| Course | PSY 470 Abnormal Psychology |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Cultural boundary analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Psychology |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY 470 Topic 5
Hearing a Voice That Others Do Not: Testing One Criterion Against Specific Settings
[Author Name]
College of Humanities and Social Sciences, Grand Canyon University
PSY-470: Abnormal Psychology
Topic 5 Cultural Boundary Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Hearing a Voice That Others Do Not: Testing One Criterion Against Specific Settings
One Criterion, Specific Settings
Discussions of culture and abnormality often stay abstract. This analysis tests one criterion against specific settings: hearing a voice that other people do not hear, which diagnostic systems treat as a hallucination and, in the right context, as a possible symptom of a psychotic disorder. The question is whether that experience means the same thing everywhere, and where the relativist answer, that it depends entirely on the setting, reaches its limit.
Voices After Bereavement
The first setting is bereavement in a community of widowed adults. Rees (1971) interviewed nearly 300 widowed people in mid-Wales and found that almost half reported experiences of the dead spouse after the death: sensing their presence, seeing them or, less often, hearing them speak. Most found these experiences helpful, few had told anyone, and the experiences were not associated with signs of mental illness. In that setting, hearing a dead spouse's voice was a common part of grief, not a symptom.
The criterion for psychosis, applied without context, would count such a voice as a hallucination. Diagnostic guidance itself recognizes the limit, noting that experiences such as briefly hearing a dead relative speak while mourning may be normal and should not be counted as psychotic symptoms when they are part of an accepted response in the person's setting.
Voices Heard by People With Psychosis, in Three Places
The second setting is psychosis itself. Luhrmann et al. (2015) interviewed people diagnosed with schizophrenia who heard voices in three places: San Mateo in California, Chennai in India and Accra in Ghana. The diagnosis was similar, but the experience of the voices differed. Participants in California more often described their voices as harsh, violent and intrusive, as symptoms of an illness and as unwelcome. Participants in Chennai more often heard the voices of relatives, sometimes giving practical advice or scolding them in the way family members might. Participants in Accra more often described voices as spiritual, sometimes as God speaking, and several described their voices as mostly positive.
The study suggests that what a voice says, how a person relates to it and how much distress it causes are shaped by the setting, including whether the culture treats the mind as a private, bounded space or as more open to others' influence. That is ethnographic evidence, gathered by interview, not an assertion about cultures.
Where Instruments Were Developed
The instruments used to assess voices and psychosis were largely developed and validated in North America and Western Europe, on samples from those settings. Their items often assume that a voice is unwanted and distressing, and their scoring may count as symptomatic an experience a person in another setting finds ordinary or meaningful. An instrument validated on one population can misclassify people in another if it treats a culturally accepted experience as a symptom, or if it misses distress expressed in local terms. Kleinman (1988) argued that psychiatric categories developed in one culture can be applied elsewhere as if universal, producing what Kleinman called a category fallacy, when the category may not fit the experience.
Table 1
The Same Criterion Across Four Settings
| Setting | Experience | Usual meaning there | Distress |
|---|---|---|---|
| Widowed adults in mid-Wales (Rees, 1971) | Hearing or sensing a dead spouse | Part of grief; often comforting | Low |
| People with psychosis in California (Luhrmann et al., 2015) | Harsh, intrusive voices | Symptom of illness | High |
| People with psychosis in Chennai | Voices of relatives, sometimes advice | Relationships, sometimes troubling | Mixed |
| People with psychosis in Accra | Voices often spiritual, some positive | Spiritual communication | Mixed to low |
The Limit of the Relativist Position
The relativist position has a limit. Some patterns cause suffering wherever they appear. Every participant in the three-site study had serious psychotic illness (Luhrmann et al., 2015), and many in each setting experienced distress and disruption to their lives; culture shaped the content and meaning of their voices, but did not make the illness disappear. Voices that command a person to harm themselves, or that bring terror and prevent sleep and work, cause suffering in any community. The cultural point is not that nothing is abnormal anywhere; it is that the same experience must be understood in its setting before it can be judged.
Implications for Assessment
For a clinician meeting someone who hears voices, the analysis suggests several questions before any judgment. What does the voice say, and whose voice is it? How does the person understand it, and how do others in their community understand such experiences? Does it bring comfort, guidance, fear or commands? Is it accompanied by other changes, such as disorganized thinking, withdrawal or a decline in daily functioning? And is the person distressed by it, or are others? An interpreter or cultural consultant may be needed when the clinician does not share the person's background. The same voice can lead to very different conclusions depending on these answers.
What Is Shared Across Settings
Some features appear common across settings even as meanings differ. At all three sites, voices were heard as real and as coming from outside the self in all three places, and people in all three struggled with them at times (Luhrmann et al., 2015). That shared core supports the view that voice-hearing in psychosis reflects something more than cultural expectation, while the variation shows how much of the experience a culture shapes.
What the Analysis Concludes
Hearing a voice others do not hear is not, by itself, a sign of disorder. In bereavement in some settings it is common and comforting. In psychosis, its content and the distress it brings vary with the setting. A criterion that treats every such voice as a symptom will mislabel some people, and instruments developed in one place need testing before use in another. But culture does not remove suffering, and the criterion remains useful when applied with attention to the setting and to whether the experience harms the person. Throughout, the people who hear voices come before their symptoms; no real community member is described here.
References
Kleinman, A. (1988). Rethinking psychiatry: From cultural category to personal experience. Free Press.
Luhrmann, T. M., Padmavati, R., Tharoor, H., & Osei, A. (2015). Differences in voice-hearing experiences of people with psychosis in the USA, India and Ghana: Interview-based study. British Journal of Psychiatry, 206(1), 41-44. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.bp.113.139048
Rees, W. D. (1971). The hallucinations of widowhood. British Medical Journal, 4(5778), 37-41. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.4.5778.37
What the PSY 470 Topic 5 instructions ask for
Topic 5 in PSY-470 asks students to analyze how culture shapes the boundary of disorder. Strong analyses work with specific settings and a specific criterion rather than culture as an abstraction, reporting what counts as expected experience there through ethnographic or epidemiological work. Students should test one criterion against those settings, examine where assessment instruments were developed and validated, and mark the limit of the relativist position, since some patterns cause suffering wherever they appear. Every description should keep people ahead of their symptoms and identify no real community member. Communities a student does not belong to should be described through cited scholarship, never through stereotype or secondhand impression, and idioms of distress should be reported in the community's own terms.
How this PSY 470 Topic 5 example is built
The finished analysis works with a specific community and a specific criterion rather than with culture as an abstraction. It reports what counts as expected conduct in that setting, citing ethnographic or epidemiological work instead of asserting it. One criterion is then tested: a belief widely held in a community, a form of grief with a customary length, or an experience of hearing a voice that carries an accepted meaning locally. Instruments are examined for where they were developed and on whom they were validated. The analysis also marks the limit of the relativist position, since some patterns cause suffering wherever they appear. Every description keeps people ahead of their symptoms and identifies no real community member.
Reading the PSY 470 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward one criterion tested in named settings. An Excellent analysis reports Rees on widowed adults in mid-Wales and Luhrmann and colleagues on voices in California, Chennai and Accra. Credit goes to a table of experience, meaning and distress across settings and to examining where instruments were validated, with Kleinman's category fallacy. The rubric values questions a clinician would ask and a shared core across sites. Strong analyses mark the relativist limit, since voices commanding harm cause suffering anywhere. Top marks go to keeping people ahead of symptoms throughout.
PSY 470 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Analyses lose marks by treating culture as a country, so a paper naming a nation and describing its people as one mind has not identified any expectation a criterion could meet. Asserting local norms without a source turns fieldwork into anecdote. The strongest versions notice both directions of error, and papers covering only the over-recorded case miss the person whose distress went unnoticed because it arrived in the wrong vocabulary. Concluding that all diagnosis is a social invention overshoots the evidence and leaves nothing to say about somebody who is genuinely suffering. Instruments accepted as neutral because they are widely used skip the question the topic is built around. Writing that presents another community as exotic reads badly and is marked accordingly.
Get a PSY-470 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send us the PSY-470 Topic 5 instructions, your classroom rubric and the community, syndrome or instrument your section named. A custom example arrives written to those criteria, with the setting sourced, one criterion tested in both directions, and the limit of the cultural argument stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More PSY 470 papers and BS in Psychology samples
- PSY 470 Topic 1: Disorder Definition Essay
- PSY 470 Topic 2: Classification System Critique
- PSY 470 Topic 3: Levels of Explanation Paper
- PSY 470 Topic 4: Treatment Evidence Review
- PSY 470 Topic 6: Comorbidity Analysis
- PSY 470 Topic 7: Stigma Discussion Response
- PSY 470 Topic 8: Case Formulation Paper
- PSY 102 Topic 5: Research Ethics Critique
- PSY 380 Topic 5: P Value Interpretation
- PSY 352 Topic 5: Health Message Critique
- PSY 357 Topic 5: Research Design Critique
PSY 470 Topic 5 questions, answered
Does culture decide what counts as a disorder?
It shapes the boundary without erasing it. What a community treats as expected conduct changes which behavior draws attention, how distress gets described and whether anyone reaches a clinician at all. Suffering and interference with daily life still occur across very different settings, so an analysis concluding that the category is purely a local invention has run past its own evidence.
What is an idiom of distress?
A customary way of expressing suffering within a community, which may be bodily, spiritual or relational rather than emotional in the terms a checklist expects. Somebody reporting heat in the head, or a burden placed on them, is describing something real in the vocabulary available to them. Papers noting this handle the under-recorded direction most markers are looking for.
How do I write about a community I do not belong to?
Through cited scholarship, and with people described as people. Report what researchers who worked in that setting found, attribute every claim, and avoid presenting a way of life as strange or picturesque. Composite examples keep any individual unidentifiable. A paper that would embarrass somebody from the community if they read it has a problem no citation repairs.
Where can I find a free PSY 470 Topic 5 sample paper?
The cultural analysis is shown here complete: one criterion, voices after bereavement, voices in psychosis in three places, where instruments were developed, assessment questions, shared features, the relativist limit and conclusions. Post your PSY 470 Topic 5 prompt and get a free analysis.
Is hearing a dead spouse's voice a symptom in PSY 470 Topic 5?
Not by itself. Among widowed adults it is common and often comforting, and diagnostic guidance treats such experiences as normal when they fit accepted mourning in the person's setting.