| Course | PHI 413V Ethical and Spiritual Decision Making in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Principlism case analysis |
| Length | About 1,070 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | RN to BSN |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PHI 413V Topic 4
Day 12 of 42: A Principlism Analysis of a Capable Patient With Endocarditis Who Wants to Leave Before His Antibiotics Are Finished
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
PHI-413V: Ethical and Spiritual Decision Making in Health Care
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Day 12 of 42: A Principlism Analysis of a Capable Patient With Endocarditis Who Wants to Leave Before His Antibiotics Are Finished
The Case
Darnell is a 34-year-old man admitted with infective endocarditis of the mitral valve, caused by Streptococcus bacteria, after two weeks of fever. He has used heroin by injection for six years. He is now on day 12 of a planned 42 days of intravenous antibiotics, his fever has resolved, his blood cultures have been negative for eight days and the cardiologist sees no need for surgery. This morning he told the nurse that he is leaving today. His mother, who raised his two children, had a stroke last week, and the children are staying with a neighbor. The team has said he cannot go home with a central line because of his drug use, and the unit's routine is to discharge him against medical advice without a plan. The four principles of biomedical ethics offer a way to see what is at stake in each direction (Beauchamp & Childress, 2019).
Respect for Autonomy
Autonomy is not simply whatever Darnell says; it depends on whether he can make this decision. Clinicians test capacity on four abilities: grasping what has been disclosed, seeing that it describes one's own situation, weighing the choices against each other and communicating a decision (Appelbaum, 2007). The hospitalist and the nurse assessed each. Darnell can explain in his own words that the infection is on his heart valve and that stopping treatment early could let it return, damage the valve or send an infected clot to his brain. He accepts that these risks apply to him, not only to patients in general. He compares staying with leaving and gives a reason grounded in his own values: his children have no one else. His choice has been the same all day. He has capacity for this decision, which means the refusal in front of the team is his to make, and an unwise choice by a capable adult is still his choice.
Respect for autonomy also requires that his choice be informed, and it is not fully informed yet. No one has told him that there may be an option between staying six weeks and leaving with nothing.
Beneficence and Nonmaleficence
Beneficence asks the team to act for Darnell's good, and nonmaleficence asks it to avoid causing harm. Here the two point in different directions. The greatest benefit would come from completing treatment, because untreated or partly treated endocarditis can relapse, destroy the valve or cause a stroke. Yet the plan the unit is defaulting to, discharge against medical advice with no antibiotics at all, produces the worst outcome of all. Sending him home with a central line could cause a different harm, since the line gives direct access to his bloodstream and could be used for injecting drugs.
There is a middle path supported by evidence. In a randomized trial of 400 adults in stable condition with endocarditis on the left side of the heart, switching to oral antibiotics after at least 10 days of intravenous treatment was noninferior to continuing intravenous treatment; the composite of death, unplanned surgery, embolic events or relapse occurred in 9.0 percent of the oral group and 12.1 percent of the intravenous group (Iversen et al., 2019). Darnell meets the trial's main criteria: his infection is left-sided, caused by a qualifying organism, and he is stable after more than 10 days of treatment. The trial was not built around people who inject drugs, so the transfer is imperfect, but oral treatment with close follow-up would give far more benefit and far less harm than no treatment.
Justice
Justice is the principle most often left out, and it reaches beyond this room. It asks whether Darnell is being treated as other patients would be. A patient with the same infection who did not use drugs would probably have been offered outpatient antibiotics weeks ago, so the unit's default treats his drug use as a reason to offer him less. Justice also concerns the wider system: 30 more days in an acute bed costs the hospital a bed other patients need, and fairness to them is a real consideration, though it should never be the reason for a worse plan for him. Finally, justice asks whether his opioid use disorder is being treated at all. Offering buprenorphine before discharge addresses the condition that caused the infection, and withholding it would leave the root problem untouched.
The Conflict and a Ranking for This Case
The principles conflict most sharply between respect for autonomy, which supports his leaving, and beneficence, which supports completing treatment. For this case, autonomy ranks first, because Darnell has capacity, understands the risk and has a serious reason grounded in duties to his children. Beneficence does not disappear; it changes what the team does next. Rather than asking whether he can leave, the team should ask how to make his leaving as safe as possible: an oral regimen chosen by infectious disease, a first dose before he goes, an appointment within a few days, a phone number to call, buprenorphine started, and a plan for readmission if symptoms return. The resolution costs something. Oral treatment carries more uncertainty for him than the trial showed, and the team has to accept a risk it would not choose.
How Worldviews Would Order the Principles
From a Christian worldview, the ordering follows from two commitments. Darnell bears the image of God (English Standard Version Bible, 2001, Genesis 1:27), so his dignity is not reduced by his addiction, and the command to love one's neighbor, illustrated by the Samaritan who crossed the road to help a man others avoided (English Standard Version Bible, 2001, Luke 10:25-37), pushes beneficence toward practical mercy rather than a signed form. Christianity also respects his responsibility for his own choices and his duty to his family, so it supports honoring his decision while doing everything possible to protect him. A strictly libertarian framework would place autonomy first and stop there, discharging him with his refusal documented. A utilitarian framework would weigh the bed days, the costs of readmission and the harm to his children, and might reach the same practical plan for different reasons. The Christian view differs from both in insisting that the plan must also express care for him as a person, not only respect for his rights or a calculation of outcomes.
References
Appelbaum, P. S. (2007). Assessment of patients' competence to consent to treatment. New England Journal of Medicine, 357(18), 1834-1840. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMcp074045
Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
English Standard Version Bible. (2001). Crossway.
Iversen, K., Ihlemann, N., Gill, S. U., Madsen, T., Elming, H., Jensen, K. T., Bruun, N. E., Høfsten, D. E., Fursted, K., Christensen, J. J., Schultz, M., Klein, C. F., Fosbøll, E. L., Rosenvinge, F., Schønheyder, H. C., Køber, L., Torp-Pedersen, C., Helweg-Larsen, J., Tønder, N., . . . Bundgaard, H. (2019). Partial oral versus intravenous antibiotic treatment of endocarditis. New England Journal of Medicine, 380(5), 415-424. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1808312
Reading the GCU PHI 413V Topic 4 instructions
The Topic 4 instructions in PHI-413V ask students to analyze a clinical case using the four principles of biomedical ethics: respect for autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence and justice. Students identify how each principle applies to the facts, explain where the principles conflict and decide which should take priority in this case and why. Many sections provide a worksheet for organizing the case before the essay. The paper is also expected to consider how the Christian worldview informs the ranking and how another framework might approach the same case differently, with scholarly support in APA format.
How this PHI 413V Topic 4 example is built
The finished example gives each principle a short definition and a long application. Autonomy is not explained in the abstract; it appears as this patient's actual capacity to decide, what they were told and whether the refusal in front of the team is informed. Beneficence and nonmaleficence are handled as competing goods rather than as a pair of synonyms, with the specific harm and the specific benefit named. Justice reaches beyond the room to the other patients, the staffing and what the decision costs elsewhere. The heart of the paper is the conflict: two principles pointing different ways, and a ranking made for this case with reasons. A section explains how the Christian worldview would order them and how another framework would differ. The conclusion says what the resolution costs.
Reading the PHI 413V Topic 4 rubric
The PHI-413V rubric for principlism rewards application over definition. Excellent papers apply each principle to the specific patient, testing capacity for autonomy, naming the concrete benefits and harms, and extending justice beyond the room to fairness and resources. The conflict criterion is met when the student identifies which principles collide and ranks them for this case with reasons, rather than claiming a fixed hierarchy. Credit also goes to a realistic resolution and an honest statement of its cost. The worldview section should explain how Christian commitments shape the ordering and compare at least one other framework.
Common PHI 413V Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Principlism papers lose marks by defining and abandoning. Four paragraphs explaining the principles, followed by a conclusion that respects all of them, leaves the application criterion empty however accurate the definitions are. The second loss is a case with no conflict, chosen because it is easy, which gives the framework nothing to weigh. Papers that assert a fixed ranking as though it were established doctrine misrepresent the approach, since the ordering is argued case by case. Reducing autonomy to whatever the patient said, with no test of capacity or information, is a quiet third leak. Justice disappears most often of the four. The strongest versions state what is sacrificed by the resolution they reach, and do not pretend that a good decision is a costless one.
Get a PHI-413V Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the Topic 4 assignment instructions and the rubric from your PHI-413V classroom, plus the case your section assigns if one is provided. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the four principles weighed against each other and the ranking defended, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free.
More PHI 413V papers and RN to BSN samples
- PHI 413V Topic 1: Worldview Analysis
- PHI 413V Topic 2: Scientism Critique
- PHI 413V Topic 3: PHI-413V Topic 3: Sample Paper, in Real Form
- PHI 413V Topic 5: Ethical Case Analysis
- PHI 413V Topic 6: End of Life Ethics Paper
- PHI 413V Topic 7: Resource Allocation Case
- PHI 413V Topic 8: Personal Worldview Statement
- HLT 362V Topic 4: Confidence Interval Report
- NRS 465 Topic 4: Change Model Application
- NRS 415 Topic 4: Interprofessional Team Analysis
- NRS 460 Topic 4: Care Plan
PHI 413V Topic 4 questions, answered
Is one principle always the most important?
No, and claiming so is a common error. The four are presented as equally binding in principle, with the ordering worked out inside a particular case. Autonomy carries great weight in Western clinical ethics, but a case involving diminished capacity, a public health risk or scarce resources can put another principle ahead of it. Argue your ranking from the facts rather than from a rule.
How does the Christian worldview change the four principles?
It does not replace them, and papers that swap the framework for scripture usually miss the assignment. What a Christian worldview supplies is a reason behind them: a view of human dignity that is not earned, a duty of care to the vulnerable, and limits on what autonomy may demand of others. State that grounding accurately, then show where it would order the principles differently from a purely secular reading.
Can I use a case from my own practice?
Many sections supply the case, and the assignment instructions will say so. Where your own is allowed, remove every identifying detail: no names, no dates, no facility, and change anything that would let a colleague recognize the patient. Real cases carry genuine conflict, which is what the analysis needs, but the obligation to protect the person in it does not end because the paper is for a class.
Where can I find a free PHI 413V Topic 4 sample paper?
This page contains the complete principlism analysis of the endocarditis case, with capacity tested, each principle applied, the conflict ranked and three worldviews compared. A free model built on the case your section assigns is available on request.
Does capacity mean the patient's choice must be followed in PHI 413V Topic 4?
It means the choice is his to make, even if the team thinks it unwise. It does not end the team's duties: the example uses beneficence to build the safest possible plan around his decision instead of discharging him with nothing.