| Course | UNV 504 Introduction to Graduate Studies in the College of Business |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Short argument paper |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for UNV 504 Topic 4
Offer Four Ten-Hour Nights, Do Not Impose Them: An Argument for Optional Compressed Schedules in a Grocery Distribution Center
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
UNV-504: Introduction to Graduate Studies in the College of Business
Topic 4 Short Argument Paper
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Offer Four Ten-Hour Nights, Do Not Impose Them: An Argument for Optional Compressed Schedules in a Grocery Distribution Center
The Question and the Position
Should a grocery distribution center move its night-shift order pickers from five eight-hour shifts to four ten-hour shifts? This paper argues that it should offer the four-day schedule as an option to pickers who choose it, rather than either refusing it or imposing it on everyone. The reasons, in order of strength, are that compressed schedules raise satisfaction with work schedules, which bears on the center's costliest problem, turnover; that the option lowers workers' commuting and childcare costs at no cost to the employer; and that it gives the center an advantage in recruiting. The strongest objection, that longer shifts raise fatigue and accident risk, is real and is answered by conditions, not dismissed.
The Strongest Reason: Satisfaction and Turnover
The center loses about 45 percent of its night pickers each year, and each replacement costs an estimated 4,000 dollars in recruiting, training and the lower productivity of new pickers. The best evidence on compressed schedules comes from a meta-analysis of studies across many workplaces (Baltes et al., 1999). It found that compressed workweeks improved employees' satisfaction with their work schedule and their overall job satisfaction, and supervisors' ratings of performance. Satisfaction matters here because of what follows from it: research on turnover consistently finds job satisfaction among the attitudes associated with employees' intentions to stay (Holtom et al., 2008). A schedule change that raises satisfaction at no direct cost addresses the center's largest controllable expense more directly than any other option under discussion.
The Second Reason: Costs Workers Save
The second reason concerns the workers themselves. A four-day schedule removes one round-trip commute a week, about 60 miles for the average night picker at this center, and one night of childcare or eldercare arrangements. For workers earning about 19 dollars an hour, those savings are a meaningful share of pay, and they cost the employer nothing. Offering a benefit the workforce values at no expense is a rare opportunity in a labor-intensive operation.
The Third Reason: Recruiting
The third reason is competitive. Two other distribution centers within twenty miles hire from the same pool of night workers and pay similar wages. Neither offers a four-day option. In a tight labor market, a schedule that workers value can distinguish an employer when wages cannot, and recruiters report that applicants already ask whether four-day schedules are available.
The Strongest Objection
The strongest objection deserves its most persuasive form. Ten-hour night shifts extend the hours worked when alertness is lowest, and picking involves lifting, forklifts and moving equipment, where a fatigued worker can be badly hurt. Folkard and Tucker (2003), reviewing studies of shift work and safety, reported that the risk of incidents rises with the length of a shift, so that a ten-hour shift carries a measurably higher risk than an eight-hour one, and that risk also rises across successive night shifts. The same meta-analysis that found gains in satisfaction found no improvement in productivity from compressed schedules. If the change raises injury risk and does not raise output, the objection runs, the employer bears real costs for a benefit that accrues mostly to workers.
Table 1
Evidence on Compressed Night Schedules
| Consideration | Evidence | Weight in the decision |
|---|---|---|
| Satisfaction with schedule and job | Meta-analysis found improvements | High: bears on turnover |
| Productivity | Meta-analysis found no improvement | Neutral: no gain, no loss |
| Accident risk | Risk rises with shift length and successive nights | High: must be managed |
| Worker costs | Commute and care savings each week | Moderate: valued by workers |
Answering the Objection
The objection is answered by conditions rather than denial. The option is limited to four consecutive ten-hour nights at most, never twelve, with an additional paid break in the eighth hour. Forklift and heavy-lift assignments are scheduled in the first six hours of each shift. Participation is voluntary, so workers who find the longer nights tiring can return to five eights, and the center tracks incident rates for both schedules separately, with a commitment to end the option if the four-day group's rate rises above the five-day group's for two consecutive quarters. On productivity, the absence of a gain is acceptable: the case for the option rests on turnover, not output.
Why an Option Rather Than a Rule
The position is narrower than a full conversion, and the reason matters. Not every worker benefits from longer nights: some have second jobs, caregiving duties at fixed hours or simply tire more on long shifts, and forcing them onto ten-hour nights would raise the very turnover the change is meant to reduce. An option lets the workers who value the schedule take it and leaves the rest unaffected. It also lets the center compare the two groups directly, which turns the change into a test rather than a bet.
How the Pilot Would Run
The option would be offered for six months to night pickers with at least ninety days of service, with the number on the four-day schedule capped at half the shift so that coverage remains even across the week. Supervisors would report attendance, incidents and cases picked per hour separately for each group, and exit interviews would ask departing workers about their schedule. At six months, the center would keep, expand or end the option based on those figures.
Conclusion
Offering optional four-day, ten-hour night schedules is justified because the strongest evidence links compressed schedules to higher satisfaction, which bears on the center's costliest problem, and because the option saves workers money and helps recruiting at no direct cost. The fatigue and safety objection is serious and is answered by limits on shift length, task scheduling, voluntary participation and a tracked commitment to reverse the option if incidents rise. Framed as an option with a test attached, the change asks the center to risk little and offers a measurable chance to reduce its largest controllable cost.
References
Baltes, B. B., Briggs, T. E., Huff, J. W., Wright, J. A., & Neuman, G. A. (1999). Flexible and compressed workweek schedules: A meta-analysis of their effects on work-related criteria. Journal of Applied Psychology, 84(4), 496-513. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.84.4.496
Folkard, S., & Tucker, P. (2003). Shift work, safety and productivity. Occupational Medicine, 53(2), 95-101. https://doi.org/10.1093/occmed/kqg047
Holtom, B. C., Mitchell, T. R., Lee, T. W., & Eberly, M. B. (2008). Turnover and retention research: A glance at the past, a closer review of the present, and a venture into the future. Academy of Management Annals, 2(1), 231-274. https://doi.org/10.5465/19416520802211552
What the UNV 504 Topic 4 instructions ask for
Topic 4 in UNV-504 asks MBA students to write a short argument paper. Strong papers state the question and a contestable position in the first paragraph, give the strongest supporting reason first with its evidence and order the remaining reasons by strength, one claim per paragraph. Students should present the counterargument in its most persuasive form, answer it with evidence or conditions rather than dismissal, and keep the paper an argument rather than a summary of what sources said. Evidence should be cited for each reason, and the paper should say plainly what the strongest objection gets right before answering it. A position narrow enough to defend fully is better than a broad one defended loosely.
How the UNV-504 Topic 4 example is put together
The finished example states a position in its first paragraph and spends the rest earning it. The thesis is contestable, meaning a competent reader could hold the opposite, which is the test that eliminates most student topic sentences. Each supporting paragraph makes one claim and evidences it, rather than gathering several ideas under a heading. The counterargument is the strongest available rather than a convenient one, and it is answered on the merits instead of dismissed. Sources are used as evidence for specific claims rather than cited to demonstrate that reading occurred. The example is short and does not pad, since the assignment rewards a tight argument rather than a long one.
Reading the UNV 504 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward a case made and defended. An Excellent paper states a narrow, contestable position and grounds its strongest reason in the meta-analysis by Baltes and colleagues. Credit goes to linking satisfaction to turnover with Holtom and colleagues and to reasons ordered by strength. The rubric values the safety objection stated at full strength, using Folkard and Tucker on shift length and incidents. Strong papers answer it with specific conditions rather than denial. Top marks go to a pilot design that turns the argument into a test. Faculty also value reasons that are distinct from one another rather than restatements of the thesis.
UNV 504 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
The topic is aimed squarely at summaries submitted where an argument was asked for, and the symptom is a paper reporting what several sources said with no position of its own. A second weakness is an uncontestable thesis, since a claim nobody would dispute leaves nothing to defend and produces paragraphs that restate it. Papers lose marks for counterarguments chosen because they are easy to refute, which faculty recognize immediately. Evidence cited without being connected to a specific claim reads as decoration. Conclusions that repeat the introduction word for word waste the one place where the argument's earned qualification belongs. Sources gathered to show reading occurred, rather than deployed against a specific claim, weaken an argument that would otherwise hold.
Get a UNV-504 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the UNV-504 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the question or prompt your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a contestable thesis, one claim per paragraph, the strongest counterargument stated fairly and answered, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More UNV 504 papers and MBA samples
- UNV 504 Topic 1: Graduate Goals Statement
- UNV 504 Topic 2: Source Evaluation Exercise
- UNV 504 Topic 3: Academic Integrity Paper
- UNV 504 Topic 5: Business Claim Analysis
- UNV 504 Topic 6: Ethical Lens Analysis
- UNV 504 Topic 7: Professional Profile Piece
- UNV 504 Topic 8: Program Plan Paper
- ACC 502 Topic 4: Inventory Method Analysis
- SYM 506 Topic 4: Normal Distribution Application
- ACC 650 Topic 4: Contribution Margin Analysis
- MKT 607 Topic 4: Secondary Research Appraisal
UNV 504 Topic 4 questions, answered
How do I know if my thesis is contestable?
Write the opposite and ask whether a reasonable person could hold it. If the reverse is obviously absurd, your thesis is a topic sentence rather than a position. Companies should behave ethically fails this test; companies should decline profitable contracts that conflict with a stated value, even where competitors accept them, passes it, because plenty of people would argue otherwise.
Which counterargument should I choose?
The one that most threatens your position, which is rarely the easiest to answer. Faculty read a great many papers that defeat a weak objection and leave the strong one unmentioned, and it is obvious. Naming the objection you found hardest, and answering it as well as you can even if not completely, demonstrates more than a comfortable refutation of something nobody was arguing.
How long should the argument be?
Whatever the rubric specifies, and these are usually short deliberately. A tight argument in three pages is what the assignment wants; padding to reach a length weakens it. If you are struggling to fill the space, the usual cause is a thesis with only one reason behind it rather than a shortage of words, and the fix is a better claim rather than more sentences.
Where can I find a free UNV 504 Topic 4 sample paper?
The full argument appears below: question and position, three reasons in order of strength, the strongest objection, the answer, why an option rather than a rule, the pilot and the conclusion. Tell us the question your course poses and an argued paper follows at no charge.
Why make the schedule optional in UNV 504 Topic 4?
Not every worker benefits from longer nights. An option lets those who value it take it, avoids pushing others out and allows a direct comparison of the two groups.