| Course | PHI 413V Ethical and Spiritual Decision Making in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Resource allocation case analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | RN to BSN |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PHI 413V Topic 7
Three Courses of Carboplatin, Six Patients: A Resource Allocation Case Applying Five Criteria and a Justice Framework During a Chemotherapy Shortage
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
PHI-413V: Ethical and Spiritual Decision Making in Health Care
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Three Courses of Carboplatin, Six Patients: A Resource Allocation Case Applying Five Criteria and a Justice Framework During a Chemotherapy Shortage
A Shortage That Cannot Be Argued Away
A community cancer center has learned that its supplier cannot deliver carboplatin, a platinum chemotherapy drug, for at least three weeks. After dose rounding and pooling vials between patients, the pharmacy has enough for three full treatment courses next week. Six patients are scheduled to receive it. Shortages of generic cancer drugs have happened repeatedly in the United States, and a national survey of hospital pharmacy managers has documented that hospitals ration drugs during them, often without a formal process (Hantel et al., 2019). The ethics committee has asked the oncology nursing team to help decide who receives the three courses.
The six patients are Ana, 34, receiving curative-intent treatment for ovarian cancer after surgery, midway through six cycles with no equally effective substitute; Mr. Hollis, 66, due to start curative chemoradiation for throat cancer, who cannot take cisplatin because of kidney disease and whose alternative is less effective; Priya, 45, receiving curative-intent treatment for breast cancer before surgery, where carboplatin adds benefit to a regimen that can continue without it; Denise, 52, with ovarian cancer that has returned, for whom carboplatin could extend life by months; Walter, 71, with lung cancer that has spread, whose regimen has a non-platinum alternative with modestly lower benefit; and Mr. Carver, 69, with advanced bladder cancer receiving palliative treatment, whose wife chairs the hospital foundation.
Five Criteria in Their Best Form
Each allocation criterion has a serious case behind it (Persad et al., 2009). Medical urgency gives priority to those who will be harmed soonest without treatment, reflecting the duty to rescue. Expected benefit gives priority to those who will gain the most, measured in chance of cure or years of life, so that a scarce drug does the most good. Waiting time, or first come, first served, respects commitments already made and treats patients as equals in the order they arrived. Age, or a life-years approach, gives priority to younger patients, on the grounds that they have had less of life and stand to lose more. A lottery treats everyone as having an equal claim and removes any human judgment about whose life counts more.
Each criterion also has a weakness. Urgency can favor the sickest even when the drug will not help them much. Expected benefit is hard to measure precisely. First come, first served rewards those who were scheduled earlier, which often reflects access rather than need. Age-based priority can seem to devalue older lives. A lottery ignores real differences in benefit.
Applying Each Criterion to the Six Patients
Applied one at a time, the criteria produce different results. Table 1 shows who would receive the three courses under each rule.
Table 1
Who Receives the Three Courses Under Each Allocation Criterion
| Criterion | Receives carboplatin | Does not receive | Main reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medical urgency | Hollis, Ana, Denise | Priya, Walter, Carver | Treatment windows that close soonest |
| Expected benefit | Ana, Hollis, Priya | Denise, Walter, Carver | Curative intent and lack of an equal substitute |
| First come, first served | Carver, Ana, Walter | Hollis, Priya, Denise | Earliest start dates on the schedule |
| Youngest first | Ana, Priya, Denise | Hollis, Carver, Walter | Life-years at stake |
| Lottery | Any three of six | The other three | Equal chance for all |
The results expose what each rule values. First come, first served would give a course to Mr. Carver and Walter, whose treatment is palliative and has alternatives, while Mr. Hollis, who has a curable cancer and no good substitute, waits three weeks at the start of chemoradiation. Youngest first would treat Denise ahead of Mr. Hollis, although his cancer is curable and hers is not. Expected benefit and urgency agree on Ana and Mr. Hollis, which suggests that their claims are the strongest.
Social Worth, Identified and Rejected
One argument has already been raised informally: that Mr. Carver should be treated because his wife's foundation funds the cancer center. That is a social worth argument, ranking a patient by his value to the institution rather than by his medical need, and it must be rejected. Social worth criteria have a history of discrimination, invite corruption and contradict the equal dignity of every patient. The same reasoning rules out ranking Ana higher because she is a mother or Walter lower because he is retired. Such facts matter to the people involved, but a scarce drug cannot be allocated by them.
A Recommendation Built on Justice
The recommendation combines criteria in a fixed order, as justice frameworks for scarce resources generally advise (Emanuel et al., 2020). First, give priority to curative-intent treatment where no equally effective alternative exists: Ana and Mr. Hollis receive two of the three courses. Second, among the remaining curative-intent patients, give priority to expected benefit: Priya receives the third, because carboplatin raises her chance of cure, whereas for Denise, Walter and Mr. Carver it would extend life without offering cure. Third, Walter and Mr. Carver switch to their non-platinum alternatives now, and Denise is first in line when the next shipment arrives, with her oncologist reviewing whether a short delay changes her plan. If two patients ever stand equal after these steps, a lottery decides.
The process matters as much as the result. Decisions should be made by the committee, not by the treating oncologist at the bedside, using criteria that are published in advance, explained to every affected patient and open to appeal, which is what fair process requires when reasonable people disagree (Daniels, 2000). From a Christian worldview, this approach honors the equal dignity of all six patients and refuses to rank them by worth, while still acting to save the lives that can be saved.
The cost is real. Denise loses weeks of a treatment that could extend her life, and Walter and Mr. Carver receive a regimen that works somewhat less well. The nurses who tell them will carry part of that cost. A just rule does not make the loss smaller; it makes it fair.
References
Daniels, N. (2000). Accountability for reasonableness. BMJ, 321(7272), 1300-1301. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.321.7272.1300
Emanuel, E. J., Persad, G., Upshur, R., Thome, B., Parker, M., Glickman, A., Zhang, C., Boyle, C., Smith, M., & Phillips, J. P. (2020). Fair allocation of scarce medical resources in the time of Covid-19. New England Journal of Medicine, 382(21), 2049-2055. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMsb2005114
Hantel, A., Siegler, M., Hlubocky, F., Colgan, K., & Daugherty, C. K. (2019). Prevalence and severity of rationing during drug shortages: A national survey of health system pharmacists. JAMA Internal Medicine, 179(5), 710-711. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.8251
Persad, G., Wertheimer, A., & Emanuel, E. J. (2009). Principles for allocation of scarce medical interventions. The Lancet, 373(9661), 423-431. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60137-9
What the PHI 413V Topic 7 instructions ask for
The Topic 7 instructions in PHI-413V ask students to analyze a case of scarce medical resources, such as an organ or a limited drug supply, where not everyone who needs treatment can receive it. Students describe the allocation criteria that could be used, evaluate them, apply them to the candidates in the case and recommend how the resource should be distributed. The paper should draw on a justice framework and on the Christian worldview's view of human dignity, and it should avoid allocating by social worth. Scholarly sources on allocation ethics and real allocation policies strengthen the analysis.
How the PHI-413V Topic 7 example is put together
The finished example starts from a shortage that cannot be argued away: one organ and several candidates, or a supply of something a hospital cannot stretch to everyone who needs it. Each allocation criterion is stated in its own best form before it is criticized, so medical urgency, expected benefit, waiting time, age and lottery all get a fair hearing. The example then does the thing that separates strong papers from weak ones and applies each criterion to the named candidates, showing who receives and who does not under each rule. Social worth arguments are identified and rejected with reasons. A justice framework carries the recommendation, and the recommendation is specific enough that someone could act on it.
PHI 413V Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like
The PHI-413V rubric for this case rewards applying criteria rather than listing them. Excellent papers state each criterion fairly, apply it to the named candidates and show the result, so the reader knows who is treated under each rule. Credit goes to identifying and rejecting social worth arguments with reasons, and to a recommendation built on a clear justice framework that someone could act on. The rubric also looks for attention to fair process, such as published criteria and appeals. The highest level connects the analysis to the Christian view of equal dignity and states honestly what the chosen rule costs. A recommendation that treats the losing candidates as an afterthought reads as incomplete.
Common PHI 413V Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them
The commonest loss on this topic is a paper that lists criteria without ever applying them, so the reader never learns who would actually receive the organ. A second is the sympathy essay, where the candidate with the most affecting story wins and the criterion doing the work is never named. Papers also lose marks for smuggling social worth back in through the side door, ranking a candidate higher for being a parent or a provider without defending that as a principle. Accuracy matters as well, since real allocation systems have published criteria and a paper that invents them is arguing about nothing. Strong versions say what their own rule costs and do not pretend the cost is small.
Get a PHI-413V Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the PHI-413V Topic 7 prompt and the rubric posted in your classroom, along with the allocation scenario your section uses. We write a custom example to those criteria, with every rule applied to the actual candidates and the losing party named, and return it inside 24 to 48 hours. Your first one costs nothing.
More PHI 413V papers and RN to BSN samples
- PHI 413V Topic 1: Worldview Analysis
- PHI 413V Topic 2: Scientism Critique
- PHI 413V Topic 3: PHI-413V Topic 3: Sample Paper, in Real Form
- PHI 413V Topic 4: Principlism Analysis
- PHI 413V Topic 5: Ethical Case Analysis
- PHI 413V Topic 6: End of Life Ethics Paper
- PHI 413V Topic 8: Personal Worldview Statement
- HLT 362V Topic 7: Correlation and Regression Analysis
- NRS 465 Topic 7: Evaluation Plan
- NRS 415 Topic 7: Safety Culture Analysis
- NRS 460 Topic 7: Goals of Care Write-up
PHI 413V Topic 7 questions, answered
Is there a right answer to the allocation case?
There is no single answer faculty are holding, but there are wrong ones. A paper that allocates by social contribution, or that reaches no decision at all, will be marked down whatever its prose is like. What faculty are marking is whether you adopted a defensible principle, applied it consistently to every candidate, and admitted what it cost the people it excluded.
Can I use a real organ allocation policy?
Yes, and it usually strengthens the paper. Published criteria from a national allocation system give you something concrete to analyze rather than a principle you invented, and they show faculty you looked. Cite the policy properly, state the year, and be careful that you are describing the criteria as they stand rather than as a news article characterized them.
Where does the Christian worldview fit in a scarcity case?
Usually in how the paper values the candidates before it ranks them. A tradition holding that every person carries the same worth rules out some criteria immediately, contribution and social standing among them, while leaving medical urgency and expected benefit open. Say which of your commitments does that work, because a worldview mentioned in the introduction and never used again earns nothing.
Where can I find a free PHI 413V Topic 7 sample paper?
The complete allocation case is on this page, with five criteria applied to six named patients, the social worth argument rejected and a justice-based recommendation with its process and cost. Request a free model for the case in your own section.
Why not use first come, first served in PHI 413V Topic 7?
Because in the example it would treat two patients whose therapy is palliative and has alternatives, while a patient with a curable cancer and no good substitute waits. Arrival order often reflects access to care rather than need or benefit.