| Course | PSY 102 General Psychology |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Research method comparison |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Psychology |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY 102 Topic 1
Does Music With Lyrics Hurt Reading Comprehension? Comparing a Survey, an Experiment and Observation on One Claim
[Author Name]
College of Humanities and Social Sciences, Grand Canyon University
PSY-102: General Psychology
Topic 1 Research Method Comparison
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Does Music With Lyrics Hurt Reading Comprehension? Comparing a Survey, an Experiment and Observation on One Claim
The Claim in Testable Form
Many students study with music playing, and many have heard that it hurts their concentration. As stated, the claim that music is bad for studying cannot be tested, because music, bad and studying could each mean many things. A testable version names each part. This paper uses the following: students who read a textbook passage while hearing music with lyrics answer fewer comprehension questions correctly than students who read the same passage in silence. That version names the kind of music, the task, the outcome and the comparison, so a study could show it to be false. The paper then asks what three research designs, a survey, an experiment and naturalistic observation, could each establish about it, and chooses the one that could actually decide the question.
What a Survey Would Collect
A survey could ask several hundred students how often they study with music, what kind of music and what grades they earn. It would be quick and cheap, and it could reach many students. It might show that students who report studying with lyrical music have lower grades on average.
That result would leave the main question undecided. A survey measures an association, and an association between two variables does not show that one causes the other (Myers & DeWall, 2018). Students who study with music might differ in other ways: they might study in busier places, study less overall or take different courses. Any of those could explain lower grades. The direction could even run the other way, if students who find reading hard turn to music to make it bearable. Self-reports add another weakness, since students may not remember accurately how often they study with music or may describe their habits as they wish they were.
What an Experiment Would Require
An experiment would manipulate the one thing the claim is about and hold everything else constant. Students would be randomly assigned to read the same passage either while hearing a song with lyrics or in silence, in the same room, for the same length of time, and then answer the same questions. Random assignment matters most: it makes the two groups alike, on average, in reading ability, interest and every other characteristic, so a difference in scores can be attributed to the music. Shadish et al. (2002) explained that this is what allows an experiment to support a causal conclusion that a survey cannot.
Studies of this kind have been done. Perham and Currie (2014) had participants read passages under several sound conditions and found that comprehension was poorer with music containing lyrics than in quiet, whether or not participants liked the music. An experiment would still leave something undecided: whether the effect holds in real studying, where students choose their own music, take breaks and read over hours rather than minutes.
What Observation Could Record
Naturalistic observation would watch students studying in a library or dormitory without interfering, recording who wore headphones, how long they read and how often they looked away. It would capture real behavior in real settings, which neither of the other designs does. But observers could not tell what music each student heard or measure comprehension without interrupting. Observation would show how students actually study, which is useful for designing a realistic experiment, but it could not test the claim.
Comparing the Three
Each design answers a different question.
Table 1
What Each Design Could Establish About the Claim
| Design | What it could show | What it would leave undecided |
|---|---|---|
| Survey | Whether studying with lyrical music is associated with lower grades | Cause, direction, accuracy of self-report |
| Experiment | Whether lyrical music lowers comprehension under controlled conditions | Whether the effect holds in everyday studying |
| Observation | How students actually study with music | Any effect on comprehension |
Practical and Ethical Points
Each design also raises practical questions. A survey is easy to run but depends on honest answers, so it would need to be anonymous. An experiment needs a quiet room, a set of passages of equal difficulty and enough participants for each condition; it also needs consent, since participants should know they are taking part in a study, even if they are not told which condition is expected to do worse until afterward. Observation in public places such as libraries is usually acceptable without consent, because people there have no expectation of privacy, but recording what individual students are doing on their screens would not be.
Could the Designs Be Combined?
The three designs are not rivals so much as steps. Observation could show what music and study conditions are typical. An experiment could then test whether lyrical music lowers comprehension under those conditions. A survey could follow, asking whether students who learn about the result change their habits. Psychology often builds evidence this way, with each design covering what the others miss. For this paper, however, the question is which single design could decide the claim as stated.
The Design Chosen
The experiment is the design that can decide the question, because the claim is causal: it says music with lyrics lowers comprehension. Only random assignment and control can separate the music's effect from everything else that differs between students. The trade it accepts is realism. A twenty-minute session in a quiet room is not a semester of studying, so a positive result would show that lyrics can impair reading comprehension, not how much they matter in a student's actual grades. A short period of observation beforehand could make the experiment more realistic, for example by using the kinds of music and the reading lengths students actually choose.
The result that would count against the claim is clear. If students reading with lyrical music answered as many questions correctly as students reading in silence, across several passages and with enough participants to detect a modest difference, the claim would not be supported.
References
Myers, D. G., & DeWall, C. N. (2018). Psychology (12th ed.). Worth.
Perham, N., & Currie, H. (2014). Does listening to preferred music improve reading comprehension performance? Applied Cognitive Psychology, 28(2), 279-284. https://doi.org/10.1002/acp.2994
Shadish, W. R., Cook, T. D., & Campbell, D. T. (2002). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Houghton Mifflin.
What the PSY 102 Topic 1 instructions ask for
Topic 1 in PSY-102 asks students to compare research methods by applying them to a single claim about behavior. Strong papers first restate the claim in testable form, naming what is manipulated, what is measured and what is compared. Students should then show what a survey, an experiment and naturalistic observation would each collect, what each could establish and what each would leave undecided, treating the limits of correlation as a practical constraint on one design. The paper should choose the design that could actually decide the claim, state the trade-off it accepts and name the result that would count against the claim. Examples from student life are welcome, but the argument must rest on what each design can and cannot show.
Inside the PSY 102 Topic 1 example
The finished example is a comparison ending in a verdict rather than a survey of methods in general. It states the claim in testable form first, since a vague version can be supported by almost anything. Each design is then applied to that same claim: what a survey would collect, what an experiment would have to manipulate and hold constant, what watching without interference could record. The example says what each option would leave undecided, which is where the comparison earns its marks. The limit on inferring cause from association appears as a practical constraint on one design rather than as a definition recited early. A closing paragraph names the design chosen, the trade it accepts, and the result that would count against the claim.
PSY 102 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward methods compared on one claim, not described in general. An Excellent paper makes the music claim testable before applying any design. Credit goes to showing what a survey would leave undecided, citing Myers and DeWall on correlation, and what random assignment adds, after Shadish, Cook and Campbell. The rubric values Perham and Currie's experiment as evidence and a table of what each design shows. Strong papers address consent and how designs combine. Top marks go to choosing the experiment and naming the result that would refute the claim. Papers that crown the experiment without naming its cost in realism lose credit.
Common PSY 102 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Marks go to the difference between what a study could show and what the writer already believes, and that is where thin versions collapse. A paper arguing from a personal anecdote has supplied an illustration where the criteria wanted a finding, and confident phrasing does not repair it. Definitions of each method copied out in order, with the claim never touched, produce a glossary instead of a comparison. Reading an association as a demonstrated cause is the most reliable single way to lose points on an opening topic. Comparisons that praise the experiment without naming what it would have to control are describing a preference. Versions reaching no verdict hand the marker three summaries and no argument.
Get a PSY-102 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send us the PSY-102 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, along with the claim your section assigned. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the claim made testable, each design applied to it and a defended verdict at the end, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More PSY 102 papers and BS in Psychology samples
- PSY 102 Topic 2: Biological Explanation Paper
- PSY 102 Topic 3: Conditioning Case Analysis
- PSY 102 Topic 4: Memory Research Summary
- PSY 102 Topic 5: Research Ethics Critique
- PSY 102 Topic 6: Trait Measurement Review
- PSY 102 Topic 7: Criteria Application Paper
- PSY 102 Topic 8: Discussion Question Response
- PSY 352 Topic 1: Biopsychosocial Analysis
- PSY 470 Topic 1: Disorder Definition Essay
- PSY 357 Topic 1: Nature and Nurture Analysis
- PSY 380 Topic 1: Descriptive Statistics Exercise
PSY 102 Topic 1 questions, answered
Why not just argue from experience?
Because experience cannot tell you what would have happened otherwise. Somebody certain that a new habit sharpened their concentration has no comparison group, no measure taken beforehand, and no way to rule out everything else that changed in the same period. The topic is asking for a design that answers those objections, which is what separates a finding from an impression.
Can an experiment answer any question?
No, and the comparison is expected to say where experiments stop. Variables that cannot be assigned without harming somebody, and variables people arrive with such as age or history, sit outside experimental control. Those questions get studied by other means and yield weaker causal claims, which is a limit worth stating in the paper rather than a gap to conceal.
How much detail does a method description need?
Enough for a reader to watch it being applied to your claim. Naming the sample, what gets measured, what is compared and what is held steady does more work than a paragraph defining the method in general. Markers are looking for the design in use, and generic definitions read as material that arrived from somewhere other than your own thinking.
Where can I find a free PSY 102 Topic 1 sample paper?
The method comparison is shown here complete: the claim made testable, the survey, the experiment, observation, practical and ethical points, combining designs and the design chosen. Post your PSY 102 Topic 1 prompt and get a free comparison.
Why does random assignment matter in PSY 102 Topic 1?
It makes the music and silence groups alike on average in reading ability, interest and everything else. A difference in scores can then be credited to the music rather than to who chose it.