and managing comparison |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 605 Topic 1
What Each Leaves Behind: Comparing Leading and Managing by Their Outputs in a Regional Grocery Chain
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-605: Leadership and Organizations
Topic 1 Leading and Managing Comparison
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
What Each Leaves Behind: Comparing Leading and Managing by Their Outputs in a Regional Grocery Chain
Comparing Outputs, Not Personalities
Most comparisons of leading and managing describe two kinds of person: the manager who counts and the leader who inspires. That contrast cannot be tested, because personality is not what an organization receives from either activity. This paper compares them by output, what each activity leaves behind when it is done well, using a composite regional grocery chain of 42 stores and one distribution center. Kotter (1990) framed the distinction in similar terms: management produces order and predictability, and leadership produces change. The question here is what that means in a grocery business and what happens when either output is missing.
What Management Produces
Management's output is a store that works the same way every day. Its tools are plans, budgets, schedules, staffing levels, inventory controls and the measures that show whether they are met (Yukl & Gardner, 2020). In the chain, good management produces shelves that are full at opening, labor hours that match customer traffic, shrink held below 2 percent of sales and food safety audits passed without findings. None of this is glamorous, and all of it is what customers notice when it fails. An organization of 42 stores and 3,000 employees cannot function without it, and most of the chain's managers spend most of their time producing it. Treating management as the lesser half misdescribes the work on which the business runs.
What Leadership Produces
Leadership's output is people moving willingly in a new direction: an agreed account of where the organization must go, and commitment from the people who must take it there. Its tools are setting direction, explaining why it matters and aligning people behind it (Kotter, 1990). In the chain, leadership shows up when a new competitor opens nearby and a store manager persuades the team to change how it serves customers, or when the company decides to build an online ordering service and staff in every store come to see it as their work rather than headquarters' project. Leadership is needed less often than management, but when it is missing, change stalls.
Each Failing Without the Other
The chain provides one example of each failure. Two years ago it installed self-checkout lanes in twenty stores. The rollout was well managed: installation finished on schedule and under budget, and training hours were logged for every cashier. But no one explained to store teams why the change was being made or what it meant for their jobs. Cashiers assumed the lanes were the first step toward layoffs, attendants were assigned reluctantly and stood back from customers, and shrink at the self-checkout lanes ran at three times the rate of staffed lanes for six months. Management without leadership produced a project completed on paper and resisted in practice. The opposite failure came at the chain's newest store, whose manager was admired by staff and customers for energy and vision. Within a year the store had the chain's highest employee engagement scores and its worst inventory accuracy, with frequent out-of-stocks on advertised items, because ordering and receiving routines were never put in place. Leadership without management produced commitment to a store that did not run reliably.
Table 1
Each Activity Failing Without the Other in One Chain
| Situation | Management output | Leadership output | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-checkout rollout | Strong: on time, on budget, training logged | Weak: no explanation of why or what it meant for staff | Lanes installed but resisted; high shrink |
| Newest store | Weak: no ordering and receiving routines | Strong: high engagement, shared enthusiasm | Committed team; unreliable shelves |
The Same Person in One Week
The two activities are not owned by different job titles. Consider one of the chain's store managers over a single week. On Monday and Tuesday the manager sets the labor schedule against forecast traffic, reviews the shrink report and follows up on a failed temperature check, all management. On Wednesday the manager meets the team to explain why the store will start offering curbside pickup and asks two experienced clerks to design the process, which is leadership. On Thursday the manager builds the pickup schedule and sets the measures for order accuracy, management again. Mintzberg (1973) found that managers' work is fragmented into many brief activities of different kinds, and this week fits that description: the manager moves between producing order and producing change several times a day.
Why the Distinction Is Not a Ranking
Research on the distinction has moved away from treating leaders and managers as different people. Yukl and Gardner (2020) note that most scholars now treat leading and managing as overlapping roles that the same person performs, and that the real question is the balance between them in a given job at a given time. That view fits the chain's evidence. Its best store managers are not those who lead instead of manage, but those who can tell which output the week requires: steady routines when the store is stable, and direction and persuasion when something must change. Treating either activity as superior would lead the chain to promote and train for the wrong thing.
Which the Chain Needs More of Now
The chain's most pressing need, in the writer's judgment, is management at the store level. Its strategy, building online ordering while defending its stores against a discount competitor, has been explained repeatedly by senior leaders and is broadly accepted. What is failing is execution: inconsistent pickup times, inventory records that do not match shelves and labor schedules built by habit rather than forecast. Investment in training store managers in forecasting, scheduling and inventory control would return more than another round of communication about direction.
Conclusion
Compared by what they leave behind, management produces order and leadership produces commitment to change. One chain shows each failing without the other: a well-managed rollout that staff resisted and an inspiring store that could not keep its shelves full. The same manager produces both outputs in a single week. For this chain at this moment, the scarcer of the two is management.
References
Kotter, J. P. (1990). A force for change: How leadership differs from management. Free Press.
Mintzberg, H. (1973). The nature of managerial work. Harper & Row.
Yukl, G., & Gardner, W. L., III. (2020). Leadership in organizations (9th ed.). Pearson.
MGT 605 Topic 1 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 1 in MGT-605 asks MBA students to compare leading and managing. Strong comparisons choose a basis, such as what each activity produces, give management its due rather than treating it as the lesser half and use one organization so each can be shown failing without the other. Students should show the same person doing both and conclude which the writer's organization needs more of now. The paper should also explain why the research literature now treats the two roles as overlapping. Definitions should come from that literature rather than from popular business writing.
How this MGT 605 Topic 1 example is built
The finished example compares by output. Management produces predictability: a budget that holds, a schedule that works, a process that repeats without supervision. The example states outright that an organization losing those is in trouble no matter how inspired anybody feels. Leadership produces direction and willingness, meaning movement toward something the current arrangements were never built to deliver. Both are then shown failing: an organization with management and no leadership optimizes its way into irrelevance, and one with leadership and no management generates initiatives nobody completes. A single firm is used throughout, so both failures become visible inside the same setting rather than being described in the abstract. Neither activity is treated as the junior partner of the other.
MGT 605 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward a comparison grounded in outputs rather than personalities. An Excellent paper draws on Kotter for the order and change distinction and tables two failures in one chain. Credit goes to a store manager's week moving between both activities, following Mintzberg on fragmented managerial work. The rubric values treating the roles as overlapping, with Yukl and Gardner. Strong papers avoid the counting manager caricature. Top marks go to deciding which output this chain is short of now. Papers that end with which output the writer's own organization lacks, and why, show the comparison applied. Credit also goes to evidence such as shrink rates or out-of-stocks rather than impressions.
Common MGT 605 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them
The caricature costs marks before anything else, and it appears as managers who count things set against leaders who inspire people. Faculty have read that version repeatedly and it demonstrates nothing about either activity. A second failure is treating management as the inferior half, which is both inaccurate and impractical given that most graduates will spend their careers doing it. Papers lose marks for comparing the two without a setting, since a distinction argued in the abstract cannot be tested against anything a reader could check. Definitions lifted from popular business writing instead of the research literature are marked down at this level. Concluding that organizations need both, with no account of which one this organization is short of, ends the paper on the one sentence everybody already agreed with.
Get an MGT-605 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-605 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, with something about the organization you would like used. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the comparison built on output, both activities credited, each shown failing alone and the current deficit named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MGT 605 papers and MBA samples
- MGT 605 Topic 2: Effectiveness Theory Survey
- MGT 605 Topic 3: Transformational and Servant Models
- MGT 605 Topic 4: Motivation Analysis
- MGT 605 Topic 5: Power and Influence Analysis
- MGT 605 Topic 6: Culture Formation Study
- MGT 605 Topic 7: Team and Change Analysis
- MGT 605 Topic 8: Personal Leadership Plan
- MGT 640 Topic 1: Strategic Initiative Triage Memo
- LDR 670 Topic 1: Cross Border Leadership Analysis
- MGT 641 Topic 1: Agile Manifesto Assumptions Paper
- HRM 640 Topic 1: Strategy and Role Behavior Paper
MGT 605 Topic 1 questions, answered
Is management really the lesser activity?
No, and papers implying it lose marks. An organization that cannot forecast, schedule or repeat a process reliably fails regardless of how compelling its direction is, and most value is produced by work that runs predictably. The popular framing treats management as bureaucratic and leadership as visionary, which flatters readers and misdescribes both. The useful question is which the situation currently needs.
Can the same person do both?
Constantly, and often within an hour. Approving a schedule and persuading a reluctant team to attempt something new are different activities performed by the same person under the same job title. Framing the comparison as two types of people is the commonest structural error in this assignment; framing it as two activities anybody in a role moves between produces a much stronger paper.
How do I make the comparison concrete?
Anchor it in one organization and show both failures there. Describe what happens when the management half is missing, initiatives launched and never closed, and what happens when the leadership half is missing, a well run operation slowly optimizing something nobody wants. Two failures in one setting are far more persuasive than a table of contrasting characteristics.
Where can I find a free MGT 605 Topic 1 sample paper?
The comparison is shown here complete: outputs rather than personalities, what management produces, what leadership produces, each failing without the other, one person's week, why it is not a ranking, what the chain needs and the conclusion. Name the organization you work in and a version for it follows free.
Why compare outputs instead of personalities in MGT 605 Topic 1?
Personality cannot be tested against anything a reader could check. Outputs can: full shelves and on-time rollouts show management, while staff adopting a change willingly shows leadership.