| Course | PSY 352 Health Psychology |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Health message critique |
| Length | About 960 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Psychology |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY 352 Topic 5
Knowing Is Not Doing: Critiquing a Fear-Based Message About Sugary Drinks and Type 2 Diabetes
[Author Name]
College of Humanities and Social Sciences, Grand Canyon University
PSY-352: Health Psychology
Topic 5 Health Message Critique
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Knowing Is Not Doing: Critiquing a Fear-Based Message About Sugary Drinks and Type 2 Diabetes
The Message
The message examined here is a composite public health poster, of a kind many city health departments have used. It shows a soda bottle pouring out a stream of sugar cubes beside a photograph of a foot with a bandaged amputation wound. The headline reads: Drinking soda every day can lead to type 2 diabetes. Diabetes can cost you your feet. Below, in smaller type, it lists the number of sugar cubes in a typical bottle. The poster was placed on buses and bus shelters in neighborhoods with high rates of diabetes and aimed at adults who drink sugary beverages daily. The behavior it seeks to move is reducing daily consumption of sugary drinks.
The Assumption Underneath
The poster assumes that people who drink sugary beverages daily either do not know they are linked to diabetes or do not appreciate how serious diabetes is, and that once they know, they will drink less. It is an information-and-fear message: it supplies a fact and a frightening image and expects behavior to follow. This critique examines that assumption against what research on health communication reports. The assumption is common because it is intuitive: if a behavior is harmful, telling people about the harm seems like the obvious response, and posters are cheap to produce and easy to count.
Awareness Is Usually High Already
The first problem is that the information is not new to most of the audience. In neighborhoods with high rates of diabetes, many residents have family members with the condition, and most adults have heard that sugary drinks are unhealthy. A message that tells people what they already know cannot change behavior by informing them. If awareness were the obstacle, the high awareness that already exists would have produced the change. The persistence of daily consumption despite that awareness suggests the obstacles lie elsewhere.
Fear Without a Workable Action
The second problem is the fear. Research on fear appeals distinguishes between the threat a message conveys and the efficacy it offers, meaning whether the audience believes there is something they can do and that they are able to do it. Witte and Allen (2000) combined studies and found that strong fear appeals increased behavior change mainly when accompanied by strong efficacy messages; when threat was high and efficacy low, people tended to respond defensively, avoiding or dismissing the message rather than acting on it. Peters et al. (2013) reanalyzed the evidence and concluded that threatening information worked only when people's efficacy was high; otherwise it had no effect or backfired.
Table 1
The Message's Assumptions Against the Research
| Assumption in the message | What research reports | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| People lack the information | Awareness is usually high in the audience | Information adds little |
| Fear will motivate change | Fear helps only with high efficacy (Witte & Allen, 2000; Peters et al., 2013) | Threat without action invites avoidance |
| Knowing leads to doing | Intention change produces smaller behavior change (Webb & Sheeran, 2006) | Gap between knowing and doing remains |
| Behavior is a matter of choice alone | Access, habit and cost shape consumption | Environment unaddressed |
The poster conveys high threat, an amputated foot, and offers no action at all. It does not say what to drink instead, how to cut down or where to find help. For a person who drinks two sodas a day, enjoys them and does not know how to stop, the image is more likely to prompt looking away than changing course. Defensive avoidance of the message itself is the predicted response.
Between Knowing and Doing
The third problem is the gap between knowing and doing. Even when a message changes what people intend, behavior changes less. Across experiments that succeeded in raising intentions, Webb and Sheeran (2006) found the resulting gains in behavior to be about half as large or less. Several obstacles sit between intending to drink less soda and actually doing so. Access: in many of the targeted neighborhoods, corner stores stock far more sugary drinks than water or unsweetened options, and bottled water may cost more than soda. Habit: a soda with lunch every day is triggered by the situation, not by deliberation. Cost and convenience: sugary drinks are cheap, available everywhere and sold in large sizes.
One Failure Followed to the Body
Following one failure through to a physical consequence shows why this matters. A person who sees the poster, feels uncomfortable, looks away and continues drinking two 20-ounce sodas a day is consuming roughly 130 grams of added sugar daily. Over years, high intake of sugary drinks is associated with weight gain and with insulin resistance, the state in which the body's cells respond less to insulin and blood sugar rises. Sustained insulin resistance can progress to type 2 diabetes, which is diagnosed by measured blood glucose or hemoglobin A1c. The poster's own warning is thus the consequence of its failure: a message that produces avoidance leaves consumption, and therefore the pathway to diabetes, unchanged.
What the Message Would Need
To reach behavior, the message would need a mechanism. It would need to pair any threat with a specific, workable action, such as swapping one soda a day for sparkling water, and with reasons to believe the audience can do it. It would need to address habit, for example by suggesting a replacement for the lunchtime soda rather than simply stopping. And because messages alone cannot change access or price, the poster would work best alongside changes in the environment: water made available and cheaper in local stores, smaller default sizes and healthier options placed where sugary drinks now dominate. A message can support behavior change; on its own, aimed at people who already know the facts, it is unlikely to produce it.
References
Peters, G.-J. Y., Ruiter, R. A. C., & Kok, G. (2013). Threatening communication: A critical re-analysis and a revised meta-analytic test of fear appeal theory. Health Psychology Review, 7(Suppl. 1), S8-S31. https://doi.org/10.1080/17437199.2012.703527
Webb, T. L., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Does changing behavioral intentions engender behavior change? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence. Psychological Bulletin, 132(2), 249-268. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.132.2.249
Witte, K., & Allen, M. (2000). A meta-analysis of fear appeals: Implications for effective public health campaigns. Health Education & Behavior, 27(5), 591-615. https://doi.org/10.1177/109019810002700506
The PSY-352 Topic 5 assignment instructions
Topic 5 in PSY-352 asks students to critique a public health message as an intervention that either has a mechanism or lacks one. Strong critiques describe the message accurately, name its audience and the behavior it seeks to move, and state the assumption underneath it, usually that people who know more will act differently. Students should set research findings against that assumption: awareness that is already high, fear that produces avoidance when no workable action is offered, and the access, habit and cost that sit between knowing and doing. The critique should follow one failure to a bodily consequence and state what the message would need to reach behavior.
How the PSY-352 Topic 5 example is put together
The finished critique treats a message as an intervention that either has a mechanism or lacks one. It reproduces or describes the message accurately, names the audience it was aimed at and states the behavior it was trying to move. It then examines the assumption underneath, which is that people who know more will act differently. Against that it sets what research reports: awareness is usually high already in the group being addressed, fear raised without a workable action tends to produce avoidance of the message itself, and access, habit and cost sit between knowing and doing. One failure is followed to a bodily consequence. A closing passage states what the message would need in order to reach behavior.
Reading the PSY 352 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward a message judged by its mechanism. An Excellent critique names the poster's audience, target behavior and assumption that information drives change. Credit goes to showing awareness is already high and to Witte and Allen and Peters and colleagues on fear that works only with efficacy, so an amputation image without an action invites avoidance. The rubric values Webb and Sheeran on the gap between intention and behavior, a table of assumptions against research, and access, habit and cost. Strong critiques trace two sodas a day to insulin resistance. Top marks go to pairing threat with a workable action and environmental change.
PSY 352 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
The reliable loss here is a critique judging a message on how it looks and reads, because clarity and design are not the mechanism the criteria ask about. Papers concluding that people need more education have repeated the very assumption under examination. Naming a fear appeal without saying what fear does when an audience has no usable action available describes a technique and skips its mechanism. Critiques ending at intention stop one link short of the outcome this course cares about. A revised message proposed without a named mechanism is a matter of taste, and a revision offering no way to check whether anything moved cannot be assessed by anyone.
Get a PSY-352 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send us the PSY-352 Topic 5 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the campaign or message your section chose. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the assumption named, the mechanisms between knowing and doing evidenced, and one failure followed into a physical outcome, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More PSY 352 papers and BS in Psychology samples
- PSY 352 Topic 1: Biopsychosocial Analysis
- PSY 352 Topic 2: Stress Pathway Paper
- PSY 352 Topic 3: Health Behavior Model Application
- PSY 352 Topic 4: Adherence Case Analysis
- PSY 352 Topic 6: Pain Experience Analysis
- PSY 352 Topic 7: Intervention Evaluation
- PSY 352 Topic 8: Health Behavior Plan
- PSY 357 Topic 5: Research Design Critique
- PSY 102 Topic 5: Research Ethics Critique
- PSY 380 Topic 5: P Value Interpretation
- PSY 470 Topic 5: Cultural Boundary Analysis
PSY 352 Topic 5 questions, answered
Why does accurate information change so little?
Because a knowledge gap is rarely what holds the behavior in place. Most people a campaign addresses already know the claim being made, and what stops them is access, cost, habit, the immediate reward of what they currently do, or a fear with nowhere to go. A message supplying information answers a question its audience had settled long ago.
Is fear ever effective in a health message?
Under conditions most campaigns fail to meet. Where an audience believes the threat applies to them and is offered an action they can actually perform, fear can move behavior. Where the threat arrives without a workable response, people tend to manage the feeling rather than the risk, often by avoiding the message entirely, which leaves them worse informed than silence would.
How do I keep this out of graphic design?
By asking what the message assumes about its reader rather than how it looks. Typography, imagery and tone matter at the margins, but the criteria in this course are about mechanism: what the campaign believes is stopping the behavior, whether that is what is stopping it, and what physical outcome follows from getting the answer wrong.
Where can I find a free PSY 352 Topic 5 sample paper?
The message critique is shown here complete: the message, its assumption, awareness, fear without action, the gap between knowing and doing, one failure followed to the body and what the message would need. Post your PSY 352 Topic 5 prompt and get a free critique.
Why might a frightening image backfire in PSY 352 Topic 5?
When a message raises threat but offers no action people believe they can take, they tend to protect themselves from the message by looking away or dismissing it, and behavior stays the same.