| Course | MKT 607 Marketing Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Secondary research appraisal |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MKT 607 Topic 4
119 Billion or 158 Billion? Appraising Three Sources on Pet Spending Before Sizing a Fresh Dog Food Market in Three States
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MKT-607: Marketing Management
Topic 4 Secondary Research Appraisal
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
119 Billion or 158 Billion? Appraising Three Sources on Pet Spending Before Sizing a Fresh Dog Food Market in Three States
The Question the Research Must Answer
Copperfield Kitchen, the composite fresh food maker followed in this course, is deciding whether its market is large enough to justify a second kitchen. The research question is narrow: roughly how much do households in those three states spend on fresh dog food, and how fast is that growing? That question determines what counts as a good source. A source must measure household spending, or something convertible to it, must separate food from other pet spending, and must be recent. Three widely cited sources were found, and each is appraised before any of its figures is used.
The Sources and Who Produced Them
The first is the federal Consumer Expenditure Surveys, compiled by a federal statistical agency, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, with no commercial interest in the result. The second is the American Pet Products Association, a trade association whose members sell pet products and whose published industry total is widely quoted in the press and in investor materials. The third is the annual report of Freshpet, Inc., a publicly traded maker of refrigerated pet food, filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Each producer has a different interest: the agency in statistical consistency, the association in a large and growing industry its members can cite, and the company in reporting its own results accurately under securities law.
Appraisal on Method, Definition, Date and Independence
The federal survey reports average household spending on pets of 880 dollars in 2024 across about 135.8 million consumer units, which implies about 119 billion dollars nationally (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025). Its method is a household interview and diary survey, which captures what households say they spent but is known to understate some categories. The association reports total pet industry spending of about 158 billion dollars, of which about 68.3 billion is pet food and treats (American Pet Products Association, 2025). Its method starts from retail scanner data across channels, adds estimates for channels the data miss and validates with cooperating retailers, and its veterinary figure comes from a separate commercial estimate. Its page labels the 158 billion figure both as 2025 actual sales and as spending in 2024, a dating ambiguity that must be resolved before the figure is used for growth rates. Freshpet reports net sales of about 975 million dollars for 2024, up from about 767 million in 2023 (Freshpet, Inc., 2025). That figure is audited and precise, but it is a manufacturer's revenue at wholesale prices, includes cat food and sales outside the United States, and comes from refrigerated retail rather than subscription.
Table 1
Three Sources Appraised
| Source | Producer | Method | Figure | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Consumer Expenditure Surveys | Federal statistical agency | Household interviews and diaries | About 119 billion dollars, all pet spending, 2024 | Household reporting understates some spending |
| Industry trends and stats | Trade association | Retail scanner data plus estimates | About 158 billion dollars; 68.3 billion food and treats | Producer's interest; unclear dating |
| Form 10-K | Refrigerated pet food maker | Audited company revenue | About 975 million dollars, 2024 | Wholesale value; one company; includes cat food |
Sources Set Aside
Several other figures appeared in the search and were not used. Commercial research firms publish summaries of fresh pet food market reports that quote a market size and a growth rate but disclose neither the definition nor the method without purchase, and some of those firms sell consulting services to companies entering the category. Blog posts and press articles repeated these figures without dates. A figure that cannot be traced to a stated method, definition and date cannot be appraised, and a figure that cannot be appraised should not be quoted. If Copperfield buys one of the reports, its method section should be read before its headline number.
Why the Two Totals Disagree
The federal and association totals differ by about 39 billion dollars, and the difference is mostly definitional rather than an error in either. The association counts sales at retail across all channels, including purchases by breeders, shelters and businesses, and spending reimbursed by pet insurance; the household survey counts only what households report spending themselves. Household surveys also tend to understate frequent small purchases such as treats. Neither is wrong; they measure different things. For Copperfield's question, about household food spending, the association's food and treats category is closer in definition, but its producer's interest and dating ambiguity mean it should be treated as an upper bound.
From National Figures to Three States
Using the association's 68.3 billion dollars for food and treats as an upper bound, and the three states' share of the national population, about 3.8 percent, gives roughly 2.6 billion dollars of pet food and treat spending in Copperfield's market. Freshpet's sales equal about 1.4 percent of the national food figure at wholesale prices; at retail prices, and adding other fresh brands, fresh food is plausibly 2 to 4 percent of food spending. That implies a fresh market in the three states of very roughly 50 to 100 million dollars a year. The range is wide because each step adds uncertainty, and the paper reports it as a range rather than a point.
What the Appraisal Means for the Decision
Copperfield's current sales of about 30 million dollars would represent a large share of that estimated market, which suggests a second kitchen should be justified mainly by expanding into neighboring states rather than by growth within the current three. Before deciding, the company should commission a survey of premium pet food buyers in the target states, since no secondary source measures fresh food spending by state.
Conclusion
Three credible sources produce figures that differ by more than a third, and appraisal shows why: a government household survey, a trade association's retail-based estimate and one company's audited wholesale revenue measure different things. Used carefully, as bounds rather than facts, they support a fresh food market in Copperfield's three states of roughly 50 to 100 million dollars, enough to question a second kitchen without regional expansion.
References
American Pet Products Association. (2025). Industry trends and stats [Data set]. https://americanpetproducts.org/industry-trends-and-stats
Freshpet, Inc. (2025). Annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2024. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&CIK=0001611647&type=10-K
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2025). Consumer expenditure surveys: Average annual expenditures on pets and number of consumer units, 2023-2024 [Data set]. https://www.bls.gov/cex/
Reading the GCU MKT 607 Topic 4 instructions
Topic 4 in MKT-607 asks MBA students to appraise secondary research before using it. Strong appraisals state the question the research must answer, identify the sources found and categorize them by producer, and judge each on method, definition, date and independence. Students should compare figures that disagree and work out whether the difference comes from method or definition, set aside figures that cannot be traced to a method, and use the remaining figures as bounds rather than facts when estimating what the firm needs to know. Undated figures and figures whose producer sells services to entrants deserve particular caution. Estimates built in several steps should be reported as ranges, with each step shown, because uncertainty compounds as figures are scaled down.
How this MKT 607 Topic 4 example is built
The finished example is skeptical about numbers. Each source is examined for who commissioned it, since a market size published by a firm selling into that market has an interest in the answer, and for how the data were collected, because a self selected online panel and a probability sample support different claims. Definitions are checked, as two market size figures frequently differ mainly in what they counted. Dates matter and are reported. The example rejects at least one source with a stated reason, and where it uses a figure with known problems it says so and qualifies the conclusion rather than quoting the number cleanly and hoping nobody checks.
Reading the MKT 607 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward data judged before it is quoted. An Excellent paper appraises a federal survey, a trade association figure and a company's audited filing by producer, method and date. Credit goes to explaining a gap of about 39 billion dollars through definition rather than error. The rubric values noticing the trade association's dating ambiguity and treating its figure as an upper bound. Strong papers set aside commercial summaries with no stated method. Top marks go to a three-state estimate reported as a range, roughly 50 to 100 million dollars, with each step shown. Faculty also value a decision drawn from the appraisal, such as commissioning primary research where no secondary source fits.
Common MKT 607 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Quoting a market figure with no appraisal is the failure this topic addresses, and the drawer line says so: judge the data before quoting it. A second weakness is treating a commercially produced market estimate as neutral, when the producer frequently sells services to firms entering that market. Papers lose marks for presenting two conflicting figures without investigating the discrepancy, since the difference is usually definitional and finding that is the analysis. Undated figures are unusable and quoting them signals the source was not examined. A conclusion stated confidently on evidence the paper itself described as weak contradicts its own appraisal section and is noticed immediately. Sample sizes omitted from survey findings make a reported percentage impossible to weigh.
Get an MKT-607 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the MKT-607 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the market question your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each source judged on producer, method, definition and date, one rejection written out and the conclusion carrying its qualification, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MKT 607 papers and MBA samples
- MKT 607 Topic 1: Value Proposition Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 2: Environmental and Competitor Scan
- MKT 607 Topic 3: Buyer Decision Process Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 5: Segmentation and Positioning Plan
- MKT 607 Topic 6: Product and Life Cycle Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 7: Pricing Strategy Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 8: Channel and Promotion Plan
- MGT 660 Topic 4: Business Level Positioning
- MGT 655 Topic 4: Control Chart Interpretation
- ACC 502 Topic 4: Inventory Method Analysis
- MGT 641 Topic 4: Story Point Estimation Memo
MKT 607 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why do market size estimates disagree so much?
Mostly because they counted different things. One includes adjacent categories another excludes, one counts revenue at retail prices and another at wholesale, one covers a region the other does not. Before concluding that a source is wrong, compare the definitions, since reconciling them usually explains the gap entirely and demonstrates far more than picking whichever figure suits the argument.
Can I use a commercially produced market report?
Yes, with the producer's interest stated. Firms that sell consulting into a market have reason to describe it as large and growing, which does not make the figures wrong but does make them worth checking against something independent. Naming the producer and their position, then using the figure with that qualification, is more credible than either citing it flatly or refusing to use it.
How old is too old for market data?
Depends entirely on how fast the market moves. Demographic data ages slowly and a figure from several years ago may be fine; anything about technology adoption, pricing or competitive share can be stale within a year. State the date every time and say whether the market has changed materially since, which is a judgment your scan from the previous topic should already support.
Where can I find a free MKT 607 Topic 4 sample paper?
Every part of the appraisal appears below: the question, the sources and producers, the appraisal, sources set aside, why the totals disagree, scaling to three states, the decision and the conclusion. Share the research question your course poses and an appraisal follows at no charge.
Why do the two pet spending totals disagree in MKT 607 Topic 4?
The federal survey counts what households report spending. The trade association counts retail sales across all channels, including businesses and insured care, so it measures more.