PSY 102 Topic 5 research ethics critique example

General Psychology Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PSY 102 Topic 5 sample paper sets the procedure of Milgram's obedience study against the protections a review board applies today. It belongs to GCU PSY 102, General Psychology, listed as PSY-102, an undergraduate course in Grand Canyon University's BS in Psychology. It reconstructs what 40 men were told, the 15-volt steps to 450 volts, the experimenter's prods and the distress reported, and the delayed full explanation. A table tests consent, withdrawal, harm and debriefing under the APA code, with Baumrind's 1964 objection. The contribution is weighed, and Burger's 150-volt replication shows a version a board approved and what it gave up.

CoursePSY 102 General Psychology
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeResearch ethics critique
LengthAbout 1,000 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Psychology
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for PSY 102 Topic 5

1

What Would Have to Change: Setting the Procedure of Milgram's Obedience Study Against the Protections a Review Board Now Applies

[Author Name]

College of Humanities and Social Sciences, Grand Canyon University

PSY-102: General Psychology

Topic 5 Research Ethics Critique

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the critique's question. The sources are real; the study described is the published original.
2

What Would Have to Change: Setting the Procedure of Milgram's Obedience Study Against the Protections a Review Board Now Applies

Why Begin With Procedure

Stanley Milgram's obedience study is one of the most famous experiments in psychology, and it is often discussed with either admiration or outrage. This critique sets both aside and begins with procedure, because the ethical question turns on what participants were told, what they agreed to, what happened to them and what they heard afterward. It sets each of those against a specific protection in the current ethics code of the American Psychological Association (2017), weighs what the study contributed, separates what could be repaired from what could not and describes a version a review board might approve.

What Participants Were Told and Agreed To

Milgram (1963) recruited 40 men from New Haven through newspaper advertisements and direct mail, offering a small payment to join what was described as research on memory and learning at Yale. On arrival, each participant met an experimenter and another man, presented as a fellow participant but in fact a confederate. A rigged drawing assigned the real participant the role of teacher and the confederate the role of learner. Participants agreed to take part in a study of the effect of punishment on learning. They were not told that the study concerned obedience, that the learner was an actor or that the shocks were not real. Their agreement was therefore given without the facts that would have mattered to their decision.

What Happened During the Procedure

The teacher was told to give the learner, strapped into a chair in another room, an electric shock for each wrong answer, increasing the voltage in 15-volt steps up to 450 volts on a generator labeled with warnings such as Danger: Severe Shock. As the voltage rose, the learner protested, pounded on the wall and then fell silent. When participants hesitated, the experimenter used four scripted prods, the last telling the participant that continuing was not optional. Twenty-six of the 40 participants, 65 percent, continued to the maximum voltage.

The original report described severe strain in many participants, including sweating, shaking and fits of nervous laughter, which in one case became so violent that the session had to end (Milgram, 1963). The participants believed, while it was happening, that they might be seriously harming another person.

Setting the Procedure Against Current Protections

Four protections apply.

Table 1

The Obedience Study Against Current Research Protections

ProtectionWhat the code requiresWhat the study didRepairable?
Informed consentParticipants told what they need to decide whether to take partPurpose, confederate and fake shocks concealedPartly: deception can be approved if justified and disclosed afterward
Right to withdrawParticipants free to stop without penalty or pressureProds told them they had no choice but to continueYes: remove or soften the prods
Protection from harmAvoid or minimize harm, including severe distressMany showed extreme stress; some seizures of laughterPartly: stop earlier, screen participants
DebriefingPromptly explain the study and correct misconceptionsParticipants met the unharmed learner; fuller explanation came laterYes: full debriefing at once

Current rules allow deception when a study's value justifies it, when no non-deceptive method would work and when participants are told the truth as early as possible (American Psychological Association, 2017). The concealment of the shocks might pass that test. The prods are harder to defend, because a participant told they have no choice is not free to withdraw. And the severity of distress is the core problem: Baumrind (1964) argued at the time that the procedure subjected participants to serious emotional strain without adequate protection, and that the potential for lasting harm to their self-image was not justified by the findings.

What Participants Heard Afterward

After the session, participants met the learner, who was unharmed, and were told the shocks had not been delivered. That reconciliation was valuable, but early participants were not given the full purpose of the study until much later, when Milgram sent a report and questionnaire. For some months, then, participants knew they had been willing to shock a man but did not know the full context that might help them understand it. Current practice requires a full debriefing as soon as possible, explaining the deception and its reasons and helping participants leave without lasting distress.

What the Study Contributed

A serious judgment weighs that cost against the study's contribution. The study showed that ordinary people would follow an authority's instructions to harm another person far more often than experts predicted; before the study, psychiatrists Milgram surveyed expected only a tiny fraction to go to the end. That finding changed how psychologists and the public understand obedience, institutional pressure and the conduct of ordinary people in atrocities, and it is still cited in discussions of professional ethics and military training. Milgram also reported that most participants, in a later follow-up questionnaire, said they were glad to have taken part.

A Version a Board Might Approve

Burger (2009) ran a partial replication that a review board did approve. Participants were screened for anxiety and depression and excluded if at risk, reminded repeatedly that stopping would cost them nothing, and the procedure stopped at 150 volts, the point at which the learner first demanded to be released. Since most people who went past 150 volts in Milgram's version went on to the end, stopping there still measured willingness to continue. The experimenter was a clinical psychologist who would stop the session at signs of excessive stress, and participants were debriefed immediately. Burger found obedience rates at 150 volts only slightly lower than Milgram's.

That version keeps the main finding but forfeits others. It cannot show how far people would go, how they behaved at the extremes or how strong the distress of continuing became. The judgment of this critique is that Milgram's original could not be run today: the prods and the severity of distress could not be repaired without changing the study into something else. A modified version can be, and it still teaches most of what the original did.

References

American Psychological Association. (2017). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct (2002, amended effective June 1, 2010, and January 1, 2017). https://www.apa.org/ethics/code

Baumrind, D. (1964). Some thoughts on ethics of research: After reading Milgram's "Behavioral study of obedience." American Psychologist, 19(6), 421-423. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0040128

Burger, J. M. (2009). Replicating Milgram: Would people still obey today? American Psychologist, 64(1), 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0010932

Milgram, S. (1963). Behavioral study of obedience. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 67(4), 371-378. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0040525

What the PSY 102 Topic 5 instructions ask for

Topic 5 in PSY-102 asks students to critique the ethics of a well-known study. Strong critiques begin with procedure, reconstructing what participants were told, what they agreed to, what happened to them and what they heard afterward. Students should set each element against a specific current protection, such as informed consent, the right to withdraw, protection from harm and debriefing, and weigh the study's contribution against its costs. The paper should separate what could be repaired from what could not and describe a version a review board might approve, naming what that version would lose. Outrage is not analysis; the judgment must come from comparing documented procedure with stated protections.

How the PSY-102 Topic 5 example is put together

The finished critique is procedural before it is moral. It reconstructs what participants were told, what they agreed to, what happened to them during the procedure and what they heard afterward, since the ethical question turns on those details rather than on the study's reputation. Each element is then set against a specific protection: consent given with the facts, the right to stop without penalty, protection from harm, and a proper explanation at the end. The critique states what the study contributed to knowledge, because a serious judgment weighs that against the cost. It separates a procedure that could be repaired from one that could not. A closing passage describes a version a board might approve and names the finding that version would forfeit.

Reading the PSY 102 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty reward a judgment built on procedure, not reputation. An Excellent critique reconstructs recruitment, the rigged drawing, the shock steps and the prods from Milgram's report. Credit goes to a table setting consent, withdrawal, harm and debriefing against the APA code, with deception judged under its conditions. The rubric values Baumrind's objection, the delayed debriefing and an honest account of what the study contributed. Strong critiques separate repairable from unrepairable features. Top marks go to Burger's replication and what stopping at 150 volts forfeits. Papers that condemn the study without weighing what it taught, or excuse it as a product of its time, lose credit.

Common PSY 102 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them

This topic punishes the essay that condemns without reconstructing, because a critique never saying what participants experienced has judged a reputation rather than a procedure. Naming a protection without applying it to a specific feature of the design leaves the marker to do the work. Essays ignoring the knowledge the study produced treat the question as settled before it was asked. Anachronism costs more subtly: current standards were written partly in response to studies like the one under examination, and a critique reads better for saying so. Versions stopping at disapproval, with no redesign and no account of what a redesign would sacrifice, leave the last part of the criteria unanswered.

Get a PSY-102 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send us the PSY-102 Topic 5 instructions, the rubric in your classroom and the study your section named. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the procedure reconstructed, each protection applied to a specific feature of the design and a redesign priced against what it would forfeit, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More PSY 102 papers and BS in Psychology samples

PSY 102 Topic 5 questions, answered

Why does the course still teach studies that were unethical?

Because they produced findings that shaped the field, and because the protections in use now were written partly in response to them. A survey course dropping those studies would lose both the results and the reason the safeguards exist. What this topic asks is that you examine the procedure closely instead of repeating the famous conclusion and the familiar objection.

Is deception ever permitted in research?

It is allowed under conditions rather than banned outright. A board generally wants the deception to be necessary for the question, the risk to participants to be low, and a full explanation to follow immediately. That is why the critique separates deception from harm: the first can sometimes be offset by what happens at the end, and the second cannot.

Do I have to conclude the study was wrong?

You have to reach a defended judgment, which is not the same thing. Some designs fail one protection and satisfy the others, and saying which is stronger than a blanket verdict. A critique specifying the failure, weighing it against what was learned, and stating what a redesign would sacrifice reads as analysis rather than as a position taken before the evidence.

Where can I find a free PSY 102 Topic 5 sample paper?

The ethics critique is shown here complete: why begin with procedure, consent, the procedure, current protections, what participants heard afterward, the contribution and a version a board might approve. A critique written to your PSY 102 Topic 5 prompt costs nothing.

Why could Milgram's original not run today in PSY 102 Topic 5?

The prods told participants they had no choice, which defeats the right to withdraw, and many showed severe distress. Repairing both would change the study into a different one.