| Course | UNV 504 Introduction to Graduate Studies in the College of Business |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Ethical lens analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for UNV 504 Topic 6
Four Lenses on One Wristband: Should a Distribution Center Discipline Pickers by Their Real-Time Rates?
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
UNV-504: Introduction to Graduate Studies in the College of Business
Topic 6 Ethical Lens Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Four Lenses on One Wristband: Should a Distribution Center Discipline Pickers by Their Real-Time Rates?
The Decision, Stated Factually
A composite grocery distribution center employing 180 order pickers is considering wrist-mounted scanners that record each picker's rate in cases per hour, minute by minute, against an engineered standard. The vendor's proposal includes automatic warnings to supervisors when a picker falls below 90 percent of standard for a shift, with progressive discipline after three warnings in a month. Management projects a 6 percent productivity gain, worth about 520,000 dollars a year in labor cost, against about 140,000 dollars a year for the system. On the other side are the pickers: their pay is hourly, many are over fifty, the center's back and shoulder injury rate is already above the industry average for warehouses, and the standard was set by the vendor from other buildings' data. The question is whether to adopt the system as proposed.
The Lenses and What Each Treats as Decisive
Four frameworks are applied, each briefly defined by what it treats as decisive (Crane et al., 2019). A consequentialist lens judges the decision by its total effects on everyone affected. A duty-based lens, drawing on Kant, asks whether the decision treats people only as means to an end or also as ends in themselves. A justice lens, drawing on Rawls, asks whether the arrangement is fair, particularly to those least advantaged by it. A virtue lens considers what managers of sound character, at a company that aspired to it, would choose here. The lenses are applied separately so that their verdicts can be compared.
The Consequentialist Verdict
On consequences, the projected gain of 520,000 dollars a year less 140,000 for the system is a net benefit of about 380,000 dollars to the company. Against it stand costs the projection omits. If pace pressure raises the injury rate, even modestly, the center's workers' compensation costs and lost workdays rise; a few additional serious back injuries a year could consume much of the net gain and impose suffering the dollar figures do not capture. Turnover could rise if pickers find the monitoring oppressive. On the evidence available, the consequentialist verdict is uncertain and leans against the system as proposed: the benefits are projected, the harms plausible and unpriced.
The Duty-Based Verdict
Kant (1785/1998) held that people must never be treated merely as means. A system that issues warnings automatically, without asking why a picker was slow, treats a rate as the whole of the person: a picker slowed by a damaged pallet, a mis-slotted product or a sore shoulder receives the same warning as one who is idling. The objection is not to measurement but to discipline without judgment. On this lens, the proposal as designed is wrong, though a version in which supervisors review the data and speak with the picker before any warning could be acceptable.
The Justice Verdict
Rawls (1971) argued that arrangements should be judged by how they treat those who fare worst under them. Here the least advantaged are older pickers and those with prior injuries, for whom a standard set from other buildings' younger workforces may be unattainable without risk. A fair arrangement would set the standard from this building's own data, adjust it for task difficulty and allow appeals. The proposal does none of these, so the justice verdict is also against it as written.
Table 1
Four Lenses Applied Separately
| Lens | Treats as decisive | Verdict on the proposal as written |
|---|---|---|
| Consequences | Total effects on everyone | Uncertain; leans against because injury and turnover costs are unpriced |
| Duty | Treating people as ends, not merely means | Against: automatic discipline ignores the person's circumstances |
| Justice | Fairness to the least advantaged | Against: borrowed standard, no adjustment, no appeal |
| Virtue | What a company of good character would do | Against the discipline; for measurement used to help |
The Virtue Verdict
A virtue lens asks what kind of company the decision would make the center. Hursthouse (1999) described right action as what a virtuous agent would characteristically do, and the relevant virtues here are fairness, honesty and care for those in one's charge. A caring and fair employer would want to know when a picker is struggling, and might use the same data to fix slotting problems, rebalance heavy routes or offer lighter duty. It would not hand discipline to an algorithm. The verdict separates the measurement, which a good employer might use, from the automatic discipline, which it would not.
Where the Lenses Disagree, and My Position
The lenses disagree mainly on whether the system's consequences could justify it if the numbers were favorable; the duty and justice lenses would object to automatic discipline even then. They agree that measurement used to help is defensible. My position follows that agreement: adopt the scanners for staffing, slotting and coaching, set standards from this building's data with adjustments for heavy routes, give every picker access to their own data and remove automatic warnings, so that any discipline follows a conversation and a supervisor's judgment. That version gives up some projected gain in exchange for avoiding the harms each lens identifies.
What the Modified Version Costs
The modified version is not free. Without automatic warnings, some of the projected 6 percent gain will not appear, perhaps half of it, leaving a net benefit of roughly 120,000 dollars a year rather than 380,000. Supervisors will spend more time reviewing data and speaking with pickers. The center should accept that cost knowingly, and measure injuries, turnover and productivity for a year to see whether the modified version delivers enough to keep.
Conclusion
Applied one at a time, four ethical lenses converge on a distinction the proposal blurs: measuring work is defensible, while disciplining people automatically by a borrowed standard is not. The consequentialist case is uncertain because the harms are unpriced, and the duty, justice and virtue lenses object to the discipline directly. Using the data to help pickers, with standards set fairly and judgment kept in human hands, is the version the analysis supports.
References
Crane, A., Matten, D., Glozer, S., & Spence, L. J. (2019). Business ethics: Managing corporate citizenship and sustainability in the age of globalization (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.
Hursthouse, R. (1999). On virtue ethics. Oxford University Press.
Kant, I. (1998). Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals (M. Gregor, Trans.). Cambridge University Press. (Original work published 1785)
Rawls, J. (1971). A theory of justice. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
The UNV-504 Topic 6 assignment instructions
In Topic 6, UNV-504 asks MBA students to analyze a business decision through several ethical frameworks. Strong analyses describe the decision factually, with the money and people on both sides, state briefly what each framework treats as decisive and apply each in turn, recording its verdict separately rather than blending them. Students should identify where the frameworks disagree and where they agree, take and defend a position and state what that position costs. Cases with an obvious answer should be avoided, since a decision nobody would defend produces no disagreement among the lenses. The position taken should say what it gives up, in money or in projected gains, and how its results would be checked.
How the UNV-504 Topic 6 example is put together
The finished example uses lenses that produce different verdicts. A decision with a real cost on both sides is chosen, since a case where the ethical answer is obvious tests nothing. Each framework is then applied to that decision rather than described: a consequence based reading counts who gains and who bears the loss; a duty based reading asks what the firm owes regardless of outcome; a worldview grounded reading asks what the decision assumes about the people affected. Where the readings agree the example says so, and where they part it identifies the exact point. The writer then commits to one and states what it cost the position they set aside.
Where the marks sit in the UNV 504 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty reward frameworks applied, not described. An Excellent paper states the decision with figures and the people affected. Credit goes to separate verdicts from consequences, from Kant on treating people as ends and from Rawls on the least advantaged, with Crane and colleagues for the frameworks. The rubric values a virtue verdict drawn from Hursthouse that separates measurement from discipline. Strong papers table the four verdicts. Top marks go to a position built on where the lenses agree, with its cost to the company stated. Faculty also value a modified decision that keeps what the lenses accept and removes what they reject.
UNV 504 Topic 6 help: mistakes that cost marks
Concluding that a company should act ethically is the empty version of this paper, and it appears more often than any other. A second weakness is frameworks described in a block and never applied, so the reader learns definitions and nothing about the decision. Papers lose marks for choosing a case with an obvious answer, since a decision nobody would defend produces no disagreement between lenses and therefore no analysis. Blending the frameworks into a single reasonable judgment loses the distinctions the assignment is built on. Endorsing a decision without acknowledging who bears its cost reads as incomplete rather than as decisive. Frameworks blended into one balanced judgment lose exactly the distinctions the topic was built on.
Get a UNV-504 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the UNV-504 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the decision or case your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each framework applied to produce a verdict, the divergence located precisely and the choice of lens defended, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More UNV 504 papers and MBA samples
- UNV 504 Topic 1: Graduate Goals Statement
- UNV 504 Topic 2: Source Evaluation Exercise
- UNV 504 Topic 3: Academic Integrity Paper
- UNV 504 Topic 4: Short Argument Paper
- UNV 504 Topic 5: Business Claim Analysis
- UNV 504 Topic 7: Professional Profile Piece
- UNV 504 Topic 8: Program Plan Paper
- ACC 502 Topic 6: Financing and Equity Analysis
- SYM 506 Topic 6: Confidence Interval Report
- ACC 650 Topic 6: Master Budget Build
- MKT 607 Topic 6: Product and Life Cycle Analysis
UNV 504 Topic 6 questions, answered
Do I have to argue from a Christian worldview?
You have to engage it seriously where the rubric asks, which is not the same as adopting it. Papers that reason from it, and papers that reach a different conclusion while showing they understood what it commits somebody to, both do well. What earns nothing is naming a worldview in the introduction and then arguing from somewhere else without saying so.
What makes a good case for this assignment?
One where a defensible argument exists on both sides. A company committing outright fraud gives every framework the same answer and the paper has nowhere to go. A decision to close a profitable facility, to accept a contract with an uncomfortable partner, or to automate a role produces genuine disagreement, and disagreement is what the assignment needs to examine.
Should I reach a single conclusion?
Yes, and most rubrics require it. Applying three frameworks and declining to choose describes a problem rather than resolving one, and it is the safest looking way to lose marks. Commit to a position, say which framework you let govern and why, and acknowledge what the other readings would have required. That combination reads as judgment rather than as indecision.
Where can I find a free UNV 504 Topic 6 sample paper?
The ethical analysis is printed here in full: the decision, the lenses, the consequentialist, duty, justice and virtue verdicts, where they disagree, the position, its cost and the conclusion. Describe the business decision your course assigns and an analysis follows at no cost.
Why do the lenses agree on measurement in UNV 504 Topic 6?
Measuring work can help fix slotting problems and support struggling pickers. What the duty, justice and virtue lenses reject is discipline issued automatically without judgment.