PHI 413V Topic 5 ethical case analysis example

Ethical and Spiritual Decision Making in Health Care Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PHI 413V Topic 5 sample paper is an ethical case analysis of parents who plan to stop their eight-year-old son's insulin after a church healing service. It belongs to GCU PHI 413V, Ethical and Spiritual Decision Making in Health Care, catalog code PHI-413V, a Grand Canyon University course in the RN to BSN program. The medical facts of type 1 diabetes are stated exactly, and the family's position is set out with its theological reasoning from the letter of James before anything is said against it. The paper identifies the ground both sides share, then works through the limits of surrogate decisions, the harm principle and professional guidance on religious refusals for children. A recommendation gives the team the words for the conversation, states the legal limit honestly and names what it costs the family.

CoursePHI 413V Ethical and Spiritual Decision Making in Health Care
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeEthical case analysis
LengthAbout 1,000 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramRN to BSN
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for PHI 413V Topic 5

1

Prayer and Insulin, or Prayer Instead? An Ethical Case Analysis of Parents Who Plan to Stop Their Son's Insulin After a Healing Service

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

PHI-413V: Ethical and Spiritual Decision Making in Health Care

Topic 5 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the choice as the family and the team each see it, which sets up an analysis that takes the family's reasoning seriously and still reaches a recommendation. The family and hospital are composites; the sources are real.
2

Prayer and Insulin, or Prayer Instead? An Ethical Case Analysis of Parents Who Plan to Stop Their Son's Insulin After a Healing Service

The Case and the Medical Facts

Eli is eight years old. Four days ago he arrived in the pediatric emergency department in diabetic ketoacidosis, breathing rapidly and barely responsive, after three weeks of thirst and weight loss. He was treated in intensive care and is now eating, walking and receiving insulin injections before meals and at bedtime. The diagnosis is type 1 diabetes. His pancreas no longer makes insulin and will not recover, so he will need insulin every day for the rest of his life. Without it, ketoacidosis returns within days and is fatal if untreated. With it, children like Eli go to school, play sports and live into old age.

His parents, Aaron and Leah, belong to a small congregation that teaches that healing comes through faith and prayer. They consented to insulin in the intensive care unit because, as Aaron said, Eli was dying and they panicked. Their church is holding a healing service on Sunday. They have told the nurse that after the service they will stop the injections and trust God to finish what He has begun.

The Family's Position, in Their Terms

Aaron and Leah are not neglectful parents, and their position has reasons. They read the letter of James as a promise: the elders are to pray over the sick, and the prayer of faith will save the one who is sick (English Standard Version Bible, 2001, James 5:14-15). In their tradition, continuing medicine after asking God for healing is a sign of doubt, and doubt may be the reason healing does not come. They have seen members of their church recover from illness without doctors and they interpret those recoveries as answered prayer. Their love for Eli is evident; Leah has slept in his room every night. From inside their worldview, stopping insulin is an act of faith for their son, not against him.

What this page is doingThe family's position is set out with its theological reasoning attached, because a paper that reports belief without reasons has already decided the case.
3

Where the Family and the Team Agree

The two sides share more ground than either expects. Both want Eli alive and well. Both believe his life is precious; the parents because God made him, the team because every child's life matters. Both accepted insulin when he was dying, which shows that the parents do not reject medicine absolutely. Both want him home and back in school. And many Christians, including most traditions that pray for healing, see medicine as one of the ways God heals rather than as a rival to prayer. Starting from this agreement changes the conversation from a contest between faith and medicine into a question about how to protect a child both sides love.

The Duties in Play

The nurse and the team owe duties of beneficence and nonmaleficence to Eli, who is the patient, and respect to his parents, who are his surrogate decision makers. Surrogate authority is not the same as an adult's authority over his own body. A competent adult may refuse insulin for himself on religious grounds; a parent's decisions for a child are limited by the child's interests, because the child cannot yet hold or reject the parent's beliefs for himself (Beauchamp & Childress, 2019). One useful threshold for when the state should override parents is the harm principle: intervention is justified when a parental refusal places the child at significant risk of serious harm, the harm is imminent and the refused treatment is effective and clearly more beneficial than the alternative (Diekema, 2004). Stopping insulin for a child with type 1 diabetes meets every part of that threshold.

The record of faith-healing deaths supports the concern. A review of 172 children who died when parents relied on religious ritual instead of medical care found that 140 had conditions for which survival with treatment would have exceeded 90 percent (Asser & Swan, 1998). Professional guidance is clear that religious belief does not permit parents to refuse life-saving treatment for a child, and that clinicians should seek legal authority when necessary (American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Bioethics, 2013).

A Recommendation for the Team

The team should aim for an arrangement in which prayer and insulin continue together, and it should be honest about what will happen if they do not. The conversation should take place before Sunday, with the attending physician, the nurse who knows the family best and, if the parents agree, their pastor or a hospital chaplain. It could begin like this: "We can see how much you love Eli, and we respect your faith. We are not asking you to stop praying. We are asking you to keep giving his insulin while you pray, because without it he will become as sick as he was last week within a few days." The team should then ask what the parents would need to see to feel that insulin and faith can go together, and offer practical help: diabetes teaching, a home health visit in the first week and a daily phone check of his glucose log.

The team must also be truthful. If the parents confirm they will stop insulin, the team is required to report to child protective services and may seek a court order, and saying so plainly is fairer than surprising them later.

What this page is doingThe recommendation gives the words the conversation depends on and states the legal limit in advance, which keeps it both respectful and honest.
4

What the Recommendation Costs

This recommendation asks the family to give up something real. For Aaron and Leah, continuing insulin after the healing service may feel like a failure of faith, and a report or court involvement would bring state oversight into their home and possibly strain their standing in their church. The team gives up something too: it accepts that the family's faith will shape Eli's care, that the pastor may be part of the conversation and that the arrangement depends on trust rather than control. Finding the narrow ground where both can hold is the work of the case, and it is the child's life, not either side's conviction, that decides where that ground lies.

References

American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Bioethics. (2013). Conflicts between religious or spiritual beliefs and pediatric care: Informed refusal, exemptions, and public funding. Pediatrics, 132(5), 962-965. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2013-2716

Asser, S. M., & Swan, R. (1998). Child fatalities from religion-motivated medical neglect. Pediatrics, 101(4), 625-629. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.101.4.625

Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.

Diekema, D. S. (2004). Parental refusals of medical treatment: The harm principle as threshold for state intervention. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 25(4), 243-264. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-004-3146-6

English Standard Version Bible. (2001). Crossway.

PHI 413V Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms

The Topic 5 instructions in PHI-413V ask students to analyze a case in which religious or spiritual beliefs conflict with recommended medical care. Students present the facts, describe the beliefs of the people involved fairly and in their own terms, apply an ethical framework such as the four principles and recommend a course of action. When a child is involved, the analysis should address the limits of parental authority and relevant legal and professional standards. The paper should show respect for the family's worldview while still reaching a defensible conclusion, supported by scholarly and, where relevant, scriptural sources.

How the PHI-413V Topic 5 example is put together

The finished example reads as careful rather than sympathetic. The family's position is set out as they hold it, with the theological reasoning attached, because a paper that reports belief without the reasons behind it has already decided the case. The medical facts are equally exact: what the treatment offers, what the delay costs, what the prognosis is with and without it. Where the parties agree is stated before where they differ, which is usually more ground than either expects. The analysis then works through the duties in play, the limits of surrogate decision making, and what the law and professional codes require when a child is involved. A recommendation follows, addressed to the clinical team, with the wording of the conversation it depends on. The paper says what its recommendation costs the family.

Reading the PHI 413V Topic 5 rubric

Marks on this case analysis go to balance and accuracy. Excellent papers present the family's belief with its reasons, not as an obstacle, and state the medical facts precisely enough that the stakes are clear. The rubric rewards identifying shared ground before disagreement and applying a named framework that does real work in the analysis. Accuracy about the difference between an adult's refusal and a decision made for a child is essential, as is correct use of professional guidance. The highest level reaches a clear recommendation, shows how it would be communicated and says honestly what it costs the people who give ground.

PHI 413V Topic 5 help before you submit

This case loses marks in two opposite directions. Papers that treat the family as obstacles, describing the belief in a clause before moving on to what should obviously be done, fail the requirement to engage a worldview seriously. Papers that sympathize so completely that no recommendation appears fail a different one, because the assignment asks what should happen. The third loss is a case analysis with no framework doing work: sentiment and quotation, with principlism or another named approach mentioned once and dropped. Confusing a competent adult's refusal with a decision made for a child costs accuracy marks, since the standards differ. The strongest versions find the narrow point where a compromise is genuinely possible, and still say what it costs whoever gives ground.

Get a PHI-413V Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the Topic 5 assignment instructions and the rubric from your PHI-413V classroom, along with the case study your section uses. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the family's reasoning and the clinical duty both stated fully before the recommendation, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free.

More PHI 413V papers and RN to BSN samples

PHI 413V Topic 5 questions, answered

Am I supposed to say the family is wrong?

You are supposed to reach a defensible position, which is not the same thing. A strong paper can conclude that the treatment should proceed while holding that the family's reasoning is coherent and sincerely held. What faculty are reading for is whether you understood the position before you argued with it, and whether your conclusion follows from the analysis rather than from your own conviction.

Which framework should I apply to the case?

Whichever your assignment instructions name, and most sections point to the four principles or to a worldview analysis carried forward from earlier topics. Whatever you choose, use one properly rather than three loosely. A paper that applies principlism thoroughly outscores one that mentions principlism, virtue ethics and deontology in a paragraph each and resolves nothing with any of them.

How do I write about a religious tradition I do not belong to?

From its own sources, and carefully. Cite writers inside the tradition rather than summaries written by critics, use the vocabulary its members use, and describe what the belief requires rather than how it appears from outside. If you cannot state the position in a way an adherent would accept, the analysis built on it will not hold, and faculty who know the tradition will see it immediately.

Where can I find a free PHI 413V Topic 5 sample paper?

The complete ethical case analysis is on this page, with the family's reasoning, the shared ground, the harm principle, professional guidance and a recommendation with conversation wording. A model built on your own section's case can be requested free.

Why can parents not refuse insulin in the PHI 413V Topic 5 case?

Because surrogate authority is limited by the child's interests. Stopping insulin in type 1 diabetes places a child at imminent risk of death from an effective, low-burden treatment, which meets the harm principle's threshold for intervention.