| Course | PSY 470 Abnormal Psychology |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Disorder definition essay |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Psychology |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY 470 Topic 1
When Does Grief Become a Disorder? Testing Four Definitions of Abnormality on One Pattern of Mourning
[Author Name]
College of Humanities and Social Sciences, Grand Canyon University
PSY-470: Abnormal Psychology
Topic 1 Disorder Definition Essay
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
When Does Grief Become a Disorder? Testing Four Definitions of Abnormality on One Pattern of Mourning
One Pattern, Described Concretely
Definitions of abnormality are easiest to compare when they are applied to the same behavior. This essay uses one pattern, described concretely enough that a definition cannot be satisfied by vagueness. Sam, a composite 68-year-old built for this exercise, lost a spouse of forty years to a sudden heart attack fourteen months ago. Sam still sets two places at the dinner table most evenings, cries for an hour or more nearly every day, spends much of each afternoon looking through photographs and finds the thought of the spouse filling most waking hours. Sam has stopped attending a weekly bridge group, rarely answers calls from adult children and says that life feels meaningless without the spouse. Sam sleeps poorly, has lost about twelve pounds and has not returned to part-time volunteering at a library. The pattern is applied below to four candidate definitions of abnormality.
Statistical Rarity
By a statistical definition, behavior is abnormal if it is rare. Most bereaved people experience intense grief that gradually eases over the first year, and the proportion who remain intensely preoccupied and impaired beyond a year is small. Shear (2015) described such persistent, impairing grief as affecting a minority of bereaved people. On this definition, Sam's grief at fourteen months is abnormal because it is uncommon.
The definition has an obvious weakness: rarity is not the same as disorder. Exceptional resilience, an unusually quick return to ordinary life after a death, is also rare, and no one would call it a disorder. Rarity alone cannot distinguish a problem from a difference.
Violation of Social Expectation
By a social definition, behavior is abnormal if it violates what a community expects. Expectations about mourning differ greatly. In some communities, a year of formal mourning with restricted social life is expected; in others, a widowed person is expected to resume ordinary activities within weeks. Setting a place for the dead at meals is part of customary practice in some traditions and would be unremarkable there. On this definition, whether Sam's grief is abnormal depends on Sam's community, and the same behavior could be normal in one setting and abnormal in another. The current diagnostic manual recognizes this by requiring that, for prolonged grief to be considered a disorder, its duration and severity clearly exceed the social, cultural or religious norms of the person's setting (American Psychiatric Association, 2022).
Personal Suffering
By a suffering definition, behavior is abnormal if it causes the person distress. Sam is clearly suffering: daily crying, a sense that life is meaningless and loneliness. But all grief involves suffering. A definition that counts suffering as abnormality would make all mourning a disorder, which would be absurd; grief is the expected response to loss. The suffering definition also misses people who cause harm without distress to themselves.
Interference With Functioning
By a functional definition, behavior is abnormal if it interferes with work, sleep, study or relationships. Sam's grief interferes in several ways: Sam has withdrawn from friends and family, given up volunteering, sleeps poorly and has lost weight. Fourteen months after the death, those are significant changes in daily life. On this definition Sam's pattern looks abnormal, though the definition does not say how much interference, for how long, is too much.
Where the Definitions Disagree
The definitions disagree, and that disagreement is the point.
Table 1
Four Definitions Applied to One Pattern of Mourning
| Definition | Applied to Sam | Verdict | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Statistical rarity | Persistent impairing grief is uncommon | Abnormal | Rare strengths are also unusual |
| Violation of social expectation | Depends on the community's mourning norms | Depends on setting | Makes disorder relative to custom |
| Personal suffering | Daily crying, meaninglessness | Abnormal, but so is all grief | Cannot separate grief from disorder |
| Interference with functioning | Withdrawal, lost roles, poor sleep, weight loss | Abnormal | Gives no threshold |
Person or Setting?
The definitions also raise the question whether the difficulty sits in the person or in the setting. Sam lives alone in a house shared with the spouse for decades, in a town where both had many joint friends. Each room and each friend recalls the loss. Someone in the same state who moved near family, or whose community offered structured mourning rituals and ongoing support, might grieve differently. Part of what keeps Sam's grief intense may be the setting rather than anything in Sam.
Why the Disagreement Matters
The disagreement is not academic. If grief that lasts beyond a year is labeled a disorder, people like Sam may gain access to treatment that helps, and Shear (2015) reported that targeted treatment for persistent grief can reduce symptoms. But the label also risks treating normal sorrow as illness, implying that a person who still mourns a forty-year marriage after a year is grieving incorrectly. Each definition draws that line in a different place, and where the line falls determines who is offered help and who is told their grief is a problem.
A Definition, and What It Includes
This essay settles on a version of the harmful dysfunction definition Wakefield (1992) proposed: a condition is a disorder when some internal mechanism fails to perform the function it was shaped to perform, and that failure causes harm as judged by the person's social values. Grief is the normal operation of attachment responding to loss; it becomes disordered only when the processes that usually allow a person to adapt to loss appear not to be working, so that grief remains intense and impairing well beyond what the person's community would expect. That definition includes persistent, impairing grief that exceeds local norms. It excludes ordinary grief, however painful, and it excludes mourning practices that look unusual from outside but are customary within a community.
Whether Sam's pattern meets that definition cannot be settled in a course essay. That would require a qualified clinician who knows Sam, Sam's history and Sam's community. This essay diagnoses no one.
References
American Psychiatric Association. (2022). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed., text rev.). American Psychiatric Publishing. https://www.psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/practice/dsm
Shear, M. K. (2015). Complicated grief. New England Journal of Medicine, 372(2), 153-160. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMcp1315618
Wakefield, J. C. (1992). The concept of mental disorder: On the boundary between biological facts and social values. American Psychologist, 47(3), 373-388. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.47.3.373
The PSY-470 Topic 1 assignment instructions
Topic 1 in PSY-470 asks students to argue over how abnormality should be defined. Strong essays describe one pattern of behavior concretely, including how often it occurs and what it costs the person, so that no definition can be satisfied by vagueness. Students should apply each candidate definition, statistical rarity, violation of social expectation, personal suffering and interference with functioning, and report where they disagree, since that disagreement is the point. The essay should ask whether the difficulty sits in the person or the setting, then settle on one definition, name what it includes and excludes and diagnose nobody. Writing about someone the student knows is best avoided, since a familiar case arrives with gaps filled from memory and affection.
Inside the PSY 470 Topic 1 example
The finished essay argues over a single pattern of behavior rather than surveying definitions of abnormality. It describes the pattern concretely, including how often it occurs and what it costs the person, because a vague sketch can be made to satisfy any definition. Each candidate definition is then applied: statistical rarity, violation of a social expectation, personal suffering, and interference with work, sleep, study or relationships. The essay reports where the definitions disagree, since that disagreement is the point of the topic. It asks whether the difficulty sits in the person or in the setting they are in. It closes on one definition, names what that choice includes and excludes, and diagnoses nobody.
Where the marks sit in the PSY 470 Topic 1 rubric
Faculty reward definitions tested on one concrete pattern. An Excellent essay describes the composite's daily crying, withdrawal and lost roles before applying any definition. Credit goes to showing rarity flags strengths too, social expectation varies by community, and suffering cannot separate grief from disorder, citing Shear and the manual's norm requirement, in a table. The rubric values asking whether the setting sustains the grief and why the disagreement matters for who gets help. Strong essays choose Wakefield's harmful dysfunction definition. Top marks go to stating what it includes and excludes and diagnosing no one.
Common PSY 470 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Marks go to the application, so an essay defining four standards and applying none of them has produced a glossary. Treating unusual behavior as disordered by itself repeats the error the topic was built to expose, since a great deal of rare behavior harms nobody and interferes with nothing. Essays that never ask about the setting turn a reasonable response to a bad situation into a condition, which is the failure with the most serious consequences outside a classroom. Announcing that the pattern is or is not a disorder in the opening paragraph reverses the reasoning, because everything afterward becomes defense of a verdict already reached. Writing about a named real person, or drifting into advice for one, abandons the analytical task entirely.
Get a PSY-470 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send us the PSY-470 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, together with the behavior or scenario your section named. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the pattern described first, every standard applied to it and a defended choice at the end, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More PSY 470 papers and BS in Psychology samples
- PSY 470 Topic 2: Classification System Critique
- PSY 470 Topic 3: Levels of Explanation Paper
- PSY 470 Topic 4: Treatment Evidence Review
- PSY 470 Topic 5: Cultural Boundary Analysis
- PSY 470 Topic 6: Comorbidity Analysis
- PSY 470 Topic 7: Stigma Discussion Response
- PSY 470 Topic 8: Case Formulation Paper
- PSY 102 Topic 1: Research Method Comparison
- PSY 380 Topic 1: Descriptive Statistics Exercise
- PSY 352 Topic 1: Biopsychosocial Analysis
- PSY 357 Topic 1: Nature and Nurture Analysis
PSY 470 Topic 1 questions, answered
Is unusual behavior the same as disordered behavior?
No, and the gap between them is most of this topic. Plenty of rare behavior costs nobody anything, while some very common patterns cause real suffering and interfere with work or sleep. An essay resting on rarity alone ends up calling eccentricity a disorder and calling widespread difficulty normal, which is why the other standards exist.
Does the essay have to reach one definition?
It has to reach a defended position, which is not the same as pretending the standards agree. Saying that impairment carries this case while social deviation would have misclassified it is a stronger finish than a summary treating all four as equally useful. The criteria reward a choice that names what it leaves out.
Can I write about someone I know?
Better not. Beyond writing about another person's health without their agreement, a familiar case arrives with gaps you will fill from memory and affection, and the essay stops being an application of standards. Build a composite instead, keep every identifying detail out, and remember that nothing on this page or in your paper assesses any actual person.
Where can I find a free PSY 470 Topic 1 sample paper?
The definition essay is shown here complete: one pattern described, four definitions applied, where they disagree, person or setting, why it matters and a defended definition. Send your PSY 470 Topic 1 prompt and a essay follows free.
Why does suffering fail as a definition in PSY 470 Topic 1?
All grief involves suffering, so a suffering definition would make every mourner disordered. It cannot separate an expected response to loss from a problem.