MGT 605 Topic 5 power and influence analysis example

Leadership and Organizations Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 605 Topic 5 sample paper separates authority from power for a grocery district manager and judges each source of power by what using it costs. It was written for GCU MGT 605, Leadership and Organizations, catalog code MGT-605, a core course in Grand Canyon University's MBA. French and Raven's five bases are tabled: legitimate, reward and coercive power are depleted by use and yield compliance, while expert and referent power accumulate and yield commitment. Yukl and Tracey's evidence on tactics frames the ethics. The case of a markdown process tested rather than imposed shows restraint as judgment. Power sources are judged by what using them leaves behind.

CourseMGT 605 Leadership and Organizations
TopicTopic 5
Paper typePower and influence analysis
LengthAbout 1,000 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 605 Topic 5

1

Authority Granted, Power Held: What Each Source of Power Costs a District Manager, and a Case for Not Using the Power Available

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-605: Leadership and Organizations

Topic 5 Power and Influence Analysis

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the distinction the analysis rests on and the case it ends with. The grocery chain and its managers are a composite; the sources are real.
2

Authority Granted, Power Held: What Each Source of Power Costs a District Manager, and a Case for Not Using the Power Available

Power Is Not Authority

Authority is granted: it is the right to direct others that comes with a position, written into an organization chart. Power is held: it is the capacity to affect what others do, whatever its source. The two often coincide but need not. In a composite regional grocery chain, a newly appointed district manager has formal authority over eight store managers but, in the first months, little power with them; a long-serving store manager with no authority over other stores may have great influence across the district because peers trust that manager's judgment. Pfeffer (1992) argued that organizational analysis that attends only to formal authority misses how decisions actually get made. This paper maps the sources of power available to the district manager, what each costs to use, which produces commitment rather than compliance and how tactics affect relationships afterward, and closes with a case of power deliberately left unused.

Sources of Power

French and Raven (1959) identified five bases of power. Legitimate power rests on the target's acceptance that the position gives the right to direct. Reward power rests on control of things the target values, such as schedules, bonuses or recommendations for promotion. Coercive power rests on the ability to impose penalties. Expert power rests on knowledge the target respects. Referent power rests on the target's identification with or liking for the person. The district manager holds the first three by virtue of the position and must earn the last two, which in a district of experienced store managers are the ones that decide whether requests are carried out with care.

What Each Costs to Use

The sources differ in what using them does to the stock of power afterward. Reward power is depleted: each bonus spent is gone, and rewards that become expected stop motivating. Coercive power is depleted and damaging: each use erodes goodwill and invites quiet resistance, so it buys less each time. Legitimate power is preserved by careful use and eroded by overuse; a manager who invokes position for every request teaches people to do the minimum the position can demand. Expert and referent power behave differently: used well, they accumulate. A district manager whose advice on reducing shrink works in one store is consulted more readily by the next.

Table 1

Sources of Power and What Using Them Costs

SourceRests onEffect of using itTypical outcome
LegitimateAccepted right of the positionPreserved if sparing; eroded if overusedCompliance
RewardControl of valued outcomesDepleted; rewards become expectedCompliance, sometimes commitment
CoerciveAbility to penalizeDepleted and damaging to goodwillCompliance or resistance
ExpertRespected knowledgeAccumulates when advice worksCommitment
ReferentIdentification and trustAccumulates through consistent conductCommitment

Compliance and Commitment

Compliance means doing what is asked with minimal effort, often only while observed. Commitment means agreeing with the request and working to make it succeed. For routine requests compliance is enough; for anything requiring judgment, persistence or initiative, such as a store manager carrying out a new process when the district manager is not present, commitment is required. Position-based power produces compliance at best. Expert and referent power are the main routes to commitment, which is why a manager who relies only on authority can get obedience but not effort.

Tactics and the Relationship Afterward

Influence tactics should be judged not only by whether they work once but by what they leave behind. In the study by Yukl and Tracey (1992), the tactics most likely to win commitment were reasoned argument, appeals to values and consulting the target, while pressure and appeals to legitimate authority were among the least effective and more likely to produce resistance. Pressure may secure a store manager's agreement today and make the next request harder. The ethical question belongs here, not in a closing paragraph: tactics that rely on withholding information, manufacturing urgency or exploiting dependence may work, but they treat colleagues as instruments, and the damage to trust is both a moral and a practical cost.

A Case of Power Not Used

Last year the chain introduced a new markdown process for perishable goods, requiring stores to discount items at fixed times before their sell-by dates. One store manager, the most experienced in the district, refused to adopt it, arguing that the store's customers bought late in the day and that the fixed times would give away margin. The district manager had the authority to require compliance and the coercive power to note the refusal in the manager's review. The district manager used neither. Instead, the district manager asked the store manager to run the new process on half the store's perishable categories for six weeks and compare shrink and margin with the other half. The reasoning was threefold. Compliance enforced by position would have produced a process followed grudgingly and abandoned when unobserved. The store manager's objection might have been right, and a test would show it. And the store manager's referent power with peers meant that coercion would have cost the district manager influence across all eight stores. The test showed the store manager was partly right: the fixed times cut margin on bakery items without reducing waste. The process was changed for bakery across the chain, and the store manager adopted the revised version and championed it to peers.

Conclusion

Authority is granted with a position; power must be held, and its sources differ in what they cost. Position-based sources produce compliance and are depleted by use, while expert and referent power produce commitment and grow when used well. Tactics should be judged by the relationship they leave behind. Restraint, as the markdown case shows, can be a deliberate use of judgment that builds the power a manager will need later. The district manager still held the authority to require the process if the test had shown the objection was simply resistance; choosing not to use it first kept that option intact.

References

French, J. R. P., Jr., & Raven, B. (1959). The bases of social power. In D. Cartwright (Ed.), Studies in social power (pp. 150-167). University of Michigan Press.

Pfeffer, J. (1992). Managing with power: Politics and influence in organizations. Harvard Business School Press.

Yukl, G., & Tracey, J. B. (1992). Consequences of influence tactics used with subordinates, peers, and the boss. Journal of Applied Psychology, 77(4), 525-535. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.77.4.525

The MGT-605 Topic 5 assignment instructions

The Topic 5 assignment in MGT-605 asks MBA students to analyze power and influence. Strong analyses distinguish power from authority, set out the sources available to a manager and ask what each costs to use. Students should separate compliance from commitment, judge tactics by their effect on the relationship afterward, integrate ethics into the analysis and work a case where power was available and not used. The paper should also show how restraint can preserve options a manager may need later. Ethical costs of tactics should be weighed alongside effectiveness. Each source of power should be linked to the outcome it typically produces, compliance or commitment.

Inside the MGT 605 Topic 5 example

The finished example is interested in what happens after power is used. The sources are distinguished, positional authority, control of rewards, the ability to punish, expertise and personal standing, and the example notes that some are depleted by use while others grow. Compliance is separated from commitment, since the coercive sources reliably produce the first and never the second. Influence tactics are then examined by what they do to the relationship afterward, which is the practical ethical question. The analysis holds that a tactic can be effective and still wrong, and it works one case where the writer had power available and declined to use it, with the reasoning stated.

Reading the MGT 605 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty reward power traced to its costs. An Excellent paper separates a new district manager's authority from a veteran store manager's influence, following Pfeffer. Credit goes to a table of French and Raven's bases with their effects and outcomes. The rubric values Yukl and Tracey on which tactics produce commitment and ethics placed inside the tactics discussion. Strong papers explain why coercion depletes. Top marks go to a case of restraint with its reasoning and result. Papers that show a test replacing an order, and the result proving the objection partly right, demonstrate why restraint can be the more effective use of power. Credit also goes to referent power traced across peers.

Common MGT 605 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Listing the sources of power with no consequences attached is the weak version, since the interesting question is what using each one costs. A second failure is treating ethics as a closing paragraph, which the topic explicitly resists by pairing the two. Papers lose marks for confusing power with authority, because a manager can hold formal authority and very little actual power, and an analysis that cannot express that has lost its most useful distinction. Describing influence tactics purely by effectiveness misses the question the assignment is asking. Concluding that leaders should use power responsibly restates the prompt without answering it, and it is the ending most of these papers reach for.

Get an MGT-605 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-605 Topic 5 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, with the situation or case your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with power separated from authority, each source costed by its use, tactics judged by their aftermath and one case of restraint worked, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More MGT 605 papers and MBA samples

MGT 605 Topic 5 questions, answered

What is the difference between power and authority?

Authority is granted by a position; power is the actual ability to affect what happens. A newly appointed manager holds full authority and very little power until they build expertise, relationships and a record. Conversely a long serving specialist with no title can have substantial power. Keeping them separate lets you describe organizations accurately rather than as the chart depicts them.

Which sources of power get used up?

Coercive power depletes fastest, since each use raises resistance and costs standing, and it eventually produces only the minimum compliance necessary. Reward power depends on having rewards available, which is often outside a manager's control. Expertise and personal standing generally accumulate with use, which is why they are the sources worth building and the ones most under an individual's influence.

Can an influence tactic be effective and still unethical?

Regularly, and recognizing it is what the topic is testing. Manipulating information, creating artificial urgency or exploiting somebody's insecurity can all produce the outcome you wanted and damage the relationship permanently. The useful test is what the other person would think if they understood exactly what you had done. Effectiveness and legitimacy are separate questions, and papers that merge them lose the ethical mark.

Where can I find a free MGT 605 Topic 5 sample paper?

The power analysis is shown here complete: power and authority, the sources, what each costs, compliance and commitment, tactics and relationships, a case of power not used and the conclusion. Describe the influence problem your course poses and we will analyze it free.

Why not order the store manager to comply in MGT 605 Topic 5?

Enforced compliance would be followed grudgingly, the objection might be right and coercion would cost influence across the district. A six-week test showed the objection was partly right.